Surgery versus conservative care for Rathke's cleft cyst

Long-term outcome of surgically treated and conservatively managed Rathke cleft cysts

OBJECTIVE

Rathke cleft cysts (RCC) are benign lesions of the sellar region that require surgical treatment in case of visual deterioration or progression of the cyst. However, the natural course is often stable and asymptomatic. We aimed to investigate the characteristics of patients with cyst progression during follow-up (FU) and to compare the natural history of patients with RCC with patients who underwent surgery.

METHODS

Patients with an MR morphologic cystic sellar lesion classified as RCC between 04/2001 and 11/2020 were included. Functional outcomes, including ophthalmologic, endocrinologic, and MRI data, were retrospectively analyzed and compared between surgically treated patients, patients on a "watch and wait" strategy (WWS), and patients on a WWS who underwent secondary surgery due to cyst progression.

RESULTS

One hundred forty patients (median age 42.8 years) with RCC on MRI were identified. 52/140 (37.1%) underwent primary surgery. Of 88 patients (62.9%) with initial WWS, 21 (23.9%) underwent surgery for secondary cyst progression. Patients on the WWS had significantly smaller cyst volumes (p = 0.0001) and fewer visual disturbances (p = 0.0004), but a similar rate of hormone deficiencies (p = 0.99) compared with surgically treated patients preoperatively. Postoperatively patients suffered significantly more often from hormone deficiencies than WWS patients (p = 0.001). Patients who switched to the surgical group were significantly more likely to have preoperative T1 hyperintense signals on MRI (p = 0.0001) and visual disturbances (p = 0.001) than patients with continuous WWS. Postoperatively, these patients suffered more frequently from new hormonal deficiencies (p = 0.001). Endocrine and ophthalmologic outcomes in patients with primary and secondary surgery were comparable. Multivariate analysis showed that WWS patients were at a higher risk of requiring surgery for cyst progression when perimetric deficits (p = 0.006), hyperprolactinemia (p = 0.003), and corticotropic deficits (p = 0.005) were present.

CONCLUSION

Surgical treatment of RCC may cause new hormonal deficiencies, which are rare in the natural course. Therefore, the indication for surgery should be carefully evaluated. Hyperprolactinemia and corticotropic deficits were significant indicators for a secondary cyst progression in patients with RCC. However, a significant amount of almost 25% of initially conservatively managed cysts showed deterioration, necessary for surgical intervention.

Durable headache relief following endoscopic endonasal resection of sub-centimeter Rathke cleft cysts in medically refractory patients

BACKGROUND

The most common presenting symptom in patients with both small and large Rathke cleft cysts (RCC) is headache (H/A). It is well established that patients with large RCC can have significant symptomatic improvement after cyst drainage. However, patients with small RCC (≤ 1 cm) are rarely operated on, even if they present with debilitating H/A. It is not well understood whether resection of these smaller RCCs can lead to durable H/A resolution.

METHODS

A retrospective search of our institutional database for sub-centimeter RCCs presenting with intractable H/A and treated with an endoscopic endonasal approach was carried out. A detailed H/A questionnaire as well as patient chart review was conducted to assess the long-term outcome of these patients after surgical intervention.

RESULTS

Ten consecutive patients with 11 endonasal surgeries met inclusion criteria. Eight responded to the questionnaire. The median cyst diameter was 6 mm (IQR 3-9). Median preoperative H/A duration was 12 months (range 2 months-15 years). H/As occurred on average for 20 days per month and all required analgesics for symptomatic control for more than 15 of these 20 days. Half of the patients also had to miss work because of H/A. Average preoperative H/A intensity was 8.7 (scale 0-10) compared with postoperative scores of 2.9 at one month, 1.6 at 3 months, and 0.9 at 1 year. There were no permanent endocrinological or other surgical complications. After a median follow-up of 2 years, one patient had radiographic and symptomatic recurrence which resolved after re-operation.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic fenestration of sub-centimeter RCCs provides a safe and durable treatment for patients with intractable H/A.

Incidence and factors associated with the recurrence of Rathke's cleft cyst after surgery: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Backgroud

Recurrence of Rathke's cleft cyst (RCC) is not uncommon after surgery, and the associated factors and incidence of relapse deserve a systematic summary.

Methods

This study was conducted in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. The Pubmed, Embase, Cochrane, and Web of Science databases were searched until September 12, 2022. Studies with significant results of recurrent factors or specific incidences of RCC recurrence and mean/median follow-up time were included. Based on a protocol of a 2-year interval grouping, included studies were categorized into four groups with follow-up periods  <24 months, 24-48 months, 48-72 months, and ≥72 months, respectively. Quality assessment was performed using the NOS score. Pooled estimations were computed by using a random-effects model in the STATA "metaprop" command. Publication bias was assessed visually through a funnel plot and statistically through Egger's linear regression test and Begg's correlation test.

Results

A total of 44 studies were included containing 2,539 cases. Squamous metaplasia was the most commonly reported factor, followed by the extent of cyst removal. The other factors were reported individually. The pooled overall incidences of RCC recurrence after surgery in four groups of the follow-up period were 7.4% (95%CI = 4.1-11.3%) in <24 months, 13.1% (95%CI = 9.7-17.0%) in 24-48 months, 13.7% (95%CI = 7.7-21.0%) in 48-72 months, and 33.8% (95%CI = 19.6-49.6%) in ≥72 months. The pooled symptomatic incidences were 2.3% (95%CI = 0.4-5.1%) in <24 months, 5.6% (95%CI = 3.6-7.9%) in 24-48 months, 5.9% (95%CI = 2.4-10.6%) in 48-72 months, and 14.1% (95%CI = 6.0-24.5%) in ≥72 months. A dramatic increase in recurrent incidence was observed when the follow-up period was more than 72 months in both overall and symptomatic recurrence. A similar trend of recurrence was found in subgroup analyses stratified by publication year, cohort size, and cyst resection strategy.

Conclusion

This study systematically reviewed recurrent factors and described the profile of trends in RCC recurrent incidence after surgery with a follow-up time based on a protocol of a 2-year interval, finding a dramatic increase in recurrent rates with a follow-up period of more than 72 months. This encouraged us to put forward a recommendation of at least a 6-year follow-up after surgery for patients with RCC.

Systematic Review Registration

https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/, identifier: CRD42021278970.

Different Faces of Rathke's Cleft Cyst

Rathke's cleft cysts (RCC) are rare benign cystic lesions that might present with different imaging features, potentially posing a problem in the radiological diagnosis of cystic sellar lesions. The purpose of this pictorial review is to present an overview of the radioclinical features of RCC through four clinical cases with different radiologic findings confirmed by pathology, as well as reviewing the common differential diagnosis to be considered. The subjects are women, aged 11 to 73 who underwent recent transsphenoidal surgical resection with a postoperative follow-up period of a few months to three years.

Natural course of Rathke's cleft cysts and risk factors for progression

OBJECTIVE

Rathke's cleft cysts (RCCs) are relatively common and often detected incidentally. They are usually asymptomatic and managed conservatively. However, little is known about their natural history. Thus, the authors aimed to examine the natural course of RCCs and identify the risk factors for their progression.

METHODS

This retrospective study examined 229 patients (median age 43.0 years) diagnosed with RCCs by MRI and followed up without surgery (median period 36.6 months). The median cyst height on the initial MRI was 10 mm. Progression or regression of RCC was defined as cyst height changes of ≥ 1 mm.

RESULTS

In total, 23 (10.0%) RCCs progressed, whereas 73 (31.9%) RCCs spontaneously regressed. The remaining 133 were noted to be stable throughout the follow-up period. Patients with progressed RCCs were significantly older than those with stable RCCs. In patients with acute headache as an initial symptom, RCCs were significantly more likely to spontaneously regress. New symptoms occurred in 6 patients, 5 of whom underwent surgery for RCC progression. Of these 6 patients, 1 patient had persistent adrenocorticotropic hormone deficiency and 1 patient developed diabetes insipidus. Kaplan-Meier analysis results showed RCC progression and new symptom development rates to be 12.0% and 4.1% at 5 years and 13.7% and 5.7% at 10 years, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

RCCs rarely progress or cause new symptoms in the long term. Patients with asymptomatic RCC should be followed up for at least 5 years to ensure RCC inactivity. RCCs in older adults may require greater surveillance.

Conservative management of complicated Rathke's cleft cyst mimicking pituitary apoplexy

Summary

Complicated Rathke's cleft cyst (RCC) is a rare occurrence of symptomatic bleeding or growth of a previously asymptomatic (and often undiagnosed) intrasellar cyst derived from remnants of Rathke's pouch, situated on the midline between the adeno- and neurohypophysis. Symptoms may be identical to those of pituitary apoplexy: acute onset of headache, hypopituitarism, and neurological disturbances. Both syndromes may also exhibit a similar appearance of a large haemorrhagic sellar mass at initial radiological evaluation. We report on two patients who presented with headache and complete hypopituitarism. Based on the initial MRI, they were first diagnosed with pituitary apoplexy but managed conservatively with hormone therapy alone because of the absence of severe visual or neurological threat. Upon follow-up at 4 months, clinical evolution was good in both patients but their pituitary mass had not reduced in size and, after careful radiologic reviewing, was more indicative of a large midline complicated RCC. In conclusion, the diagnosis of complicated RCC is challenging because it can mimic pituitary apoplexy clinically, biologically, and radiologically. Clinicians should distinguish between the two entities using specific radiological signs or evolution of the mass at MRI if the patient does not undergo surgery. To our knowledge, we report conservative management of this rare condition for the first time, though it seems appropriate in the absence of neurological compromise or visual compression. Long-term follow-up is however mandatory.

Learning points

Complicated Rathke's cleft cyst can mimic pituitary apoplexy, presenting with sudden onset of headache, hypopituitarism, and visual and neurological compromise in the most severe cases. At diagnosis, pituitary MRI may not be able to differentiate between the two entities, showing a large haemorrhagic mass inside the sella, with little or no normal pituitary tissue visible. Patients are often diagnosed with apoplexy at this stage and may undergo pituitary surgery. When surgery has not been performed initially in these patients, repeat imaging at 3-6 months is unchanged and does not show the expected involution usually seen after adenoma apoplexy. Conservative management with hormonal replacement seems a valid option in the absence of visual or neurological deficits that would require trans-sphenoidal surgery.

Natural history and surgical outcome of Rathke's cleft cysts-A study from the Swedish Pituitary Registry

OBJECTIVE

Rathke's cleft cysts are benign, embryological remnants in the pituitary gland. The majority of them are small and asymptomatic but a few may become large, and cause mass effects, pituitary hormone deficiencies and visual impairment. Recommendations for the follow-up of Rathke's cleft cysts vary since data on the natural history are sparse.

PATIENTS AND DESIGN

Data at diagnosis and at 1, 5 and 10 years for patients with a Rathke's cleft cyst (434 at diagnosis, 317 females) were retrieved from the Swedish Pituitary Registry. Cysts ≤3 mm in diameter were excluded from the study.

MEASUREMENTS

Data included demographics, cyst size, pituitary function, visual defects and surgery.

RESULTS

The mean age at diagnosis was 45 years. In patients with cysts <10 mm in diameter (n = 204) 2.9% had pituitary hormone deficiencies and 2% had visual field impairments. Cyst size did not progress during the 5 years. Cysts with a diameter of ≥10 mm that were not operated (n = 174) decreased in size over the years (p < .01). Pituitary hormone deficiencies and visual impairments were more frequent (18% and 5.7%, respectively) but were stable over time. Transphenoidal surgery was performed in 56 patients of whom 51 underwent surgery before the 1-year follow-up. The mean cyst diameter at diagnosis was 18 mm (range: 9─30 mm), 36% had pituitary hormone deficiency, 45% had visual field defects and 20% had impaired visual acuity. One year after surgery 60% had no cyst remnants, 50% had a pituitary deficiency, 26% had visual field defects and 12% had impaired visual acuity. No major changes were observed after 5 years. Twelve of the operated patients had a follow-up at 10 years, in eight the cyst remnants or recurrences increased in size over time (p < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Rathke's cleft cysts with a size less than 10 mm rarely grow and our results indicate that radiological follow-up can be restricted to 5 years. In contrast, progression of postoperative remnants or recurrent cysts is more likely and require long-term follow-up.

Analysis of the Clinical Characteristics and Pituitary Function of Patients in Central China With Rathke's Cleft Cysts

OBJECTIVE

A Rathke's cleft cyst (RCC) is a common, benign, cystic disease that often leads to hypophyseal dysfunction or head symptoms. The relationship between RCCs and pituitary gland function is not clear. We therefore carried out a study to examine this relationship in greater detail.

METHODS

The study was a retrospective, cohort design in patients diagnosed with a RCC between January 2019 to July 2021 at the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University, China.

RESULTS

A total of 221 patients were enrolled and then divided into study cohorts according to the diameter of the RCC, clinical manifestations, and surgical treatment received. The majority of patients were symptomatic (143/221), including 83 cases of dizziness and headache, 9 of vision loss and visual field defect, and 2 of diabetes insipidus. 52 cases had abnormal pituitary function, with 8 cases interestingly showing high adrenocorticotropic-hormone (ACTH) and cortisone levels, while 8 juvenile cases had developed central precocious puberty. Patients with larger RCCs were more likely to present with headaches and dizziness, with subjects who suffered from these symptoms having high ACTH and cortisone levels.

CONCLUSION

Although the size of a RCC is not an important factor influencing hypopituitary function, we consider that endocrine evaluation should be carried out in all patients with a RCC.