Hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers promote systemic hyperfibrinolysis that is both dependent and independent of plasmin

Re-analysis of the PolyHeme Phase III trial dataset: Lessons for future haemoglobin-based oxygen carrier trauma trials

INTRODUCTION

To assist design of future HBOC clinical trials for pre-hospital and prolonged field care, the haemoglobin-based-oxygen carrier (HBOC) Phase III trauma trial database comparing PolyHeme to blood transfusion was re-analysed to identify causes of adverse early outcomes versus the 30-day mortality outcome of the original trial. We questioned if failure of PolyHeme (10 g/dl) to increase haemoglobin concentration and dilutional coagulopathy versus blood, caused higher Day 1 mortality in the PolyHeme arm of the trial.

METHODS

New analyses of the original trial database, including Fisher's exact test, examined impact of interval changes in total haemoglobin [THb], coagulation, fluid volumes administered and mortality on Day 1 in the Control (pre-hospital crystalloids, then blood after trauma centre admission) and PolyHeme arms of the trial.

RESULTS

Admission [THb] was significantly greater (p<0.05) in PolyHeme (12.3 [SD = 1.8] g/dl) versus Control (11.5 [SD= 2.9] g/dl) patients. This early [THb] advantage was reversed within 6 h. Early mortality was negatively correlated with [THb] and maximum 1.4 h after hospital admission (17/365 for Control vs. 5/349 for PolyHeme). The mortality trend began reversing, when Control arm received blood. Coagulopathy was more common in the PolyHeme arm. Mortality rate was 2-fold greater for patients with coagulopathy in the control arm (18% vs. 9%, p = 0.1008) and 4-fold greater in PolyHeme arm (33% vs. 8.5%, p < 0.001). In a subgroup analysis of patients with major haemorrhage (n = 55), mortality was significantly higher in PolyHeme patients [12/26 (46.2%) versus 4/29 (13.8%) in control cohort (p = 0.018)], related to mean 10 liters more IV fluid administration and more severe anaemia (6.2 g/dL vs. 9.2 g/dL) in the PolyHeme cohort.

CONCLUSIONS

PolyHeme (10 g/dL) diminished pre-hospital anaemia. The inability of PolyHeme to reverse acute anaemia in a subset of major haemorrhage patients was due to volume overload secondary to high PolyHeme doses, resulting in dilution of clotting factors and low circulating THb (versus transfused controls) during the first 12 h of the trial. Haemodilution was associated with prolonged administration of PolyHeme, while blood transfusion was available to Control patients following hospital admission. Coagulopathy exacerbated bleeding, anaemia, contributing to excess mortality in the PolyHeme arm. Future trials for prolonged field care should evaluate HBOC with higher haemoglobin concentration, lower volume administration and transition upon trauma centre admission to blood plus coagulation factors or whole blood.

The α-globin chain of hemoglobin potentiates tissue plasminogen activator induced hyperfibrinolysis in vitro

BACKGROUND

Severe injury predisposes patients to trauma-induced coagulopathy, which may be subdivided by the state of fibrinolysis. Systemic hyperfibrinolysis (HF) occurs in approximately 25% of these patients with mortality as high as 70%. Severe injury also causes the release of numerous intracellular proteins, which may affect coagulation, one of which is hemoglobin, and hemoglobin substitutes induce HF in vitro. We hypothesize that the α-globin chain of hemoglobin potentiates HF in vitro by augmenting plasmin activity.

METHODS

Proteomic analysis was completed on a pilot study of 30 injured patients before blood component resuscitation, stratified by their state of fibrinolysis, plus 10 healthy controls. Different concentrations of intact hemoglobin A, the α- and β-globin chains, or normal saline (controls) were added to whole blood, and tissue plasminogen activator (tPA)-challenged thrombelastography was used to assess the degree of fibrinolysis. Interactions with plasminogen (PLG) were evaluated using surface plasmon resonance. Tissue plasminogen activator-induced plasmin activity was evaluated in the presence of the α-globin chain.

RESULTS

Only the α- and β-globin chains increased in HF patients (p < 0.01). The α-globin chain but not hemoglobin A or the β-globin chain decreased the reaction time and significantly increased lysis time 30 on citrated native thrombelastographies (p < 0.05). The PLG and α-globin chain had interaction kinetics similar to tPA:PLG, and the α-globin chain increased tPA-induced plasmin activity.

CONCLUSIONS

The α-globin chain caused HF in vitro by binding to PLG and augmenting plasmin activity and may represent a circulating "moonlighting" mediator released by the tissue damage and hemorrhagic shock inherent to severe injury.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Prognostic, level III.

A Novel Cross-Linked Hemoglobin-Based Oxygen Carrier, YQ23, Extended the Golden Hour for Uncontrolled Hemorrhagic Shock in Rats and Miniature Pigs

Background: Hypotensive resuscitation is widely applied for trauma and war injury to reduce bleeding during damage-control resuscitation, but the treatment time window is limited in order to avoid hypoxia-associated organ injury. Whether a novel hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier (HBOC), YQ23 in this study, could protect organ function, and extend the Golden Hour for treatment is unclear. Method: Uncontrolled hemorrhagic shock rats and miniature pigs were infused with 0.5, 2, and 5% YQ23 before bleeding was controlled, while Lactate Ringer's solution (LR) and fresh whole blood plus LR (WB + LR) were set as controls. During hypotensive resuscitation the mean blood pressure was maintained at 50-60 mmHg for 60 min. Hemodynamics, oxygen delivery and utilization, blood loss, fluid demand, organ function, animal survival as well as side effects were observed. Besides, in order to observe whether YQ23 could extend the Golden Hour, the hypotensive resuscitation duration was extended to 180 min and animal survival was observed. Results: Compared with LR, infusion of YQ23 in the 60 min pre-hospital hypotensive resuscitation significantly reduced blood loss and the fluid demand in both rats and pigs. Besides, YQ23 could effectively stabilize hemodynamics, and increase tissue oxygen consumption, increase the cardiac output, reduce liver and kidney injury, which helped to reduce the early death and improve animal survival. In addition, the hypotensive resuscitation duration could be extended to 180 min using YQ23. Side effects such as vasoconstriction and renal injury were not observed. The beneficial effects of 5% YQ23 are equivalent to similar volume of WB + LR. Conclusion: HBOC, such as YQ23, played vital roles in damage-control resuscitation for emergency care and benefited the uncontrolled hemorrhagic shock in the pre-hospital treatment by increasing oxygen delivery, reducing organ injury. Besides, HBOC could benefit the injured and trauma patients by extending the Golden Hour.

Fluids of the Future

Fluids are a vital tool in the armament of acute care clinicians in both civilian and military resuscitation. We now better understand complications from inappropriate resuscitation with currently available fluids; however, fluid resuscitation undeniably remains a life-saving intervention. Military research has driven the most significant advances in the field of fluid resuscitation and is currently leading the search for the fluids of the future. The veterinary community, much like our civilian human counterparts, should expect the fluid of the future to be the fruit of military research. The fluids of the future not only are expected to improve patient outcomes but also be field expedient. Those fluids should be compatible with military environments or natural disaster environments. For decades, military personnel and disaster responders have faced the peculiar demands of austere environments, prolonged field care, and delayed evacuation. Large scale natural disasters present field limitations often similar to those encountered in the battlefield. The fluids of the future should, therefore, have a long shelf-life, a small footprint, and be resistant to large temperature swings, for instance. Traumatic brain injury and hemorrhagic shock are the leading causes of preventable death for military casualties and a significant burden in civilian populations. The military and civilian health systems are focusing efforts on field-expedient fluids that will be specifically relevant for the management of those conditions. Fluids are expected to be compatible with blood products, increase oxygen-carrying capabilities, promote hemostasis, and be easy to administer in the prehospital setting, to match the broad spectrum of current acute care challenges, such as sepsis and severe systemic inflammation. This article will review historical military and civilian contributions to current resuscitation strategies, describe the expectations for the fluids of the future, and describe select ongoing research efforts with a review of current animal data.

Freeze-dried plasma mitigates the dilution effects of a hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier (HBOC-201) in a model of resuscitation for hemorrhage and hemodilution

BACKGROUND

Hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs) have proven useful for supplementing oxygen delivery when red cells are unavailable; however, HBOCs do not promote hemostasis. The need for prehospital bridges to blood transfusion informed this study which sought to determine the impact of HBOCs on coagulation, with or without cotransfusion of freeze-dried plasma (FDP).

METHODS

Treatment was simulated in vitro by replacing whole blood volume (or whole blood prediluted with 25% plasmalyte A as a hemodilution model) with HBOC-201, FDP, or both at ratios of 10% to 50% of original volume. Prothrombin time (PT), activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT), fibrinogen, complete blood count, viscosity, thromboelastography (TEG), and platelet adhesion to collagen under flow were evaluated. Subsequently, tissue plasminogen activator was added to model hemorrhagic shock effects on fibrinolysis.

RESULTS

Substituting blood with HBOC resulted in dose-dependent decreases in fibrinogen and cells, which lengthened PT (+61% at highest dose) and aPTT (+40% at highest dose) and produced TEG parameters consistent with dilutional coagulopathy. While substituting blood with FDP decreased cell counts accordingly, fibrinogen, PT, aPTT, and TEG parameters were not statistically changed. When HBOC and FDP were combined 1:1 for volume replacement, observed HBOC-only detriments were mitigated: PT and aPTT were increased by 17% and 11%, respectively, at the highest doses. In prediluted samples, similar trends were seen with exacerbated differences. Platelet adhesion to collagen was directly affected by hematocrit. Samples containing both HBOC and tissue plasminogen activator were highly susceptible to fibrinolysis.

CONCLUSION

A dose equivalent to 1 unit to 2 units each of HBOC-201 and FDP had a modest impact on functional coagulation measures and is reasonable to consider for clinical study as a part of early transfusion intervention. Higher doses may impart hemodilution risks similar to resuscitation with crystalloid or other colloids in coagulation-compromised patients. Further study of HBOC effects on fibrinolysis is also indicated.

STUDY TYPE

In vitro laboratory study.

Fibrinolysis in trauma: a review

Fibrinolytic dysregulation is an important mechanism in traumatic coagulopathy. It is an incompletely understood process that consists of a spectrum ranging from excessive breakdown (hyperfibrinolysis) and the shutdown of fibrinolysis. Both hyperfibrinolysis and shutdown are associated with excess mortality and post-traumatic organ failure. The pathophysiology appears to relate to endothelial injury and hypoperfusion, with several molecular markers identified in playing a role. Although there are no universally accepted diagnostic tests, viscoelastic studies appear to offer the greatest potential for timely identification of patients presenting with fibrinolytic dysregulation. Treatment is multimodal, involving prompt hemorrhage control and resuscitation, with controversy surrounding the use of antifibrinolytic drug therapy. This review presents the current evidence on the pathophysiology, diagnostic challenges, as well as the management of this hemostatic dysfunction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.