Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts

Evaluation of agreement in macular vascular density measured by different protocols: 4.5 mm × 4.5 mm and 6 mm × 6 mm

PURPOSE

To evaluate the agreement in the macular vascular density (MVD) measured by two protocols: 4.5 mm × 4.5 mm and 6 mm × 6 mm.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional observational study.

METHODS

Healthy volunteers between the age group of 19 and 39 years were recruited. Topcon DRI OCT Triton plus (Topcon Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) was used to acquire the fovea-centered optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) image using two protocols: 4.5 mm × 4.5 mm and 6 mm × 6 mm. MVD was measured by the manufacturer software in the superficial capillary plexus slab in five regions: central, superior, nasal, inferior, and temporal subfields of early treatment diabetic retinopathy study grid in each protocol.

RESULTS

The study included 79 eyes of 40 healthy volunteers. The difference in the mean MVD between two protocols was 3.84% in right eye and 4.2% in left eye in central subfield, 0.93% in right eye and 1.13% in left eye in superior subfield, 0.06% in right eye and 1.45% in left eye in nasal subfield, 1.65% in right eye and 0.7% in left eye in inferior subfield, 0.4% in right eye and 0.54% in left eye in temporal subfield. The measurements were significantly higher in 6 mm × 6 mm in central subfield in both the eyes and in nasal field in the left eye. Whereas, the measurements were significantly higher in 4.5 mm × 4.5 mm in superior and inferior subfield in both the eyes and in temporal subfield in the left eye.

CONCLUSION

The protocols should not be used interchangeably and it is necessary to include recommendation of the field of view to measure MVD while standardizing OCTA reporting.

Practical Utility of Widefield OCT Angiography to Detect Retinal Neovascularization in Eyes with Proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy

PURPOSE

To assess the real clinical utility of widefield OCT angiography (WF-OCTA) for detecting retinal neovascularization (RNV) in eyes with proliferative diabetic retinopathy (PDR).

DESIGN

A retrospective cross sectional study.

PARTICIPANTS

Consecutive eyes clinically suspected of PDR by physicians at a tertiary eye center between March 2021 and November 2022.

METHODS

All eyes underwent ultrawidefield fluorescein angiography (UWF-FA) (California, Optos) and WF-OCTA (S1, Canon) with a 23 × 20 mm scan area. Two independent graders detected individual RNV lesions using UWF-FA and used them as the ground truth. Widefield OCT angiography images were first evaluated to determine whether the images successfully illustrated retinal vasculature, regardless of the image quality index or the presence of vitreous hemorrhage. The graders then identified the RNV lesions with WF-OCTA. We detected RNV by utilizing both the entire retinal slab, including flow signals in the retina, and the custom vitreoretinal interface slab, defined as flow signals from 20 μm below the internal limiting membrane (ILM) to 2000 μm above the ILM. We evaluated the applicability to real clinical practice by not correcting segmentation errors.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The success rate of imaging and the detection rate of RNV using WF-OCTA.

RESULTS

Initially, 69 consecutive patients who underwent UWF-FA were identified. Of these, 114 eyes from 57 (83%) patients underwent both UWF-FA and WF-OCTA. Of the 114 eyes, 108 (95%) produced gradable WF-OCTA images. Using UWF-FA, the graders identified 175 RNV lesions in 40 eyes. Widefield OCT angiography achieved a sensitivity of 95% and specificity of 88% for detecting eyes with RNV. At the level of individual RNV lesions, graders detected 156 RNV lesions with WF-OCTA, with 118 of these confirmed by UWF-FA (true positive). Among the 57 false-negative lesions, the primary causes were being out of the scan range (26 lesions) and segmentation errors (21 lesions).

CONCLUSIONS

Widefield OCT angiography imaging had a high success rate, achieving a sensitivity of 95% and a specificity of 88% for detecting eyes with RNV in a real clinical setting. Despite a 67% detection rate for individual RNV lesions, WF-OCTA may serve as a valuable noninvasive method for RNV detection in eyes with diabetic retinopathy.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Imaging Modalities for Assessing the Vascular Component of Diabetic Retinal Disease: Review and Consensus for an Updated Staging System

Purpose

To review the evidence for imaging modalities in assessing the vascular component of diabetic retinal disease (DRD), to inform updates to the DRD staging system.

Design

Standardized narrative review of the literature by an international expert workgroup, as part of the DRD Staging System Update Effort, a project of the Mary Tyler Moore Vision Initiative. Overall, there were 6 workgroups: Vascular Retina, Neural Retina, Systemic Health, Basic and Cellular Mechanisms, Visual Function, and Quality of Life.

Participants

The Vascular Retina workgroup, including 16 participants from 4 countries.

Methods

Literature review was conducted using standardized evidence grids for 5 modalities: standard color fundus photography (CFP), widefield color photography (WFCP), standard fluorescein angiography (FA), widefield FA (WFFA), and OCT angiography (OCTA). Summary levels of evidence were determined on a validated scale from I (highest) to V (lowest). Five virtual workshops were held for discussion and consensus.

Main Outcome Measures

Level of evidence for each modality.

Results

Levels of evidence for standard CFP, WFCP, standard FA, WFFA, and OCTA were I, II, I, I, and II respectively. Traditional vascular lesions on standard CFP should continue to be included in an updated staging system, but more studies are required before they can be used in posttreatment eyes. Widefield color photographs can be used for severity grading within the area covered by standard CFPs, although these gradings may not be directly interchangeable with each other. Evaluation of the peripheral retina on WFCP can be considered, but the method of grading needs to be clarified and validated. Standard FA and WFFA provide independent prognostic value, but the need for dye administration should be considered. OCT angiography has significant potential for inclusion in the DRD staging system, but various barriers need to be addressed first.

Conclusions

This study provides evidence-based recommendations on the utility of various imaging modalities for assessment of the vascular component of DRD, which can inform future updates to the DRD staging system. Although new imaging modalities offer a wealth of information, there are still major gaps and unmet research needs that need to be addressed before this potential can be realized.

Financial Disclosures

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Optical coherence tomography angiography analysis methods: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) is widely used for non-invasive retinal vascular imaging, but the OCTA methods used to assess retinal perfusion vary. We evaluated the different methods used to assess retinal perfusion between OCTA studies. MEDLINE and Embase were searched from 2014 to August 2021. We included prospective studies including ≥ 50 participants using OCTA to assess retinal perfusion in either global retinal or systemic disorders. Risk of bias was assessed using the National Institute of Health quality assessment tool for observational cohort and cross-sectional studies. Heterogeneity of data was assessed by Q statistics, Chi-square test, and I2 index. Of the 5974 studies identified, 191 studies were included in this evaluation. The selected studies employed seven OCTA devices, six macula volume dimensions, four macula subregions, nine perfusion analyses, and five vessel layer definitions, totalling 197 distinct methods of assessing macula perfusion and over 7000 possible combinations. Meta-analysis was performed on 88 studies reporting vessel density and foveal avascular zone area, showing lower retinal perfusion in patients with diabetes mellitus than in healthy controls, but with high heterogeneity. Heterogeneity was lowest and reported vascular effects strongest in superficial capillary plexus assessments. Systematic review of OCTA studies revealed massive heterogeneity in the methods employed to assess retinal perfusion, supporting calls for standardisation of methodology.

Optical Coherence Tomography Angiography as a Diagnostic Tool for Diabetic Retinopathy

Diabetic retinopathy (DR) is the most common microvascular complication of diabetes mellitus, leading to visual impairment if left untreated. This review discusses the use of optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) as a diagnostic tool for the early detection and management of DR. OCTA is a fast, non-invasive, non-contact test that enables the detailed visualisation of the macular microvasculature in different plexuses. OCTA offers several advantages over fundus fluorescein angiography (FFA), notably offering quantitative data. OCTA is not without limitations, including the requirement for careful interpretation of artefacts and the limited region of interest that can be captured currently. We explore how OCTA has been instrumental in detecting early microvascular changes that precede clinical signs of DR. We also discuss the application of OCTA in the diagnosis and management of various stages of DR, including non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy (NPDR), proliferative diabetic retinopathy (PDR), diabetic macular oedema (DMO), diabetic macular ischaemia (DMI), and pre-diabetes. Finally, we discuss the future role of OCTA and how it may be used to enhance the clinical outcomes of DR.

Advantages of the Utilization of Wide-Field OCT and Wide-Field OCT Angiography in Clinical Practice

Wide-field (WF) retinal imaging is becoming a standard diagnostic tool for diseases involving the peripheral retina. Technological progress elicited the advent of wide-field optical coherence tomography (WF-OCT) and WF-OCT angiography (WF-OCTA) examinations. This review presents the results of studies that analyzed the implementation of these procedures in clinical practice and refers to them as traditional and ultra-wide-field fluorescein angiography (UWF-FA). A PUBMED search was performed using the terms WF-OCT OR WF-OCTA OR UWF-FA AND the specific clinical entity, and another search for diabetic retinopathy (DR), retinal vein occlusion (RVO), Coats disease, peripheral retinal telangiectasia, peripheral retinal degeneration, lattice degeneration, and posterior vitreous detachment. The analysis only included the studies in which the analyzed field of view for the OCT or OCTA exam was larger than 55 degrees. The evaluation of the extracted studies indicates that WF imaging with OCT and OCTA provides substantial information on retinal disorders involving the peripheral retina. Vascular diseases, such as DR or RVO, can be reliably evaluated using WF-OCTA with results superior to standard-field fluorescein angiography. Nevertheless, UWF-FA provides a larger field of view and still has advantages over WF-OCTA concerning the evaluation of areas of non-perfusion and peripheral neovascularization. Detailed information on the vascular morphology of peripheral changes should be obtained via WF-OCTA and not angiographic examinations. WF-OCT can serve as a valuable tool for the detection and evaluation of vitreoretinal traction, posterior vitreous detachment, and peripheral retinal degeneration, and guide therapeutic decisions on a patient's eligibility for surgical procedures.

Optical coherence tomography angiography in diabetic retinopathy

There remain many unanswered questions on how to assess and treat the pathology and complications that arise from diabetic retinopathy (DR). Optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) is a novel and non-invasive three-dimensional imaging method that can visualize capillaries in all retinal layers. Numerous studies have confirmed that OCTA can identify early evidence of microvascular changes and provide quantitative assessment of the extent of diseases such as DR and its complications. A number of informative OCTA metrics could be used to assess DR in clinical trials, including measurements of the foveal avascular zone (FAZ; area, acircularity, 3D para-FAZ vessel density), vessel density, extrafoveal avascular zones, and neovascularization. Assessing patients with DR using a full-retinal slab OCTA image can limit segmentation errors and confounding factors such as those related to center-involved diabetic macular edema. Given emerging data suggesting the importance of the peripheral retinal vasculature in assessing and predicting DR progression, wide-field OCTA imaging should also be used. Finally, the use of automated methods and algorithms for OCTA image analysis, such as those that can distinguish between areas of true and false signals, reconstruct images, and produce quantitative metrics, such as FAZ area, will greatly improve the efficiency and standardization of results between studies. Most importantly, clinical trial protocols should account for the relatively high frequency of poor-quality data related to sub-optimal imaging conditions in DR and should incorporate time for assessing OCTA image quality and re-imaging patients where necessary.

OCT angiography and its retinal biomarkers [Invited]

Optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) is a high-resolution, depth-resolved imaging modality with important applications in ophthalmic practice. An extension of structural OCT, OCTA enables non-invasive, high-contrast imaging of retinal and choroidal vasculature that are amenable to quantification. As such, OCTA offers the capability to identify and characterize biomarkers important for clinical practice and therapeutic research. Here, we review new methods for analyzing biomarkers and discuss new insights provided by OCTA.

Is There a Nonperfusion Threshold on OCT Angiography Associated With New Vessels Detected on Ultra-Wide-Field Imaging in Diabetic Retinopathy?

Purpose

To determine whether the nonperfusion index (NPI) measured on widefield (WF) optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) could be used as an alternative method for the diagnosis of proliferative diabetic retinopathy (PDR) and to study the relationship between the NPI and the location of new vessels (NV) in eyes with PDR.

Methods

Fifty-one treatment-naïve eyes with either severe nonproliferative DR (NPDR) or PDR were imaged using ultra-wide-field imaging and wide-field OCTA.

Results

The NPI was significantly higher in eyes with PDR (18.94% vs. 7.51%; P < 0.01). Using the NPI on the whole image to assess PDR status, the area under the curve was 0.770, but the area under the curve increased when the NPI of the most peripheral circle was used (area under the curve of 0.792). Four eyes with PDR (17%) had NV outside the OCTA image field, and their mean NPI (6.15 %) did not differ from that measured in severe NPDR eyes (7.51%; P = 0.67) and was lower than in other eyes with PDR (21.49%; P = 0.023). The presence of NV in a sector was associated with a higher NPI in the same sector (29.2% vs. 6.0%; P < 10-15).

Conclusions

Although the NPI was significantly higher in eyes with PDR compared with severe NPDR eyes, its measurement on the whole wide-field OCTA image was not sensitive enough to replace the detection of NV for the diagnosis of PDR.

Translational Relevance

Because the presence of new vessels was related to the local nonperfusion index in the same sector, the assessment of nonperfusion outside the optical coherence tomography angiography field is important in diabetic retinopathy.

Clinical utility of ultra-widefield fluorescein angiography and optical coherence tomography angiography for retinal vein occlusions

Retinal vein occlusions (RVOs) are the second most common retinal vascular disease after diabetic retinopathy, and are a significant cause of visual impairment, especially in the elderly population. RVOs result in visual loss due to macular ischemia, cystoid macular edema (CME), and complications related to neovascularization. Vascular assessment in RVOs traditionally relies on standard fluorescein angiography (FA) for assessment of macular and retinal ischemia, which aids in prognostication and guides intervention. Standard FA has significant limitations-it is time-consuming, requires invasive dye administration, allows for limited assessment of the peripheral retina, and is usually evaluated semi-qualitatively, by ophthalmologists with tertiary expertise. More recently, the introduction of ultra-widefield FA (UWF FA) and optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) into clinical practice has changed the tools available for vascular evaluation in RVOs. UWF FA allows for evaluation of peripheral retinal perfusion, and OCTA is non-invasive, rapidly-acquired, and provides more information on capillary perfusion. Both modalities can be used to provide more quantitative parameters related to retinal perfusion. In this article, we review the clinical utility and impact of UWF FA and OCTA in the evaluation and management of patients with RVOs.

Optical Coherence Tomography Angiography in Retinal Vascular Disorders

Traditionally, abnormalities of the retinal vasculature and perfusion in retinal vascular disorders, such as diabetic retinopathy and retinal vascular occlusions, have been visualized with dye-based fluorescein angiography (FA). Optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) is a newer, alternative modality for imaging the retinal vasculature, which has some advantages over FA, such as its dye-free, non-invasive nature, and depth resolution. The depth resolution of OCTA allows for characterization of the retinal microvasculature in distinct anatomic layers, and commercial OCTA platforms also provide automated quantitative vascular and perfusion metrics. Quantitative and qualitative OCTA analysis in various retinal vascular disorders has facilitated the detection of pre-clinical vascular changes, greater understanding of known clinical signs, and the development of imaging biomarkers to prognosticate and guide treatment. With further technological improvements, such as a greater field of view and better image quality processing algorithms, it is likely that OCTA will play an integral role in the study and management of retinal vascular disorders. Artificial intelligence methods-in particular, deep learning-show promise in refining the insights to be gained from the use of OCTA in retinal vascular disorders. This review aims to summarize the current literature on this imaging modality in relation to common retinal vascular disorders.

Prevalence of venous loops and association with retinal ischemia in diabetic retinopathy using widefield swept-source OCT angiography

PURPOSE

To investigate the prevalence and clinical characteristics of diabetic patients with retinal venous loops (RVLs) and to assess the association with retinal ischemia using widefield swept-source optical coherence tomography angiography (WF SS-OCTA).

METHODS

In this retrospective, cross-sectional study, a total of 195 eyes of 132 diabetic patients (31 eyes with no diabetic retinopathy (DR), 76 eyes with nonproliferative DR (NPDR), and 88 eyes with proliferative DR (PDR)) were imaged with WF SS-OCTA using Angio 6 × 6 mm and Montage 15 × 15 mm scans. Quantitative ischemia-related parameters, including ischemia index (ratio of nonperfusion area to total retinal area), foveal avascular zone (FAZ), and neovascularization features, were evaluated. RVLs were classified as type I or type II according to the branching level of the feeder vessel. A multivariate generalized estimating equations (GEE) logistic regression model was used to analyze the association of systemic parameters and ischemia-related metrics with RVLs in PDR eyes.

RESULTS

Forty-eight RVLs were identified in 22 eyes (11.28%). The prevalence of RVLs was higher in PDR compared to NPDR eyes (21.59% vs. 3.95%, P < 0.05). Type II RVLs accounted for a higher proportion than type I (89.58% vs. 10.42%, P < 0.001). RVLs were more likely to originate from superior (vs. inferior) and temporal (vs. nasal) veins (P < 0.05). The GEE model showed that neovascularization (NV) flow area and diastolic blood pressure were associated with RVLs in the PDR group (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

WF SS-OCTA is useful for the identification of RVLs in patients with DR. NV flow area and diastolic blood pressure were associated with the presence of RVLs in eyes with PDR. Ischemia index, FAZ, and other WF SS-OCTA parameters were not associated with RVLs. Further longitudinal studies are needed to identify the role of RVLs in DR progression.

Imaging in retinal vascular disease: A review

Retinal vascular diseases represent a broad field of ocular pathologies. Retinal imaging is an important tool for diagnosis, prognosis and follow up of retinal vascular diseases. It includes a wide variety of imaging techniques ranging from colour fundus photography and optical coherence tomography to dynamic diagnostic options such as fluorescein angiography, and optical coherence tomography angiography. The newest developments in respective imaging techniques include widefield imaging to assess the retinal periphery, which is of especial interest in retinal vascular diseases. Automatic image analysis and artificial intelligence may support the image analysis and may prove valuable for prognostic purposes. This review provides a broad overview of the imaging techniques that have been used in the past, today and maybe in the future to stage and monitor retinal vascular disease with focus on the main disease entities including diabetic retinopathy, retinal vein occlusion, and retinal artery occlusion.