Establishing Local Diagnostic Reference Levels in IR Procedures with Dose Management Software

Establishment of Diagnostic Reference Levels in Portuguese Interventional Radiology departments

PURPOSE

To establish Portuguese Diagnostic Reference Levels (DRLs), for six body fluoroscopy guided interventional procedures (FGIP).

METHOD

A retrospective study was conducted in five interventional departments most representative of Interventional Radiology (IR) practice. Dose values, in terms of air kerma area product (PKA in Gy.cm2), air kerma at the patient entrance reference point (Ka,r in mGy), and exposure parameters (fluoroscopy time (FT) and number of cine runs) were collected. Examinations were selected per procedure (at least 20), according to the antero-posterior and lateral diameter mean value (±5 cm), measured on previous Computed Tomography (CT) examinations.

RESULTS

Data of 489 body FGIP show a large variation on dose values per procedure and per department. National DRLs in terms of PKA were 20.2 Gy.cm2 for Percutaneous transhepatic biliary drainage (PTBD), 98.2 Gy.cm2 for Bronchial artery embolisation (BAE), 247.7 Gy.cm2 for Transarterial chemoembolisation (TACE), 331.6 Gy.cm2 for Inferior epigastric arteries embolisation (IEAE), 312.0 Gy.cm2 for Transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) and 19.3 Gy.cm2 for Endovascular treatment of femoral popliteal arteries (ETFPA).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study reporting Interventional Radiology DRLs in Portugal and we propose preliminary national estimates for the six more common body FGIP. The results of this study will be presented and discussed with all Portuguese IR departments, to promote procedures optimisation.

Neurointerventions on two generations of angiography systems: Recent systems reduce radiation exposure by half

PURPOSE

Fluoroscopically-guided neurointervention may be associated with prolonged procedure time and substantial radiation exposure to the patient and staff. This study sought to examine technological features affecting the potential radiation exposure reduction of new angiography systems, compared to older systems, for neurointerventional procedures.

METHODS

Consecutive neurointerventional patients (2020-2022) were retrospectively analyzed. The air kerma at the reference point (Ka,r) and kerma-area product (KAP) were compared between Artis icono and Artis zee (Siemens) using statistical analyses (two-tailed t tests), where P < 0.05 is considered significant. X-ray tube potential and copper filtration were examined. Tests with an anthropomorphic phantom (Sun Nuclear) on Artis icono were conducted and entrance skin exposure and x-ray spectral half value layer were measured. Effective spectral filtration was characterized by x-ray spectral modeling.

RESULTS

The number of procedures was 1158 [median (range) age, 59 (7-95) years] on Artis zee and 1087 [60 (1-95) years] on Artis icono, without significant difference in age (p = 0.059) between cohorts. Ka,r was 925.4 (890.6-960.1) mGy [mean (95 % CI)] and KAP was 119.8 (115-124.5) Gy∙cm2 on Artis zee. The measures were 48-50 % lower on Artis icono, 440.5 (411.7-469.4) mGy (Ka,r) and 59.5 (55.4-63.6) Gy∙cm2 (KAP); while the difference in fluoroscopic time between the two generations of angiography systems was insignificant (p = 0.55).

CONCLUSIONS

The newer angiography system, with updated hardware and software, was found to result in half the radiation exposure compared to older technology of the same manufacturer, even though fluoroscopic time was similar.

Cumulative Effective Dose During Fluoroscopically Guided Interventions (FGI): Analysis of More Than 5000 FGIs in a Single European Center

BACKGROUND

The number of fluoroscopically guided interventions (FGI) has increased significantly over time. However, little attention has been paid to possible stochastic radiation effects. The aim of this retrospective study was to investigate the number of patients who received cumulative effective doses over 100 mSv during FGI procedures.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Five thousand five hundred and fifty four classified FGI procedures were included. Radiation dose data, retrieved from an in-house-dose-management system, was analysed. Effective doses and cumulative effective doses (CED) were calculated. Patients who received a CED > 100 mSv were identified. Radiology reports, patient age, imaging and clinical data of these patients were used to identify reasons for CED ≥ 100 mSv.

RESULTS

One Hundred and thirty two (41.1% female) of 3981 patients received a CED > 100 mSy, with a mean CED of 173.5 ± 84.5 mSv. Mean age at first intervention was 66.1 ± 11.7 years. 81 (61.4%) of 132 were older than 64 years, one patient was < 30 years. 110 patients received ≥ 100 mSv within one year (83.4%), through FGIs: EVAR, pelvic/mesenteric interventions (stent or embolization), hepatic interventions (chemoembolization, TIPSS), embolization of cerebral aneurysms or arterio-venous-malformations.

CONCLUSIONS

Substantial CED may occur in a small but not ignorable fraction of patients (~ 3%) undergoing FGIs. Approximately 2/3rd of patients may most likely not encounter radiation-related stochastic effects due to life-threatening diseases and age at first treatment > 65 years but 1/3rd may. Patients undergoing more than one FGI (77%) carry a higher risk of accumulating effective doses > 100 mSv. Remarkably, 23% received a mean CED 162.2 ± 72.3 mSv in a single procedure.

An audit of patient radiation doses in interventional radiology at a South African hospital

Background

Interventional radiology (IR) is becoming more relevant in patient care and is associated with increased patient radiation exposure and radiation-induced adverse effects. Diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) are crucial for radiation control. There is a paucity of published DRLs for IR in South Africa and sub-Saharan Africa.

Objectives

This study aimed to determine local DRLs for fluoroscopically-guided IR procedures and compare the achieved DRLs with published local and international DRLs.

Method

Retrospective, descriptive, single-centre study. Kerma air product (KAP), reference point air kerma (K_a,r) and fluoroscopy time (FT) were collected for patients (12 years and older) who underwent IR procedures at a university hospital from 01 January 2019 to 31 December 2019. The 75th percentile of the distribution of each dose parameter (KAP, K_a,r and FT) per procedure was calculated and taken as the local diagnostic reference levels (LDRL). The established LDRLs were compared to published DRLs.

Results

A total of 564 cases were evaluated. The 13 most frequent procedures (with 15 or more cases) represented 86.1% (487/564). Percutaneous transhepatic biliary drainage was the most common procedure (n = 146, 25.9%). Diagnostic cerebral angiogram DRLs exceeded the published DRL data ranges for all parameters (DRL 209.3), and interventional cerebral angiogram exceeded published ranges (DRL 275). Uterine artery embolisation (UAE) exceeded these ranges for KAP and K_a,r. (KAP-954.9 Gy/cm², K_a,r-2640.8 mGy).

Conclusion

The LDRLs for diagnostic cerebral angiogram, interventional cerebral angiogram and UAE exceeded published international DRL ranges. These procedures require radiation optimisation as recommended by the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP).

Contribution

In addition to informing radiation protection practices at the level of the institution, the established LDRLs contribute towards Regional and National DRLs.

Typical doses and typical values for fluoroscopic diagnostic and interventional procedures

To implement typical doses (TD) and typical values (TV) for fluoroscopic diagnostic and interventional procedures. A total of 3811 fluoroscopic procedures performed within 34 months on three devices were included in this retrospective study. Dose-, patient- and procedure-related information were extracted using the institutional dose management system (DMS). TD/TV were defined as median dose and calculated for the five most frequent procedures per device for dose area product (DAP), cumulative air kerma (CAK) and fluoroscopy time (FT). National diagnostic reference levels and other single facility studies were compared to our results. Additionally, the five procedures with the highest doses of each device were analysed. To evaluate the data coverage of the DMS compared to the picture archiving and communication system (PACS), procedure lists were extracted from the PACS and compared to the procedure information extracted from the DMS. TD/TV for 15 procedures were implemented. Among all devices, TD for DAP ranged between 0.6 Gycm²for port catheter control (n= 64) and 145.9 Gycm²for transarterial chemoembolisation (n= 84). TD for CAK ranged between 5 mGy for port catheter control and 1397 mGy for aneurysm treatment (n= 129) and TV for FT ranged between 0.3 min for upper cavography (n= 67) and 51.4 min for aneurysm treatment. TD for DAP and CAK were lower or within the range of other single facility studies. The five procedures with the highest median DAP per device were identified, 6 of 15 procedures were also found to be among the most frequent procedures. Data coverage of the DMS compared to the PACS ranged between 71% (device 2, stroke treatment) and 78% (device 1, lower limb angiography) for the most common procedure per device. Thus, in 22%-29% of cases dose data of the performed procedure was not transferred into the DMS. We implemented TD/TV for fluoroscopic diagnostic and interventional procedures which enable a comprehensive dose analysis and comparison with previously published values.

Radiation exposure in 101 non-coronary fluoroscopically guided interventional procedures: reference levels of air kerma at the reference point and air kerma area product

OBJECTIVES

To present the median value and 75th percentile of air kerma at the reference point (K_a,r), air kerma-area product (KAP), and fluoroscopic time for a large number of fluoroscopically guided interventional (FGI) procedures.

METHODS

This retrospective study included the consecutive non-coronary FGI procedures from a Radiology department between May 2016 and October 2018 at a large tertiary-care hospital in the U.S. An in-house developed, semi-automated software, integrated with a dictation system, was used to record patient examination information, including K_a,r, KAP and fluoroscopic time. The included patient procedures were categorized into procedure types. A software package R (v. 3.5.1, R Foundation) was used to calculate procedure-specific quartiles of radiation exposure.

RESULTS

Based on analysis of 24,911 FGI cases, median value and 75th percentile are presented for each of K_a,r, KAP and fluoroscopic time for 101 procedures that can act as benchmark for comparison for dose optimization studies.

CONCLUSION

This study provides reference levels ( 50th and 75th percentiles) for a comprehensive list of FGI procedures, reflecting an overall picture of the latest FGI studies for diagnosis, targeted minimally invasive intervention, and therapeutic treatment.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

This study provides reference levels (50th and 75th percentiles) for the largest number of fluoroscopically guided interventional procedures reported to date (101 procedures), in terms of air kerma at the reference point, air kerma-area product, and fluoroscopic time, among which these quartiles for ≥50 procedures are presented for the first time.

Local dose reference levels during transarterial chemoembolization procedure

The aim of this study was to develop local diagnostic reference levels (LDRL) during Transarterial chemoembolization (TACE). This cross-sectional study reports radiation dose indicators of 108 patients in a Mexican hospital, obtained over a period of 35 months. Kerma-area product (P_KA), air-kerma at the reference point (K_{a, r}), and descriptive statistical analysis were examined according to sociodemographic characteristics of the sample patients. The LDRL obtained were then compared to a similar international framework. The present study contributes to the establishment of a TACE LDRL and identifies significant correlations among radiology factors and dosimetric quantities obtained.

Institutional Diagnostic Reference Levels and Peak Skin Doses in selected diagnostic and therapeutic interventional radiology procedures

PURPOSE

Institutional (local) Diagnostic Reference Levels for Cerebral Angiography (CA), Percutaneous Transhepatic Cholangiography (PTC), Transarterial Chemoembolization (TACE) and Percutaneous Transhepatic Biliary Drainage (PTBD) are reported in this study.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data for air kerma-area product (P_KA), air kerma at the patient entrance reference point (K_a,r), fluoroscopy time (FT) and number of images (NI) as well as estimates of Peak Skin Dose (PSD) were collected for 142 patients. Therapeutic procedure complexity was also evaluated, in an attempt to incorporate it into the DRL analysis.

RESULTS

Local P_KA DRL values were 70, 34, 189 and 54 Gy.cm² for CA, PTC, TACE and PTBD respectively. The corresponding DRL values for K_a,r were 494, 194, 1186 and 400 mGy, for FT they were 9.2, 14.2, 27.5 and 22.9 min, for the NI they were 844, 32, 602 and 13 and for PSD they were 254, 256, 1598 and 540 mGy respectively. P_KA for medium complexity PTBD procedures was 2.5 times higher than for simple procedures. For TACE, the corresponding ratio was 1.6. PSD was estimated to be roughly 50% of recorded K_a,r for procedures in the head/neck region and 10% higher than recorded K_a,r for procedures in the body region. In only 5 cases the 2 Gy dose alarm threshold for skin deterministic effects was exceeded.

CONCLUSION

Procedure complexity can differentiate DRLs in Interventional Radiology procedures. PSD could be deduced with reasonable accuracy from values of K_a,r that are reported in every angiography system.

KERMA-AREA PRODUCT, ENTRANCE SURFACE DOSE AND EFFECTIVE DOSE IN ABDOMINAL ENDOVASCULAR ANEURYSM REPAIR

This study aims to evaluate patient radiation dose during fluoroscopically guided endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) procedures. Fluoroscopy time (FT) and kerma-area product (KAP) were recorded from 87 patients that underwent EVAR procedures with a mobile C-arm fluoroscopy system. Effective dose (ED) and organs' doses were calculated utilising appropriate conversion coefficients based on the recorded KAP values. Entrance surface dose (ESD) was calculated based on KAP values and technical parameters. The mean FT was 22.7 min (range 6.4-76.8 min), resulting in a mean KAP of 36.6 Gy cm2 (range 2.0-167.8 Gy cm2), a mean ED of 6.2 mSv (range 0.3-28.5 mSv) and a mean ESD of 458 mGy (range 26-2098 mGy). The corresponding median values were 17.4 min, 25.6 Gy cm2, 4.4 mSv and 320 mGy. The threshold of 2 Gy for skin erythema was exceeded in two procedures for a focus-to-skin distance (FSD) of 40 cm and six procedures when an FSD of 30 cm was considered. The highest doses absorbed by the adrenals, kidneys, spleen and pancreas and ranged between 3.7 and 313.3 mGy (average 66.8 mGy), 3.3 and 285.1 mGy (average 60.8 mGy), 1.3 and 111.1 mGy (average 23.7 mGy), 1.1 and 92.1 mGy (average 19.6 mGy), respectively. A wide range of patient doses was reported in the literature. The radiation dose received by the patients was comparative or lower than most of the previously reported values. However, higher doses can be revealed due to the X-ray system's non-optimum use and extended FTs, mainly affected by complex clinical conditions, patients' body habitus and vascular surgeon experience. The large variation of patient doses highlights the potential to optimise the EVAR procedure by considering the balance between the radiation dose and the required image quality. Additional studies need to be conducted in increasing the vascular surgeons' awareness regarding patient dose and radiation protection issues during EVAR procedures.

Diagnostic reference levels for fluoroscopically guided procedures in a South African tertiary hospital

BACKGROUND

The burgeoning usage and complexity of fluoroscopically guided procedures (FGPs) contribute to extended examination times and increased risk of adverse radiation effects. Diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) play a pivotal role in dose optimization. There are limited DRL data for FGPs in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs).

PURPOSE

To determine local DRLs (LDRLs) for common FGPs in the South African (SA) context and compare these with published international data.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A three-year, retrospective study of the 15 most frequently performed FGPs at a SA institution. For each procedure, the 50th and 75th percentiles of kerma area product (KAP), reference point air kerma (K_a,r), and fluoroscopy time data were derived. Published international FGP DRL data were collated and compared with the 75th percentiles of local institutional dosage parameters.

RESULTS

The commonest FGPs were aorto-bifemoral diagnostic angiography (n = 590), aorto-bifemoral interventional angiography (n = 287), nephrostomy (n = 265), and bronchial arterial embolization (BAE) (n = 208). Selective abdominal vessel interventional angiography (KAP = 170 Gy . cm²; K_a,r = 877 mGy) recorded the highest LDRL dosages; BAE was the longest procedure (LDRL = 38 min). Nephrostomies achieved the lowest LDRLs across all parameters (KAP = 10 Gy . cm²; K_a,r = 63 mGy, fluoroscopy time = 4.3 min). All Tygerberg Hospital LDRLs with comprehensive comparable data were within or below published ranges.

CONCLUSION

This study advances international radiation protection initiatives, addresses the paucity of LMIC DRL data, demonstrates broad alignment of Tygerberg Hospital FGP practice with international norms and highlights areas for optimization of institutional practice.

Diagnostic reference levels during fluoroscopically guided interventions using mobile C-arms in operating rooms: A national multicentric survey

PURPOSE

To establish diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) and achievable levels (ALs) for the most common fluoroscopically guided interventions (FGIs) performed in operating rooms using mobile C-arm equipment.

METHODS

A national survey was performed in 57 centers in France. Anonymous data from 6817 patients undergoing FGIs were prospectively collected over a period of 7 months. DRLs (third quartile of the distribution) and ALs (median of the distribution) were determined for each type of intervention in terms of kerma area product (KAP) and fluoroscopy time (FT).

RESULTS

DRLs and ALs were proposed for 31 procedure types related to seven surgical specialties: orthopedics (n = 9), urology (n = 3), vascular (n = 6), cardiology (n = 5), neurosurgery (n = 3), gastrointestinal (n = 3), and multi-specialty (n = 2). DRLs in terms of KAP ranged from 0.1 Gy·cm² for hallux valgus to 78 Gy·cm² for abdominal aortic aneurysm endovascular repair. A factor of 155 was obtained between the FTs for a herniated lumbar disk (0.2 min) and an abdominal aortic aneurysm endovascular repair (31 min). The highest variations were obtained within orthopedic procedures in terms of KAP (ratio 122) and within gastrointestinal procedures in terms of FT (ratio 9). Overall, the FGIs associated with the highest radiation exposure (KAP > 10 Gy·cm²) were found in the cardiology, vascular, and gastrointestinal specialties.

CONCLUSIONS

DRLs and ALs are suggested for a wide range of FGIs performed in operating rooms using a mobile C-arm. We aim at providing a practical optimization tool for medical physicists and surgeons.

PATIENT SIZE INDICES AND DOSE IN FLUOROSCOPICALLY GUIDED LUMBAR DISCECTOMY AND FUSION: A PRELIMINARY STUDY

Patient dose values varied significantly during interventional procedures, mainly due to the patient size, operators' choices and clinical complexity. In this study, the effect of applying a previously described and validated size-correction method to normalise kerma-area product (KAP) and average KAP rate values of the whole procedure (KAP rate) and isolate variations in dose due to the patient size and complexity, during lumbar discectomy and fusion (LDF) procedures, was investigated. Fluoroscopy time (FT), KAP, KAP rate and patient size data (weight, height and equivalent diameter) were recorded, for 96 patients who underwent single or multilevel LDF procedures by three senior neurosurgeons, defining three different patient groups (surgeon 1, surgeon 2, surgeon 3). Simple linear regression and coefficients of determination were used to investigate the relationship between uncorrected and corrected KAP and KAP rate values and patient size indices in these groups. The results showed that the size correction decreased the influence of patient size and could contribute to the isolation of the variations in patient dose due to the patient size. From this point of view, dose surveys during lumbar spine interventions may include dosimetric data from all patients independently of their body size and not only for standard-sized patients, providing the advantage of accessible data collection for the establishment of local dose reference levels and optimisation purposes, within the framework of the radiation protection program in the Neurosurgery Department.

Factors affecting radiation exposure in endovascular repair of abdominal aortic aneurysms: a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Radiation exposure during endovascular repair (EVAR) of abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs) is a potential issue. Several studies have identified factors affecting radiation exposure, although they are limited. The aim of this study was to identify independent factors affecting radiation exposure in patients with AAA undergoing standard EVAR.

METHODS

Forty-eight consecutive patients underwent elective EVAR for infrarenal AAA managed between April 2019 and April 2020. Fluoroscopy time (FT) and kerma area product (KAP) were the main outcome measures.

RESULTS

Median (interquartile range) FT and KAP values were 1018 (653-1619) s and 2.68 (2.08-3.81) mGy·m², respectively. C3 Excluder graft use and main body insertion site from the right femoral were associated with significantly lower FT. Coronary artery disease, endografts with two docking limbs, AAA diameter, neck angle and length, procedure duration, contrast amount, and hospitalization were associated with significantly higher FT. Neck angle was the single independent perioperative factor related to FT higher than the median value observed in the study (P=0.004, odds ratio: 1.073, 95% confidence interval: 1.023-1.126). The use of the C3 Excluder device was associated with lower KAP. AAA diameter, neck angle, procedure duration, contrast medium amount and postoperative hospitalization were associated with higher KAP. AAA diameter was the single independent factor related to KAP higher than the median value observed in the study (P=0.013, odds ratio: 3.73, 95% confidence interval: 1.32-10.56).

CONCLUSIONS

This study has identified factors affecting radiation exposure during standard EVAR for infrarenal AAAs. These factors should be taken into account when contemplating AAA repair.

ESTABLISHING LOCAL AND NATIONAL DIAGNOSTIC AND INTERVENTIONAL CARDIOLOGY AND RADIOLOGY REFERENCE LEVELS IN A SMALL EUROPEAN STATE: THE CASE OF MALTA

European Directive 2013/59/EURATOM requires the establishment and use of diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) for diagnostic and interventional procedures. The purpose of this study was to establish local DRLs for a major tertiary public hospital. As the hospital is the only such hospital in Malta, the same data collected for setting local DRLs can also be used for setting national DRLs, making local DRLs de facto national DRLs. A retrospective survey of cumulative kerma-area product (KAP) and fluoroscopy time data from the cardiac catheterisation laboratory and interventional radiology suites was carried out. The effect of system upgrades on cumulative KAP was also assessed. Local DRLs were set for common cardiology and interventional radiology procedures. All DRLs compare favourably with those in European literature. A Philips Allura Clarity upgrade to the cardiac catheterisation laboratories led to significant reductions in cumulative KAP (p ≪  0.05) for most procedures.

SURVEY OF KEY RADIATION SAFETY PRACTICES IN INTERVENTIONAL RADIOLOGY: AN IRISH AND ENGLISH STUDY

Interventional radiology is a rapidly evolving speciality with potential to deliver high patient radiation doses, as a result high standards of radiation safety practice are imperative. IR radiation safety practice must be considered before during and after procedures through appropriate patient consent, dose monitoring and patient follow-up. This questionnaire-based study surveyed fixed IR departments across Ireland and England to establish clinical practice in relation to radiation safety. Pre-procedure IR patient consent includes all radiation effects in 11% of cases. The patient skin dose surrogate parameter of Kerma to air at a reference point (Kar) is under-reported. Only 39% of respondents use a substantial radiation dose level and inform patients after these have been reached. Poor compliance with unambiguous, readily available best practice guidance was observed throughout highlighting patient communication, patient dose quantification and subsequent patient dose management concerns.

Patient Radiation Dose Reduction Considerations in a Contemporary Interventional Radiology Suite

PURPOSE

We sought to evaluate patient radiation exposure during complex liver interventional procedures performed with newer angiography equipment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted a retrospective study of transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) creations and liver tumor embolizations performed in our new angiography suite (Discovery IGS740, GE Healthcare). T tests were used to compare air kerma-area product (P_KA) and reference plane air kerma (K_a,r) in the new room versus data from historical rooms and previous studies (including the RAD IR study). Results were expressed as medians [interquartile ranges (Q1, Q3)].

RESULTS

From February 2015 to June 2016, 134 complex liver interventional procedures were performed in the new room, including 14 TIPS creations, 60 hepatic tumor arterial embolizations (HAEs), 26 Y90 mappings (Y90m), and 34 Y90 radioembolizations (Y90). K_a,r (Gy) values were as follows: TIPS, 0.65 (0.24, 1.15); HAE, 0.89 (0.49, 1.49); Y90m, 0.54 (0.38, 0.94); Y90, 0.46 (0.21, 1.06). P_KA (Gy·cm²) values were as follows: TIPS, 148.2 (66.7, 326.5); HAE, 142.6 (88, 217.8); Y90m, 148.3 (98.2, 247); Y90, 90.8 (43.9, 161.5). K_a,r and P_KA were lower in the new room than in historical rooms [K_a,r and P_KA reductions: TIPS, 58 and 49%; HAE, 31 and 39%; Y90m, 58 and 52%; Y90, 49 and 56% (p < 0.05)] and versus the RAD IR study [K_a,r and P_KA reductions: TIPS, 64 and 43%; HAE, 26 and 40% (p < 0.05)].

CONCLUSIONS

Using the latest technology and image processing tools enables significant reduction in radiation exposure during complex liver interventional procedures.