Defining sources and ramifications of mistreatment among female vascular surgery trainees

Bullying, Harassment, and Undermining Behavior in Cardiothoracic Surgery in the United Kingdom and Ireland

BACKGROUND

Bullying, harassment, and undermining behavior has a profound detrimental effect on the multiprofessional team, patient safety, and clinical outcomes. Bullying creates a poor working and training environment, increasing stress, damaging confidence, and impairing well-being. We sought to characterize the prevalence and nature of bullying, harassment, and undermining within cardiothoracic surgery in the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland.

METHODS

A 21-question survey was sent to all members of the Society for Cardiothoracic Surgery in Great Britain and Ireland. Participants were asked about baseline demographics and their experience of bullying as victim or witness.

RESULTS

The survey was sent to 1326 Society for Cardiothoracic Surgery members, and there were 278 responses (21.0%). Most respondents were physicians (75.2%; n = 209), and most were male (58.3%; n = 162). Most (79.1%; n = 220) had experienced or witnessed bullying in some form within the last 3 years (or appointment as a professional). This was experienced directly by most respondents (62%; n = 136), and a large minority (23.6%; n = 52) had witnessed it in their workplace.

CONCLUSIONS

Bullying is observed or experienced by a concerning proportion of health care professionals working in cardiothoracic surgery. Ongoing initiatives to reduce this within British and Irish health care need to be strengthened to improve prevention, reporting and investigation, and support for victims and perpetrators to keep workplaces safe for teams and individuals and to facilitate the delivery of the best possible patient care.

Trainee Perception of Virtual Interviews and Associations of Virtual Engagement with Vascular Surgery Culture and Community

BACKGROUND

In recent years, the vascular surgery community has increased the utilization of virtual interviews and virtual engagement or use of online technologies for educational, networking, and mentorship activities. This study evaluates trainee preferences of virtual interviews and associations of virtual engagement with wellness.

METHODS

Deidentified data were collected from a confidential, voluntary survey of residents and fellows in vascular surgery programs administered following the 2023 Vascular Surgery In-Training Examination (VSITE). A 5-point Likert scale measured resident perceptions of virtual interviews and virtual interactions. Multivariable logistic regression modeling was used to compare factors associated with preference of virtual interviews and virtual engagement.

RESULTS

Of 521 trainees who participated in the survey (78.2% response rate), 60.8% were male, 48.8% were non-White, and there was a relatively equal distribution among training years. Only 41.2% of the trainees reported they would have preferred virtual interviews in retrospect. These trainees were more likely to be non-White and in postgraduate years one or 2 (P = 0.03 and P < 0.001, respectively). Overall, 83.5% of trainees were classified as virtually engaged. These trainees were more likely to be male (86.5% vs. 78.9%, P = 0.033) and had 2.8 increased odds of satisfaction with time for their personal lives (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

While most trainees surveyed reported a preference for in-person interviews, trainees report that virtual interviews are reflective of program culture. Additionally, trainees who were virtually engaged were more likely to report satisfaction with their time for their personal lives. Our study supports continued hybrid approaches to interviews and trainee engagement.

A multi-institutional study from the United States Resident OPerative Experience Consortium examining factors influencing vascular surgery specialization among general surgery residents

OBJECTIVE

There remains a progressive projected deficit in the vascular surgery (VS) workforce for decades. Despite the expanding integrated VS residency pathway, the fellowship training model remains critical in supporting our future workforce. Therefore, it is imperative to understand the resident and program-specific factors that influence VS specialization among general surgery (GS) residents.

METHODS

Data from the United States Resident OPerative Experience (ROPE) Consortium, which comprises 20 Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education-accredited GS residency programs across the United States, were queried for resident demographics and residency program-related details. Logistic regression analysis was used to identify factors associated with VS specialization.

RESULTS

From 2010 to 2020, a total of 1343 graduating GS residents were included in the study. Of these, 135 (10.1%) pursued VS fellowship training. Residents pursuing VS were more frequently male (80.7% vs 62.8%; P < .0001) and younger (median age, 32 vs 33 years; P = .03) compared with other GS residents. Racial and ethnic group, underrepresented in medicine status, and international medical graduate status were similar between the VS and non-VS groups. Residency program-level details were also similar between groups, including program type (university vs community-based), region, size, resident volume, dedicated research experience, and National Institutes of Health funding. Dedicated vascular rotations were common among all GS programs (95.4%), and total months spent on a VS rotation (median, 4 vs 4.5 months; P = .11) did not differ among residents pursuing VS and all other residents. The presence of a collocated traditional (5 + 2) VS fellowship (91.1% vs 90.4%; P = .79) or integrated (0 + 5) VS residency (56.3% vs 55.0%; P = .77) were also similar between groups. On multivariate analysis, only male sex (odds ratio, 2.34; 95% confidence interval, 1.50-3.81; P < .001) was associated with pursuing VS fellowship. Factors that did not impact VS specialization included resident age, underrepresented in medicine status, international medical graduate status, program volume, dedicated research experience, or total months spent on a VS rotation.

CONCLUSIONS

In this multi-institutional study, we did not find any program-specific factors that influence VS specialization among GS residents. Notably, the presence of a collocated 0 + 5 residency or 5 + 2 fellowship program did not appear to deter GS residents from pursuing a VS fellowship. These data suggest that individual factors, such as mentorship, may be more impactful in recruiting GS residents to the VS specialty.

Burnout is not associated with trainee performance on the Vascular Surgery In-Training Exam

OBJECTIVE

The Vascular Surgery In-Training Examination (VSITE) is a yearly exam evaluating vascular trainees' knowledge base. Although multiple studies have evaluated variables associated with exam outcomes, few have incorporated training program-specific metrics. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the impact of the learning environment and burnout on VSITE performance.

METHODS

Data was collected from a confidential, voluntary survey administered after the 2020 to 2022 VSITE as part of the SECOND Trial. VSITE scores were calculated as percent correct then standardized per the American Board of Surgery. Generalized estimating equations with robust standard errors and an independent correlation structure were used to evaluate trainee and program factors associated with exam outcomes. Analyses were further stratified by integrated and independent training paradigms.

RESULTS

A total of 1385 trainee responses with burnout data were collected over 3 years (408 in 2020, 459 in 2021, 498 in 2022). On average, 46% of responses reported at least weekly burnout symptoms. On unadjusted analysis, burnout symptoms correlated with a 14 point drop in VSITE score (95% confidence interval [CI], -24 to -4; P = .006). However, burnout was no longer significant after adjusted analysis. Instead, higher postgraduate year level, being in a relationship, identifying as male gender with or without kids, identifying as non-Hispanic white, larger programs, and having a sense of belonging within a program were associated with higher VSITE scores.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite high rates of burnout, trainees generally demonstrate resilience in gaining the medical knowledge necessary to pass the VSITE. Performance on standardized exams is associated with trainee and program characteristics, including availability of support systems and program belongingness.

The Diversity of Surgical Trainees Index identifies racial and ethnic disparities among surgical specialties

OBJECTIVE

Racial and ethnic disparities have been well-described among surgical specialties; however, variations in underrepresented in medicine (URiM) representation between these specialties have not previously been quantified.

METHODS

Data collected from Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) annual reports were used to derive the Diversity of Surgical Trainee Index (DoSTI), which was calculated as the proportion of URiM residents and fellow physicians within a given surgical specialty, relative to the overall proportion of URiM trainees within all surgical and non-surgical ACGME-accredited programs in the same academic year.

RESULTS

From 2013 to 2022, a total of 108,193 ACGME-accredited residency programs trained 1,296,204 residents and fellows in the United States. Of these, 14.1% (n = 182,680) of trainees self-identified as URiM over the study period. The mean DoSTI among all surgical specialties was 0.80 (standard error, 0.01) compared with all ACGME-accredited programs. High DoSTI specialties incorporated significantly higher proportions of trainees who identify as Hispanic (8.7% vs 6.3%) and Black or African American (5.2% vs 2.5%) when compared with low DoSTI specialties (P < .0001 each). General surgery (1.06 ± 0.01), plastic surgery (traditional) (1.12 ± 0.06), vascular surgery (integrated) (0.96 ± 0.03), and vascular surgery (traditional) (0.94 ± 0.06) had the highest DoSTI (P < .05 each vs composite). On linear regression analysis, only ophthalmology (+0.01/year; R2 = 0.41; P = .019), orthopedic surgery (+0.01/year; R2 = 0.33; P = .047), otolaryngology (+0.02/year; R2 = 0.86; P < .001), and pediatric surgery (+0.06/year; R2 = 0.33; P = .048) demonstrated an annual increase in DoSTI.

CONCLUSIONS

The DoSTI is a novel metric used to quantify the degree of URiM representation among surgical specialties. DoSTI has revealed specialty-specific variations in racial/ethnic minority representation among surgical training programs. This metric may be used to improve provider awareness and identify high performing DoSTI specialties to highlight best practices to ultimately recruit a more diverse surgical workforce.

Gender-Related Disparities Among Vascular Surgeons in Italy: Results from a Cross-Sectional Survey

BACKGROUND

To assess the presence, quality and impact of gender-related discrepancies in academic vascular surgery at a national level.

METHODS

This was an anonymous national structured nonvalidated cross-sectional survey on gender disparity perceptions, named "I love it when you call me Señorita", distributed to 645 participants from academic Italian vascular centers. Endpoints were related to job-related characteristics, satisfaction, and sexual harassment.

RESULTS

The survey yielded a 27% response rate (n = 174, 78 males and 96 females). Significant differences between male and female responders were found in terms of job satisfaction (83.3% vs. 53.1%, P < 0.001), perception of career opportunities (91.7% vs. 67.9%, P < 0.001), surgical activity in the operating theater (34.6% vs. 7.3%, P < 0.001), involvement in scientific activities (contribution in peer-reviewed articles: 37.2% vs. 9.4%, P < 0.001; scientific meeting attendance/year: 42.3% vs. 20.8%, P = 0.002), and perception of lower peer support at work (2.6% vs. 22.9%, P < 0.001). In addition, female physicians more frequently suffered sexual harassment from male peers/colleagues (10% vs. 34%, P < 0.001), male health-care workers (7% vs. 26%, P = 0.001), or patients/caregivers independently from their sex (6% vs. 38.5%, P < 0.001 for males and 5% vs. 22%, P = 0.001 for females).

CONCLUSIONS

A significant number of the female vascular surgeons in Italian academic vascular centers responding to the survey have experienced workplace inequality and sexual harassment. Substantial efforts and ongoing initiatives are still required to address gender disparities, emphasizing the need for the promotion of specific guidelines within scientific societies.

Reported pain at work is a risk factor for vascular surgery trainee burnout

BACKGROUND

Work-related pain is a known risk factor for vascular surgeon burnout. It risks early attrition from our workforce and is a recognized threat to the specialty. Our study aimed to understand whether work-related pain similarly contributed to vascular surgery trainee well-being.

METHODS

A confidential, voluntary survey was administered after the 2022 Vascular Surgery In-Service Examination to trainees in all Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education-accredited vascular surgery programs. Burnout was measured by a modified, abbreviated Maslach Burnout Inventory; pain after a full day of work was measured using a 10-point Likert scale and then dichotomized as "no to mild pain" (0-2) vs "moderate to severe pain" (3-9). Univariable analyses and multivariable regression assessed associations of pain with well-being indicators (eg, burnout, thoughts of attrition, and thoughts of career change). Pain management strategies were included as additional covariables in our study.

RESULTS

We included 527 trainees who completed the survey (82.2% response rate); 38% reported moderate to severe pain after a full day of work, of whom 73.6% reported using ergonomic adjustments and 67.0% used over-the-counter medications. Significantly more women reported moderate to severe pain than men (44.3% vs 34.5%; P < .01). After adjusting for gender, training level, race/ethnicity, mistreatment, and dissatisfaction with operative autonomy, moderate-to-severe pain (odds ratio, 2.52; 95% confidence interval, 1.48-4.26) and using physiotherapy as pain management (odds ratio, 3.06; 95% confidence interval, 1.02-9.14) were risk factors for burnout. Moderate to severe pain was not a risk factor for thoughts of attrition or career change after adjustment.

CONCLUSIONS

Physical pain is prevalent among vascular surgery trainees and represents a risk factor for trainee burnout. Programs should consider mitigating this occupational hazard by offering ergonomic education and adjuncts, such as posture awareness and microbreaks during surgery, early and throughout training.

Burnout and Its Consequences among Vascular Surgeons and Trainees: A Danish National Survey

BACKGROUND

Burnout among physicians has widespread negative consequences. Little is known about burnout among European vascular surgeons (VS). A previously published study found that 82% of VS and vascular surgical trainees (VST) in Denmark experience burnout symptoms. The present study aimed to investigate work- and health-related consequences of burnout.

STUDY DESIGN

An electronic survey was distributed to all VS/VST in Denmark in January 2020. Validated assessment tools were used to measure burnout, mental health, and psychosocial work environment aspects.

RESULTS

Of 104 invited VS/VST, 82% (n = 85) completed the survey. VS accounted for 72% (n = 61) of the respondents, and 40% (n = 33) were female. Statistically significant associations were found between higher levels of burnout and a range of work- and health-related outcomes, including a sense of meaning at work, workplace commitment, conflicts between work and private life, work stress, sick leave, and depressive symptoms. VS/VST using pain medication daily or weekly had significantly higher burnout scores than respondents who rarely or never use pain medication. A significant association between burnout and job satisfaction and retention was found, with respondents indicating an intention to stay within the specialty having significantly lower burnout scores than those who considered leaving within 5 years. Among those who indicated leaving the specialty, 35% (n = 13) attributed this to their current working conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

Burnout among VS/VST in Denmark is negatively associated with various work- and health-related outcomes. The work environment seems to play an essential role in these associations, and alterations in workplace organization may remedy this situation.