A comparison of two different navigated hip replacement techniques on leg length discrepancy

The effectiveness and influencing factors of the "Y" line technique in reducing the leg length discrepancy after total hip arthroplasty

Objective

To introduce a surgical technique (the "Y" line technique) that will control leg length discrepancy (LLD) after total hip arthroplasty and to observe its effectiveness and influencing factors.

Methods

According to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, a total of 350 patients were selected in this study; 134 patients in whom used the "Y" line technique was used to control lower limb length were included in Group A and 166 patients treated with freehand methods to control lower limb length were included in Group B. A total of 50 patients in whom the standard anteroposterior x-ray of bilateral hips was taken preoperatively and in whom the "Y" line technique was used during the operation were included in Group C.

Results

The postoperative LLD of Group A was 4.74 mm (3.93), that of Group B was 5.85 mm (4.60), and that of Group C was 2 mm (1.00)-the difference was statistically significant (p < 0.001). There were significant statistical differences when comparisons were made between any two groups (p < 0.01). The distribution of postoperative LLD in Group A was better than that in Group B, and this factor was better in Group C than in Group A-the difference was statistically significant (p < 0.001). Severe unequal length rates of the lower extremities (LLD > 10 mm) were 5.97% (8/134) in Group A, 14.3% (24/166) in Group B, and 0% (0/50) in Group C-the difference was statistically significant (p < 0.001). There were significant differences between Group A and Group B and between Group B and Group C (p < 0.05), but there was no significant difference between Group A and Group C (p = 0.078).

Conclusion

The "Y" line technique, which does not increase the operating time and patient cost, can effectively reduce postoperative LLD. Insufficient internal rotation of the healthy lower extremity and the low projection position in the preoperative anteroposterior x-ray of the bilateral hips were important factors affecting the accuracy of the "Y" line technique.

Anatomical Mapping of the External Obturator Footprint: A Study In Cadavers with Implications for Direct Anterior THA

BACKGROUND

The external obturator footprint in the trochanteric fossa has been suggested as a potential landmark for stem depth in direct anterior THA. Its upper border can be visualized during surgical exposure of the femur. A recent study reported that the height of the tendon has little variability (6.4 ± 1.4 mm) as measured on CT scans and that the trochanteric fossa is consistently visible on conventional pelvic radiographs. However, it is unclear where exactly the footprint of this tendon should be templated during preoperative planning so that it can be useful intraoperatively.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

In this study, we sought: (1) to provide instructions on exactly where to template the external obturator footprint on a preoperative planning radiograph, and (2) to confirm the small variability in height of the external obturator footprint found on CT scans in a cadaver study.

METHODS

Two-dimensional (2-D) and three-dimensional (3-D) imaging was used to map the anatomy of the external obturator footprint. This dual approach was chosen because of their complementarity; conventional 2-D radiographs translate to clinical practice but 3-D navigation-based digitalization combined with CT allows for a better understanding of the cortical lines that comprise the outline of the trochanteric fossa. In 12 (four males, mean age 80 years, range 69 to 88) formalin-treated cadaveric lower extremities including the pelvis, the external obturator tendon was dissected, and the top and bottom end of its footprint marked with two small needles, and calibrated radiographs were taken. For another five (three males, mean age 75.7 years, range 61 to 91) fresh-frozen cadaveric lower extremities, including femoral reflective marker frames, CT scans were obtained and the exact location of the external obturator footprint was recorded using 3-D navigation-based digitalization. Qualitative analysis of both imaging modalities was used to develop instructions on where the external obturator footprint should be templated on a preoperative planning radiograph. Quantitative analysis of the dimensions of the external obturator footprint was performed.

RESULTS

The lowest point of the external obturator footprint was consistently found (± 1 mm) at the intersection of the vertical line comprised of the lateral wall of the trochanteric fossa and the oblique line formed by the intertrochanteric crest and therefore allows templating of this structure on the preoperative planning radiograph. The median (range) height of the footprint measured 6.4 mm and demonstrated small variability (4.7 to 7.6).

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest templating a 6.4-mm circle with its bottom on the intersection described above.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The distance between the templated shoulder of the stem and the top of the circle can be used intraoperatively for guidance. Discrepancy should lead to re-evaluation of stem depth and leg length. Future work will investigate the usability, validity, and reliability of the proposed methodology in daily clinical practice.