Implication of the SH3TC2 gene in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease associated with deafness and/or scoliosis: Illustration with four new pathogenic variants

Neuropathy due to bi-allelic SH3TC2 variants: genotype-phenotype correlation and natural history

Recessive SH3TC2 variants cause Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 4C (CMT4C). CMT4C is typically a sensorimotor demyelinating polyneuropathy, marked by early onset spinal deformities, but its clinical characteristics and severity are quite variable. Clear relationships between pathogenic variants and the spectrum of disease manifestations are to date lacking. Gene replacement therapy has been shown to ameliorate the phenotype in a mouse model of CMT4C, emphasizing the need for natural history studies to inform clinical trial readiness. Data, including both genetic information and clinical characteristics, were compiled from the longitudinal, prospective dataset of the Inherited Neuropathy Consortium, a member of the Rare Diseases Clinical Research Network (INC-RDCRN). The Charcot Marie Tooth Neuropathy Score (CMTNS), Examination Score (CMTES) and the Rasch-weighted CMTES (CMTES-R) were used to describe symptoms, neurological examinations and neurophysiological characteristics. Standardized response means were calculated at yearly intervals and a mixed model for repeated measures was used to estimate the change in CMTES and CMTES-R over time. Fifty-six individuals (59% female), median age 27 years (range 2-67 years) with homozygous or compound heterozygous variants in SH3TC2 were identified, including 34 unique variants, 14 of which have not previously been published. Twenty-eight participants had longitudinal data available. While there was no significant difference in the CMTES in those with protein truncating versus non-protein truncating variants, there were significant differences in the mean ulnar nerve compound muscle action potential amplitude, the mean radial sensory nerve action potential amplitude, and in the prevalence of scoliosis, suggesting the possibility of a milder phenotype in individuals with one or two non-protein-truncating variants. Overall, the mean value of the CMTES was 13, reflecting moderate clinical severity. There was a high rate of scoliosis (81%), scoliosis surgery (36%), and walking difficulty (94%) among study participants. The CMTES and CMTES-R appeared moderately responsive to change over extended follow-up, demonstrating a standardized response mean of 0.81 standard deviation units or 0.71 standard deviation units, respectively, over 3 years. Our analysis represents the largest cross-sectional and only longitudinal study to date, of the clinical phenotype of both adults and children with CMT4C. With the promise of upcoming genetic treatments, these data will further define the natural history of the disease and inform study design in preparation for clinical trials.

Characterisation of Patients with SH3TC2 Associated Neuropathy in an Indian Cohort

Background

SH3TC2 variations lead to demyelinating recessive Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) disease, which is commonly associated with early-onset scoliosis and cranial neuropathy. Data from Indian ethnicity is limited.

Objective

We aim to report the characteristics of patients with SH3TC2-associated neuropathy from an Indian cohort.

Patients and Methods

Data of five unrelated subjects with SH3TC2 variations were analyzed.

Results

Clinical features included female predominance (n = 4), early-onset neuropathy (n = 2), pes cavus and hammer toes (n = 4), kyphoscoliosis (n = 1), impaired vision and hearing (n = 1), facial muscle weakness (n = 1), impaired kinaesthetic sense (n = 3), tremor (n = 2), and ataxia (n = 1). Four patients had the "CMT" phenotype, while one patient had Roussy-Levy syndrome. All had demyelinating electrophysiology with conduction velocities being "very slow" in one, "slow" in one, "mildly slow" in two, and "intermediate" in one patient. Brain stem auditory evoked potentials were universally abnormal though only one patient had symptomatic deafness. Seven variants were identified in SH3TC2 [homozygous = 3 (c.1412del, c.69del, c.3152G>A), heterozygous = 4 (c.1105C>T, c.3511C>T, c.2028G>C, c.254A>T)]. Except for c.3511C>T variant, the rest were novel. Three patients had additional variations in genes having pathobiological relevance in other CMTs or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.

Conclusion

We provide data on a cohort of patients of Indian origin with SH3TC2 variations and highlight differences from other cohorts. Though the majority were not symptomatic for hearing impairment, evoked potentials disclosed abnormalities in all. Further studies are required to establish the functional consequences of novel variants and their interacting molecular partners identified in the present study to strengthen their association with the phenotype.

Evaluation of Pathogenicity and Causativity of Variants in the MPZ and SH3TC2 Genes in a Family Case of Hereditary Peripheral Neuropathy

The implementation of NGS methods into clinical practice allowed researchers effectively to establish the molecular cause of a disorder in cases of a genetically heterogeneous pathology. In cases of several potentially causative variants, we need additional analysis that can help in choosing a proper causative variant. In the current study, we described a family case of hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy (HMSN) type 1 (Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease). DNA analysis revealed two variants in the SH3TC2 gene (c.279G>A and c.1177+5G>A), as well as a previously described variant c.449-9C>T in the MPZ gene, in a heterozygous state. This family segregation study was incomplete because of the proband's father's unavailability. To evaluate the variants' pathogenicity, minigene splicing assay was carried out. This study showed no effect of the MPZ variant on splicing, but the c.1177+5G>A variant in the SH3TC2 gene leads to the retention of 122 nucleotides from intron 10 in the RNA sequence, causing a frameshift and an occurrence of a premature stop codon (NP_078853.2:p.Ala393GlyfsTer2).

From Negative to Positive Diagnosis: Structural Variation Could Be the Second Mutation You Are Looking for in a Recessive Autosomal Gene

Next-generation sequencing (NGS) allows the detection of plentiful mutations increasing the rate of patients getting a positive diagnosis. However, while single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) or small indels can be easily detected, structural variations (SVs) such as copy number variants (CNVs) are often not researched. In Charcot–Marie–Tooth disease (CMT), the most common hereditary peripheral neuropathy, the PMP22-duplication was the first variation detected. Since then, more than 90 other genes have been associated with CMT, with point mutations or small indels mostly described. Herein, we present a personalized approach we performed to obtain a positive diagnosis of a patient suffering from demyelinating CMT. His NGS data were aligned to the human reference sequence but also studied using the CovCopCan software, designed to detect large CNVs. This approach allowed the detection of only one mutation in SH3TC2, the frequent p.Arg954*, while SH3TC2 is known to be responsible for autosomal recessive demyelinating CMT forms. Interestingly, by modifying the standard CovCopCan use, we detected the second mutation of this patient corresponding to a 922 bp deletion in SH3TC2 (Chr5:148,390,609-Chr5:148,389,687), including only one exon (exon 14). This highlights that SVs, different from PMP22 duplication, can be responsible for peripheral neuropathy and should be searched systematically. This approach could also be employed to improve the diagnosis of all inherited diseases.

A Search for Undiagnosed Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease Among Patients Registered with Unspecified Polyneuropathy in the Danish National Patient Registry

Purpose

In a recent study based on data from the Danish National Patients Registry (DNPR), we reported the prevalence of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) in Denmark to be 22.5 per 100.000. This prevalence is most likely a minimum estimate, as many cases of CMT may be misdiagnosed or remain undiagnosed due to the heterogeneous nature of the disorder. The aim of this study was to investigate the possible number of undiagnosed CMT cases among patients registered with unspecified polyneuropathy (UP) diagnoses in the DNPR.

Patients and Methods

From the DNPR we extracted data on all patients given an UP diagnosis in the period 1977 to 2012. We selected all patients diagnosed with a primary UP diagnosis before age 40 at a department of neurology, neurophysiology, clinical genetics or pediatrics, and excluded all patients with a specified polyneuropathy diagnosis or with diagnostic codes related to alcohol and diabetes mellitus. To assess the proportion of possible CMT patients, we performed medical record review in a random sample of patients diagnosed in the Central Denmark Region. To further investigate the possible overlap between UP and CMT in the DNPR, we performed a series of searches for ICD-8 and ICD-10 codes related to CMT.

Results

Between 1977 and 2012, 30.903 patients were diagnosed with UP without also being diagnosed with CMT. A total of 940 patients fulfilled the selection criteria. We found that 21.5% (95% CI 13.1%–32.2%) of the cases in the random sample fulfilled our criteria for CMT. This estimate increases the prevalence of CMT in Denmark with 3.6 per 100,000 (95% CI 2.4%–5.5%).

Conclusion

This study illustrates how hitherto undiagnosed CMT patients may be identified in the DNPR and further reports the number of possible CMT cases. Our results support the hypothesis that the true prevalence of CMT is higher than recently reported.