Association of Neighboring β-Strands of Outer Membrane Protein A in Lipid Bilayers Revealed by Site-Directed Fluorescence Quenching

The Formation of β-Strand Nine (β9) in the Folding and Insertion of BamA from an Unfolded Form into Lipid Bilayers

Transmembrane proteins span lipid bilayer membranes and serve essential functions in all living cells. Membrane-inserted domains are of either α-helical or β-barrel structure. Despite their biological importance, the biophysical mechanisms of the folding and insertion of proteins into membranes are not well understood. While the relative composition of the secondary structure has been examined by circular dichroism spectroscopy in folding studies for several outer membrane proteins, it is currently not known how individual β-strands fold. Here, the folding and insertion of the β-barrel assembly machinery protein A (BamA) from the outer membrane of Escherichia coli into lipid bilayers were investigated, and the formation of strand nine (β₉) of BamA was examined. Eight single-cysteine mutants of BamA were overexpressed and isolated in unfolded form in 8 M urea. In each of these mutants, one of the residues of strand β₉, from R572 to V579, was replaced by a cysteine and labeled with the fluorophore IAEDANS for site-directed fluorescence spectroscopy. Upon urea-dilution, the mutants folded into the native structure and were inserted into lipid bilayers of dilauroylphosphatidylcholine, similar to wild-type BamA. An aqueous and a membrane-adsorbed folding intermediate of BamA could be identified by strong shifts in the intensity maxima of the IAEDANS fluorescence of the labeled mutants of BamA towards shorter wavelengths, even in the absence of lipid bilayers. The shifts were greatest for membrane-adsorbed mutants and smaller for the inserted, folded mutants or the aqueous intermediates. The spectra of the mutants V573C-, L575C-, G577C-, and V579C-BamA, facing the lipid bilayer, displayed stronger shifts than the spectra recorded for the mutants R572C-, N574C-, T576C-, and K578C-BamA, facing the β-barrel lumen, in both the membrane-adsorbed form and the folded, inserted form. This alternating pattern was neither observed for the IAEDANS spectra of the unfolded forms nor for the water-collapsed forms, indicating that strand β₉ forms in a membrane-adsorbed folding intermediate of BamA. The combination of cysteine scanning mutagenesis and site-directed fluorescence labeling is shown to be a valuable tool in examining the local secondary structure formation of transmembrane proteins.

Transmembrane β-barrel proteins of bacteria: From structure to function

The outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria is a specialized organelle conferring protection to the cell against various environmental stresses and resistance to many harmful compounds. The outer membrane has a number of unique features, including an asymmetric lipid bilayer, the presence of lipopolysaccharides and an individual proteome. The vast majority of the integral transmembrane proteins in the outer membrane belongs to the family of β-barrel proteins. These evolutionarily related proteins share a cylindrical, anti-parallel β-sheet core fold spanning the outer membrane. The loops and accessory domains attached to the β-barrel allow for a remarkable versatility in function for these proteins, ranging from diffusion pores and transporters to enzymes and adhesins. We summarize the current knowledge on β-barrel structure and folding and give an overview of their functions, evolution, and potential as drug targets.

Folding of Circularly Permuted and Split Outer Membrane Protein F via Electrostatic Interactions with Terminal Residues

Membrane proteins are essential targets in drug design, biosensing, and catalysis. In this study, we explored the folding of engineered outer membrane protein F (OmpF), an abundant and functional β-barrel protein expressed in Gram-negative bacteria. We carried out circular permutation, splitting and self-complementation, and point mutation. The folding efficiency and kinetic analyses demonstrated that the N- and C-terminal residues of OmpF played critical roles in folding via electrostatic interactions with lipid headgroups. Our results indicate that native porins without charged terminal residues may be tightly downregulated to retain the integrity of the outer membrane, and this modification may facilitate the insertion and folding of modified membrane proteins under in vitro and in vivo conditions for various applications.

Role of the lipid bilayer in outer membrane protein folding in Gram-negative bacteria

β-Barrel outer membrane proteins (OMPs) represent the major proteinaceous component of the outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative bacteria. These proteins perform key roles in cell structure and morphology, nutrient acquisition, colonization and invasion, and protection against external toxic threats such as antibiotics. To become functional, OMPs must fold and insert into a crowded and asymmetric OM that lacks much freely accessible lipid. This feat is accomplished in the absence of an external energy source and is thought to be driven by the high thermodynamic stability of folded OMPs in the OM. With such a stable fold, the challenge that bacteria face in assembling OMPs into the OM is how to overcome the initial energy barrier of membrane insertion. In this review, we highlight the roles of the lipid environment and the OM in modulating the OMP-folding landscape and discuss the factors that guide folding in vitro and in vivo We particularly focus on the composition, architecture, and physical properties of the OM and how an understanding of the folding properties of OMPs in vitro can help explain the challenges they encounter during folding in vivo Current models of OMP biogenesis in the cellular environment are still in flux, but the stakes for improving the accuracy of these models are high. OMP folding is an essential process in all Gram-negative bacteria, and considering the looming crisis of widespread microbial drug resistance it is an attractive target. To bring down this vital OMP-supported barrier to antibiotics, we must first understand how bacterial cells build it.

Folding of β-Barrel Membrane Proteins into Lipid Membranes by Site-Directed Fluorescence Spectroscopy

Protein-lipid interactions are important for folding and membrane insertion of integral membrane proteins that are composed either of α-helical or of β-barrel structure in their transmembrane domains. While α-helical transmembrane proteins fold co-translationally while they are synthesized by a ribosome, β-barrel transmembrane proteins (β-TMPs) fold and insert posttranslationally-in bacteria after translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane, in cell organelles of eukaryotes after import across the outer membrane of the organelle. β-TMPs can be unfolded in aqueous solutions of chaotropic denaturants like urea and spontaneously refold upon denaturant dilution in the presence of preformed lipid bilayers. This facilitates studies on lipid interactions during folding into lipid bilayers. For several β-TMPs, the kinetics of folding has been reported as strongly dependent on protein-lipid interactions. The kinetics of adsorption/insertion and folding of β-TMPs can be monitored by fluorescence spectroscopy. These fluorescence methods are even more powerful when combined with site-directed mutagenesis for the preparation of mutants of a β-TMP that are site-specifically labeled with a fluorophore or a fluorophore and fluorescence quencher or fluorescence resonance energy acceptor. Single tryptophan or single cysteine mutants of the β-TMP allow for the investigation of local protein-lipid interactions, at specific regions within the protein. To examine the structure formation of β-TMPs in a lipid environment, fluorescence spectroscopy has been used for double mutants of β-TMPs that contain a fluorescent tryptophan and a spin-label, covalently attached to a cysteine as a fluorescence quencher. The sites of mutation are selected so that the tryptophan is in close proximity to the quencher at the cysteine only when the β-TMP is folded. In a folding experiment, the evolution of fluorescence quenching as a function of time at specific sites within the protein can provide important information on the folding mechanism of the β-TMP. Here, we report protocols to examine membrane protein folding for two β-TMPs in a lipid environment, the outer membrane protein A from Escherichia coli, OmpA, and the voltage-dependent anion-selective channel, human isoform 1, hVDAC1, from mitochondria.

Molecular Switch between Structural Compaction and Thermodynamic Stability by the Xxx-Pro Interface in Transmembrane β-Barrels

Transmembrane β-barrel scaffolds found in outer membrane proteins are formed and stabilized by a defined pattern of interstrand intraprotein H-bonds, in hydrophobic lipid bilayers. Introducing the conformationally constrained proline in β-barrels can cause significant destabilization of these structural regions that require H-bonding, with proline additionally acting as a secondary structure breaker. Membrane protein β-barrels are therefore expected to show poor tolerance to the presence of a transmembrane proline. Here, we assign a thermodynamic measure for the extent to which a single proline can be tolerated at the C-terminal interface of the model transmembrane β-barrel PagP. We find that proline drastically destabilizes PagP by 7.0 kcal mol^-1 with respect to wild-type PagP (F¹⁶¹ → P¹⁶¹). Interestingly, strategic modulation of the preceding residue can modify the measured energetics. Placing a hydrophobic or bulky side chain as the preceding residue increases the thermodynamic stability by ≤8.0 kcal mol^-1. While polar substituents at the preceding residue decrease the PagP stability, these residues demonstrate stronger tertiary packing interactions in the barrel and retain the catalytic activity of native PagP. This biophysical interplay between enhanced thermodynamic stability and attaining a structurally compact functional β-barrel scaffold highlights the detrimental effect caused by proline incorporation. Our findings also reveal alternative mechanisms that protein sequences can employ to salvage the structural integrity of transmembrane protein structures.

Kinetics of Insertion and Folding of Outer Membrane Proteins by Gel Electrophoresis

To examine the mechanisms of folding and insertion of TMPs into membranes, kinetic studies are instrumental, for example, for the analysis of folding steps and involved intermediates or for the determination of activation energies. For many β-barrel transmembrane proteins (β-TMPs) it has been shown that the folded, functional form can be separated from the unfolded form by a simple electrophoretic mobility assay. The only requirements for a separation by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) are that the folded form is sufficiently stable and that the samples are not heat-denatured before the electrophoresis is performed. Many folded β-TMPs resist the treatment with SDS at room temperature and are stable against forces during electrophoresis. On the other side, SDS also binds to unfolded forms of β-TMPs and prevents their folding into β-barrel structure. These observations have been used to develop a simple assay to monitor the kinetics of β-barrel tertiary structure formation in a membrane environment by electrophoresis. A folding reaction of a β-TMP is initiated by dilution of the denaturant in the presence of preformed lipid bilayers, proteoliposomes or membrane vesicles. At selected times, samples are taken from the reaction. In these samples, folding is stopped by addition of SDS. At the end of the entire folding reaction, all samples are analyzed by SDS-PAGE and the fractions of folded β-TMP that they contain are determined by densitometry.An advantage of this kinetic assay is that it not only allows a direct determination of fractions of folded and unfolded forms at a selected time during folding of the β-TMP into a membrane, but also facilitates the determination of the impact of folding factors (e.g., molecular chaperones) or folding machinery that most often have a different molecular mass and electrophoretic mobility. The assay has been very useful to examine how folding and insertion is affected by the structure of the phospholipids in the lipid bilayer and how folding machinery compensates for the presence of membrane lipids that retard folding and insertion of β-TMPs.

C-terminal kink formation is required for lateral gating in BamA

In Gram-negative bacteria, the outer membrane contains primarily β-barrel transmembrane proteins and lipoproteins. The insertion and assembly of β-barrel outer-membrane proteins (OMPs) is mediated by the β-barrel assembly machinery (BAM) complex, the core component of which is the 16-stranded transmembrane β-barrel BamA. Recent studies have indicated a possible role played by the seam between the first and last β-barrel strands of BamA in the OMP insertion process through lateral gating and a destabilized membrane region. In this study, we have determined the stability and dynamics of the lateral gate through over 12.5 μs of equilibrium simulations and 4 μs of free-energy calculations. From the equilibrium simulations, we have identified a persistent kink in the C-terminal strand and observed spontaneous lateral-gate separation in a mimic of the native bacterial outer membrane. Free-energy calculations of lateral gate opening revealed a significantly lower barrier to opening in the C-terminal kinked conformation; mutagenesis experiments confirm the relevance of C-terminal kinking to BamA structure and function.

Outer Membrane Biogenesis

The hallmark of gram-negative bacteria and organelles such as mitochondria and chloroplasts is the presence of an outer membrane. In bacteria such as Escherichia coli, the outer membrane is a unique asymmetric lipid bilayer with lipopolysaccharide in the outer leaflet. Integral transmembrane proteins assume a β-barrel structure, and their assembly is catalyzed by the heteropentameric Bam complex containing the outer membrane protein BamA and four lipoproteins, BamB-E. How the Bam complex assembles a great diversity of outer membrane proteins into a membrane without an obvious energy source is a particularly challenging problem, because folding intermediates are predicted to be unstable in either an aqueous or a hydrophobic environment. Two models have been put forward: the budding model, based largely on structural data, and the BamA assisted model, based on genetic and biochemical studies. Here we offer a critical discussion of the pros and cons of each.

Outer membrane protein folding from an energy landscape perspective

The cell envelope is essential for the survival of Gram-negative bacteria. This specialised membrane is densely packed with outer membrane proteins (OMPs), which perform a variety of functions. How OMPs fold into this crowded environment remains an open question. Here, we review current knowledge about OMP folding mechanisms in vitro and discuss how the need to fold to a stable native state has shaped their folding energy landscapes. We also highlight the role of chaperones and the β-barrel assembly machinery (BAM) in assisting OMP folding in vivo and discuss proposed mechanisms by which this fascinating machinery may catalyse OMP folding.

Novel Kinetic Intermediates Populated along the Folding Pathway of the Transmembrane β-Barrel OmpA

We examined the folding of the β-barrel membrane protein OmpA from Escherichia coli. Although previous studies identified several intermediate states followed by a concerted translocation mechanism across the bilayer, some aspects of the pathway were still unclear, including the extent of secondary structure formation in the intermediate states and how the mechanism gave rise to multiple exponential phases in the folding kinetics. We addressed these questions by investigating the folding kinetics of the OmpA transmembrane β-barrel domain over a range of bilayer thicknesses, allowing us to observe different regions of the folding pathway. The fastest folding into the thinnest bilayers provided information about the later stages of the process, and the slowest folding into thicker bilayers revealed early kinetic steps. Folding was monitored using sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and circular dichroism spectroscopy, which provide complementary information about tertiary and secondary structure formation. We globally fit the folding data to kinetic schemes and found that the same core pathway was followed under all lipid conditions. We propose a multistep folding mechanism for OmpA that includes unstructured surface-adsorbed states converting through a partially inserted state with substantial β-sheet structure to the final natively inserted barrel. Kinetic models show that all steps of the main folding pathway are accelerated by membrane defects that occur as a result of thinning the bilayer or incubation of lipids at the phase transition temperature. In addition to suppressing off-pathway states, β-barrel assembly machinery-catalyzed folding in vivo could accelerate any or all of these main folding steps to ensure efficient outer membrane protein biogenesis in vivo.

Direct Monitoring of β-Sheet Formation in the Outer Membrane Protein TtoA Assisted by TtOmp85

Attenuated total reflection Fourier-transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy was applied to investigate the folding of an outer membrane protein, TtoA, assisted by TtOmp85, both from the thermophilic eubacterium Thermus thermophilus. To directly monitor the formation of β-sheet structure in TtoA and to analyze the function of TtOmp85, we immobilized unfolded TtoA on an ATR crystal. Interaction with TtOmp85 initiated TtoA folding as shown by time-dependent spectra recorded during the folding process. Our ATR-FTIR experiments prove that TtOmp85 possesses specific functionality to assist β-sheet formation of TtoA. We demonstrate the potential of this spectroscopic approach to study the interaction of outer membrane proteins in vitro and in a time-resolved manner.

Characterization of a stalled complex on the β-barrel assembly machine

The assembly of β-barrel proteins into membranes is mediated by an evolutionarily conserved machine. This process is poorly understood because no stable partially folded barrel substrates have been characterized. Here, we slowed the folding of the Escherichia coli β-barrel protein, LptD, with its lipoprotein plug, LptE. We identified a late-stage intermediate in which LptD is folded around LptE, and both components interact with the two essential β-barrel assembly machine (Bam) components, BamA and BamD. We propose a model in which BamA and BamD act in concert to catalyze folding, with the final step in the process involving closure of the ends of the barrel with release from the Bam components. Because BamD and LptE are both soluble proteins, the simplest model consistent with these findings is that barrel folding by the Bam complex begins in the periplasm at the membrane interface.

A growing toolbox of techniques for studying β-barrel outer membrane protein folding and biogenesis

Great strides into understanding protein folding have been made since the seminal work of Anfinsen over 40 years ago, but progress in the study of membrane protein folding has lagged behind that of their water soluble counterparts. Researchers in these fields continue to turn to more advanced techniques such as NMR, mass spectrometry, molecular dynamics (MD) and single molecule methods to interrogate how proteins fold. Our understanding of β-barrel outer membrane protein (OMP) folding has benefited from these advances in the last decade. This class of proteins must traverse the periplasm and then insert into an asymmetric lipid membrane in the absence of a chemical energy source. In this review we discuss old, new and emerging techniques used to examine the process of OMP folding and biogenesis in vitro and describe some of the insights and new questions these techniques have revealed.

Folding of β-barrel membrane proteins in lipid bilayers - Unassisted and assisted folding and insertion

In cells, β-barrel membrane proteins are transported in unfolded form to an outer membrane into which they fold and insert. Model systems have been established to investigate the mechanisms of insertion and folding of these versatile proteins into detergent micelles, lipid bilayers and even synthetic amphipathic polymers. In these experiments, insertion into lipid membranes is initiated from unfolded forms that do not display residual β-sheet secondary structure. These studies therefore have allowed the investigation of membrane protein folding and insertion in great detail. Folding of β-barrel membrane proteins into lipid bilayers has been monitored from unfolded forms by dilution of chaotropic denaturants that keep the protein unfolded as well as from unfolded forms present in complexes with molecular chaperones from cells. This review is aimed to provide an overview of the principles and mechanisms observed for the folding of β-barrel transmembrane proteins into lipid bilayers, the importance of lipid-protein interactions and the function of molecular chaperones and folding assistants. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Lipid-protein interactions.

Mechanistic studies of the biogenesis and folding of outer membrane proteins in vitro and in vivo: what have we learned to date?

Research into the mechanisms by which proteins fold into their native structures has been on-going since the work of Anfinsen in the 1960s. Since that time, the folding mechanisms of small, water-soluble proteins have been well characterised. By contrast, progress in understanding the biogenesis and folding mechanisms of integral membrane proteins has lagged significantly because of the need to create a membrane mimetic environment for folding studies in vitro and the difficulties in finding suitable conditions in which reversible folding can be achieved. Improved knowledge of the factors that promote membrane protein folding and disfavour aggregation now allows studies of folding into lipid bilayers in vitro to be performed. Consequently, mechanistic details and structural information about membrane protein folding are now emerging at an ever increasing pace. Using the panoply of methods developed for studies of the folding of water-soluble proteins. This review summarises current knowledge of the mechanisms of outer membrane protein biogenesis and folding into lipid bilayers in vivo and in vitro and discusses the experimental techniques utilised to gain this information. The emerging knowledge is beginning to allow comparisons to be made between the folding of membrane proteins with current understanding of the mechanisms of folding of water-soluble proteins.

Folding and stability of integral membrane proteins in amphipols

Amphipols (APols) are a family of amphipathic polymers designed to keep transmembrane proteins (TMPs) soluble in aqueous solutions in the absence of detergent. APols have proven remarkably efficient at (i) stabilizing TMPs, as compared to detergent solutions, and (ii) folding them from a denatured state to a native, functional one. The underlying physical-chemical mechanisms are discussed.

Model for coupled insertion and folding of membrane-spanning proteins

Current understanding of the forces directing the folding of integral membrane proteins is very limited compared to the detailed picture available for water-soluble proteins. While mechanistic studies of the folding process in vitro have been conducted for only a small number of membrane proteins, the available evidence indicates that their folding process is thermodynamically driven like that of soluble proteins. In vivo, however, the majority of integral membrane proteins are installed in membranes by dedicated machinery, suggesting that the cellular systems may act to facilitate and regulate the spontaneous physical process of folding. Both the in vitro folding process and the in vivo pathway must navigate an energy landscape dominated by the energetically favorable burial of hydrophobic segments in the membrane interior and the opposition to folding due to the need for passage of polar segments across the membrane. This manuscript describes a simple, exactly solvable model which incorporates these essential features of membrane protein folding. The model is used to compare the folding time under conditions which depict both the in vitro and in vivo pathways. It is proposed that the cellular complexes responsible for insertion of membrane proteins act by lowering the energy barrier for passage of polar regions through the membrane, thereby allowing the chain to more rapidly achieve the folded state.

The lipid bilayer-inserted membrane protein BamA of Escherichia coli facilitates insertion and folding of outer membrane protein A from its complex with Skp

Folding of β-barrel membrane proteins, either from a urea-unfolded form or from chaperone-bound aqueous forms, has been characterized for pure lipid bilayers. The impact of preinserted integral proteins from biomembranes has not been examined in biophysical comparisons, but this knowledge is important for the characterization of protein assembly machinery in membranes to distinguish specific effects from unspecific effects. Here, folding was studied for a β-barrel membrane protein, outer membrane protein A (OmpA) from Escherichia coli, in the absence and presence of two other preinserted integral proteins, BamA of the β-barrel assembly machinery complex (BAM) from E. coli and FomA from Fusobacterium nucleatum. Three different preformed lipid membranes of phosphatidylcholine were prepared to compare the folding kinetics of OmpA, namely, proteoliposomes containing either BamA or FomA and pure liposomes. Urea-unfolded OmpA folded faster into phosphatidylcholine bilayers containing FomA than into pure lipid bilayers, but the kinetics of OmpA folding and insertion were fastest for bilayers containing BamA. Incorporation of BamA into lipid bilayers composed of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine greatly weakened the inhibiting effect of phosphatidylethanolamine on the folding of OmpA. Folding of OmpA from its complex with the periplasmic chaperone Skp into bilayers composed of phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylcholine was inhibited in the absence of BamA but facilitated when BamA was present, indicating an interaction of Skp-OmpA complexes with BamA.

A knowledge-based potential highlights unique features of membrane α-helical and β-barrel protein insertion and folding

Outer membrane β-barrel proteins differ from α-helical inner membrane proteins in lipid environment, secondary structure, and the proposed processes of folding and insertion. It is reasonable to expect that outer membrane proteins may contain primary sequence information specific for their folding and insertion behavior. In previous work, a depth-dependent insertion potential, E(z) , was derived for α-helical inner membrane proteins. We have generated an equivalent potential for TM β-barrel proteins. The similarities and differences between these two potentials provide insight into unique aspects of the folding and insertion of β-barrel membrane proteins. This potential can predict orientation within the membrane and identify functional residues involved in intermolecular interactions.

Protein folding mechanisms studied by pulsed oxidative labeling and mass spectrometry

Deciphering the mechanisms of protein folding remains a considerable challenge. In this review we discuss the application of pulsed oxidative labeling for tracking protein structural changes in a time-resolved fashion. Exposure to a microsecond OH pulse at selected time points during folding induces the oxidation of solvent-accessible side chains, whereas buried residues are protected. Oxidative modifications can be detected by mass spectrometry. Folding is associated with dramatic accessibility changes, and therefore this method can provide detailed mechanistic insights. Solvent accessibility patterns are complementary to H/D exchange investigations, which report on the extent of hydrogen bonding. This review highlights the application of pulsed OH labeling to soluble proteins as well as membrane proteins.

Folding studies of purified LamB protein, the maltoporin from the Escherichia coli outer membrane: trimer dissociation can be separated from unfolding

The folding mechanisms for β-barrel membrane proteins present unique challenges because acquisition of both secondary and tertiary structure is coupled with insertion into the bilayer. For the porins in Escherichia coli outer membrane, the assembly pathway also includes association into homotrimers. We study the folding pathway for purified LamB protein in detergent and observe extreme hysteresis in unfolding and refolding, as indicated by the shift in intrinsic fluorescence. The strong hysteresis is not seen in unfolding and refolding a mutant LamB protein lacking the disulfide bond, as it unfolds at much lower denaturant concentrations than wild type LamB protein. The disulfide bond is proposed to stabilize the structure of LamB protein by clasping together the two sides of Loop 1 as it lines the inner cavity of the barrel. In addition we find that low pH promotes dissociation of the LamB trimer to folded monomers, which run at about one third the size of the native trimer during SDS PAGE and are much more resistant to trypsin than the unfolded protein. We postulate the loss at low pH of two salt bridges between Loop 2 of the neighboring subunit and the inner wall of the monomer barrel destabilizes the quaternary structure.