Identification of Quaternary Structure and Functional Domains of the CI Repressor from Bacteriophage TP901-1

CI:Mor interactions in the lysogeny switches of Lactococcus lactis TP901-1 and Staphylococcus aureus φ13 bacteriophages

Aim: To structurally characterize in detail the interactions between the phage repressor (CI) and the antirepressor (Mor) in the lysis-lysogeny switches of two Gram-positive bacteriophages, the lactococcal TP901-1 and staphylococcal φ13. Methods: We use crystallographic structure determination, computational structural modeling, and analysis, as well as biochemical methods, to elucidate similarities and differences in the CI:Mor interactions for the two genetic switches. Results: By comparing a newly determined and other available crystal structures for the N-terminal domain of CI (CI-NTD), we show that the CI interface involved in Mor binding undergoes structural changes upon binding in TP901-1. Most importantly, we show experimentally for the first time the direct interaction between CI and Mor for φ13, and model computationally the interaction interface. The computational modeling supports similar side chain rearrangements in TP901-1 and φ13. Conclusion: This study ascertains experimentally that, like in the TP901-1 lysogeny switch, staphylococcal φ13 CI and Mor interact with each other. The structural basis of the interaction of φ13 CI and Mor was computationally modeled and is similar to the interaction demonstrated experimentally between TP901-1 CI-NTD and Mor, likely involving similar rearrangement of residue side chains during the formation of the complex. The study identifies one CI residue, Glu69, which unusually interacts primarily through its aliphatic chain with an aromatic residue on Mor after changing its conformation compared to the un-complexed structure. This and other residues at the interface are suggested for investigation in future studies.

Flexible linker modulates the binding affinity of the TP901-1 CI phage repressor to DNA

Temperate bacteriophages can switch between two life cycles following infection of a host bacterium: the lytic or lysogenic life cycle. The choice between these is controlled by a bistable genetic switch. We investigated the genetic switch of the lactococcal temperate bacteriophage, TP901-1, which is controlled by two regulatory proteins, the Clear 1 (CI) repressor and modulator of repression (MOR) antirepressor. CI consists of a DNA-binding N-terminal domain and a C-terminal domain responsible for oligomerization, connected by a flexible interdomain linker. Full-length CI is hexameric, whereas the truncated version CI with 58 C-terminal residues truncated (CIΔ58), missing the second C-terminal subdomain, is dimeric, but binds with the same affinity as full-length CI to the O_L operator site, responsible for lytic genes transcription repression. Three variants of CIΔ58 with shorter, longer, and PP substituted linkers were produced and confirmed by circular dichroism spectroscopy and nanodifferential scanning fluorimetry to be well folded. With small-angle X-ray scattering, we delineated the conformational space sampled by the variants and wild-type in solution and found that shortening and lengthening the linker decrease and increase this, respectively, as also substantiated by molecular dynamics and as intended. Isoelectric focusing electrophoresis confirmed that all variants are able to bind to the MOR antirepressor. However, using electrophoretic mobility shift assays, we showed that shortening and lengthening the linker lead to a 94 and 17 times decrease in affinity to O_L , respectively. Thus, an appropriate linker length appears to be crucial for appropriate DNA-binding and subsequent TP901-1 genetic switch function.

Revealing the mechanism of repressor inactivation during switching of a temperate bacteriophage

Temperate bacteriophages can enter one of two life cycles following infection of a sensitive host: the lysogenic or the lytic life cycle. The choice between the two alternative life cycles is dependent upon a tight regulation of promoters and their cognate regulatory proteins within the phage genome. We investigated the genetic switch of TP901-1, a bacteriophage of Lactococcus lactis, controlled by the CI repressor and the modulator of repression (MOR) antirepressor and their interactions with DNA. We determined the solution structure of MOR, and we solved the crystal structure of MOR in complex with the N-terminal domain of CI, revealing the structural basis of MOR inhibition of CI binding to the DNA operator sites. ¹⁵N NMR Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) relaxation dispersion and rotating frame R _1ρ measurements demonstrate that MOR displays molecular recognition dynamics on two different time scales involving a repacking of aromatic residues at the interface with CI. Mutations in the CI:MOR binding interface impair complex formation in vitro, and when introduced in vivo, the bacteriophage switch is unable to choose the lytic life cycle showing that the CI:MOR complex is essential for proper functioning of the genetic switch. On the basis of sequence alignments, we show that the structural features of the MOR:CI complex are likely conserved among a larger family of bacteriophages from human pathogens implicated in transfer of antibiotic resistance.

Structural basis of the bacteriophage TP901-1 CI repressor dimerization and interaction with DNA

Temperate bacteriophages are known for their bistability, which in TP901-1 is controlled by two proteins, CI and MOR. Clear 1 repressor (CI) is hexameric and binds three palindromic operator sites via an N-terminal helix-turn-helix domain (NTD). A dimeric form, such as the truncated CI∆58 investigated here, is necessary for high-affinity binding to DNA. The crystal structure of the dimerization region (CTD₁ ) is determined here, showing that it forms a pair of helical hooks. This newly determined structure is used together with the known crystal structure of the CI-NTD and small angle X-ray scattering data, to determine the solution structure of CI∆58 in complex with a palindromic operator site, showing that the two NTDs bind on opposing sides of the DNA helix.

Structural and dynamics studies of a truncated variant of CI repressor from bacteriophage TP901-1

The CI repressor from the temperate bacteriophage TP901-1 consists of two folded domains, an N-terminal helix-turn-helix DNA-binding domain (NTD) and a C-terminal oligomerization domain (CTD), which we here suggest to be further divided into CTD1 and CTD2. Full-length CI is a hexameric protein, whereas a truncated version, CI∆58, forms dimers. We identify the dimerization region of CI∆58 as CTD1 and determine its secondary structure to be helical both within the context of CI∆58 and in isolation. To our knowledge this is the first time that a helical dimerization domain has been found in a phage repressor. We also precisely determine the length of the flexible linker connecting the NTD to the CTD. Using electrophoretic mobility shift assays and native mass spectrometry, we show that CI∆58 interacts with the OL operator site as one dimer bound to both half-sites, and with much higher affinity than the isolated NTD domain thus demonstrating cooperativity between the two DNA binding domains. Finally, using small angle X-ray scattering data and state-of-the-art ensemble selection techniques, we delineate the conformational space sampled by CI∆58 in solution, and we discuss the possible role that the dynamics play in CI-repressor function.

Clear Plaque Mutants of Lactococcal Phage TP901-1

We report a method for obtaining turbid plaques of the lactococcal bacteriophage TP901-1 and its derivative TP901-BC1034. We have further used the method to isolate clear plaque mutants of this phage. Analysis of 8 such mutants that were unable to lysogenize the host included whole genome resequencing. Four of the mutants had different mutations in structural genes with no relation to the genetic switch. However all 8 mutants had a mutation in the cI repressor gene region. Three of these were located in the promoter and Shine-Dalgarno sequences and five in the N-terminal part of the encoded CI protein involved in the DNA binding. The conclusion is that cI is the only gene involved in clear plaque formation i.e. the CI protein is the determining factor for the lysogenic pathway and its maintenance in the lactococcal phage TP901-1.

Evidence-Based Structural Model of the Staphylococcal Repressor Protein: Separation of Functions into Different Domains

Horizontal transfer of mobile genetic elements within Staphylococci is of high biomedical significance as such elements are frequently responsible for virulence and toxic effects. Staphylococcus-encoded repressor proteins regulate the replication of these mobile genetic elements that are located within the so-called pathogenicity islands. Here, we report structural and functional characterization of one such repressor protein, namely the Stl protein encoded by the pathogenicity island SaPIbov1. We create a 3D structural model and based on this prediction, we investigate the different functionalities of truncated and point mutant constructs. Results suggest that a helix-turn-helix motif governs the interaction of the Stl protein with its cognate DNA site: point mutations within this motif drastically decrease DNA-binding ability, whereas the interaction with the Stl-binding partner protein dUTPase is unperturbed by these point mutations. The 3D model also suggested the potential independent folding of a carboxy-terminal domain. This suggestion was fully verified by independent experiments revealing that the carboxy-terminal domain does not bind to DNA but is still capable of binding to and inhibiting dUTPase. A general model is proposed, which suggests that among the several structurally different repressor superfamilies Stl-like Staphylococcal repressor proteins belong to the helix-turn-helix transcription factor group and the HTH motif is suggested to reside within N-terminal segment.

The N-terminal domain of the repressor of Staphylococcus aureus phage Φ11 possesses an unusual dimerization ability and DNA binding affinity

Bacteriophage Φ11 uses Staphylococcus aureus as its host and, like lambdoid phages, harbors three homologous operators in between its two divergently oriented repressor genes. None of the repressors of Φ11, however, showed binding to all three operators, even at high concentrations. To understand why the DNA binding mechanism of Φ11 repressors does not match that of lambdoid phage repressors, we studied the N-terminal domain of the Φ11 lysogenic repressor, as it harbors a putative helix-turn-helix motif. Our data revealed that the secondary and tertiary structures of the N-terminal domain were different from those of the full-length repressor. Nonetheless, the N-terminal domain was able to dimerize and bind to the operators similar to the intact repressor. In addition, the operator base specificity, binding stoichiometry, and binding mechanism of this domain were nearly identical to those of the whole repressor. The binding affinities of the repressor and its N-terminal domain were reduced to a similar extent when the temperature was increased to 42°C. Both proteins also adequately dislodged a RNA polymerase from a Φ11 DNA fragment carrying two operators and a promoter. Unlike the intact repressor, the binding of the N-terminal domain to two adjacent operator sites was not cooperative in nature. Taken together, we suggest that the dimerization and DNA binding abilities of the N-terminal domain of the Φ11 repressor are distinct from those of the DNA binding domains of other phage repressors.

Key players in the genetic switch of bacteriophage TP901-1

After infection of a sensitive host temperate phages may enter either a lytic or a lysogenic pathway leading to new phage assembly or silencing as a prophage, respectively. The decision about which pathway to enter is centered in the genetic switch of the phage. In this work, we explore the bistable genetic switch of bacteriophage TP901-1 through experiments and statistical mechanical modeling. We examine the activity of the lysogenic promoter P(R) at different concentrations of the phage repressor, CI, and compare the effect of CI on P(R) in the presence or absence of the phage-encoded MOR protein expressed from the lytic promoter P(L). We find that the presence of large amounts of MOR prevents repression of the P(R) promoter, verifying that MOR works as an antirepressor. We compare our experimental data with simulations based on previous mathematical formulations of this switch. Good agreement between data and simulations verify the model of CI repression of P(R). By including MOR in the simulations, we are able to discard a model that assumes that CI and MOR do not interact before binding together at the DNA to repress P(R). The second model of Pr repression assumes the formation of a CI:MOR complex in the cytoplasm. We suggest that a CI:MOR complex may exist in different forms that either prevent or invoke P(R) repression, introducing a new twist on mixed feedback systems.

Small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering as a tool for structural systems biology

Small-angle scattering (SAS) of X-rays and neutrons reveals low-resolution structures of biological macromolecules in solution. With the recent experimental and methodological advances, SAS became a unique tool for characterising biological systems. The method covers an extremely broad range of molecule sizes (from a few kDa to hundreds of MDa) and experimental conditions (temperature, pH, salinity, ligand addition, etc.), which is of primary importance for a systemic approach in structural biology. The method provides unique information about the overall structure and conformational changes of native individual proteins, functional complexes, flexible macromolecules and hierarchical systems. New developments in small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering studies of biological macromolecules in solution are briefly reviewed, with a special emphasis on technical and methodological approaches useful for structural systems biology. Possibilities of synergistic use of the method with other techniques are considered.

Characterization of the CI repressor protein encoded by the temperate lactococcal phage TP901-1

The gene regulatory mechanism determining the developmental pathway of the temperate bacteriophage TP901-1 is regulated by two phage-encoded proteins, CI and MOR. Functional domains of the CI repressor were investigated by introducing linkers of 15 bp at various positions in cI and by limited proteolysis of purified CI protein. We show that insertions of five amino acids at positions in the N-terminal half of CI resulted in mutant proteins that could no longer repress transcription from the lytic promoter, P(L). We confirmed that the N-terminal domain of CI contains the DNA binding site, and we showed that this part of the protein is tightly folded, whereas the central part and the C-terminal part of CI seem to contain more flexible structures. Furthermore, insertions at several different positions in the central part of the CI protein reduced the cooperative binding of CI to the operator sites and possibly altered the interaction with MOR.

Modeling of the genetic switch of bacteriophage TP901-1: A heteromer of CI and MOR ensures robust bistability

The lytic-lysogenic switch of the temperate lactococcal phage TP901-1 is fundamentally different from that of phage lambda. In phage TP901-1, the lytic promoter P(L) is repressed by CI, whereas repression of the lysogenic promoter P(R) requires the presence of both of the antagonistic regulator proteins, MOR and CI. We model the central part of the switch and compare the two cases for P(R) repression: the one where the two regulators interact only on the DNA and the other where the two regulators form a heteromer complex in the cytoplasm prior to DNA binding. The models are analyzed for bistability, and the predicted promoter repression folds are compared to experimental data. We conclude that the experimental data are best reproduced the latter case, where a heteromer complex forms in solution. We further find that CI sequestration by the formation of MOR:CI complexes in cytoplasm makes the genetic switch robust.

The role of MOR and the CI operator sites on the genetic switch of the temperate bacteriophage TP901-1

A genetic switch controls whether the temperate bacteriophage TP901-1 will enter a lytic or a lysogenic life cycle after infection of its host, Lactococcus lactis. We studied this bistable switch encoded in a small DNA fragment of 979 bp by fusing it to a reporter gene on a low-copy-number plasmid. The cloned DNA fragment contained the two divergently oriented promoters, P(R) and P(L), transcribing the lysogenic and lytic gene clusters; the two promoter-proximal genes, cI and mor; and the three CI operator sites, O(R), O(L) and O(D). We show that mor encodes a protein and that this protein in concert with CI is required for the bistability. Furthermore, interaction of CI at O(R) represses transcription from the lysogenic promoter, P(R). Thus, CI regulates its own transcription. Interaction of CI at O(L) represses transcription from the lytic promoter, P(L). The presence of only O(L) (absence of O(R) and O(D)) is enough to maintain a bistable system. The distantly located operator site, O(D), functions as a helper site by increasing binding of CI at O(R) and O(L). In the immune state, O(D) increases repression of the lytic promoter, P(L). Our results strongly support the model that a hexameric form of CI binds cooperatively to the three operator sites in the immune state forming a CI-DNA loop structure. Finally, we show that in the anti-immune state, repression of the lysogenic promoter is independent of the known CI operator sites but requires the presence of both CI and MOR.