Abnormal corticospinal tract modulation of the soleus H reflex in patients with pure spastic paraparesis

Corticospinal modulation of vibration-induced H-reflex depression

The purpose of this study was to examine corticospinal modulation of spinal reflex excitability, by determining the effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) on soleus H-reflexes while they were almost completely suppressed by lower extremity vibration. In 15 healthy adults, a novel method of single-limb vibration (0.6 g, 30 Hz, 0.33 mm displacement) was applied to the non-dominant leg. Soleus muscle responses were examined in six stimulation conditions: (1) H-reflex elicited by tibial nerve stimulation, (2) tibial nerve stimulation during vibration, (3) subthreshold TMS, (4) subthreshold TMS during vibration, (5) tibial nerve stimulation 10 ms after a subthreshold TMS pulse, and (6) tibial nerve stimulation 10 ms after a subthreshold TMS pulse, during vibration. With or without vibration, subthreshold TMS produced no motor evoked potentials and had no effect on soleus electromyography (p > 0.05). In the absence of vibration, H-reflex amplitudes were not affected by subthreshold TMS conditioning (median (md) 35, interquartile range (IQ) 18-56 vs. md 46, IQ 22-59% of the maximal M wave (Mmax), p > 0.05). During vibration, however, unconditioned H-reflexes were nearly abolished, and a TMS conditioning pulse increased the H-reflex more than fourfold (md 0.3, IQ 0.1-0.7 vs. md 2, IQ 0.9-5.0% of Mmax, p < 0.008). Limb vibration alone had no significant effect on corticospinal excitability. In the absence of vibration, a subthreshold TMS pulse did not influence the soleus H-reflex. During limb vibration, however, while the H-reflex was almost completely suppressed, a subthreshold TMS pulse partially restored the H-reflex. This disinhibition of the H-reflex by a corticospinal signal may represent a mechanism involved in the control of voluntary movement. Corticospinal signals that carry the descending motor command may also reduce presynaptic inhibition, temporarily increasing the impact of sensory inputs on motoneuron activation.

Temporal Profile of Descending Cortical Modulation of Spinal Excitability: Group and Individual-Specific Effects

Sensorimotor control is modulated through complex interactions between descending corticomotor pathways and ascending sensory inputs. Pairing sub-threshold transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) with peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) modulates the Hoffmann’s reflex (H-reflex), providing a neurophysiologic probe into the influence of descending cortical drive on spinal segmental circuits. However, individual variability in the timing and magnitude of H-reflex modulation is poorly understood. Here, we varied the inter-stimulus interval (ISI) between TMS and PNS to systematically manipulate the relative timing of convergence of descending TMS-induced volleys with respect to ascending PNS-induced afferent volleys in the spinal cord to: (1) characterize effective connectivity between the primary motor cortex (M1) and spinal circuits, mediated by both direct, fastest-conducting, and indirect, slower-conducting descending pathways; and (2) compare the effect of individual-specific vs. standard ISIs. Unconditioned and TMS-conditioned H-reflexes (24 different ISIs ranging from −6 to 12 ms) were recorded from the soleus muscle in 10 able-bodied individuals. The magnitude of H-reflex modulation at individualized ISIs (earliest facilitation delay or EFD and individual-specific peak facilitation) was compared with standard ISIs. Our results revealed a significant effect of ISI on H-reflex modulation. ISIs eliciting earliest-onset facilitation (EFD 0 ms) ranged from −3 to −5 ms across individuals. No difference in the magnitude of facilitation was observed at EFD 0 ms vs. a standardized short-interval ISI of −1.5 ms. Peak facilitation occurred at longer ISIs, ranging from +3 to +11 ms. The magnitude of H-reflex facilitation derived using an individual-specific peak facilitation was significantly larger than facilitation observed at a standardized longer-interval ISI of +10 ms. Our results suggest that unique insights can be provided with individual-specific measures of top-down effective connectivity mediated by direct and/or fastest-conducting pathways (indicated by the magnitude of facilitation observed at EFD 0 ms) and other descending pathways that encompass relatively slower and/or indirect connections from M1 to spinal circuits (indicated by peak facilitation and facilitation at longer ISIs). By comprehensively characterizing the temporal profile and inter-individual variability of descending modulation of spinal reflexes, our findings provide methodological guidelines and normative reference values to inform future studies on neurophysiological correlates of the complex array of descending neural connections between M1 and spinal circuits.

Characterizing the effect of low intensity transcranial magnetic stimulation on the soleus H-reflex at rest

Modulation of a Hoffmann (H)-reflex following transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) has been used to assess the nature of signals transmitted from cortical centers to lower motor neurons. Further characterizing the recruitment and time-course of the TMS-induced effect onto the soleus H-reflex adds to the discussion of these pathways and may improve its utility in clinical studies. In 10 healthy controls, TMS was used to condition the soleus H-reflex using TMS intensities from 65 to 110% of the resting motor threshold (RMT). Early facilitation [- 5 to - 3 ms condition-test (C-T) interval] was evident when TMS was 110% of RMT (P < 0.05). By comparison, late facilitation (+ 10 to + 20 ms C-T interval) was several times larger and observed over a wider range of TMS intensities, including 65-110% of RMT. The early inhibition (- 3 to - 1 ms C-T interval) had a low TMS threshold and was elicited over a wide range of intensity from 65% to 95% of RMT (all P < 0.05). A second inhibitory phase was seen ~ 4 ms later (+ 1 to + 4 ms C-T intervals) and was only observed for a TMS intensity of 95% of RMT (P < 0.05). The present findings reaffirm that subthreshold TMS strongly modulates soleus motor neurons and demonstrates that distinct pathways can be selectively probed at discrete C-T intervals when using specific TMS intensities.

Motor Evoked Potentials in Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia-A Systematic Review

Background: Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia (HSP) is a slowly progressive neurodegenerative disorder with no disease modifying treatment. Potential therapeutic approaches are emerging and large-scale clinical drug trials for patients with HSP are imminent. A sensitive biomarker to measure the drug efficacy in these trials is required. Motor evoked potentials (MEPs) are a potential biomarker for HSP as they assess the central motor pathways and can be standardized with set protocols and guidelines.

Objectives: We performed a systematic review to investigate the utility of MEPs as a diagnostic and disease severity biomarker for HSP.

Search Methods: Systematic searches of PubMed, Embase, Medline, and Scopus were performed.

Selection Criteria: Studies reporting on central motor conduction time measured with MEPs in adult and pediatric patients with HSP were included. We excluded studies in non-HSP patient cohorts, not in English, not original research, and unpublished journal articles.

Data Collection and analysis: Search results were de-duplicated and screened according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. The included papers were reviewed independently by two reviewers and data was collected on patient cohorts, test methods, results, and study quality. Results were analyzed using descriptive methods.

Results: Of the 882 search results, 32 studies were included in the review. The most common finding was absent or prolonged lower limb (LL) central motor conduction time (CMCT) in patients with HSP (78% of patients studied). Quality assessment revealed variability in study methodology and reporting of results. Variations included patient cohorts of various genotypes as well as variations in equipment and techniques used. Aside from CMCT, none of the MEP parameter measures correlated with disease severity and many did not show significant difference between HSP patients and controls.

Conclusion: Systematic review of MEP studies in HSP patient cohorts demonstrated mixed findings. Lower limb CMCT was the most promising parameter in terms of differentiating HSP patients from controls, with one study demonstrating a weak correlation with clinical disease severity. It is possible that the lack of consistency in study methodologies and small patient cohorts have contributed to the variable findings. A longitudinal study of MEPs in a large cohort of HSP patients with the same genotype will help clarify the utility of MEPs as a biomarker for disease severity and use in clinical trials.

Vestibulospinal and Corticospinal Modulation of Lumbosacral Network Excitability in Human Subjects

As part of a project aimed to develop a novel, non-invasive techniques for comprehensive assessment of supraspinal-spinal connectivity in humans, the present study sought to explore the convergence of descending vestibulospinal and corticospinal pathways onto lumbosacral motor pools. Transcutaneous electrical spinal stimulation-evoked motor potentials were recorded from knee and ankle flexors and extensors in resting neurologically intact participants. Descending influences on lumbosacral motor neurons were studied using galvanic vestibular (GVS) or transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to elicit descending vestibulospinal or corticospinal volleys, respectively. Facilitatory conditioning effects of descending corticospinal volleys were manifested by a significant increase of spinally evoked motor potentials in recorded knee and ankle muscles bilaterally, and were observed at the 10–30 ms conditioning-test intervals (CTIs); whereas, facilitatory conditioning effects of vestibulospinal volleys manifested at longer latencies (CTIs of 90 and 110 ms), and lasted up to 250 ms. TMS mediated volleys revealed the conditioning effects at both short and long latencies, suggestive of both direct and indirect influence. In contrast, vestibulospinally mediated conditioning effects occurred at longer latencies, consistent with this pathway’s known anatomical and functional interfaces with other descending systems including the reticulospinal pathway and, suggestively, propriospinal interneurons. Our work demonstrates the utility and sensitivity of transcutaneous spinal stimulation in human neurophysiological studies as a technique for quantitative characterization of excitatory conditioning effects in multiple lumbosacral motor pools, obtained through descending pathways. This characterization becomes critical in understanding the neuroplasticity in the central nervous system during motor learning and neurological recovery.

Multimodal cortical and subcortical exercise compared with treadmill training for spinal cord injury

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Spared fibers after spinal cord injury (SCI) tend to consist predominantly of subcortical circuits that are not under volitional (cortical) control. We aim to improve function after SCI by using targeted physical exercises designed to simultaneously stimulate cortical and spared subcortical neural circuits.

METHODS

Participants with chronic motor-incomplete SCI enrolled in a single-center, prospective interventional crossover study. Participants underwent 48 sessions each of weight-supported robotic-assisted treadmill training and a novel combination of balance and fine hand exercises, in randomized order, with a 6-week washout period. Change post-intervention was measured for lower extremity motor score, soleus H-reflex facilitation; seated balance function; ambulation; spasticity; and pain.

RESULTS

Only 9 of 21 enrolled participants completed both interventions. Thirteen participants completed at least one intervention. Although there were no statistically significant differences, multimodal training tended to increase short-interval H-reflex facilitation, whereas treadmill training tended to improve dynamic seated balance.

DISCUSSION

The low number of participants who completed both phases of the crossover intervention limited the power of this study to detect significant effects. Other potential explanations for the lack of significant differences with multimodal training could include insufficient engagement of lower extremity motor cortex using skilled upper extremity exercises; and lack of skill transfer from upright postural stability during multimodal training to seated dynamic balance during testing. To our knowledge, this is the first published study to report seated posturography outcomes after rehabilitation interventions in individuals with SCI.

CONCLUSION

In participants with chronic incomplete SCI, a novel mix of multimodal exercises incorporating balance exercises with skilled upper extremity exercises showed no benefit compared to an active control program of body weight-supported treadmill training. To improve participant retention in long-term rehabilitation studies, subsequent trials would benefit from a parallel group rather than crossover study design.

Reduced postactivation depression of soleus H reflex and root evoked potential after transcranial magnetic stimulation

Postactivation depression of the Hoffmann (H) reflex is associated with a transient period of suppression following activation of the reflex pathway. In soleus, the depression lasts for 100-200 ms during voluntary contraction and up to 10 s at rest. A reflex root evoked potential (REP), elicited after a single pulse of transcutaneous stimulation to the thoracolumbar spine, has been shown to exhibit similar suppression. The present study systematically characterized the effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) on postactivation depression using double-pulse H reflexes and REPs. A TMS pulse reduced the period of depression to 10-15 ms for both reflexes. TMS could even produce postactivation facilitation of the H reflex, as the second reflex response was increased to 243 ± 51% of control values at the 75-ms interval. The time course was qualitatively similar for the REP, yet the overall increase was less. While recovery of the H reflex was slower in the relaxed muscle, the profile exhibited a distinct bimodal shape characterized by an early peak at the 25-ms interval, reaching 72 ± 23% of control values, followed by a trough at 50 ms, and then a gradual recovery at intervals > 50 ms. The rapid recovery of two successively depressed H reflexes, ∼ 25 ms apart, was also possible with double-pulse TMS. The effect of the TMS-induced corticospinal excitation on postactivation depression may be explained by a combination of pre- and postsynaptic mechanisms, although further investigation is required to distinguish between them.

Acute changes in soleus H-reflex facilitation and central motor conduction after targeted physical exercises

We tested the acute effect of exercises targeted simultaneously at cortical and brainstem circuits on neural transmission through corticobulbar connections. Corticobulbar pathways represent a potential target for rehabilitation after spinal cord injury (SCI), which tends to spare brainstem circuits to a greater degree than cortical circuits. To explore this concept, able-bodied volunteers (n=20) underwent one session each of three exercises targeted at different nervous system components: treadmill walking (spinal locomotor circuits), isolated balance exercise (brainstem and other pathways), and multimodal balance plus skilled hand exercise (hand motor cortex and corticospinal tract). We found that short-interval soleus H-reflex facilitation increased after one session of balance and multimodal exercise by 13.2±4.0% and 8.3±4.7%, and slightly decreased by 1.9±4.4% after treadmill exercise (p=0.042 on ANOVA across exercise type). Increases in long-interval H-reflex facilitation were not significantly different between exercises. Both balance and multimodal exercise increased central motor conduction velocity by 4.3±2.6% and 4.5±2.8%, whereas velocity decreased by 4.3±2.7% after treadmill exercise (p=0.045 on ANOVA across exercise type). In conclusion, electrophysiological transmission between the motor cortex and spinal motor neurons in able-bodied subjects increased more following one session of balance exercise than treadmill exercise.

Plasticity of corticospinal neural control after locomotor training in human spinal cord injury

Spinal lesions substantially impair ambulation, occur generally in young and otherwise healthy individuals, and result in devastating effects on quality of life. Restoration of locomotion after damage to the spinal cord is challenging because axons of the damaged neurons do not regenerate spontaneously. Body-weight-supported treadmill training (BWSTT) is a therapeutic approach in which a person with a spinal cord injury (SCI) steps on a motorized treadmill while some body weight is removed through an upper body harness. BWSTT improves temporal gait parameters, muscle activation patterns, and clinical outcome measures in persons with SCI. These changes are likely the result of reorganization that occurs simultaneously in supraspinal and spinal cord neural circuits. This paper will focus on the cortical control of human locomotion and motor output, spinal reflex circuits, and spinal interneuronal circuits and how corticospinal control is reorganized after locomotor training in people with SCI. Based on neurophysiological studies, it is apparent that corticospinal plasticity is involved in restoration of locomotion after training. However, the neural mechanisms underlying restoration of lost voluntary motor function are not well understood and translational neuroscience research is needed so patient-orientated rehabilitation protocols to be developed.

Spinal associative stimulation: a non-invasive stimulation paradigm to modulate spinal excitability

OBJECTIVE

Repetitive, paired peripheral and transcranial stimulation targeting the cerebral cortex can increase cortical excitability, outlasting the stimulation period. It is unknown whether paired stimulation specifically targeting the spinal cord can modulate spinal excitability. We tested whether the H-reflex facilitation from a sub-threshold conditioning TMS pulse could modulate spinal excitability if delivered repetitively.

METHOD

In 13 healthy subjects, we delivered single-pulse TMS (80% RMT) for the right soleus muscle, 20 ms prior to an electrical peripheral nerve stimulus delivered over the posterior tibial nerve on the same side at 0.1 Hz during 15 min.

RESULTS

PNS alone evoked an H-reflex of 0.25 mV ± 0.06 SEM, while pairing of TMS and PNS facilitated the H-reflex to 0.7 ± 0.11 mV. TMS-PNS pairs delivered at 0.1 Hz for 15 min progressively increased in the evoked response to ∼130% (r(2) = 0.97) of the starting amplitude (normalized to 1st min). Post-intervention, H-reflex threshold decreased (pre = 12.9 ± 1.7 mA; post =11.6 ± 1.6 mA; p = 0.04), as did the stimulus intensity at maximum H-reflex amplitude (pre = 23.5 ± 02.8 mA; post = 21.6 ± 2.6 mA; p = 0.03), and recruitment curve width (pre = 11.6 ± 1.5 mA; post = 10.93 ± 1.4 mA; p = 0.03). No such changes were observed with intervention of PNS or TMS alone.

CONCLUSION

Paired stimulation targeting spinal facilitatory interactions, when applied repetitively, can increase spinal excitability during and after the intervention.

SIGNIFICANCE

Spinal associative stimulation may have potential for neuromodulation in spinal cord injury patients.