DYT1 mutations amongst adult primary dystonia patients in Singapore with review of literature comparing East and West

Investigating DYT1 in a Taiwanese dystonia cohort

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

A heterozygous three-nucleotide (GAG) in-frame deletion in the TOR1A gene causes the rare disease, dystonia (DYT1), which typically presents as focal limb dystonia during adolescence, then spreads to other limbs. This study investigated the frequency and clinical features of DYT1 in a Taiwanese dystonia cohort.

METHODS

We performed targeted next generation sequencing in 318 patients with primary dystonia. We identified one DYT1 family with various types of dystonia, and we described the clinical presentations observed in this family during a 30-year follow-up. We compared the clinical characteristics to those reported in previous studies on DYT1 from 2000 to 2020.

RESULTS

Among 318 patients, we identified only one DYT1 patient (0.3%) with an autosomal dominant family history of dystonia. The proband was a 43-year-old man that experienced progressive onset of focal lower limb dystonia from age 11 years. The disease spread caudal-rostrally to the upper limbs and cervical muscles. Prominent cervical dystonia was noted during follow-up, which was an atypical presentation of DYT1. Clinical assessments of other family members showed intrafamily variability. The proband's father and an affected sibling demonstrated only mild right-hand writer's cramp. A systematic review of previously reported DTY1 cases showed that Asian patients had a higher frequency of cervical dystonia (44.8%) than groups of Ashkenazi Jews (35%) and Non-Jewish Caucasians (30.5%) (P = 0.04).

CONCLUSION

Our findings revealed that DYT1 is rare in a Taiwanese dystonia cohort. The presentation of marked cervical dystonia could be the main feature of Asian patients with DYT1.

Genetic screening of THAP1 in primary dystonia patients of India

BACKGROUND

Primary Dystonia is a common movement disorder manifested by dystonic symptoms only. DYT6, a major genetic factor, plays a significant role in primary pure dystonia pathogenesis. In this study we analyzed THAP1 (DYT 6) gene in primary pure dystonia patients, which has been widely studied in other populations but not in Indians.

METHODS

The study cohort contained 227 index primary pure dystonia patients with the involvement of cervical region and 254 neurologically control individuals collected from East Indian population. All three exons of THAP1 and their flanking sequences, including exon-intron boundaries, were screened by PCR, DNA sequencing and/or RFLP analysis.

RESULTS

A total of three nucleotide variants were detected, which include a reported missense mutation (c.427 A>G; p.Met143Val) in a juvenile onset generalized dystonia patient, a novel frameshift deletion mutation (c.208-209 ΔAA; p.K70VfsX15) in a juvenile onset cervical dystonia patient and a rare variant in 3' UTR of THAP1 (c.*157 T>C) in an adult-onset blepharospasm patient. In addition, two SNPs (rs71521601 and rs111989331) were detected both in the patients and controls with the major allele of the latter being significantly over represented in the patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study suggests that the THAP1 is likely to have a causative role in the pathogenesis of Indian primary pure dystonia patients. Though the phenotypic spectrum is extensively diverse, the cervical involvement with dystonic tremor and speech problem is common amongst the patients harboring mutations.

The genetics of dystonia: new twists in an old tale

Dystonia is a common movement disorder seen by neurologists in clinic. Genetic forms of the disease are important to recognize clinically and also provide valuable information about possible pathogenic mechanisms within the wider disorder. In the past few years, with the advent of new sequencing technologies, there has been a step change in the pace of discovery in the field of dystonia genetics. In just over a year, four new genes have been shown to cause primary dystonia (CIZ1, ANO3, TUBB4A and GNAL), PRRT2 has been identified as the cause of paroxysmal kinesigenic dystonia and other genes, such as SLC30A10 and ATP1A3, have been linked to more complicated forms of dystonia or new phenotypes. In this review, we provide an overview of the current state of knowledge regarding genetic forms of dystonia—related to both new and well-known genes alike—and incorporating genetic, clinical and molecular information. We discuss the mechanistic insights provided by the study of the genetic causes of dystonia and provide a helpful clinical algorithm to aid clinicians in correctly predicting the genetic basis of various forms of dystonia.

Association of rs1182 polymorphism of the DYT1 gene with primary dystonia in Chinese population

BACKGROUND

The deletion mutation of glutamate codon (GAG) in the TOR1A gene is a major cause of primary generalized dystonia. Recent genetic studies suggest that the rs1182 polymorphism in the same gene may represent a risk factor for primary dystonia. However, this finding has been inconsistent. Furthermore, no data on such an association in a Chinese population have been published.

METHODS

A total of 291 patients with primary dystonia from the Department of Neurology, West China Hospital of Sichuan University were included. From the same region, 294 healthy individuals were recruited as a control group. The SNP was identified by polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism.

RESULTS

In the present study, focal dystonia was the most common presented form. No difference was found in the genotype frequency, minor allele frequencies, and "G" allele frequency between all dystonia patients and controls. No difference was found either, between early- and late-onset dystonia patients, patients with and without a positive family history, patients with pain and without pain, and patients with and without sensory trick. Moreover, no significant differences in the genotype and allele frequencies were found among different dystonia subtypes.

CONCLUSION

No association of the rs1182 of TOR1A with Chinese primary dystonia was found. More studies on such an association involving a larger number of participants, especially from Asian populations, are needed to confirm the present findings.

Clinical and genetic evaluation of DYT1 and DYT6 primary dystonia in China

BACKGROUND

Dystonia is defined as the presence of sustained involuntary muscle contractions, often leading to abnormal posture and movement. DYT1 is caused by a mutation in the TOR1A gene, whilst mutations in THAP1 gene have been identified as responsible for DYT6. The relative frequency and phenotype differences between DYT1 and DYT6 amongst Chinese primary dystonia patients have not been well-characterized.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

One hundred eleven unrelated Chinese patients with primary dystonia were screened for mutations in TOR1A and THAP1 genes, and correlate this with clinical presentation. Exon 5 of TOR1A and all three exons and exon-intron conjunctions in THAP1 were screened by direct sequencing.

RESULTS

Three subjects were found to have the GAG deletion in the TOR1A gene, and two patients were detected with THAP1 gene mutations/variations (c.224A>T, c.449A>C). The overall mutation frequency was 4.5% in this cohort with TOR1A mutations found in 2.7% and THAP1 mutations found in 1.8%. No mutations were detected in the controls composed of 100 normal Chinese subjects. The clinical presentations of the DYT1 cases included onset in the limbs that could progress to the generalized dystonia within several years but without cranial involvement. Whilst in the DYT6 cases, the onset was cranial or cervical and progresses very slowly.

CONCLUSION

The major clinical differences between DYT1 and DYT6 dystonia in China were the cranial involvement in DYT6 and progress to general dystonia within several years in DYT1.

Clinical feature and DYT1 mutation screening in primary dystonia patients from South-West China

BACKGROUND

Clinical presentation and DYT1 status amongst Chinese patients with primary dystonia have not been well studied.

METHODS

One hundred and twenty patients with primary dystonia from South-West China were studied in a prospective survey for 3.5 years. Severity and the resulting disability were assessed using the Burke-Fahn-Marsden dystonia rating scale (BFMDRS). Health related quality of life (HRQL) was measured through the 36-item short-form (SF-36). The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) was utilized to identify and quantify depression and anxiety. Mutations in the DYT1 exon 5 were screened by direct sequencing.

RESULTS

Cervical dystonia was found to be the most frequent form of focal dystonia and was discovered to occur at an early age. Pain and tremor were the common associated symptoms. Family history was positive in 19.5% of the cases, with a trend of earlier onset. Depression (14.5%) and anxiety (6.6%) were the main HRQL impairments. Multiple linear regression analysis suggested that gender, depression, anxiety and functional disability were amongst the principal determinants of lower HRQL. Only one instance of DYT1 GAG deletion (1.4%) was detected in 71 patients.

CONCLUSION

Our data on a cohort of Chinese patients show some difference from descriptions in other ethnic groups. This includes an earlier age of onset, a lower incidence of depression and female serving as a predictor factor of a HRQL. Similar to other cohorts, DYT1 gene mutations are rare.

Genetics and treatment of dystonia

The torsion dystonias encompass a broad collection of etiologic subtypes, often divided into primary and secondary classes. Tremendous advances have been made in uncovering the genetic basis of dystonia, including discovery of a gene causing early onset primary torsion dystonia-a GAG deletion in exon 5 of the DYT1 gene that encodes torsinA. Although the exact function of torsinA remains elusive, evidence suggests aberrant localization and interaction of mutated protein; this may result in an abnormal response to stress or interference with cytoskeletal events and the development of neuronal brain pathways. Breakthroughs include the discovery of a genetic modifier that protects against clinical expression in DYT1 dystonia and the identification of the gene causing DYT6, THAP1. The authors review genetic etiologies and discuss phenotypes as well as counseling of patients regarding prognosis and progression of the disease. They also address pharmacologic and surgical treatment options for various forms of dystonia.

High-throughput mutational analysis of TOR1A in primary dystonia

Background

Although the c.904_906delGAG mutation in Exon 5 of TOR1A typically manifests as early-onset generalized dystonia, DYT1 dystonia is genetically and clinically heterogeneous. Recently, another Exon 5 mutation (c.863G>A) has been associated with early-onset generalized dystonia and some ΔGAG mutation carriers present with late-onset focal dystonia. The aim of this study was to identify TOR1A Exon 5 mutations in a large cohort of subjects with mainly non-generalized primary dystonia.

Methods

High resolution melting (HRM) was used to examine the entire TOR1A Exon 5 coding sequence in 1014 subjects with primary dystonia (422 spasmodic dysphonia, 285 cervical dystonia, 67 blepharospasm, 41 writer's cramp, 16 oromandibular dystonia, 38 other primary focal dystonia, 112 segmental dystonia, 16 multifocal dystonia, and 17 generalized dystonia) and 250 controls (150 neurologically normal and 100 with other movement disorders). Diagnostic sensitivity and specificity were evaluated in an additional 8 subjects with known ΔGAG DYT1 dystonia and 88 subjects with ΔGAG-negative dystonia.

Results

HRM of TOR1A Exon 5 showed high (100%) diagnostic sensitivity and specificity. HRM was rapid and economical. HRM reliably differentiated the TOR1A ΔGAG and c.863G>A mutations. Melting curves were normal in 250/250 controls and 1012/1014 subjects with primary dystonia. The two subjects with shifted melting curves were found to harbor the classic ΔGAG deletion: 1) a non-Jewish Caucasian female with childhood-onset multifocal dystonia and 2) an Ashkenazi Jewish female with adolescent-onset spasmodic dysphonia.

Conclusion

First, HRM is an inexpensive, diagnostically sensitive and specific, high-throughput method for mutation discovery. Second, Exon 5 mutations in TOR1A are rarely associated with non-generalized primary dystonia.

DYT1 mutations in early onset primary torsion dystonia and Parkinson disease patients in Chinese populations

Torsion dystonia is an autosomal dominant movement disorder characterized by involuntary, repetitive muscle contractions and twisted postures. The most severe early onset form of dystonia has been linked to mutations in the human DYT1 (TOR1A) gene encoding a protein termed torsinA. Moreover, dystonia and Parkinson disease share the common feature of reduced dopamine neurotransmission in the striatum, so we assumed that mutations in the DYT1 gene might have the same role in cases of early onset primary torsion dystonia (EOPTD) and early onset Parkinson disease (EOPD) that present dystonia. In this present study, 17 patients with EOPTD, 221 patients with EOPD and 164 control subjects were screened for mutations of the DYT1 gene by denaturing high performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC), polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) analysis and DNA sequencing. Our results showed that the GAG deletion was identified in 7 EOPTD patients, which results in Glu302del of DYT1 gene. No mutations were found in EOPD patients and control subjects. By carefully reviewing the available literature on studies of sporadic, non-Ashkenazi Jewish populations, the results showed that the prevalence rate of DYT1 mutation was not significantly different (p=0.267) between European (27.3%) and Asian (22.2%) patients with early onset primary torsion dystonia.