Comparison of variables affecting the surgical outcomes of tubularized incised plate urethroplasty in adult and pediatric hypospadias

"What should be next in lifelong posterior hypospadias: Conclusions from the 2023 ERN eUROGEN and EJP-RD networking meeting"

BACKGROUND

A congenital disease is for life. Posterior hypospadias, the severe form of hypospadias with a penoscrotal, scrotal, or perineal meatus, is a challenging condition with a major impact on lifelong quality of life.

AIM

Our network meeting is aimed to identify what is currently missing in the lifelong treatment of posterior hypospadias, to improve care, quality of life, and awareness for these patients.

METHODS

The network meeting "Lifelong Posterior Hypospadias" in Utrecht, The Netherlands was granted by the European Joint Programme on Rare Diseases-Networking Support Scheme. There was a combination of interactive sessions (hackathons) and lectures. This paper can be regarded as the last phase of the hackathon.

RESULTS

Surgery for hypospadias remains challenging and complications may occur until adulthood. Posterior hypospadias affects sexual function, fertility, and hormonal status. Transitional care from childhood into adulthood is currently insufficiently established. Patients should be more involved in defining desired treatment approach and outcome measures. For optimal outcome evaluation standardization of data collection and registration at European level is necessary. Tissue engineering may provide a solution to the shortage of healthy tissue in posterior hypospadias. For optimal results, cooperation between basic researchers from different centers, as well as involving clinicians and patients is necessary.

CONCLUSIONS

To improve outcomes for patients with posterior hypospadias, patient voices should be included and lifelong care by dedicated healthcare professionals guaranteed. Other requirements are joining forces at European level in uniform registration of outcome data and cooperation in basic research.

Trilayer composite scaffold for urethral reconstruction:in vitroevaluation of mechanical, biological, and angiogenic properties

Regeneration of damaged urethral tissue remains a major challenge in the field of lower urinary tract reconstruction. To address this issue, various synthetic and natural biodegradable biomaterials are currently being explored for the fabrication of scaffolds that promote urethral regeneration and healing. In this study, we present an approach to fabricate a trilayer hybrid scaffold comprising a central layer of poly(lactic acid) (PLA) between two layers of chitosan. The chitosan/PLA/chitosan (CPC) scaffolds were fabricated by a sequential electrospinning process and their properties were evaluated for their suitability for urethral tissue engineering. The physical and biological properties of the CPC scaffolds were evaluated in comparison to electrospun PLA scaffolds and acellular dermis (Alloderm) as controls for a synthetic and a natural scaffold, respectively. Compared to the controls, the CPC scaffolds exhibited higher elastic modulus and ultimate tensile strength, while maintaining extensibility and suture retention strength appropriate for clinical use. The CPC scaffolds displayed significant hydrophilicity, which was associated with a higher water absorption capacity of the chitosan nanofibres. The degradation products of the CPC scaffolds did not exhibit cytotoxicity and promoted wound closure by fibroblastsin vitro. In addition, CPC scaffolds showed increased growth of smooth muscle cells, an essential component for functional regeneration of urethral tissue. Furthermore, in a chicken embryo-based assay, CPC scaffolds demonstrated significantly higher angiogenic potential, indicating their ability to promote vascularisation, a crucial aspect for successful urethral reconstruction. Overall, these results suggest that CPC hybrid scaffolds containing both natural and synthetic components offer significant advantages over conventional acellular or synthetic materials alone. CPC scaffolds show promise as potential candidates for further research into the reconstruction of the urethrain vivo.

Comparative outcomes among inlay grafted incised plate, onlay preputial flap and tubularized incised plate urethroplasty for the repair of distal penile hypospadias with a narrow urethral plate

PURPOSE

We conducted this study, comparing the outcomes among Transverse Onlay Island Flap, inlay grafted incised plate and our previous records of tubularized incised plate urethroplasty (TIPU) in patients with narrow urethral plates, aiming to determine which method of repair provides a good outcome.

METHODS

This hybrid study included two datasets. The first from a prospective randomized study evaluating outcomes of two treatment modalities; Inlay graft and only flap for distal hypospadias with shallow urethral plate with 80 patients (40 patients in each group) included, the second based on our previous records of TIPU in 40 patients with distal primary hypospadias with narrow urethral plate.

RESULTS

The success rate in inlay graft urethroplasty group (n = 40) was 87.5%; glandular dehiscence occurred in one case (2.5%), fistulas occurred in 2 cases (5%), and narrow meatus occurred in two cases (5%). Success rate in onlay flap urethroplasty group (n = 40) was 82.5%; glandular dehiscence occurred in two cases (5%), fistulas occurred in two cases (5%), and narrow meatus occurred in three cases (7.5%). TIPU group (n = 40) had success rate of 62.5%; glandular dehiscence occurred in eight cases (20%), fistulas occurred in five cases (12.5%), and narrow meatus occurred in seven cases (17.5%), with five cases exhibiting both narrow meatus with fistula.

CONCLUSION

Inlay graft and onlay flap urethroplasty for repair of distal penile hypospadias with narrow urethral plate had higher success rate and fewer complications than traditional TIPU. Moreover, operative time was shorter in TIPU.

Deep learning based automated quantification of urethral plate characteristics using the plate objective scoring tool (POST)

INTRODUCTION

The plate objective scoring tool (POST) was recently introduced as a reproducible and precise approach to quantifying urethral plate (UP) characteristics and guide to selecting particular surgical techniques. However, defining the landmarks mandatory for the POST score from captured images can potentially leads to variability. Although artificial intelligence (AI) is yet to be wholly accepted and explored in hypospadiology, it has certainly brought new possibilities to light.

OBJECTIVES

To explore the capacity of deep learning algorithm to further streamline and optimize UP characteristics appraisal on 2D images using the POST, aiming to increase the objectivity and reproducibility of UP appraisal in hypospadias repair.

METHODS

The five key POST landmarks were marked by specialists in a 691-image dataset of prepubertal boys undergoing primary hypospadias repair. This dataset was then used to develop and validate a deep learning-based landmark detection model. The proposed framework begins with glans localization and detection, where the input image is cropped using the predicted bounding box. Next, a deep convolutional neural network (CNN) architecture is used to predict the coordinates of the five POST landmarks. These predicted landmarks are then used to assess UP characteristics in distal hypospadias.

RESULTS

The proposed model accurately localized the glans area, with a mean average precision (mAP) of 99.5% and an overall sensitivity of 99.1%. A normalized mean error (NME) of 0.07152 was achieved in predicting the coordinates of the landmarks, with a mean squared error (MSE) of 0.001 and a 2.5% failure rate at a threshold of 0.2 NME.

DISCUSSION

Our results support the possibility of further standardizing UP assessment from captured hypospadias images, and the use of machine learning algorithms and image recognition shows that these novel artificial intelligence technologies are useful for scoring hypospadias. External validation can provide valuable information on the generalizability and reliability of deep learning algorithms, which can aid in assessments, decision-making and predictions for surgical outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

This deep learning application shows robustness and high precision in using POST to appraise UP characteristics. Further assessment using international multi-centre image-based databases is ongoing.

Risk factors for postoperative complications in children with proximal hypospadias with severe chordee who underwent urethral plate transection

OBJECTIVES

To identify the risk factors associated with developing complications after transection of the urethral plate for proximal hypospadias with severe chordee.

METHODS

We used a prospective database to identify patients with proximal hypospadias and severe chordee who underwent transection of the urethral plate and primary hypospadias repair in 2011 and 2021. All patients underwent urethroplasty with a follow-up period of >12 months. The association between variables (age, surgical technique, length of urethral defect, and surgeon volume) and postoperative complications (fistulas, urethral strictures, diverticula and glans dehiscence) was analyzed.

RESULTS

Altogether, 493 patients were included, of whom 133 (26.9%) had postoperative complications. Univariate and multivariate analyses revealed that the preoperative proximal meatal position, one-stage repair, longer urethral defect length, and low surgeon volume were significant risk factors for postoperative complications with proximal hypospadias with severe chordee who underwent transection of the urethral plate. A urethral defect length of ≥4.55 cm was considered the best cutoff value for predicting postoperative complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Preoperative proximal meatal location, one-stage repair, longer urethral defect length, and low surgeon volume were associated with postoperative complications in patients with proximal hypospadias with severe chordee who underwent transection of the urethral plate. A urethral defect length of ≥4.55 cm was significantly associated with the development of complications.

Urethral complex thickness and thickness index are the independent risk factors for urethroplasty complications after tubularized incised plate hypospadias repair

INTRODUCTION

In tubularized incised plate urethroplasty, the depth of the mid-line relaxing incision is the key factor for urethral plate tubularization without tension. The incision depths will be different from one case to the other even if they have been done by the same surgeon. This difference in depths resulted from the different thicknesses of the urethral plate and the underlying corpus spongiosum (urethral complex).

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the urethral complex thickness and thickness index as risk factors for the complications of TIPU in penile shaft hypospadias repair.

STUDY DESIGN

All primary penile shaft (distal and mid-penile) hypospadias (with or without mild penile chordee) were operated with TIPU between March 2018 and February 2021. We measured the urethral complex thickness in the hypospadiac and proximal normal parts of urethra pre-operatively with superficial U/S probe. Intraoperative, we measured the urethral plate width before and after the midline relaxing incision, calculate the relative increase in urethral plate width (RIUPW). Stepwise logistic regression assessed the effect of different variables on the complication rate. These variables include; urethral plate width before and after incision, urethral complex thickness, thickness index, RIUPW, site of hypospadiac meatus and patients ages.

RESULTS

10 cases had 11 complications (12.7%). Fistulae were the commonest complication (8.9%). Complication rate has significant negative correlations with many variables on Univariate analysis. Stepwise logistic regression shows that urethral plate thickness and thickness index are the independent risk factors for complications after TIPU in penile shaft hypospadias.

DISCUSSION

Urethral plate width was suggested to be a risk factor for TIPU complications. In our study, Univariate analysis shows that complications were more with plate width ˂8 mm but without significant difference (P = 0.487). Also it shows that post incision width and RIUPW have significant negative correlation with complications rate. Multivariate analysis showed that the urethral complex thickness and thickness index are the independent risk factors for complications after TIPU hypospadias repair (AUC 0.94 95% CI 0.894-0.972 P ˂ 0.001 and 0.965 95% CI 0.921-0.996, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The thickness of the urethral plate and the underlying spongiosum is the determining factor for TIPU success. We can use it as an objective reproducible assessment tool for urethral plate quality and to predict TIPU complications.

Predictors of successful outcome of tubularized incised plate for primary distal hypospadias repair

Background

Several preoperative factors affect the outcome of Tabularized Incised Plate (TIP) repair. Our aim was to collect and analyze all these factors to define what the most important predictive factors are.

Methods

Hundred patients (1–5 years old) with primary distal hypospadias were included. Exclusion criteria included previous penile operations and hormonal treatment or associated congenital anomalies. Anogenital distance (AGD), stretched penile length (SPL), meatal site, glanular shape, chordee and torsion degree, plate width and glans meatus shaft (GMS) score were assessed. TIP repair was done to all patients and followed up for one year. The outcome was correlated with the above parameters.

Results

Mean ± SD of age of patients was 3.5 ± 1.5 years, while weight was 14.1 ± 3.0 kg. Complication rate was 18% including urethrocutaneous fistula (UCF) and meatal stenosis 14%, repair breakdown 1% and urethral stricture 3%. Patients with chordee degree < 30° and distal penile meatal location were associated with increased risk for complications by 11.6 and 8.2 times; 95% CI was (1.46–91.75) and (1.02–66.52), respectively (p < 0.05 for each). Plate width ≥ 9 mm, AGD > 5 cm, GMS score ≤ 7 (p < 0.001 for each), age of patient ≤ 2 years old, and SPL > 3.5 cm (p < 0.01 for each) were associated with successful outcome of repair.

Conclusion

The proposed successful criteria of TIP repair were absent chordee, coronal/subcoronal penile meatal location, plate width ≥ 9 mm, AGD > 5 cm, age of patient ≤ 2 years old, GMS score ≤ 7, SPL > 3.5 cm and grooved glanular shape.

Concomitant repair of meatal stenosis and urethral fistula does not increase the risk of fistula recurrence post-hypospadias surgery

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate whether meatal stenosis treated concomitantly with urethral fistula repair alters the results of fistula closure.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study, included were all children who underwent local fistula closure following hypospadias repair between 2006-2017. Patients who underwent reoperative urethroplasty were excluded. Data were extracted from electronic records, and missing data were supplied by telephone interviews. Characteristics of patients and fistulas were compared between children who underwent fistula closure only and those who underwent meatoplasty for meatal stenosis during the same surgery. The primary endpoint was fistula recurrence.

RESULTS

In total, 106 local repairs of urethrocutaneous fistulas were performed during the study period, and 25 of them included concomitant meatoplasty for meatal stenosis. There was no difference in terms of location, size, and number of fistulas or the number of recurrent fistulas between the 81 patients who underwent fistula closure only and the 25 who underwent concomitant meatoplasty. The fistula recurrence rate was 17/81 (21%) for the fistula only group and 5/25 (20%) for the fistula and meatoplasty group after a median follow-up of 7 and 8 years, respectively. Meatoplasty was required in a subsequent procedure in 5/81 in the former group vs. 3/25 patients in the latter group.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence and repair of meatal stenosis does not alter the recurrence rate of urethrocutaneous fistulas repaired concomitantly following hypospadias repair.

Urethral plate quality assessment and its impact on hypospadias repair outcomes: A systematic review and quality assessment

BACKGROUND

The variability of the urethral plate (UP) characteristics is one of the factors that influence technical choices for hypospadias correction. However, it is difficult to objectively evaluate the UP, leading to controversies in this subject, and vague terms utilized in the literature to describe its characteristics.

OBJECTIVE

We aim to analyze the previously described methods used to characterize and evaluate UP quality, emphasizing the pros and cons of each system, and highlighting its possible influence on different postoperative outcomes.

METHODS

We searched the databases PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library CENTRAL from January 1, 2000 to August 20, 2020. The following concepts were searched: urethra reconstruction/urethra replacement/urethroplasty AND hypospadias/hypospadias, AND children AND "plate" with the gray literature search. Subgroup analyses were also carried out. The quality of the involved studies was reviewed operating a modified version of the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS).

RESULTS

996 citations perceived as relevant to screening were retrieved. Thirteen studies were included comprising a total of 1552 cases. The number of patients in each study varied between 42 and 442, and the average post-surgical follow-up duration ranged between 6 months and twenty-six months. All studies used postoperative urethral stents of variable sizes and types. The impact of UP was most frequently assessed for cases treated with the tubularized incised plate (TIP) repair.

CONCLUSION

The UP quality seems to play a role as an independent factor influencing postoperative outcomes of hypospadias repair. Currently used strategies for the appraisal of UP quality are highly subjective with a low index of generalizability. Various attempts to overcome these limitations exist but none was consistently accepted, leaving a wide space for creative investigation in order to obtain an objective, reproducible, precise, and well-validated tool.

Creation of Tissue-Engineered Urethras for Large Urethral Defect Repair in a Rabbit Experimental Model

Introduction: Tissue engineering is a potential source of urethral substitutes to treat severe urethral defects. Our aim was to create tissue-engineered urethras by harvesting autologous cells obtained by bladder washes and then using these cells to create a neourethra in a chronic large urethral defect in a rabbit model. Methods: A large urethral defect was first created in male New Zealand rabbits by resecting an elliptic defect (70 mm²) in the ventral penile urethra and then letting it settle down as a chronic defect for 5-6 weeks. Urothelial cells were harvested noninvasively by washing the bladder with saline and isolating urothelial cells. Neourethras were created by seeding urothelial cells on a commercially available decellularized intestinal submucosa matrix (Biodesign® Cook-Biotech®). Twenty-two rabbits were divided into three groups. Group-A (n = 2) is a control group (urethral defect unrepaired). Group-B (n = 10) and group-C (n = 10) underwent on-lay urethroplasty, with unseeded matrix (group-B) and urothelial cell-seeded matrix (group-C). Macroscopic appearance, radiology, and histology were assessed. Results: The chronic large urethral defect model was successfully created. Stratified urothelial cultures attached to the matrix were obtained. All group-A rabbits kept the urethral defect size unchanged (70 ± 2.5 mm²). All group-B rabbits presented urethroplasty dehiscence, with a median defect of 61 mm² (range 34-70). In group-C, five presented complete correction and five almost total correction with fistula, with a median defect of 0.3 mm² (range 0-12.5), demonstrating a significant better result (p = 7.85 × 10^-5). Urethrography showed more fistulas in group-B (10/10, versus 5/10 in group-C) (p = 0.04). No strictures were found in any of the groups. Group-B histology identified the absence of ventral urethra in unrepaired areas, with squamous cell metaplasia in the edges toward the defect. In group-C repaired areas, ventral multilayer urothelium was identified with cells staining for urothelial cell marker cytokeratin-7. Conclusions: The importance of this study is that we used a chronic large urethral defect animal model and clearly found that cell-seeded transplants were superior to nonseeded. In addition, bladder washing was a feasible method for harvesting viable autologous cells in a noninvasive way. There is a place for considering tissue-engineered transplants in the surgical armamentarium for treating complex urethral defects and hypospadias cases.

Is primary adult hypospadiatic prepuce different from healthy prepuce in terms of microvascular density and androgen-estrogen-progesterone receptors?

This study aims to determine the histological data such as microvessel density, nerve density, and the androgen, oestrogen and progesterone receptor density in the prepuce of primary distal hypospadias cases in adulthood, compared to that of healthy individuals in the same age group. Between 2014 and 2019, we prospectively evaluated adult hypospadias and adult circumcision patients. A total of 28 patients were included: Group 1 (18 patients) primary distal hypospadias and Group 2 (10 patients-control group) healthy individuals who had a previous circumcision request for social/religious reasons. The prepuce of healthy individuals that were excised after the circumcision and the excised parts excluded from the prepuce that was used in reconstruction during the repair of hypospadias, were shaped and stored to be able to perform a study by the pathology clinic. Histopathological findings on adult distal hypospadias cases showed that the microvascular density and inflammation in the prepuce with hypospadias were found to be increased compared to the healthy prepuce and the density of androgen and oestrogen receptors was similar in both groups. Unlike childhood studies, in this study with adults, the progesterone receptor was detected in both groups and found to be significantly lower in the hypospadias group.

Use of dCELL (Decellularized Human Dermis) in Repair of Urethrocutaneous Fistulas or Glans Dehiscence

Background

In hypospadias repairs, there is some evidence to suggest that a "waterproofing" layer can be helpful in reducing the risk of urethrocutaneous fistula formation. The most likely role of this layer is to prevent the creation of overlapping suture lines. Many hypospadias surgeons use a dartos fascia interposition flap for this purpose. However, raising a dartos fascia flap adds time to the procedure, can result in devascularization of the overlying skin, and can create unsightly torsion of the penis, which may be hard to correct. To avoid these problems, the senior author has started to use dCELL (decellularized human dermis) as an alternative to dartos fascia to separate the suture lines.

Methods

Between March and July 2018, a pilot study was performed in 8 patients undergoing closure of a urethrocutaneous fistula or glans dehiscence combined with dCELL. Data on infections, wound breakdown, length of stay and catheterization, surgical time, and hospital stay were collected.

Results

All patients had a successful reconstruction. One patient developed a urinary tract infection, possibly related to prolonged catheterization following his repair.

Conclusion

Our results suggest that dCELL may be useful in the repair of urethrocutaneous fistulas and glans dehiscence after hypospadias surgery.

Plate Objective Scoring Tool (POST); An objective methodology for the assessment of urethral plate in distal hypospadias

BACKGROUND

Estimation of the quality of the urethral plate (UP) seems to be important when assessing postoperative outcomes of hypospadias repair, but its evaluation remains subjective. We developed an objective model aiming to standardize this assessment, proposing a methodology that could be adopted in future studies designed to evaluate outcomes in the treatment of hypospadias.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the inter and intra observer reliability of a method to assess the quality of the urethral plate (UP) in hypospadias (POST - Plate Objective Scoring Tool) based on elements of glans characteristics. The reliability of such scoring methodology was compared to an analog accepted tool: the Glans-Urethral Meatus-Shaft (GMS) score. A secondary goal was to compare some characteristics of the UP in GMS score to POST values; aiming to find the threshold between favorable and unfavorable plates.

METHODS

Data were prospectively obtained from prepubertal boys who underwent primary hypospadias repair between January 2018 and November 2019. Intrinsic elements of the glanular UP (A: distal midline mucocutaneous junction; B: Glanular knob where the mucosal edges of the UP's edge change direction; C: Glanular/coronal junction) were marked and the AB/BC ratio calculated. The "G" and "M" components of the GMS score were measured electronically three times by four different reviewers with variable pediatric urology experience and blinded to each other values. Favorable UP, according to the GMS score was compared to measurements obtained by POST (AB/BC ratio).

RESULTS

84 subjects were enrolled. The POST score had an excellent inter-observer agreement for the evaluation of the UP in distal hypospadias (Kappa = 0.832) while the "G" parameter of the GMS correlated poorly among the observers. The Inter-Class Correlation (ICC) analysis to examine the intra-rater agreement value was 0.914 (95% CI 0.87, 0.95.). AB/BC ratio values ranged from 0.6 to 1.6, with a mean of 1.12. The POST cut-off value for "favorable" UP was 1.2 (AUC = 0.62) 95% CI (0.52-0.84) (sensitivity 80% and specificity 60%).

CONCLUSIONS

The POST score has higher inter-observer reliability and functions favorably when compared to the GMS. In addition, it demonstrated a high intra-observer reliability among observers of variable experience. Our findings suggest that the POST score adds to evaluation of the UP and could be incorporated as an additional criterion to assess outcomes in distal hypospadias repairs.

TIPU outcomes for hypospadias treatment and predictive factors causing urethrocutaneous fistula and external urethral meatus stenosis in TIPU: Clinical study

Our aim is to present patient outcomes for the TIPU method, currently mostly used for distal and sometimes proximal hypospadias treatment, and to identify predictive factors for the most commonly encountered complications of this surgery of urethrocutaneous fistula and urethral meatus stenosis. TIPU is a versatile, reliable, cosmetic and functionally successful surgical method mainly used for distal hypospadias patients but also in recent times for some proximal hypospadias patients. The main complications are urethrocutaneous fistula, urethral meatus stenosis, glans dehiscence and urethral meatus dehiscence. The pre-operative anatomic features of patients were assessed with the glans-meatus-shaft (GMS) scoring. Post-operative assessment of surgical outcomes was performed with the hypospadias objective scoring evaluation (HOSE). The mean total urethrocutaneous fistula and meatal stenosis development rates were 20 (12.3%) and 25 (15.4%). Both complications were found to be significantly high among hypospadias patients with narrow urethral plate, flat glandular groove and small glans (p < .001). Multivariate binary logistic regression analysis found urethral plate, glandular groove and glans shape were predictive factors for fistula and stenosis development.

Transitioning patients with hypospadias and other penile abnormalities to adulthood: What to expect?

Hypospadias patients presenting to adult urologists do so with a wide range of symptoms and problems, including urethral stricture (45-72%), lower urinary tract symptoms (with or without stricture) (50-82%), urethrocutaneous fistula (16-30%), persisting hypospadias (14-43%), micturition spraying (24%), ventral curvature (14-24%), urinary tract infection (15-25%), or lichen sclerosus (13%; range 8-43). Many of these men have concurrent complications as the result of multiple operations and a variety of techniques. Patients with childhood repairs performed by a pediatric urologist are often lost to followup during adolescence and will reemerge in adulthood after what appeared to be a successful pediatric single-stage repair, stressing the need for long-term followup and transitional care. One of the major challenges in successful transitional care is that patients can feel traumatized with feelings of hopelessness surrounding their defects, leaving them hesitant to seek care. As well, these patients often have little knowledge regarding the type of repair or original location of the meatus. Urethral stricture is the most common presenting complication and could be related to various factors, with the clear etiology still under debate. These strictures can fall under four categories based on length, location, and previous surgeries. To lessen the difficulties in transitioning hypospadias patients from pediatric to adult practitioners, followup throughout childhood and adolescence for physical examination, as well as uroflowmetry, is mandatory.

Application of the STROBE statement to the hypospadias literature: Report of the international pediatric urology task force on hypospadias

INTRODUCTION

Observational studies, particularly case series, represent the majority of the current hypospadias research. As a result, this literature lacks standardization of surgical techniques, uniform definitions of hypospadias complications, and consistency of outcome reporting, which may make it difficult to compare results across studies. A modified version of the STROBE statement, containing 20 items, was presented at the International Pediatric Urology Task Force on Hypospadias meeting to assist with clear and transparent reporting of hypospadias studies. The adoption and implementation of this modified tool will allow investigators and health care providers to critically evaluate quality and identify bias within the literature. In addition this instrument will ensure consistency of reporting, improving objective comparisons between studies, unification of results, and development of evidence-based clinical guidelines.

METHODS

In this article, we have applied the modified STROBE statement to the hypospadias literature, aiming to create a guide on study reporting for pediatric urologists, and ultimately improve the quality of research in our field. We present itemized recommendations for adequate reporting of hypospadias studies and case series, ranging from drafting the abstract to addressing biases and potential sources of confounding. Included with each item is a brief explanation of its importance and potential effect on the study, as well as pertinent examples of hypospadias articles.

RESULTS

A modified STROBE summary table containing 20 items is presented in (Supplementary Table 1).

CONCLUSIONS

If properly conducted and reported, hypospadias studies have the potential to provide useful information to clinicians and surgeons. However, authors should recognize the inherent limitations of these observational studies, especially in the form of bias, which may introduce invalid data or limit generalizability. Thus, we expect that the use of this guiding tool will not only improve transparency of hypospadias reporting, but also improve its methodological quality, allowing proper comparison and interpretation of data across different institutions.

Proximal hypospadias: we aren't always keeping our promises

Hypospadias surgery is a humbling art form. The evolution of surgical techniques has made distal hypospadias outcomes favorable, but recent publications suggest that our complication rates for proximal hypospadias are much higher than previously reported. To explain these shortcomings, we examine the literature and focus on the lack of standardized documentation, the subsequent inability to objectify the severity of the phenotype, and the underestimation of complications due to lack of long-term follow up. The variability in surgical technique and the fact that the literature abounds with small case series from single institutions also limits our ability to compare outcomes. We believe that the use of standardized and scored phenotype assessments from diagnosis through the extended postoperative period will allow for improved scientific assessment of outcomes. This will facilitate multi-institution collaboration and tabulation of outcomes, allowing rapid data accumulation and assessment for this rare disorder. As surgeons, we must follow boys through puberty into adulthood and must honestly report our results in order to advance our surgical approach to this complicated problem.

Hypospadias: Are we as good as we think when we correct proximal hypospadias?

OBJECTIVE

Hypospadias surgery is a humbling art form. Although outcomes with distal hypospadias are favorable, recent publications have suggested that the complication rates are much higher than previously anticipated for proximal hypospadias. The present review examined the literature concerning proximal hypospadias, to explore some of the inadequacies and identify some of the reasons behind these shortfalls in the reported data.

METHODS

A systematic review of the published literature was conducted using keywords relevant to proximal hypospadias and long-term outcomes.

RESULTS

The literature for hypospadias was reviewed, and outcomes for distal vs proximal variants were compared. The quality of the literature for proximal hypospadias was examined, and the shortcomings that led to underreporting of the surgical outcomes were identified. Special focus was on the lack of standardized documentation, the subsequent inability to objectify the severity of the phenotype, and the underestimation of complications due to lack of long-term follow-up. There was also a great deal of variability in the utilized techniques, and the literature was filled with small case series from single institutions. To enable scientific assessment of outcomes, it is proposed that the following be implemented: acceptance and incorporation of standardized phenotype assessment scores in the pre-operative period, objective intraoperative hypospadias characterization, and postoperative score assessment.

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment of proximal hypospadias is much less successful than the distal variant. A specialty wide commitment to standardize the hypospadias language is required to make advancement in surgical outcomes. Boys need to be followed through puberty into adulthood, and honest reporting of outcomes must be discussed so that surgical techniques for this complicated disease process can be advanced.