A simple technique to achieve bloodless excision of carotid body tumors

Morbidity and Long-Term Patient-Reported Outcomes Following Advanced Carotid Body Tumor Resection

BACKGROUND

The reported risk of a cranial nerve (CN) injury is up to 1 in 4 patients in large registries of carotid body tumor (CBT) resection. Functional outcome for this population is unknown.

METHODS

We evaluated consecutive patients who underwent CBT resection from November 2013 through October 2020. Demographics, intraoperative details, complications, and outcomes were recorded from the medical record. Permanent CN nerve injury was defined as deficits lasting >6 months. Frequency statistics, averages, chi-squared test, and multiple logistic regression were completed for primary end points of complications and disease-free survival. Patient-reported outcomes were gathered via telephone survey of patients conducted in September 2021.

RESULTS

Fifty-one patients presented with CBTs and the following Shamblin classes: I (n = 7; 14%), II (n = 36; 69%), and III (n = 9; 17%). Head and neck oncology and vascular surgery jointly did 52% of CBT resections, including 6 of 9 Shamblin III cases. Eight patients (15.3%, all Shamblin II or III) suffered a total of 12 CN injuries - 8 CN XII (5 temporary and 3 permanent), 3 CN X (all permanent), and 1 CN XI (permanent). Seven of the CN injury subgroup had preoperative embolization and 5 were joint oncology/vascular cases. In addition, 4 separate carotid injuries required repair. Notably, all patients had disease-free survival postoperatively at a mean follow-up of 6 months. Patient-reported outcomes obtained in 70.6% of patients 1 year or more from index operation demonstrated that two-thirds of patients live without any permanent functional deficits, and the majority of those with continued deficits rate the symptoms as daily but mild in severity.

CONCLUSIONS

In a series of complex CBT patients treated with preoperative embolization capabilities and multidisciplinary surgical approach, disease-free survival was achieved in all patients despite a high rate of iatrogenic CN injuries, most commonly CN XII. Patient-reported outcomes survey results indicate that injuries identified on clinical exam underreport patients' true postoperative CN deficits - especially branches of CN X. This data support the practice of aggressive primary resection of CBTs while providing guidance for expected functional outcomes due to CN injury risk.

Retrospective analysis of carotid body tumor surgical management: roles of preoperative image investigation and preoperative embolization

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the management of carotid body tumors (CBTs), particularly the use of preoperative embolization (EMB) and image features in minimizing surgical complications.

BACKGROUND

CBT surgery is a challenging procedure, and the role of EMB in CBT surgery has remained unclear.

METHODS

A total of 200 CBTs were identified among 184 medical records involving CBT surgery. Regression analysis was used to explore the prognostic predictors of cranial nerve deficit (CND), including image features. In addition, blood loss, operation times, and complication rates were compared between patients who had surgery only versus patients who had surgery along with preoperative EMB.

RESULTS

Overall, 96 males and 88 females were identified for inclusion in the study, with a median age of 37.0 years. Computed tomography angiography (CTA) showed the presence of a tiny gap adjacent to the encasement of carotid vessels, which could help minimize carotid arterial injury. High-lying tumors that encased the cranial nerve were usually managed with synchronous cranial nerve resection. Regression analysis revealed that the incidence of CND was positively associated with Shamblin Ⅲ, high-lying, and a maximal CBT diameter of ≥ 5cm. Among 146 EMB cases, two cases of intracranial arterial embolization occurred. No statistical difference was found between the EBM and Non-EBM groups in terms of bleeding volume, operation time, blood loss, blood transfusion requirement, stroke, and permanent CND. Subgroup analysis revealed that EMB decreased CND in Shamblin III and low-lying tumors.

CONCLUSIONS

CBT surgery should be performed with preoperative CTA to identify favorable factors for minimizing surgical complications. Shamblin Ⅲ or high-lying tumors, as well as CBT diameter, are predictors of permanent CND. EBM does not reduce blood loss or shorten operation time.

Shamblin III Chemodectoma: The vascular surgeon's point of view

Chemodectomas (CBTs) are the most frequently encountered tumours at the carotid bifurcation. Even if rare and commonly benign, their development close to the head and neck structures is often source of morbidity by compression and infiltration. Therefore, in order to avoid permanent neurologic or vascular complications these infrequent lesions need to be early removed. The total excision may be technically challenging and requires extensive expertise in surgical neck anatomy and a cooperative multidisciplinary approach. Almost a quarter of CBTs infiltrate carotid vessels so vascular expertise is pivotal in their resection. The present study aims to give an overview of vascular specificity and procedures required during surgical excision of such tumors to assist and guide treating physicians who encounter CBTs. This overview will particularly emphasize current therapeutic options: we discuss the referral criteria that should guide the decision about what type of preoperative care and surgical procedure should be offered to the affected patients. We also specify the epidemiologic data, screening recommendations and outcomes achieved with the different therapeutic approaches. The clinical, operative and follow-up data about a case of a Shamblin III carotid body tumour surgically removed by a multidisciplinary team at our Institution are also reported.

The Outcome of Multidisciplinary Management of Carotid Body Tumors: Retrospective Cohort Study

Background

Carotid body tumor (CBT) is a rare paraganglionic hyper-vascular tumor of the carotid body. The standard treatment for CBTs is surgery, but it involves risk. The study is aimed to assess the CBTs and evaluate the outcome of multidisciplinary management.

Materials and Methods

A retrospective cohort study included patients with CBTs who were managed by surgical excision between May 2006 and April 2018. A multidisciplinary team was established to excise the tumor completely with minimal neurovascular compromise.

Results

The study comprised of 32 patients in the age group of 23-65 years. The main presentation was a unilateral painless neck mass. Six cases (18.75%) were Shamblin I, 10 (31.25%) Shamblin II and 16 (50%) Shamblin III. Complete excision was performed for all cases. Ligation of the external carotid artery was done in 15 cases (46.88%) and repair of the internal carotid artery in 6 (18.75%). Postoperative cranial nerve complications occurred in six patients (18.75%): four transient hypoglossal pareses and two hoarseness of voice. Histopathologically, one case (3.125%) was malignant. No recurrence was detected through the follow-up period.

Conclusion

A multidisciplinary approach is essential for management of CBTs. Early diagnosis and surgical resection minimize morbidity and carry good surgical outcome.

Trial Registration Number

ChiCTR1800018722 (Agency: Chinese Clinical Trial Registry).

A meta-analysis on the surgical management of paraganglioma of the carotid body per Shamblin class

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the risk associated with different types of surgery for carotid body paraganglioma of different Shamblin class. A meta-analysis was conducted to evaluate per tumour class, the local control, cranial nerve damage and complication rates of different techniques using internal carotid artery (ICA) and external carotid artery (ECA) ligation, clamping or bypassing, as well as the craniocaudal vs caudocranial techniques.

DESIGN

A meta-analysis is conducted after a systematic search in PubMed and the Cochrane library, in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Local control, cranial nerve damage, complications, function recovery.

RESULTS

Out of 3565 articles, 27 were selected. The overall quality of evidence of studies was low. Cranial nerve damage (3%, 17% and 39%) and complication rates (0%, 1% and 10%) were significantly related to Shamblin class (class 1, 2 and 3, respectively, P < .01). For class 3 tumours, an increased risk of complications was found associated with routine ICA manipulation/reconstruction (RR 3.12 with a 95% CI of 1.29-7.59), as well as a trend towards enhanced risk of routine ECA ligation (RR 3.48 with a 95% CI of 0.88-13.81).

CONCLUSIONS

For class 1 and 2 tumours, surgery seems a viable treatment option. For class 3 tumours, morbidity in terms of cranial nerve deficit and complications is considerable; particularly, the use of ICA manipulation/reconstruction and potentially ECA ligation seem to be accompanied by high stroke incidence.

Carotid Body Tumor with Skull Base Extension

Patient: Male, 59

Final Diagnosis: Benign carotid body tumor

Symptoms: Neck mass

Medication: —

Clinical Procedure: —

Specialty: Otolaryngology

Case Report: Managing a giant, high-grade carotid body tumor in a resource-limited setting

Herein we report the management of a giant, high-grade and vascular carotid body tumor in a young woman. She presented with slowly progressive neck swelling. Vascular imaging revealed a left-sided, high-grade giant carotid body tumor (> 8cm).  The tumor was completely excised by caudocranial subadventitial dissection. Histology of the tumor revealed a characteristic Zellballen pattern of the lesion, suggestive of a paraganglioma. The patient made an uneventful recovery. We also discuss newer insights regarding the management of such highly vascular lesions.

The "INT-EX Technique": Internal to External Approach in Carotid Body Tumour Surgery

Carotid body tumours are rare and mostly benign neoplasm. They are slow growing but can evade or exert pressure on neighbouring important neurovascular structures. Hence, surgical resection remains the treatment modality of choice for large tumours partially or completely encasing the carotid arteries. But the surgical resection of these tumours with minimum morbidity is challenging because of their highly vascular nature. Earlier literature has dealt with various aspects of management of carotid body tumours including classification, morbidity, work-up, embolisation and extent of resection. However, the options in techniques of dissection for carotid body tumours have not been elaborated much. Here, we describe a stepwise dissection technique of carotid body tumours from the internal carotid towards the external carotid artery. This surgical technique, named as "the internal to external (INT-EX) technique", provides better control of bleeding during the surgery, ease of dissection and lesser post-operative morbidity.

Multidisciplinary Management of Carotid Body Tumors in a Tertiary Urban Institution

Objective. Aim of this study is to present the experience of our institution in carotid body tumors (CBTs) treatment. Methods. All cases treated in a Vascular Surgery Department within 2.5 years (03/2013-09/2015) were retrospectively evaluated. Demographics, diagnostic, and treatment strategy were recorded. All patients with known CBT underwent ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging preoperatively. All cases were classified according to the Shamblin type and evaluated by a radiologist, otolaryngologist, and anesthesiologist before and after surgery. Major outcomes included mortality, stroke, cranial nerve injury, and recurrence. Results. Overall, nine patients (mean age: 59.5 ± 16.3 years) with a total of ten CBTs were treated. There was no gender prevalence and most of the cases (55%) were asymptomatic. There were no functional or familial cases. There was only one bilateral case treated in a staged manner. No preoperative embolization of CBTs was performed. Mortality and stroke rates were null. No severe complication was observed in the early and late setting. No malignancy was recorded. Mean follow-up was 15.6 ± 7.8 months. Conclusions. Multidisciplinary management of patients with CBTs is imperative for optimal results, especially in type III tumors, bilateral or functional cases. After careful treatment planning and intraoperative manipulations, complications could be avoided even without preoperative embolization.