The efficacy of unilateral laparoscopic nephrectomy in the pediatric hypertensive patient

How effective is nephrectomy in curing hypertension in children with unilateral poorly functioning kidney? A systematic review

PURPOSE

Some children with hypertension (HTN) have unilateral poorly functional kidney (PFK). This provides an opportunity for the clinician to cure the HTN by removal of the PFK, thereby avoiding the problems of long-term medication. However, there is sparse data in children regarding the effect of PFK nephrectomy on curing HTN. In this review, we analysed the etiology of PFK causing HTN and the effectiveness of nephrectomy in curing HTN in children.

METHODS

We searched the databases to identify papers between January 2000 to December 2020 pertaining to children with PFK and HTN who underwent nephrectomy. Outcome analyzed was the resolution of HTN following nephrectomy. Duplicate publications, review articles and incomplete articles were excluded. Meta-analysis of heterogeneity was reported with I2statistics. Forest plot was constructed to compare the pooled prevalence of HTN resolution.

RESULTS

Five articles with 88 patients were included. Majority (43%) of PFK were due to the unilateral atrophic kidney with or without vesicoureteral reflux (VUR); ureteropelvic junction obstruction and multicystic dysplastic kidney together accounted for 35% of cases and renovascular pathology for 22% of cases. With a follow-up of 1.5 to 3.3 years, nephrectomy was effective to cure HTN in 65.9% (95% CI 55-75%) children.

CONCLUSIONS

In children with HTN and a unilateral PFK, nephrectomy cured the HTN in two-thirds of children. Unilateral atrophic kidney due to VUR was the most common cause of PFK. An increase in the utilisation of laparoscopy was observed in recent publications, hence laparoscopic nephrectomy may be considered a first choice of treatment in these children.

Results of Temporary Drainage of Poorly Functioning Kidneys With Ureteropelvic Junction Obstruction: Does the Histology of Persistent Poor Functioning Kidneys Indicate an Increased Risk of Hypertension?

OBJECTIVE

To review our experience with managing poorly functioning kidneys with ureteropelvic junction obstruction (PFK-UPJO) with differential renal function (DRF) <10% by a trial of temporary drainage, as the management of such kidneys is controversial. We also studied the histopathologic changes in the nephrectomy specimens of persistent PFK-UPJO, as tubulointerstitial damage may predispose to hypertension.

METHODS

A retrospective review of cases undergoing treatment for unilateral UPJO over 5-year period in 2 centers was conducted. In PFK-UPJO, 4-6 weeks trial of drainage with double J stent or percutaneous nephrostomy was employed. Those kidneys that improved DRF to >10% underwent pyeloplasty, while persistent PFK underwent nephrectomy; the specimens were studied for interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy (IF/TA), arterial lesions, and arteriole lesions.

RESULTS

Of 402 patients with unilateral UPJO that underwent surgical management, 17 (4.1%) had PFK-UPJO. After 4-6 weeks trial of drainage, 6 kidneys (35.2%) with improved DRF underwent pyeloplasty, while 11 kidneys with persistent PFK underwent nephrectomy; significant IF/TA, arterial, and arteriolar changes were noted in 9 (82%), 9 (82%), and 4 (36%) kidneys, respectively, including 7 kidneys in normotensive children. Two (11.7%) children had hypertension at presentation; 1 child remains hypertensive even after nephrectomy.

CONCLUSION

In PFK-UPJO, trial of temporary drainage seems appropriate to decide plan of management; 35% of such kidneys improved function after drainage. Most persistent PFK demonstrated severe and irreversible histologic changes that may predispose to hypertension if they are preserved, and we suggest that such kidneys may be removed. Long-term follow-up of all preserved PFK-UPJO is strongly recommended.

Native nephrectomy in the management of hypertension in children with kidney disease: a tool to improve blood pressure control

AIM

Hypertension in children with abnormal kidneys often requires multiple antihypertensive agents (complex), or could present with complications (e.g. hypertensive encephalopathy). Our objective in this report is to evaluate blood pressure control following unilateral or bilateral laparoscopic native nephrectomy in children with renal hypertension.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Single-centre retrospective review of all children who underwent nephrectomy for management of hypertension over a recent study period (2008-2017) with post-operative follow-up of at least 3 years. We describe the association of age, primary kidney disease and blood pressure and its management including time to resolution following unilateral or bilateral nephrectomy.

RESULTS

During the 9-year study period, 21 of 215 (9.8%) children underwent nephrectomy for management of hypertension. We included 19 children [6 with unilateral native nephrectomy (UNN) and 13 with bilateral native nephrectomy (BNN)] in this study as they continued with their follow-up at our centre. Out of the 19 children, 15 had laparoscopic retroperitoneoscopic nephrectomies and 4 had laparoscopic transperitoneal nephrectomies. Six children had unilateral nephrectomy and 13 children had bilateral nephrectomies [7 were pre-transplant (haemodialysis-6, peritoneal dialysis-1) and 6 were post-kidney transplant]. Fifteen of 19 children (79%) had complete resolution [5 UNN and 10 BNN] and 3 (16%) partial resolution [1 UNN and 2 BNN]. One patient with BNN was observed to have no change in blood pressure control.

CONCLUSION

Our data demonstrate improved management of hypertension in 95% of the children. Nephrectomy could offer a reasonable treatment option for selected group of complex and complicated renal hypertension.