Reporting adverse events in a surgical trial for complex congenital heart disease: the Pediatric Heart Network experience

Triiodothyronine Supplementation in Infants Undergoing Cardiopulmonary Bypass: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) profoundly suppresses circulating thyroid hormone levels in infants. We performed a multicenter randomized placebo controlled trial to determine if triiodothyronine (T3) supplementation improves reduces time to extubation (TTE) in infants after CPB. Infants (n = 220) undergoing cardiac surgery with CPB and stratified into 2 age cohorts: ≤30 days and >30 days to <152 days were randomization to receive either intravenous triiodothyronine or placebo bolus followed by study drug infusion until extubated or at 48 hours, whichever preceded. T3 did not significantly alter the primary endpoint, TTE (hazard ratio for chance of extubation (1.08, 95% CI: 0.82-1.43, P = 0.575) in the entire randomized population with censoring at 21 days. T3 showed no significant effect on TTE (HR 0.82, 95% CI:0.55-1.23, P = 0.341) in the younger subgroup or in the older (HR 1.38, 95% CI:0.95-2.2, P = 0.095). T3 also did not significantly impact TTE during the first 48 hours while T3 levels were maintained (HR 1.371, 95% CI:0.942-1.95, P = 0.099) No significant differences occurred for arrhythmias or other sentinel adverse events in the entire cohort or in the subgroups. This trial showed no significant benefit on TTE in the entire cohort. T3 supplementation appears safe as it did not cause an increase in adverse events. The study implementation and analysis were complicated by marked variability in surgical risk, although risk categories were balanced between treatment groups.

Unique Challenges of Randomised Controlled Trials in Pediatric Cardiology

Pediatric cardiology has evolved over time with reductions in childhood mortality due to congenital heart disease. Surgical innovation drove early changes in care. Increasingly, the need for more robust evidence provided by randomised controlled trials (RCTs) has been recognised. Although the number of RCTs has increased, there remains a relative paucity of truly impactful trials in the field. However, those trials that have changed practice have demonstrated the potential and importance of this work. Examples include the PRIMACORP trial, which established the safety and efficacy of milrinone after cardiac surgery, and the Single Ventricle Reconstruction trial, which was the first multicentre pediatric cardiac surgical RCT. The successful conduct and important findings emanating from these trials serve as beacons as clinicians strive to improve the evidence base in this field. The establishment of national and international networks such as the Pediatric Heart Network and the Canadian Pediatric Cardiology Research Network provide a strong foundation for future collaborative work. Despite this progress, there remain important challenges to designing and executing RCTs in pediatric cardiology. These include issues of greater disease and patient heterogeneity and increased costs. The use of innovative study designs and analytic methods and the establishment of core outcome measures have the potential to overcome some of the issues related to the smaller patient numbers compared with adult disciplines. As pediatric cardiologists look to the future, it is imperative that we work together to derive the maximum benefit from the considerable efforts directed toward conducting impactful clinical trials in pediatric cardiology.

Adrenergic receptor genotypes influence postoperative outcomes in infants in the Single-Ventricle Reconstruction Trial

OBJECTIVES

Adrenergic receptor (ADR) genotypes have been associated with adverse outcomes in heart failure. Our objective was to evaluate the association of ADR genotypes with post-Norwood outcomes in infants with hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS).

METHODS

Infants with HLHS participating in the Pediatric Heart Network Single-Ventricle Reconstruction Trial underwent genotyping for 4 single-nucleotide polymorphisms in 3 ADR genes: ADRB1_231A/G, ADRB1_1165G/C, ADRB2_5318C/G, and ADRA2A_2790C/T. The association of genotype with freedom from serious adverse events (SAEs) (death, transplant, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, acute shunt failure, unplanned reoperations, or necrotizing enterocolitis) during 14 months' follow-up was assessed with Cox regression and the association with post-Norwood complications was assessed with Poisson regression. Models were adjusted for clinical and surgical factors.

RESULTS

The study included 351 eligible patients (62% male; 83% white). The mean age at Norwood procedure was 5.6 ± 3.6 days. A total of 152 patients had SAEs during 14-month follow-up including 84 deaths and 10 transplants. ADRA2A_2790CC genotype had lower SAE-free survival compared with CT/TT genotypes during follow-up (Log rank test, P = .02), and this association was independent of clinical and surgical risk factors (adjusted Cox regression, hazard ratio 1.54 [95% confidence interval 1.04, 2.30] P = .033). Post-Norwood complication rate did not differ by genotype.

CONCLUSIONS

Infants with HLHS harboring ADR genotypes that are associated with greater catecholamine release or sensitivity had lower event-free survival after staged palliation. Excess catecholamine activation may adversely affect cardiovascular adaptation after the Norwood procedure. Future studies should explore whether targeting adrenergic activation in those harboring risk genotypes can improve outcomes. (ClinicalTrials.gov number NCT00115934).

Impact of postoperative complications on hospital costs following the Norwood operation

Introduction Patients undergoing the Norwood operation consume considerable healthcare resources; however, detailed information regarding factors impacting hospitalisation costs is lacking. We evaluated the association of postoperative complications with hospital costs.

METHODS

In the present study, we utilised a unique data set consisting of prospectively collected clinical data from the Pediatric Heart Network Single Ventricle Reconstruction trial linked at the patient level with cost data for 10 hospitals participating in the Children's Hospital Association Case Mix database during the trial period. The relationship between complications and cost was modelled using linear regression, accounting for the skewed distribution of cost, adjusting for within-centre clustering and baseline patient characteristics.

RESULTS

A total of 334 eligible Norwood records (97.5%) were matched between data sets. Overall, 82% suffered from at least one complication (median 2; with a range from 0 to 33). Those with complications had longer postoperative length of stay (25 versus 12 days, p<0.001), more total ventilator days (7 versus 5 days, p<0.001), and higher in-hospital mortality (17.6 versus 3.4%, p<0.006). Mean adjusted hospital cost in those with a complication was $190,689 (95% CI $111,344-$326,577) versus $120,584 (95% CI $69,246-$209,983) in those without complications (p=0.002). Costs increased with the number of complications (1-2 complications=$132,800 versus 3-4 complications=$182,353 versus ⩾5 complications=$309,372 [p<0.001]).

CONCLUSIONS

This merged data set of clinical trial and cost data demonstrated that postoperative complications are common following the Norwood operation and are associated with worse clinical outcomes and higher costs. Efforts to reduce complications in this population may lead to improved outcomes and cost savings.

The pediatric heart network: meeting the challenges to multicenter studies in pediatric heart disease

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Because of the relatively small numbers of pediatric patients with congenital heart disease cared for in any individual center, there is a significant need for multicenter clinical studies to validate new medical or surgical therapies. The Pediatric Heart Network (PHN), with 15 years of experience in multicenter clinical research, has tackled numerous challenges when conducting multicenter studies.

RECENT FINDINGS

This review describes the challenges encountered and the strategies employed to conduct high-quality, collaborative research in pediatric cardiovascular disease.

SUMMARY

Sharing lessons learned from the PHN can provide guidance to investigators interested in conducting pediatric multicenter studies.

Technical performance score is associated with outcomes after the Norwood procedure

OBJECTIVES

The technical performance score (TPS) has been reported in a single center study to predict the outcomes after congenital cardiac surgery. We sought to determine the association of the TPS with outcomes in patients undergoing the Norwood procedure in the Single Ventricle Reconstruction trial.

METHODS

We calculated the TPS (class 1, optimal; class 2, adequate; class 3, inadequate) according to the predischarge echocardiograms analyzed in a core laboratory and unplanned reinterventions that occurred before discharge from the Norwood hospitalization. Multivariable regression examined the association of the TPS with interval to first extubation, Norwood length of stay, death or transplantation, unplanned postdischarge reinterventions, and neurodevelopment at 14 months old.

RESULTS

Of 549 patients undergoing a Norwood procedure, 356 (65%) had an echocardiogram adequate to assess atrial septal restriction or arch obstruction or an unplanned reintervention, enabling calculation of the TPS. On multivariable regression, adjusting for preoperative variables, a better TPS was an independent predictor of a shorter interval to first extubation (P=.019), better transplant-free survival before Norwood discharge (P<.001; odds ratio, 9.1 for inadequate vs optimal), shorter hospital length of stay (P<.001), fewer unplanned reinterventions between Norwood discharge and stage II (P=.004), and a higher Bayley II psychomotor development index at 14 months (P=.031). The TPS was not associated with transplant-free survival after Norwood discharge, unplanned reinterventions after stage II, or the Bayley II mental development index at 14 months.

CONCLUSIONS

TPS is an independent predictor of important outcomes after Norwood and could serve as a tool for quality improvement.

Neonatal right ventricle to pulmonary connection as a palliative procedure for pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect or severe tetralogy of Fallot

OBJECTIVES

Right ventricle to pulmonary artery connection (RVPA connection) without prosthetic material has been our ideal strategy to palliate pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect (VSD) or severe tetralogy of Fallot for the last decade. We speculate that RVPA connection ensures adequate postoperative haemodynamics for symptomatic neonates and promotes pulmonary artery rehabilitation. The present study was undertaken to assess the outcome of this strategy.

METHODS

Between 2000 and 2010, among 107 patients who benefited from an RVPA connection, 57 were neonates. Forty-eight of these underwent autologous tissue reconstruction, 5 using left atrial appendage. Median weight was 2.9 kg (range 1.8-4.4). Median Nakata index was 100 mm2/m2 (range 17-185 mm2/m2); 12% had major aortopulmonary collaterals. All patients were reviewed retrospectively. End-points were death or complete repair; reintervention for restrictive pulmonary blood flow was considered as failure. At follow-up, we evaluated reintervention after complete repair, and quality of life.

RESULTS

There were 2 early deaths (RV hypoplasia and RV failure) and 3 late sudden deaths (range 3-6 months). Pulmonary blood flow required to be increased in 8 patients: 4 underwent shunt after a median delay of 1 month; RVPA connection enlargement was needed in 3; 1 patient had percutaneous angioplasty. Finally, 47 patients (81%) had a complete repair, of which 70% were performed without prosthetic material at a median age of 7 months (range 2-53), with a median Nakata index of 221 mm2/m2 (range 102-891). One patient died early and 1 was a failure with opening of the VSD after intracardiac repair. At last follow-up, 4 patients were still awaiting repair, with 1 late death and 5 who had required reintervention after intracardiac repair; there were 3 conduit replacements and 2 balloon dilatation patch enlargements.

CONCLUSIONS

The neonatal RVPA connection approach (i) provides an acceptable survival rate with a satisfactory haemodynamic adaptation, (ii) facilitates rehabilitation of PAs and (iii) avoids the use of prosthetic graft at correction.

Therapeutic hypothermia after pediatric cardiac arrest trials: the vanguard phase experience and implications for other trials

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether an 18-month vanguard phase, in the Therapeutic Hypothermia after Pediatric Cardiac Arrest trials, confirmed study feasibility and patient safety, a prerequisite to continued funding by the sponsor.

DESIGN

Randomized controlled trial.

SETTING

Pediatric intensive care and pediatric cardiac care units in 15 clinical sites in the United States and Canada.

PATIENTS

Children aged 48 hrs to 18 yrs of age, with return of circulation after cardiac arrest.

INTERVENTIONS

Therapeutic hypothermia vs. therapeutic normothermia.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The first 15 of 20 potential sites to obtain Institutional Review Board and subcontract approvals were selected as vanguard sites. Institutional Review Board approvals were obtained 92 days (median, interquartile range 65-114) and subcontracts signed 34 days (interquartile range 20-48) after distribution. Sites screened subjects at 13 days (interquartile range 9-21) and enrolled the first subjects 64 days (interquartile range 13-154) after study launch. The recruitment milestone was reached 4 months ahead of schedule, with no safety concerns identified. Overall recruitment in this ongoing trial remains on target.

CONCLUSIONS

The Therapeutic Hypothermia after Pediatric Cardiac Arrest vanguard phase proved beneficial for the investigators and funding agency. Because complex multicenter trials are rarely ready to launch when grant funds are received, the vanguard allowed time to refine the protocol and recruitment approaches. Competition for vanguard positions led to expedient Institutional Review Board and subcontract completion. Early success and sustained momentum contributed to recruitment at or above goals. Financial risks to the sponsor were minimized by tying funding for the full trial to achieving prespecified milestones. A vanguard phase may be a desirable strategy for the successful conduct of other complex clinical trials.

Pediatric cardiovascular safety: challenges in drug and device development and clinical application

Development of pediatric medications and devices is complicated by differences in pediatric physiology and pathophysiology (both compared with adults and within the pediatric age range), small patient populations, and practical and ethical challenges to designing clinical trials. This article summarizes the discussions that occurred at a Cardiac Safety Research Consortium-sponsored Think Tank convened on December 10, 2010, where members from academia, industry, and regulatory agencies discussed important issues regarding pediatric cardiovascular safety of medications and cardiovascular devices. Pediatric drug and device development may use adult data but often requires additional preclinical and clinical testing to characterize effects on cardiac function and development. Challenges in preclinical trials include identifying appropriate animal models, clinically relevant efficacy end points, and methods to monitor cardiovascular safety. Pediatric clinical trials have different ethical concerns from adult trials, including consideration of the subjects' families. Clinical trial design in pediatrics should assess risks and benefits as well as incorporate input from families. Postmarketing surveillance, mandated by federal law, plays an important role in both drug and device safety assessment and becomes crucial in the pediatric population because of the limitations of premarketing pediatric studies. Solutions for this wide array of issues will require collaboration between academia, industry, and government as well as creativity in pediatric study design. Formation of various epidemiologic tools including registries to describe outcomes of pediatric cardiac disease and its treatment as well as cardiac effects of noncardiovascular medications, should inform preclinical and clinical development and improve benefit-risk assessments for the patients. The discussions in this article summarize areas of emerging consensus and other areas in which consensus remains elusive and provide suggestions for additional research to further our knowledge and understanding of this topic.

Interstage mortality after the Norwood procedure: Results of the multicenter Single Ventricle Reconstruction trial

OBJECTIVE

For infants with single ventricle malformations undergoing staged repair, interstage mortality is reported at 2% to 20%. The Single Ventricle Reconstruction trial randomized subjects with a single morphologic right ventricle undergoing a Norwood procedure to a modified Blalock-Taussig shunt (MBTS) or a right ventricle-to-pulmonary artery shunt (RVPAS). The aim of this analysis was to explore the associations of interstage mortality and shunt type, and demographic, anatomic, and perioperative factors.

METHODS

Participants in the Single Ventricle Reconstruction trial who survived to discharge after the Norwood procedure were included (n = 426). Interstage mortality was defined as death postdischarge after the Norwood procedure and before the stage II procedure. Univariate analysis and multivariable logistic regression were performed adjusting for site.

RESULTS

Overall interstage mortality was 50 of 426 (12%)-13 of 225 (6%) for RVPAS and 37 of 201 (18%) for MBTS (odds ratio [OR] for MBTS, 3.4; P < .001). When moderate to severe postoperative atrioventricular valve regurgitation (AVVR) was present, interstage mortality was similar between shunt types. Interstage mortality was independently associated with gestational age less than 37 weeks (OR, 3.9; P = .008), Hispanic ethnicity (OR, 2.6; P = .04), aortic atresia/mitral atresia (OR, 2.3; P = .03), greater number of post-Norwood complications (OR, 1.2; P = .006), census block poverty level (P = .003), and MBTS in subjects with no or mild postoperative AVVR (OR, 9.7; P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

Interstage mortality remains high at 12% and is increased with the MBTS compared with the RVPAS if postoperative AVVR is absent or mild. Preterm delivery, anatomic, and socioeconomic factors are also important. Avoiding preterm delivery when possible and close surveillance after Norwood hospitalization for infants with identified risk factors may reduce interstage mortality.