Ensworth A, Barlow L, Kozlowski P, MacMillan E, Laule C. The Goldilocks Zone for 3-T MRS Studies Using Semi-LASER: Determining the Optimal Balance Between Repetition Time and Scan Time.
NMR IN BIOMEDICINE 2025;
38:e70064. [PMID:
40432418 PMCID:
PMC12117354 DOI:
10.1002/nbm.70064]
[Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Key Words] [MESH Headings] [Grants] [Track Full Text] [Download PDF] [Figures] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 09/24/2024] [Revised: 05/03/2025] [Accepted: 05/06/2025] [Indexed: 05/29/2025]
Abstract
1H-MR spectroscopy studies often use a short TR to reduce scan time. However, this causes significant T1-weighting (T1w), which can alter metabolite estimates due to acquisition factors rather than biochemistry. Our goal was to determine the optimal balance between scan time and TR that minimizes T1w effects in semi-LASER MRS at 3 T. Spectra were acquired in the posterior cingulate cortex of five healthy volunteers (2 male/3 female, mean age 25 ± 2 years) and analyzed using FSL-MRS. The SNR and metabolite estimates of five metabolites were compared at TR = 2, 5, and 8 s, under conditions of "similar scan time" with varying acquisition numbers and "constant number of acquisitions" with varying scan times. T1 relaxation times derived from metabolite estimates were compared to literature. With a 25% longer scan time, SNRTR = 5s was 34% higher and SNRTR = 2s was 29% higher than SNRTR = 8s for data with "similar scan times." Using a TR = 5 s or longer, the SNR per minute is consistent for metabolites with T1s less than 2 s. Metabolite estimate trends were similar for the two different scenarios of "similar scan time" and "same number of acquisitions," where all metabolite estimates were obtained without metabolite T1 correction. The largest metabolite estimates were found at TR = 8 s, they were 10-15% lower at TR = 5 s and 15-30% lower at TR = 2 s. T1 values agreed with literature values. At TR = 2 s, SNR per minute and metabolite estimates were lower due to reduced signal availability via T1w effects. TR = 8 s had the least amount of T1w effects, but results in lower SNR per minute. TR = 5 s had enough signal recovery to be robust to T1w effects, and yielded the largest SNR for similar scan times, with a clinically feasible scan time of 5 m 40 s. Using semi-LASER MRS with a TR = 5 s is recommended to improve the sensitivity of MRS to changes in metabolite estimates.
Collapse