Aplicación de la biopsia por endoscopia flexible en el diagnóstico de la patología tumoral en otorrinolaringología

A systematic review on efficacy, safety and cost-effectiveness of office-based laryngeal biopsy

OBJECTIVE

Laryngeal cancer is the second most prevalent head and neck malignancy in the USA. With recent advances in technology, this procedure is increasingly performed under local anaesthesia. This study aimed to identify the efficacy, safety and cost-effectiveness of laryngeal biopsy in out-patients by conducting a systematic review.

METHOD

A literature search was conducted using PubMed, Medline, Google Scholar and Embase over a 20-year period. Inclusion criteria were: studies performed on out-patient diagnostic biopsy procedures of the larynx. Exclusion criteria included all therapeutic procedures. The outcome measures were sensitivity and specificity, complication rate and cost-savings.

RESULTS

Thirty-five studies were included in the analysis. The sensitivity and specificity varied from 60 to 100 per cent with a low complication rate and cost savings.

CONCLUSION

Office-based laryngeal biopsies are increasingly used in the diagnosis of laryngeal cancers, resulting in earlier diagnosis and commencement of treatment. The barrier to undertaking this procedure is low sensitivity.

The effect of local anaesthetic biopsy in head and neck cancer on cancer pathway waiting times

INTRODUCTION

The 31-day target in urgent suspicion of cancer (USOC) referrals fast-tracks patients through the cancer pathway. Local anaesthetic (LA) biopsy can be performed during an outpatient clinic and may improve pathway times. The aim of this study was to compare LA biopsy in head and neck USOC referrals with the traditional general anaesthetic (GA) pathway.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study of USOC referrals to the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde head and neck multidisciplinary team between 1 June 2018 and 28 December 2020, and compared pathway times in LA and GA biopsies.

RESULTS

The mean number of days from clinic to biopsy was 4.4 in the LA group and 28.0 in the GA group. This was significantly faster in the LA biopsy group (p < 0.05). The overall pathway time in the LA and GA biopsy groups was 35.7 and 61.5 days, respectively, and was significantly faster in LA biopsy group (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The LA cohort had significantly faster pathway times compared with GA biopsy. LA biopsy requires careful patient selection, but is an effective alternative to GA biopsy in the appropriate patient group.

Diagnostic Yield of Office-Based Laryngeal Biopsy in Patients With Leukoplakia; A Case Study With Review of the Literature

OBJECTIVE

To review the authors experience in un-sedated office-based biopsies of patients with vocal fold leukoplakia and to review the literature.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

A retrospective review of 29 patients was conducted.

RESULTS

A total of 41 office-based procedures were performed (eight patients had bilateral vocal fold lesions and four patients had the procedure performed twice). In 26 out of the 41 biopsies, the pathology revealed benign lesion. In eight cases, the pathology showed dysplasia (four high-grade and four low-grade). Seven biopsies revealed squamous cell carcinoma. Five patients underwent suspension micro-laryngoscopy for definitive diagnosis. Four of whom had a change in their diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

Un-sedated office-based biopsy of vocal fold leukoplakia is an alternative to suspension microlaryngoscopy in case of carcinoma or nonmalignant lesions.

Diagnostic Usefulness of Flexible Fibroscopy Biopsy in Suspected Lesions of the Otolaryngological Area

The efficiency in the management of patients with suspected malignant lesions represents the main objective of the oncology of head and neck. Flexible nasopahyngolaryngoscopy with working channel allows to quickly and safely assess and obtain histological samples of this type of lesion. Our objective is to describe the usefulness of this technique in lesions suggestive of malignancy in terms of efficiency, sensitivity and specificity. A retrospective study was carried out over a period of time from December 2014 to December 2019, including patients biopsied with flexible fibroscopy of lesions of debut suspected of malignancy. Here we assess the location of the lesion, the histological results, the diagnostic time and the epidemiological variables. 104 patients were included in the study. More than half of the lesions, 55.2% (57), were located in the larynx; 57.7% (60) resulted positive for malignancy in the flexible fiberscope biopsy; 19.2% (20) were taken to the operating room to get biopsied under general anesthesia resulting in 7.4% (14) positive for malignancy, which shows a sensitivity of the test of 81%. In our sample, a diagnostic time of 15 days was obtained. Considering our results, the few complications and the revised literature, flexible fiberscope biopsy with working channel is an efficient procedure for the management of oncological patients of head and neck.

A systematic review: impact of in-office biopsy on safety and waiting times in head and neck cancer

Objective

This study aimed to assess the current literature on the safety and impact of in-office biopsy on cancer waiting times as well as review evidence regarding cost-efficacy and patient satisfaction.

Method

A search of Cinahl, Cochrane Library, Embase, Medline, Prospero, PubMed and Web of Science was conducted for papers relevant to this study. Included articles were quality assessed and critically appraised.

Results

Of 19 741 identified studies, 22 articles were included. Lower costs were consistently reported for in-office biopsy compared with operating room biopsy. Four complications requiring intervention were documented. In-office biopsy is highly tolerated, with a procedure abandonment rate of less than 1 per cent. When compared with operating room biopsy, it is associated with significantly reduced time-to-diagnosis and time-to-treatment initiation. It is linked to improved overall three-year survival.

Conclusion

In-office biopsy is a safe procedure that may help certain patients avoid general anaesthetic. It was shown to significantly reduce time-to-diagnosis and time-to-treatment initiation when compared with operating room biopsy. This may have important implications for oncological outcomes. In-office biopsy requires fewer resources and is likely to be cost-saving five-years following introduction. With high rates of sensitivity and specificity, in-office biopsy should be considered as the first-line procedure to achieve tissue diagnosis.

Diagnostic Accuracy Outcomes of Office-Based (Outpatient) Biopsies in patients with Laryngopharyngeal Lesions: A Systematic Review

Background

In‐office biopsies (IOB) using local anaesthetic for laryngopharyngeal tumours has become an increasingly popular approach since the advent of distal chip endoscopes. Although a wide range of studies advocate use in clinical practice, the widespread application of the procedure is hampered by concerns regarding diagnostic accuracy.

Objective

To assess the diagnostic accuracy of IOB performed via flexible endoscopy. In addition, to analyse modifiable factors that may affect diagnostic accuracy of IOB.

Design

A systematic review following the PRISMA guidelines was conducted. PubMed, EMBASE, the Cochrane Library, Web of Science and CINAHL were used in the literature database search. Quality assessment of included studies was perfomed using the Newcastle‐Ottawa Scale.

Results

A total of 875 studies were identified, 16 of which were included into the systematic review; 1572 successful biopsies were performed using flexible endoscopy; 1283 cases were accurately diagnosed in the outpatient setting (81.6%) and 289 samples did not provide an accurate diagnosis (18.4%). The median sensitivity of IOB was 73%, and the specificity was 96.7%. Analysis of variable factors did not show any significant differences in method of approach, size of equipment (forceps) and additional lighting system or learning curve.

Conclusion

IOB are a viable tool for diagnostic workup of laryngopharyngeal tumours. Clinicians should be wary of reported limitations of IOB when benign or pre‐malignant diagnoses are made. In cases suspicious of malignancy, confirmatory investigation should be conducted.

Flexible Endoscopic Biopsy: Identifying Factors to Increase Accuracy in Diagnosing Benign and Malignant Laryngopharyngeal Pathology

OBJECTIVES

To assess the influence that several factors, such as the amount of obtained biopsies, difficult procedures, biopsy site and the experience of the attending physician, have on accuracy of flexible endoscopic biopsy (FEB).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

203 FEB procedures for benign or malignant laryngopharyngeal lesions were prospectively included. During the procedure, three representative biopsies (macroscopically containing vital tumor tissue and not only necrosis or healthy tissue) were obtained. The accuracy of each biopsy was separately analyzed. Difficulties during the procedures leading to failure of acquiring three representative biopsies were recorded and classified into tumor, patient and procedural factors. Histological results of FEB were defined correct when consistent with clinical context, additional biopsies or Positron emission tomography-computed tomography (PET-CT) revealed equivalent pathology, or the lesion was stable or resolved in >6 months follow-up.

RESULTS

The first representative biopsy yielded a correct diagnosis in 65% of the cases. After the second representative biopsy, 78% was correctly diagnosed. The contribution of the third and fourth representative biopsies to accuracy was 3%. The overall accuracy of FEB was 85%. Difficult procedures were more likely to result in misdiagnosis, whereas biopsy site or experience of the attending physician did not influence results.

CONCLUSIONS

FEB was accurate in diagnosing laryngopharyngeal lesions when at least two representative biopsies were obtained. Accuracy of FEB could be further improved by limiting possible constraints during the procedures, for example by selecting, informing, and anesthetizing patients carefully.