Comparing continuous wave progressive saturation EPR and time domain saturation recovery EPR over the entire motional range of nitroxide spin labels

The Synergetic Effects of Combining Structural Biology and EPR Spectroscopy on Membrane Proteins

Protein structures as provided by structural biology such as X-ray crystallography, cryo-electron microscopy and NMR spectroscopy are key elements to understand the function of a protein on the molecular level. Nonetheless, they might be error-prone due to crystallization artifacts or, in particular in case of membrane-imbedded proteins, a mostly artificial environment. In this review, we will introduce different EPR spectroscopy methods as powerful tools to complement and validate structural data gaining insights in the dynamics of proteins and protein complexes such that functional cycles can be derived. We will highlight the use of EPR spectroscopy on membrane-embedded proteins and protein complexes ranging from receptors to secondary active transporters as structural information is still limited in this field and the lipid environment is a particular challenge.

Rapid-scan coherence signals in X-band EPR spectra of semiquinones with small hyperfine splittings

Rapid-scan EPR signals for semiquinones with very-small well-resolved hyperfine splittings exhibit coherence signals at a time after passing through the EPR line that is proportional to the reciprocal of the hyperfine splitting. Such coherences are a general phenomenon due to constructive interference of the responses to transient excitation of spins by rapid scan of the magnetic field across equally spaced spin packets. Examples are shown for 2,3,5,6-tetramethoxy-1,4-benzosemiquinone with aH=46 mG for 12 protons and for 2,5-di-t-butyl-1,4-benzosemiquinone with aH=59 mG for 18 protons.

First determination of the spin relaxation properties of a nitronyl nitroxide in solution by electron spin echoes at X-band: a comparison with Tempone

We studied by electron spin echo pulse methods the spin relaxation properties of a phenyl nitronyl nitroxide radical (2-phenyl-4,4,5,5-tetramethylimidazoline-1-oxyl 3-oxide, PTIO) at X-band in fluid toluene solution in a wide temperature range, and in a water/glycerol 1:1 mixture near room temperature. The relaxation properties of PTIO have been compared with that of Tempone, as a widely used nitroxide. By a new procedure, based on experimental results on the temperature dependences of the relaxation times T(1) and T(2), and on the approximation of an isotropic brownian rotational diffusion, we separated non-secular, spin rotational and residual terms from the transverse relaxation rate to isolate secular and pseudosecular contributions. By comparing the results for the two radicals we found the differences in the magnetic properties that give rise to slower transverse (T(2)) and longitudinal (T(1)) electron spin relaxation for PTIO in the whole temperature range explored in this work.

Direct simulation of magnetic resonance relaxation rates and line shapes from molecular trajectories

We simulate spin relaxation processes, which may be measured by either continuous wave or pulsed magnetic resonance techniques, using trajectory-based simulation methodologies. The spin-lattice relaxation rates are extracted numerically from the relaxation simulations. The rates obtained from the numerical fitting of the relaxation curves are compared to those obtained by direct simulation from the relaxation Bloch-Wangsness-Abragam-Redfield theory (BWART). We have restricted our study to anisotropic rigid-body rotational processes, and to the chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) and a single spin-spin dipolar (END) coupling mechanisms. Examples using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) nitroxide and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) deuterium quadrupolar systems are provided. The objective is to compare those rates obtained by numerical simulations with the rates obtained by BWART. There is excellent agreement between the simulated and BWART rates for a Hamiltonian describing a single spin (an electron) interacting with the bath through the chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) mechanism undergoing anisotropic rotational diffusion. In contrast, when the Hamiltonian contains both the chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) and the spin-spin dipolar (END) mechanisms, the decay rate of a single exponential fit of the simulated spin-lattice relaxation rate is up to a factor of 0.2 smaller than that predicted by BWART. When the relaxation curves are fit to a double exponential, the slow and fast rates extracted from the decay curves bound the BWART prediction. An extended BWART theory, in the literature, includes the need for multiple relaxation rates and indicates that the multiexponential decay is due to the combined effects of direct and cross-relaxation mechanisms.

Multiple Pathway Relaxation Enhancement in the System Composed of Three Paramagnetic Species: Nitroxide Radical-Ln(3+)-O2

Longitudinal relaxation of nitroxide spin-labels has been measured for a membrane-incorporated α-helical polypeptide in the presence and absence of residual amounts of membrane-dissolved O2 and paramagnetic Dy(3+) ions. Such a model system, containing three different types of paramagnetic species, provides an important example of nonadditivity of two different relaxation channels for the nitroxide spins.

Spin labeling EPR

Site-directed spin labeling in combination with electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy has emerged as an efficient tool to elucidate the structure and conformational dynamics of biomolecules under native-like conditions. This article summarizes the basics as well as recent progress of site-directed spin labeling. Continuous wave EPR spectra analyses and pulse EPR techniques are reviewed with special emphasis on applications to the sensory rhodopsin-transducer complex mediating the photophobic response of the halophilic archaeum Natronomonas pharaonis and the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26.

Conformational equilibria of bulged sites in duplex DNA studied by EPR spectroscopy

Conformational flexibility in nucleic acids provides a basis for complex structures, binding, and signaling. One-base bulges directly neighboring single-base mismatches in nucleic acids can be present in a minimum of two distinct conformations, complicating the examination of the thermodynamics by calorimetry or UV-monitored melting techniques. To provide additional information about such structures, we demonstrate how electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) active spin-labeled base analogues, base-specifically incorporated into the DNA, are monitors of the superposition of different bulge-mismatch conformations. EPR spectra provide information about the dynamic environments of the probe. This information is cast in terms of "dynamic signatures" that have an underlying basis in structural variations. By examining the changes in the equilibrium of the different states across a range of temperatures, the enthalpy and entropy of the interconversion among possible conformations can be determined. The DNA constructs with a single bulge neighboring a single-base mismatch ("bulge-mismatches") may be approximately modeled as an equilibrium between two possible conformations. This structural information provides insight into the local composition of the bulge-mismatch sequences. Experiments on the bulge-mismatches show that basepairing across the helix can be understood in terms of purine and pyrimidine interactions, rather than specific bases. Measurements of the enthalpy and entropy of formation for the bulge-mismatches by differential scanning calorimetry and UV-monitored melting confirm that the formation of bulge-mismatches is in fact more complicated than a simple two-state process, consistent with the base-specific spectral data that bulge-mismatches exist in multiple conformations in the premelting temperature region. We find that the calculations with the nearest-neighbor (NN) model for the two likely conformations do not correlate well with the populations of structures and thermodynamic parameters inferred from the base-specific EPR dynamics probe. We report that the base-specific spin probes are able to identify a bistable, temperature dependent, switching between conformations for a particular complex bulged construct.

Microstrip resonators for electron paramagnetic resonance experiments

In this article we evaluate the performance of an electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) setup using a microstrip resonator (MR). The design and characterization of the resonator are described and parameters of importance to EPR and spin manipulation are examined, including cavity quality factor, filling factor, and microwave magnetic field in the sample region. Simulated microwave electric and magnetic field distributions in the resonator are also presented and compared with qualitative measurements of the field distribution obtained by a perturbation technique. Based on EPR experiments carried out with a standard marker at room temperature and a MR resonating at 8.17 GHz, the minimum detectable number of spins was found to be 5 x 10(10) spins/GHz(1/2) despite the low MR unloaded quality factor Q0=60. The functionality of the EPR setup was further evaluated at low temperature, where the spin resonance of Cr dopants present in a GaAs wafer was detected at 2.3 K. The design and characterization of a more versatile MR targeting an improved EPR sensitivity and featuring an integrated biasing circuit for the study of samples that require an electrical contact are also discussed.

Inertial rotation and matrix interaction effects on the EPR spectra of methyl radicals isolated in 'inert' cryogenic matrices

The CW-EPR lineshapes of methyl and small methyl-like radicals trapped in noble gas matrices at liquid He temperatures are substantially different from the expected classical EPR spectra. At low temperatures they show small or negligible anisotropy in studies using different experimental techniques and have a temperature dependence that differs from systems whose motional dynamics is diffusion controlled. At liquid He temperatures, before the Boltzmann statistics take over in the classical high temperature realm, the spectral intensities are dominated by quantum statistics. These properties, which were obtained experimentally at temperatures about 5 K and lower, and up to about 20 K, can be attributed to quantum effects of inertial rotary motion and its coupling to the nuclear spin of the radical. Methyl-like radicals have nuclear-exchange symmetry and contain the lightest possible isotopes, protons, and deuterons. In the ideal case of absent radical-matrix interaction, the methyl rotation about the central heavier carbon atom guaranties minimal moments of inertia. However, the theoretical interpretation of the above effects and other related quantum effects, as well as recognition of the important physics which lead to them, is not a simple matter. The literature accumulated on the subject over the years is successful but contains several unresolved questions. Recently obtained spectra of methyl radicals in Kr, N(2) and CO matrices, which are less inert than the smaller noble gas Ar, were shown to exhibit greater, but certainly slight, overall anisotropic spectral features while in earlier experimental studies the anisotropy was practically absent. Even gases of smaller radii such as Ne and H(2) at liquid He temperatures show interesting differences as hosts of methyl radicals compared to Ar. Investigation of other possible causes of this difference, not excluding the experimentally controlled ones related to the sample preparation and the MW power saturation of the CW-EPR measurement, were conducted in this work.

Site-directed spin labeling studies on nucleic acid structure and dynamics

Site-directed spin labeling (SDSL) uses electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to monitor the behavior of a stable nitroxide radical attached at specific locations within a macromolecule such as protein, DNA, or RNA. Parameters obtained from EPR measurements, such as internitroxide distances and descriptions of the rotational motion of a nitroxide, provide unique information on features near the labeling site. With recent advances in solid-phase synthesis of nucleic acids and developments in EPR methodologies, particularly pulsed EPR technologies, SDSL has been increasingly used to study the structure and dynamics of DNA and RNA at the level of the individual nucleotides. This chapter summarizes the current SDSL studies on nucleic acids, with discussions focusing on literature from the last decade.

A paramagnetic molecular voltmeter

We have developed a general electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) method to measure electrostatic potential at spin labels on proteins to millivolt accuracy. Electrostatic potential is fundamental to energy-transducing proteins like myosin, because molecular energy storage and retrieval is primarily electrostatic. Quantitative analysis of protein electrostatics demands a site-specific spectroscopic method sensitive to millivolt changes. Previous electrostatic potential studies on macromolecules fell short in sensitivity, accuracy and/or specificity. Our approach uses fast-relaxing charged and neutral paramagnetic relaxation agents (PRAs) to increase nitroxide spin label relaxation rate solely through collisional spin exchange. These PRAs were calibrated in experiments on small nitroxides of known structure and charge to account for differences in their relaxation efficiency. Nitroxide longitudinal (R(1)) and transverse (R(2)) relaxation rates were separated by applying lineshape analysis to progressive saturation spectra. The ratio of measured R(1) increases for each pair of charged and neutral PRAs measures the shift in local PRA concentration due to electrostatic potential. Voltage at the spin label is then calculated using the Boltzmann equation. Measured voltages for two small charged nitroxides agree with Debye-Hückel calculations. Voltage for spin-labeled myosin fragment S1 also agrees with calculation based on the pK shift of the reacted cysteine.

Explanation of spin-lattice relaxation rates of spin labels obtained with multifrequency saturation recovery EPR

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) pulsed saturation recovery (pSR) measurements of spin-lattice relaxation rates have been made on nitroxide-containing fatty acids embedded in lipid bilayers by Hyde and co-workers. The data have been collected for a number of spin-labeled fatty acids at several microwave spectrometer frequencies (from 2 to 35 GHz). We compare these spin-lattice relaxation rates to those predicted by the Redfield theory incorporating several mechanisms. The dominant relaxation mechanism at low spectrometer frequencies is the electron-nuclear dipolar (END) process, with spin rotation (SR), chemical shift anisotropy (CSA), and a generalized spin diffusion (GSD) mechanism all contributing. The use of a wide range of spectrometer frequencies makes clear that the dynamics cannot be modeled adequately by rigid-body isotropic rotational motion. The dynamics of rigid-body anisotropic rotational motion is sufficient to explain the experimental relaxation rates within the experimental error. More refined models of the motion could have been considered, and our analysis does not rule them out. However, the results demonstrate that measurements at only two suitably chosen spectrometer frequencies are sufficient to distinguish anisotropic from isotropic motion. The results presented demonstrate that the principal mechanisms responsible for anisotropically driven spin-lattice relaxation are well understood in the liquids regime.

Room-temperature electron spin dynamics in free-standing ZnO quantum dots

Conduction band electrons in colloidal ZnO quantum dots have been prepared photochemically and examined by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. Nanocrystals of 4.6 nm diameter containing single S-shell conduction band electrons have g(*)=1.962 and a room-temperature ensemble spin-dephasing time of T(2)(*)=25 ns, as determined from linewidth analysis. Increasing the electron population leads to increased g(*) and decreased T(2)(*), both associated with formation of P-shell configurations. A clear relationship between T(2)(*) and hyperfine coupling with 67Zn(I=5/2) is observed.

Electron paramagnetic resonance studies of magnetically aligned phospholipid bilayers utilizing a phospholipid spin label: The effect of cholesterol

X-band EPR spectroscopy has been employed to study the dynamic properties of magnetically aligned phospholipid bilayers (bicelles) utilizing a variety of phosphocholine spin labels (n-PCSL) as a function of cholesterol content. The utilization of both perpendicular and parallel aligned bicelles in EPR spectroscopy provides a more detailed structural and orientational picture of the phospholipid bilayers. The magnetically aligned EPR spectra of the bicelles and the hyperfine splitting values reveal that the addition of cholesterol increases the phase transition temperature and alignment temperature of the DMPC/DHPC bicelles. The corresponding molecular order parameter, Smol, of the DMPC/DHPC bicelles increased upon addition of cholesterol. Cholesterol also decreased the rotational motion and increased the degree of anisotropy in the interior region of the bicelles. This report reveals that the dynamic properties of DMPC/DHPC bicelles agree well with other model membrane systems and that the magnetically aligned bicelles are an excellent model membrane system.

Accessibility of nitroxide side chains: absolute Heisenberg exchange rates from power saturation EPR

In site-directed spin labeling, the relative solvent accessibility of spin-labeled side chains is taken to be proportional to the Heisenberg exchange rate (W(ex)) of the nitroxide with a paramagnetic reagent in solution. In turn, relative values of W(ex) are determined by continuous wave power saturation methods and expressed as a proportional and dimensionless parameter Pi. In the experiments presented here, NiEDDA is characterized as a paramagnetic reagent for solvent accessibility studies, and it is shown that absolute values of W(ex) can be determined from Pi, and that the proportionality constant relating them is independent of the paramagnetic reagent and mobility of the nitroxide. Based on absolute exchange rates, an accessibility factor is defined (0 < rho < 1) that serves as a quantitative measure of side-chain solvent accessibility. The accessibility factors for a nitroxide side chain at 14 different sites in T4 lysozyme are shown to correlate with a structure-based accessibility parameter derived from the crystal structure of the protein. These results provide a useful means for relating crystallographic and site-directed spin labeling data, and hence comparing crystal and solution structures.

Accessibility and dynamics of nitroxide side chains in T4 lysozyme measured by saturation recovery EPR

Long pulse saturation recovery electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy is applied to the investigation of spin-labeled side chains placed along a regular helix extending from 128 to 135 in T4 lysozyme. Under an argon atmosphere, analysis of the exponential saturation recovery curves gives the spin-lattice relaxation rates of the nitroxides, which depend on the nitroxide side-chain dynamics. In the presence of the fast-relaxing paramagnetic reagents O(2) or NiEDDA, global analysis of the saturation recovery provides the spin-lattice relaxation rates as well as the Heisenberg exchange rates of the nitroxide with the reagents. As previously shown with power saturation methods, such exchange rates are direct measures of the solvent accessibility of the nitroxide side chains in the protein structure. The periodic dependence of the spin-lattice relaxation rates and the exchange rates along the 128-135 sequence reveal the presence of the helical structure, demonstrating the use of these parameters in structure determination. In general, multiple exponentials are required to fit the saturation recovery data, thus identifying multiple states of the side chain. In one case, multiple conformations detected in the spectrum are not evident in the saturation recovery, suggesting rapid exchange on the timescale of spin-lattice relaxation.

A ruler for determining the position of proteins in membranes

Both the oxygen diffusion rate and the oxygen solubility vary with depth into the interior of biological membranes. The product of these two gradients generates a single gradient, a permeability gradient, which is a smooth continuous function of the distance from the center of the membrane. Using electron paramagnetic resonance and the spin-probe method, the relaxation gradient of oxygen, which is directly proportional to the permeability gradient, is the quantity that can be directly measured in membranes under physiological conditions. The gradient obtained provides a calibrated ruler for determining the membrane depth of residues either from loop regions of membrane-binding proteins or from the membrane-exposed residues of transmembrane proteins. We have determined the relaxation gradient of oxygen in zwitterionic and anionic phospholipid membranes by attaching a single nitroxide probe to a transmembrane alpha-helical polypeptide at specific residues. The peptide ruler was used to determine the depth of penetration of the calcium-binding loops of the C2 domain of cytosolic phospholipase A(2). The positions of selected residues of this membrane-binding protein that penetrate into the membrane, determined using this ruler, compared favorably with previous determinations using more complex methods. The relaxation gradient constrains the possible values of the membrane-dependent oxygen concentration and the oxygen diffusion gradients. The average oxygen diffusion coefficient is estimated to be at least 2-fold smaller in the membrane than that in water.