Ethical and legal implications of genetic testing in androgen insensitivity syndrome

Late diagnosis of complete androgen insensitivity syndrome and transmission/carriers of the condition in a family with mutation c.2495G> T p.(Arg832Leu) in exon 7 of the androgen receptor gene: genetic, clinical and ethical aspects

BACKGROUND

The complete androgen insensitivity syndrome (CAIS) is a rare genetic disorder causing insensitivity to androgens in a person with female phenotype and 46,XY karyotype due to a mutation in the androgen receptor gene located on chromosome X. These children are born with female external genitalia, and females are transmitters.

CASE REPORT

We illustrate an unexpected diagnosis of CAIS in two siblings during examination for short stature, and describe transmission/carriers in the family along with ethical aspects.

CONCLUSION

A genetic examination could have earlier revealed the transmission of c.2495G>Tp.(Arg832Leu) mutation in exon 7. Our experience highlights the possibility of prenatal testing for the management of pregnancy in a family with a history of CAIS. The implications of prenatal testing in relation to CAIS with clearer explication of ethical and clinical issues warrant further investigation.

Inguinal hernia as a presentation of testicular feminization

We present a case of a 20-year-old female who was admitted to our department for an elective inguinal hernia repair. An oval-shaped mass was found in the hernia sac during the surgery that was suspected to be an ovary. Histological examination revealed testicular tissue. Further evaluation confirmed testicular feminization. She underwent laparoscopic orchiectomy and hernia repair from the contralateral side 3 months later.

Complete androgen insensitivity syndrome: diagnosis and management

Complete androgen insensitivity syndrome (CAIS) is an X-linked genetic disorder affecting 46,XY individuals, characterized by the loss of function of the androgen receptor gene resulting in complete peripheral androgen resistance. Patients have a nonambiguous female phenotype with normal female external genitalia. Gonads are undescended testes (either intra-abdominal or inguinal), there is no uterus and the length of the vagina is usually very short. Gender identity is always female. This review focuses on the importance of accurate diagnosis of CAIS versus partial androgen insensitivity syndrome and other disorders of sex development by genotyping the androgen receptor, and raises issues of the optimal management of these patients. In the era of the Consensus Statement on Management of Intersex Disorders, we provide new insights into CAIS screening, surgical management of the gonads (balancing between hormonal production and malignancy risk) and of vaginal adequacy, and the ethics concerned with the disclosure to patients and their families.