Surgical treatment of recurrent proximal tibio-fibular joint ganglion cysts

The current trend of proximal tibiofibular ganglion cyst: A summary of 7 case series and 61 case reports

Purpose

To review the different types of ganglion cysts surrounding the proximal tibio-fibular joint, their management options, outcomes, and recurrence.

Design

Descriptive analytical review.

Results

7 case series consisting of a total of 159 patients and 61 case reports consisting of 80 patients (with three patients having bilateral pathology) were included in this review. (Total cysts 159 + 83 = 242). The mean age was 41 years, and 71 % of the patients were males. 96.5 % of the cases were managed operatively, out of which 98 % of patients felt improvement in local symptoms and 71.5 % had improvement in neurological symptoms. Complete excision of the cyst is the primary mode of operative management. Many added procedures with complete excision are to mitigate the risk of recurrence. The recurrence rate of aspiration, simple excision alone, simple excision with recurrent articular branch neurectomy, and simple excision with PTFJ procedures were 77 %, 56 %, 11.5 %, and 0 %, respectively. Outcomes beyond recurrence were poorly reported.

Conclusion

There is not enough literature regarding the topic from which any formal systematic review can be done. Our summary suggests that aspiration alone or with steroid injection is associated with the highest recurrence rates among all the procedures. Complete excision with recurrent articular branch neurectomy should be the primary management. Revision cyst excision in isolation is an inadequate treatment option, therefore should be done in conjunction with PTFJ arthrodesis, which reduces the recurrence rates. Better quality studies are needed that report patient-centered outcomes and morbidities following PTFJ procedures.

Management and outcomes of proximal tibiofibular joint ganglion cysts: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Proximal tibiofibular joint (PTFJ) ganglion cysts are rare; however, their optimal management remains unclear. This study aimed to systematically review the surgical treatment options with a focus on recurrence rates and complications.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature was performed, searching three electronic databases, according to the PRISMA guidelines. The presentation, treatment, and outcomes of PTFJ ganglion cysts of minimum 1-year follow-up was collected. Study quality was assessed using the Modified Downs and Blacks checklist. Surgical interventions were considered ordinally from simple to more extensive as follows; cyst aspiration, cyst excision, cyst excision with an intervention to the PTFJ, either a hemi-resection or arthrodesis.

RESULTS

Twenty-two studies comprising 100 patients (101 knees) met inclusion criteria. Among all patients, pain was present in 59.7%, a lateral fullness in 71.6% and symptoms of the common peroneal nerve in 57.4%. The overall rate of recurrence after primary treatment was 28.9%. Recurrence rates for aspiration, cyst excision, PTFJ hemi-resection and PTFJ arthrodesis were 81.8%, 27.4%, 8.3% and 0%, respectively. Revision excision for recurrence failed in all cases. Outcomes beyond recurrence were poorly reported.

CONCLUSION

Addressing the PTFJ at the time of cyst excision reduces recurrence rates, however, the morbidity from PTFJ hemi-resection and arthrodesis are poorly reported. Whilst primary excision offers resolution in most cases (73%), revision cyst excision in isolation for the treatment of recurrent cysts is an inadequate treatment option. Cyst aspiration is ineffective. Data pertaining to patient reported outcomes for all treatment types are lacking.

Intraneural ganglion cysts: a systematic review and reinterpretation of the world's literature

OBJECTIVE The etiology of intraneural ganglion cysts has been controversial. In recent years, substantial evidence has been presented to support the articular (synovial) theory for their pathogenesis. The authors sought to 1) perform a systematic review of the world's literature on intraneural cysts, and 2) reinterpret available published MR images in articles by other authors to identify unrecognized joint connections. METHODS In Part 1, all cases were analyzed for demographic data, duration of symptoms, the presence of a history of trauma, whether electromyography or nerve conduction studies were performed, the type of imaging, surgical treatment, presence of a joint connection, intraneural cyst recurrence, and postoperative imaging. Two univariate analyses were completed: 1) to compare the proportion of intraneural ganglion cyst publications per decade and 2) to assess the number of recurrences from 1914 to 2003 compared with the years 2004-2015. Three multivariate regression models were used to identify risk factors for intraneural cyst recurrence. In Part 2, the authors analyzed all available published MR images and obtained MR images from selected cases in which joint connections were not identified by the original authors, specifically looking for unrecognized joint connections. Two univariate analyses were done: 1) to determine a possible association between the identification of a joint connection and obtaining an MRI and 2) to assess the number of joint connections reported from 1914 to 2003 compared with 2004 to 2015. RESULTS In Part 1, 417 articles (645 patients) were selected for analysis. Joint connections were identified in 313 intraneural cysts (48%). Both intraneural ganglion cyst cases and cyst recurrences were more frequently reported since 2004 (statistically significant difference for both). There was a statistically significant association between cyst recurrence and percutaneous aspiration as well as failure to disconnect the articular branch or address the joint. In Part 2, the authors identified 43 examples of joint connections that initially went unrecognized: 27 based on their retrospective MR image reinterpretation of published cases and 16 of 16 cases from their sampling of original MR images from published cases. Overall, joint connections were more commonly found in patients who received an MRI examination and were more frequently reported during the years 2004 to 2015 (statistically significant difference for both). CONCLUSIONS This comprehensive review of the world's literature and the MR images further supports the articular (synovial) theory and provides baseline data for future investigators.