A systematic review and network meta-analysis of the effectiveness of sclerotherapy for venous malformation

Safety and efficacy of cryoablation of soft-tissue tumours: a systematic review

OBJECTIVES

To assess the safety and efficacy of percutaneous cryoablation (CA) of soft-tissue tumours [desmoid tumours (DTs), vascular malformations (VMs), and abdominal wall endometriosis (AWE)].

METHODS

This systematic review of studies published before January 2024 encompassed a detailed analysis of CA techniques and technical aspects for the treatment of soft-tissue tumours. Data concerning CA efficacy, complication rates, and other relevant metrics were extracted and included for analysis.

RESULTS

The analysis included 27 studies totalling 554 CA procedures. For DT (13 studies, 393 sessions), CA showed an average pain reduction of 79 ± 17% (range: 57-100) and a lesion volume decrease of 71.5 ± 9.8% (range: 44-97). VM (4 studies, 58 sessions) had a 100% technical success rate and an average pain reduction of 72 ± 25% (range: 63-85). The average pain reduction for AWE (6 studies, 103 sessions) was 82 ± 13% (range: 62-100). Overall, the complication rate for CA was low, with minor adverse events (AEs) in about 20% of patients and major events in less than 5% of patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Showing substantial efficacy in pain reduction and lesion volume decrease, as well as low incidence of severe AE, CA presents as a highly effective and safe alternative for the treatment of soft-tissue tumours.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

CA is effective and safe in treating soft-tissue tumours, particularly DT, VM, and AWE.

Efficacy of sclerotherapy with pingyangmycin and polidocanol for venous malformations

Objective

To investigate the treatment outcomes of sclerotherapy with pingyangmycin and polidocanol for venous malformations.

Methods

This retrospective study included patients with venous malformations who underwent sclerotherapy between January 2022 and June 2024. Patient demographics, symptoms, treatment information were gathered from the electronic medical records, and imaging data from the hospital's picture archiving and communication system were reviewed.

Results

A total of 29 patients, composed of 12 males and 17 females, with venous malformations, who underwent 66 procedures during the study period, were analyzed. The lesions were located in the lower limbs in 13 cases, in the upper limbs in 9, in the head and neck in 5, and in the trunk in 2. Twenty-four patients presented with pain, with a median visual analog scale (VAS) score of 4 and the correlation with age was statistically significant. After sclerotherapy, the median VAS score declined to 1, and there was a statistical difference in the overall median VAS score between pre- and post-treatment. According to the evaluation criteria, the treatment response was evaluated as grade 4 in 4 cases, as grade 3 in 17 cases, and as grade 2 in 8 cases; none of the treatment responses was evaluated as grade 1. None of the patients experienced serious adverse reactions.

Conclusion

Sclerotherapy with pingyangmycin and polidocanol is a treatment modality for relieving the clinical symptoms of venous malformations, with good efficacy and few potential risks.

Application of ultrasound-guided microwave ablation combined with polidocanol injection in benign cystic-solid thyroid nodules and recurrence analysis

OBJECTIVE

This study is intended to investigate the efficacy of ultrasound-guided microwave ablation (MWA) combined with polyguinol injection in treating benign cystic-solid thyroid nodules and its effect on recurrence rates.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was conducted on 120 patients with benign cystic-solid thyroid nodules, who were divided into two groups based on different treatment modalities: the control group (60 cases) and the observation group (60 cases). The control group underwent ultrasound-guided MWA combined with anhydrous ethanol sclerotherapy, while the observation group received ultrasound-guided MWA combined with polidocanol sclerotherapy. Treatment efficacy was assessed postoperatively. Serum levels of free triiodothyronine (FT3), free thyroxine (FT4), and thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH)were measured before and after surgery. Changes in nodule volume and volume reduction rates were compared. The incidence of adverse reactions and recurrence rates were recorded.

RESULTS

The observation group demonstrated a significantly higher overall treatment efficacy compared to the control group (P < 0.05). There were no significant differences in preoperative and postoperative FT3, FT4, and TSH levels between the two groups, indicating preserved thyroid function. Postoperative thyroid nodule volumes were significantly reduced in both groups compared to pre-treatment values, with the observation group achieving greater reductions than the control group (P < 0.05). The volume reduction rate was also notably higher in the observation group (P < 0.05). Additionally, the observation group experienced a lower incidence of adverse reactions and recurrence compared to the control group (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Ultrasound-guided MWA combined with polidocanol injection is more effective in treating benign cystic-solid thyroid nodules. This approach accelerates nodule ablation, significantly reduces nodule size, preserves thyroid function, lowers recurrence rates, and enhances overall safety.

Percutaneous image-guided cryoablation of venous malformation and fibro-adipose vascular anomaly: prognostic factors of clinical efficacy

OBJECTIVE

To assess the prognostic factors for clinical and radiological responses to percutaneous image-guided cryoablation (CA) in treating venous malformation (VM) and fibro-adipose vascular anomaly (FAVA).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty-five patients (12 males, 43 females; median age: 30 years) with symptomatic lesions (median VAS pain score: 70; median initial volume: 12.2 mm³) underwent CA between 2012 and 2023. CA was a first-line treatment in 23 patients (42%) and second-line in 32 (58%). Lesions were Goyal grade 1 in 24 cases (43%) and located on extremities in 44 (80%). Technical efficacy was assessed using MRI and applying RECIST criteria, while clinical efficacy was based on changes in VAS pain scores. Prognostic factors for residual pain were analyzed using univariable and multivariable analyses.

RESULTS

With a median follow-up of 13 months, technical success was achieved in all cases, and 20% of patients underwent multiple sessions. Technical efficacy was observed in 69% of cases, with 33% achieving complete response and 36% partial response (mean volume reduction: 47%). Clinical efficacy was reached in 72% of cases. Univariable analysis linked residual pain to sex (female, p = 0.013), initial pain level (p = 0.014), Goyal grade (p = 0.029), and residual volume (p = 0.012). Multivariable analysis revealed that grade (p = 0.035), post-therapeutic volume (p = 0.048), and completeness of treatment (p = 0.029) were statistically significant predictors.

CONCLUSION

Cryoablation is an effective management strategy for venous malformation and FAVA, with residual volume emerging as a significant indicator of clinical success.

KEY POINTS

Question Venous malformations (VA) and fibro-adipose vascular anomalies (FAVA) often cause chronic pain, with limited effective treatment options. Identifying predictors of pain relief following cryoablation could optimize patient outcomes. Findings Cryoablation achieved 72% pain relief for VA and FAVA. High lesion grade, treatment completeness, and residual volume were significantly associated with residual pain. Clinical relevance Cryoablation provides an effective, minimally invasive treatment for VA and FAVA, achieving significant pain relief while identifying predictors to optimize patient selection and outcomes.

Benign Soft Tissue Lesions Responsible for Pain: When and How Should the IR Intervene

In most of the cases Interventional Radiology techniques and therapies are proposed for the management of symptomatic soft tissue benign tumors responsible for pain and/or compression symptoms aiming to offer a curative intent by means of tumor necrosis with subsequent symptoms' management and improvement of life quality. The ablative therapies include chemical, thermal and non-thermal approaches while, trans-arterial (chemo)embolization also has a distinct role. Adjunct ancillary techniques should be performed whenever necessary to increase efficacy and safety and avoid or reduce complications. The purpose of the current review is to identify the basis for treating soft tissue benign tumors with Interventional Radiology therapies, to offer a detailed review of them, to explain the expected outcomes and describe techniques for avoiding complications. Furthermore, a reflection upon future directions will be suggested.

Percutaneous cryoablation in soft tissue tumor management: an educational review

BACKGROUND

Percutaneous cryoablation (PCA), having shown effectiveness in treating liver, lung, prostate, breast, and kidney tumors, is now gaining attention for the treatment of soft tissue tumors. PCA functions by freezing tissue, which induces ice crystal formation and cell death without damaging collagen structures. Technical considerations include the selection and handling of cryoprobes and cryogenic agents, procedural duration, and choice of image guidance for precision. This review aims to synthesize the mechanisms, applications, and technical aspects of PCA in the treatment of soft tissue tumors.

METHODS

Adhering to PRISMA 2020 guidelines, a review was conducted of studies published prior to March 2024 that investigated PCA of soft tissue tumors. The review focused on technical and procedural aspects of cryoablation, cryobiological principles, cellular and tissue responses to extreme cold, intra- and post-procedure physiological mechanisms during and post-procedure, and main clinical applications.

RESULTS

PCA is efficient in treating soft tissue tumors, including desmoid tumors, vascular malformations, and abdominal wall endometriosis. Several cryobiological mechanisms are involved, notably ice crystal formation, cellular dehydration, osmotic effects, and the inflammatory response, all of which contribute to its efficacy. Key technical aspects include the choice of cryoprobes, cryogenic agents (argon gas or liquid nitrogen), and the duration and control of freezing/thawing cycles. PCA also frequently outperformed traditional treatments like surgery and radiotherapy in terms of pain reduction, tumor size reduction, and patient outcomes. Moreover, its nerve sideration properties make it effective under local anesthesia.

CONCLUSION

Demonstrating substantial pain reduction, tumor size decrease, and high technical success rates, PCA offers a promising and minimally invasive alternative for soft tissue tumor treatment.

CRITICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT

Percutaneous cryoablation provides a minimally invasive, precise alternative for soft tissue tumor management, advancing clinical radiology by offering effective treatment with reduced patient risk and enhanced outcomes through image-guided procedures.

KEY POINTS

Percutaneous cryoablation (PCA) offers a promising, minimally invasive alternative for managing soft tissue tumors. PCA employs image-guided techniques to accurately target and treat tumors, ensuring high precision and control. PCA preserves structures like collagen, reduces pain, decreases tumor size, and generally enhances patient outcomes.

Effectiveness of polidocanol sclerotherapy in alleviating symptoms in patients with venous malformations

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to retrospectively evaluate the effectiveness of polidocanol in managing pain, swelling, functional limiting and cosmetic disorders in patients with venous malformations (VMs).

METHODS

This retrospective study included patients who underwent sclerotherapy with polidocanol for VMs between 2020 and 2022. Patient records, imaging findings, and evaluation questionnaires used in the preprocedure and follow-up phases were reviewed. After sclerotherapy, patients were followed up at 1, 2, 3, and 6 months. During these visits, the previously used 11-point verbal numerical rating scale (from 0 [no pain] to 10 [worst pain thinkable]) was used to evaluate the severity of symptoms such as pain, swelling, cosmetic discomfort, and functional limitation, and patients were asked to report the number of days per week they experienced these symptoms owing to the VM.

RESULTS

A total of 194 sclerotherapy procedures (mean, 1.6 ± 0.3 procedures) in 84 patients (55 female and 29 male patients; mean age, 22.45 ± 11.83 years) were conducted. The majority of these malformations (81%, or 68 patients) were located in the extremities. We found a significant decrease in pain, swelling, functional limitation, cosmetic appearance, and number of painful days between all time points, except for the comparison between months 3 and 6 (P < .001) CONCLUSIONS: Polidocanol sclerotherapy is a safe and effective treatment for VMs that significantly decreases patient complaints and has a very low complication rate. Particularly, following patients at short intervals and administering additional sclerotherapy sessions when necessary will significantly increase patient satisfaction.

Comparison of bleomycin polidocanol foam vs electrochemotherapy combined with polidocanol foam for treatment of venous malformations

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to investigate the difference in safety and efficacy between two treatments for venous malformations (VMs), electrochemotherapy combined with polidocanol foam (ECP) and bleomycin polidocanol foam (BPF), providing alternative therapies for VMs.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective review of 152 patients with VMs treated with ECP and BPF. Pre- and post-treatment magnetic resonance images (MRIs) were collected, and clinical follow-up assessments were performed. Imaging results were used to calculate lesion volume changes. Clinical outcomes included changes in pain and improvements in perceived swelling. Patients were followed up at 1 week and 6 months after surgery. All emerging complications were documented in detail.

RESULTS

Of the 152 patients, 87 (57.2%) received BPF treatment, and 65 (42.8%) received ECP treatment. The most common location of VMs was the lower extremities (92/152; 60.2%), and the most common symptom was pain (108/152; 71.1%). Forty-three patients had previously undergone therapy in the BPF group (43/87; 49.4%), whereas 30 patients had received prior treatment in the ECP group (30/65; 46.2%). The study found that the percentage of lesion volume reduction in the BPF group was not significantly different from that in the ECP group (75.00% ± 17.85% vs 74.69% ± 8.48%; P = .899). ECP was more effective when the initial lesion volume was greater than 30 mL (67.66% ± 12.34% vs 73.47% ± 8.00%; P = .048). Patients treated with BPF had significantly less posttreatment pain than those treated with ECP, in different baseline lesion size. In the overall sample, pain relief was significantly higher in the BPF group than in the ECP group (4.21 ± 1.19 vs 3.57 ± 0.76; P = .002). However, there was no difference in pain relief between the two groups for the treatment of initially large VMs (4.20 ± 0.94 vs 3.70 ± 0.87; P = .113). The ECP group was significantly more likely to develop hyperpigmentation (5/87; 5.75% vs 11/65; 16.92%; P = .026) and swelling (9/87; 10.34% vs 16/65; 24.62%; P = .019) 1 week after surgery than the BPF group.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates that both BPF and ECP are effective treatments for VMs, with BPF being a safer option. ECP is a better choice for patients with the initial lesion volume greater than 30 mL, but it is more likely to lead to early swelling and hyperpigmentation.

Magnetic resonance - guided treatment of low-flow vascular malformations and the technologies to potentiate adoption

Vascular malformations are congenital, non-neoplastic lesions that arise secondary to defects in angiogenesis. Vascular malformations are divided into high-flow (arteriovenous malformation) and low-flow (venous malformations and lymphatic malformations). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is the standard for pre-and post-intervention assessments, while ultrasound (US), X-ray fluoroscopy and computed tomography (CT) are used for intra-procedural guidance. Sclerotherapy, an image-guided therapy that involves the injection of a sclerosant directly into the malformation, is typically the first-line therapy for treating low-flow vascular malformations. Sclerotherapy induces endothelial damage and necrosis/fibrosis with eventual involution of the malformation. Image-guided thermal therapies involve freezing or heating target tissue to induce cell death and necrosis. MRI is an alternative for intra-procedural guidance and monitoring during the treatment of vascular malformations. MR can provide dynamic, multiplanar imaging that delineates surrounding critical structures such as nerves and vasculature. Multiple studies have demonstrated that MR-guided treatment of vascular malformations is safe and effective. This review will detail (1) the use of MR for the classification and diagnosis of vascular malformations, (2) the current literature surrounding MR-guided treatment of vascular malformations, (3) a series of cases of MR-guided sclerotherapy and thermal ablation for the treatment of vascular malformations, and (4) a discussion of technologies that may potentiate interventional MRI adoption including high intensity focused ultrasound and guided laser ablation.

Clinical outcomes and predictors of bleomycin polidocanol foam sclerotherapy treatment response in venous malformations

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the safety and efficacy of bleomycin polidocanol foam (BPF) sclerotherapy for venous malformations (VMs) and analyze the associated clinical outcomes and predictors.

METHODS

We retrospectively assessed BPF sclerotherapy outcomes in 138 patients with VMs. We analyzed pain levels, lesion volume reduction, and subjective perception of response. Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify potential predictors of treatment outcome. Additionally, we carefully monitored and recorded complications.

RESULTS

There was a notable average reduction in lesion volume by 78.50% ± 15.71%. The pain numerical rating scale (NRS) score decreased from 4.17 ± 2.63 prior to treatment to 1.05 ± 1.54 afterward, and 70.3% of the patients experienced effective relief after a single BPF treatment. Multivariate analysis revealed that a high baseline NRS (odds ratio [OR]:  4.026) and elevated activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT, OR: 1.200) were positive predictors of pain reduction. Additionally, a high baseline NRS score (OR: 1.992) and elevated thrombocytocrit (PCT, OR: 2.543) were positive predictors of incomplete postoperative pain relief. Minor complications occurred in 31 (22.46%) patients.

CONCLUSION

BPF sclerotherapy is safe and effective for VMs, resulting in significant reduction in lesion volume, improved symptoms, and minimal complications. APTT and PCT levels are important predictors of pain outcomes following BPF treatment.