Do immature and mature sibling oocytes recovered from stimulated cycles have the same reproductive potential?

Usable blastocysts developed from in-vitro-matured metaphase I oocytes in preimplantation genetic testing cycles

RESEARCH QUESTION

Are blastocysts derived from in-vitro-matured metaphase I (MI) oocytes less likely to produce usable embryos for transfer compared with those derived from in-vivo-matured oocytes in cycles undergoing preimplantation genetic testing (PGT)?

DESIGN

The primary outcome was usable blastocyst rate, which was compared between blastocysts derived from in-vitro-matured MI oocytes after ovarian stimulation and from in-vivo-matured oocytes. Logistic regression analysis using generalized estimating equations was used to control for confounders in the analysis of factors that may influence the chance of a blastocyst being usable and in the comparison of embryological outcomes. Student's t-test, Mann-Whitney U test, chi-squared tests or Fisher's exact tests were used to compare clinical and pregnancy outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 1810 injected metaphase II (MII) oocytes from 154 PGT cycles involving 154 couples were included in this study. A total of 1577 MII oocytes were in-vivo-matured and 233 were in-vitro-matured MI oocytes. The usable blastocyst rate was similar between the in-vitro-matured MI oocyte group and the in-vivo-matured oocyte group (adjusted RR 0.97, 95% CI 0.40 to 2.34). Three live births were achieved using usable blastocysts derived from in-vitro-matured MI oocytes.

CONCLUSIONS

If in-vitro-matured MI oocytes can be fertilized and develop into blastocysts, their ability to provide usable embryos for transfer is similar compared with those developed from in-vivo-matured oocytes. These blastocysts could be considered valuable for women with few viable embryos in assisted reproductive technology cycles.

Addition of rapamycin or co-culture with cumulus cells from younger reproductive age women does not improve rescue in vitro oocyte maturation or euploidy rates in older reproductive age women

Both spontaneously conceived pregnancies and those achieved using assisted reproduction decline with advancing maternal age. In this study, we tested if rapamycin and/or cumulus cells (CCs) from young donors could improve oocyte maturation and euploidy rates of germinal vesicle (GV) stage oocytes obtained from older women of reproductive age. A total of 498 GVs from 201 women >38 years (40.6 ± 1.8, mean ± SD) were included. GVs were randomly assigned into five groups for rescue IVM: control (with no CCs and no rapamycin); with autologous CCs; with autologous CCs and rapamycin; with CCs from young women (<35 years); and with CCs from young women and rapamycin. After 24 h of culture, the first polar body (PB) was biopsied in metaphase II oocytes, and the cytogenetic constitution was assessed using next-generation sequencing for both oocytes and PBs. Comparable maturation rates were found (56.2%, 60.0%, 46.5%, 51.7%, and 48.5% for groups 1-5, respectively; P = 0.30). Similarly, comparable euploidy rates were observed in the five groups (41.5%, 37.8%, 47.2%, 43.6%, and 47.8% for Groups 1-5, respectively; P = 0.87). Our findings indicate that rescue IVM is effective for obtaining mature euploid oocytes in older women of reproductive age, and that incubation with rapamycin or CCs obtained from young donors does not improve the maturation or euploidy rate.

Focusing on the accumulation of chromatin/chromosomes around nucleoli and optimizing the timing of ICSI to facilitate the rescue in vitro maturation of denuded GV stage oocytes

PURPOSE

This study aims to achieve the methodological improvement of rescue IVM by predicting germinal vesicle breakdown (GVBD) and optimizing the timing of ICSI.

METHODS

Time lapse analysis was performed retrospectively to evaluated the relationship between the presence of AC around the nucleoli and GVBD. To find the optimal timing of ICSI, the time from the initiation of the first polar body extrusion to ICSI were measured, and the rates of fertilization at each point were calculated.

RESULTS

The GVBD rate of GV stage oocytes with AC around the nucleoli was significantly higher than that of GV stage oocytes without AC. The GV stage oocytes required more time for nuclear maturation after polar body extrusion than MI oocytes, with GV stage oocytes taking 400-600 min from polar body extrusion to the optimal timing of ICSI, while the MI stage oocytes took 200-400 min. The GV stage oocytes resulted in the birth of healthy babies with the appropriate timing of ICSI.

CONCLUSION

It was found that GV stage oocytes with AC around nucleoli can initiate GVBD and reach the MII stage with a high rate, and that GV stage oocytes required more time than MI stage oocytes to reach the optimal timing of ICSI. Considering these factors, ART laboratories may employ immature GV stage oocytes in routine ART procedures rather than discarding them.

The developmental potential of mature oocytes derived from rescue in vitro maturation

OBJECTIVE

To examine the developmental competence of immature oocytes in stimulated cycles, that matured after rescue in vitro maturation (IVM) compared with their sibling in vivo matured oocytes.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

IVF clinic.

PATIENTS

A total of 182 patients underwent 200 controlled ovarian stimulation cycles with intracytoplasmic sperm injection cycles in which immature oocytes were retrieved and at least one mature oocyte was obtained through rescue IVM.

INTERVENTION

In vitro culture of immature germinal vesicle (GV) and metaphase I (MI) oocytes, retrieved in stimulated cycles.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Fertilization rate, cleavage rate, blastulation rate, ploidy of embryos evaluated using preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy, morphokinetic parameters and pregnancy outcomes.

RESULTS

In total, 2,288 oocytes were retrieved from 200 cycles. After denudation, 1,056 of the oocytes (46% ± 16%) were classified as metaphase II (MII). A total of 333/375 (89%) of MI oocytes and 292/540 (54%) of GV oocytes matured overnight and underwent intracytoplasmic sperm injection. The fertilization rates of matured oocytes from MI rescue IVM (R-MI) and from GV rescue IVM (R-GV) were comparable with those of their sibling MII oocytes (71% vs. 66%; 66% vs. 63%, respectively). Early cleavage rates (80% ± 35% vs. 92% ± 20%; 80% ± 42% vs. 95% ± 28%, respectively) and blastulation rates (32 ± 40% vs. 62 ± 33%; 24 ± 37% vs. 60 ± 35%, respectively) were significantly decreased in rescue IVM matured oocytes (R-oocytes)-derived zygotes, but the blastocyst (BL) euploidy rate and "good quality" BL rate were comparable with those of MII sibling-derived embryos. In addition, rescue IVM embryos showed significantly higher levels of multinucleation at the 2- and 4-cell stages, as well as higher rates of zygote direct cleavage from one to 3 to 4 cells. Overall, 21 transfers of rescue IVM embryos resulted in 3 healthy live births.

CONCLUSIONS

For patients with a low maturation rate and/or low numbers of mature oocytes at retrieval, rescue IVM may contribute more competent oocytes and additional viable BLs for transfer from the same stimulation cycle, maximizing the chances for pregnancy and live birth.

Chromatin Morphology in Human Germinal Vesicle Oocytes and Their Competence to Mature in Stimulated Cycles

The search for simple morphological predictors of oocyte quality is an important task for assisted reproduction technologies (ARTs). One such predictor may be the morphology of the oocyte nucleus, called the germinal vesicle (GV), including the level of chromatin aggregation around the atypical nucleolus (ANu)-a peculiar nuclear organelle, formerly referred to as the nucleolus-like body. A prospective cohort study allowed distinguishing three classes of GV oocytes among 135 oocytes retrieved from 64 patients: with a non-surrounded ANu and rare chromatin blocks in the nucleoplasm (Class A), with a complete peri-ANu heterochromatic rim assembling all chromatin (Class C), and intermediate variants (Class B). Comparison of the chromatin state and the ability of oocytes to complete meiosis allowed us to conclude that Class B and C oocytes are more capable of resuming meiosis in vitro and completing the first meiotic division, while Class A oocytes can resume maturation but often stop their development either at metaphase I (MI arrest) or before the onset of GV breakdown (GVBD arrest). In addition, oocytes with a low chromatin condensation demonstrated a high level of aneuploidy during the resumption of meiosis. Considering that the degree of chromatin condensation/compaction can be determined in vivo under a light microscope, this characteristic of the GV can be considered a promising criterion for selecting the best-quality GV oocytes in IVM rescue programs.

Chromatin Configuration in Diplotene Mouse and Human Oocytes during the Period of Transcriptional Activity Extinction

In the oocyte nucleus, called the germinal vesicle (GV) at the prolonged diplotene stage of the meiotic prophase, chromatin undergoes a global rearrangement, which is often accompanied by the cessation of its transcriptional activity. In many mammals, including mice and humans, chromatin condenses around a special nuclear organelle called the atypical nucleolus or formerly nucleolus-like body. Chromatin configuration is an important indicator of the quality of GV oocytes and largely predicts their ability to resume meiosis and successful embryonic development. In mice, GV oocytes are traditionally divided into the NSN (non-surrounded nucleolus) and SN (surrounded nucleolus) based on the specific chromatin configuration. The NSN-SN transition is a key event in mouse oogenesis and the main prerequisite for the normal development of the embryo. As for humans, there is no single nomenclature for the chromatin configuration at the GV stage. This often leads to discrepancies and misunderstandings, the overcoming of which should expand the scope of the application of mouse oocytes as a model for developing new methods for assessing and improving the quality of human oocytes. As a first approximation and with a certain proviso, the mouse NSN/SN classification can be used for the primary characterization of human GV oocytes. The task of this review is to analyze and discuss the existing classifications of chromatin configuration in mouse and human GV oocytes with an emphasis on transcriptional activity extinction at the end of oocyte growth.

Potential Development of Vitrified Immature Human Oocytes: Influence of the Culture Medium and the Timing of Vitrification

How does the in vitro maturation (IVM) medium and the vitrification procedure affect the survival of germinal vesicle (GV) oocytes obtained from stimulated cycles and their development to the blastocyst stage? In total, 1085 GV human oocytes were obtained after women underwent a cycle of controlled ovarian stimulation, and these oocytes were subjected to IVM before or after their vitrification. IVM was carried out in two commercial culture media not specifically designed for maturation. MII oocytes were then activated and embryo development until day 6 was evaluated. According to the results, a higher percentage of oocytes reach the MII stage if they are vitrified before they undergo IVM. Nevertheless, the medium used and the sample size determine whether these differences become significant or not. Similar survival rates and development to blastocysts were observed in all the conditions studied.

Rapamycin improves the quality and developmental competence of in vitro matured oocytes in aged mice and humans

Women over age 35 suffer from the inadequate number and poor quality of oocytes during assisted reproductive treatment, and making full use of the oocytes by in vitro maturation (IVM) is crucial. Rapamycin could improve the developmental competences of the post-maturation oocytes during in vitro aging, yet its effects on the IVM process of oocytes from an aged population were not clear. In this study, the immature oocytes from aged mice or older women underwent IVM with or without 10 nM rapamycin, followed by parthenogenetic activation or insemination and embryo culture. The developmental competence and quality of IVM oocytes in both groups were compared. The results showed that in aged mice, the maturation rate, activation rate, and cleavage rate of IVM oocytes were significantly elevated in the rapamycin group. Additionally, oocytes cultured with rapamycin presented decreased ROS levels, reduced chromosome aberration, and attenuated levels of γ-H2AX. During IVM of oocytes from older women, the GVBD rate, 24 h maturation rate, and 48 h maturation rate were increased in the rapamycin group, compared with those in the control group, although without significant differences. After intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) and further culture of human oocytes, the high-quality embryo rate in the rapamycin group was significantly elevated. Overall, rapamycin improved IVM outcomes of oocytes from aged mice and older women. The specific mechanism of the positive effects of rapamycin on IVM outcomes might be reducing ROS levels, mitigating DNA damage, and promoting developmental potential.

Rapamycin improves the developmental competence of human oocytes by alleviating DNA damage during IVM

STUDY QUESTION

Can rapamycin improve the developmental competence of human oocytes during the IVM process?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Rapamycin at 10 nM could markedly improve the developmental competence of human oocytes undergoing IVM.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Embryos derived from oocytes that mature in vitro have lower developmental competence than sibling embryos derived from oocytes matured in vivo. Rapamycin was shown to effectively improve IVM outcomes in mammalian oocytes; however, its effects on IVM of human oocytes have not been investigated.

STUDY DESIGN SIZE DURATION

In 2021, donated immature oocytes (n = 202) from 80 infertile couples receiving ICSI were included in a control group, and 156 oocytes from 72 couples were included in a rapamycin group. The oocytes underwent IVM with 10 nM rapamycin or without (control) rapamycin, followed by insemination by ICSI and embryo culture.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS SETTING METHODS

The germinal vesicle breakdown (GVBD), maturation, normal fertilization, high-quality embryo (HQE) and blastocyst formation rates were calculated to evaluate the developmental competence of IVM oocytes, and fluorescence staining was used to assess DNA damage levels of oocytes in both groups. Whole-genome amplification and DNA sequencing were performed to analyze chromosome euploidy in embryos derived from the rapamycin group.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

The baseline characteristics of patients who donated oocytes for the two experimental groups were similar. In the control group, GVBD happened in 135 (66.8%) oocytes, and the maturation rate reached 52.5% at 24 h and 63.4% at 48 h. In the rapamycin group, 143 (91.7%) oocytes underwent GVBD, and the maturation rate reached 60.3% at 24 h and 82.7% at 48 h. Following ICSI, more HQEs were obtained in the rapamycin group versus control (34.2% versus 22.1%, respectively, P = 0.040), although with comparable fertilization rates in the two groups. In addition, the levels of histone γH2AX in oocytes cultured with 10 nM rapamycin were markedly decreased, compared with those in the control group (0.3 ± 0.0 versus 0.6 ± 0.1, respectively, P = 0.048). Embryos with normal karyotype could be obtained from oocytes cultured with rapamycin.

LIMITATIONS REASONS FOR CAUTION

Our preliminary results indicated that the addition of rapamycin during human oocyte IVM did not cause extra aneuploidy. However, this safety evaluation of rapamycin treatment was based on limited samples and more data are needed before possible application in the clinic.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

In the current study, 10 nM rapamycin was applied in the IVM process of human oocytes for the first time and showed positive effects, providing new insights for potentially improving IVM outcomes in the clinic. There were subtle differences between the results presented here on human oocytes and our previous studies on mouse oocytes, indicating the necessity of more research on human samples.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS

This work was supported by the research grants from National Key Research and Development Project (2018YFC1002103) and Health Commission of Hubei Province scientific research project (WJ2021M110). All authors declared no conflicts of interest.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

Ultrastructural Evaluation of the Human Oocyte at the Germinal Vesicle Stage during the Application of Assisted Reproductive Technologies

After its discovery in 1825 by the physiologist J.E. Purkinje, the human germinal vesicle (GV) attracted the interest of scientists. Discarded after laparotomy or laparoscopic ovum pick up from the pool of retrieved mature oocytes, the leftover GV was mainly used for research purposes. After the discovery of Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ARTs) such as in vitro maturation (IVM), in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer (IVF-ET) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), its developing potential was explored, and recognized as an important source of germ cells, especially in the case of scarce availability of mature oocytes for pathological/clinical conditions or in the case of previous recurrent implantation failure. We here review the ultrastructural data available on GV-stage human oocytes and their application to ARTs.

Present state and future outlook for the application of in vitro oocyte maturation (IVM) in human infertility treatment

In vitro oocyte maturation (IVM) is an assisted reproductive technology in which a meiotically immature oocyte (prophase I or germinal vesicle stage) is recovered from an antral follicle and matured in vitro prior to fertilization. This technology, although in widespread use in domestic livestock, is not typically implemented during human IVF cycles. This review examines how IVM is currently used in the clinical setting, including the various ways IVM is defined in practice. The role of IVM in patient care, and the major challenges for implementation are described. Efficiency and safety are critically explored. The role of IVM in oncofertility will also be discussed. Finally, the outlook for the future of clinical IVM is considered.

Rescue in vitro maturation may increase the pregnancy outcomes among women undergoing intracytoplasmic sperm injection

INTRODUCTION

To investigate whether rescue in vitro maturation (R-IVM) improves the reproductive outcomes among women undergoing intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) after one oocyte retrieved cycle.

METHODS

Between January 2019 and December 2020, 2602 women who underwent ICSI in the Reproductive Medicine Center of Tongji Hospital, Wuhan, China, were included in our retrospective cohort study. There were 2112 women undergoing only ICSI and 490 women with R-IVM followed by ICSI. The intermediate reproductive outcomes and pregnancy outcomes were assessed, including the number of normally fertilized embryos, number of cleaved embryos, number of good-quality embryos, number of day-3 available embryos, number of embryos cultured past day-3, number of blastocysts, number of available blastocysts, biochemical pregnancy, miscarriage, clinical pregnancy and live birth. The perinatal outcomes were also assessed, including preterm birth and birth weight. The abovementioned outcomes were also calculated for in vivo matured and R-IVM oocytes separately in women undergoing ICSI with R-IVM group.

RESULTS

Compared with the women who underwent only ICSI, those who underwent ICSI with R-IVM had higher numbers of MII oocytes, normally fertilized embryos, cleaved embryos, day-3 available embryos, embryos cultured past day-3, and higher oocyte maturation rate, available embryo rate than women undergoing only ICSI. Additionally, we found that women undergoing ICSI with R-IVM had an increased chance of clinical pregnancy (adjusted OR=1.50, 95% CI: 1.17-1.93) and cumulative live birth (adjusted OR=1.35, 95% CI: 1.07-1.71). After propensity score matching (PSM), the cumulative live birth rate was 60.1% for women undergoing ICSI with R-IVM versus 54.9% for women undergoing only ICSI (OR=1.24, 95% CI: 0.94-1.63). The reproductive outcomes were also significantly different when calculated for in vivo matured and R-IVM oocytes separately in women undergoing ICSI with R-IVM group. All live births from R-IVM embryos were healthy and without malformations or complications.

CONCLUSION

R-IVM may improve the reproductive outcomes of women undergoing ICSI. It may also provide a reference for the safety of R-IVM. This study maybe support a routine application of R-IVM among patients who intend to undergo ICSI.

Analysis of maturation dynamics and developmental competence of in vitro matured oocytes under time-lapse monitoring

BACKGROUND

To improve the developmental competence of in vitro cultured oocytes, extensive literature focused on maturation rate improvement with different additives in culture medium, while studies investigating the maturation dynamics of oocytes during in vitro maturation (IVM) and the influencing factors on oocyte viability are scarce.

METHODS

The study involved a retrospective observation by time-lapse monitoring of the IVM process of 157 donated GV oocytes from 59 infertile couples receiving ICSI in 2019, in Tongji Hospital, Wuhan, China. The GV oocytes derived from controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH) cycles underwent rescue IVM (R-IVM), and the maturation dynamics, including GVBD time (GV-MI), time from GVBD to maturation (MI-MII), maturation time (GV-MII), and MII arrest duration (MII-ICSI), were recorded by time-lapse monitoring. The matured oocytes were inseminated at different MII arrest points and subsequent embryo developments were assessed. The effects of baseline clinical characteristics, oocyte diameters, and maturation dynamics on the developmental competence of the oocytes were also analyzed.

RESULTS

Totally, 157 GV oocytes were collected. GVBD happened in 111 oocytes, with a median GV-MI duration of 3.7 h. The median MI-MII duration was 15.6 h and the median GV-MII duration was 19.5 h. The maturation rate reached 56.7% at 24 h and 66.9% at 48 h, and the clinical factors, including patient age, FSH level, AMH level, ovarian stimulation protocol, and serum estradiol and progesterone levels on hCG trigger day, showed no effects on the 24-h maturation rate. The normal fertilization rate of oocytes resuming meiosis within 8 h and matured within 24 h was significantly higher than that of oocytes resuming meiosis after 8 h and matured after 24 h. Furthermore, among those oocytes matured within 24 h, the high-quality embryo formation rate of oocytes resuming meiosis within 4.5 h and matured within 19 h was significantly higher. All stated time was measured from the start point of IVM. Additionally, for oocytes from patients with serum progesterone levels less than 1 ng/ml on hCG trigger day, the high-quality embryo formation rate was significantly increased.

CONCLUSION

R-IVM technology could increase the available embryos for patients in routine COH cycles, but excessive culture beyond 24 h is not recommended. GV-MI duration of the oocyte, recorded by time-lapse system, and serum progesterone levels of patients on hCG trigger day can significantly affect the developmental potential of the IVM oocytes.

Fertilization and early embryonic development of in vitro matured metaphase I oocytes in patients with unexpected low oocyte maturity rate

To determine the fertilization and embryonic potential of immature metaphase I (MI) oocytes in patients with low oocyte maturity rate in whom the percentage of mature oocytes obtained was less than 75% of the total retrieved ones. In vivo matured metaphase II (MII) oocytes (MII-ICSI, n = 244), and in vitro matured MI oocytes (MI-MII-ICSI, n = 202) underwent an intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) procedure. Maturation rate, fertilization rate and early embryonic development were compared in both groups. In total, 683 oocytes were collected from 117 ICSI cycles of 117 patients. Among them, 244 (35.7%) were mature MII and 259 (37.9%) were MI after the denudation process. Of those 259 MI oocytes, 202 (77.9%) progressed to MII oocytes after an incubation period of 18-24 h. The maturation rate was 77.9%. Fertilization rate was found to be significantly higher in the rescued in vitro matured MI oocyte group when compared with the in vivo matured MII oocyte group (41.6% vs 25.8%; P = 0.0006). However, no significant difference was observed in terms of cleavage rates on days 2 and 3 between the groups (P = 0.9126 and P = 0.5031, respectively). There may be unidentified in vivo factors on the oocyte maturation causing low developmental capacity in spite of high fertilization rates in the group of patients with low oocyte maturity rate. Furthermore, studies are needed to determine the appropriate culture characteristics as well as culture period and ICSI timing of these oocytes.

Single-cell RNA sequencing identifies molecular targets associated with poor in vitro maturation performance of oocytes collected from ovarian stimulation

STUDY QUESTION

What is the transcriptome signature associated with poor performance of rescue IVM (rIVM) oocytes and how can we rejuvenate them?

SUMMARY ANSWER

The GATA-1/CREB1/WNT signalling axis was repressed in rIVM oocytes, particularly those of poor quality; restoration of this axis may produce more usable rIVM oocytes.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

rIVM aims to produce mature oocytes (MII) for IVF through IVM of immature oocytes collected from stimulated ovaries. It is not popular due to limited success rate in infertility treatment. Genetic aberrations, cellular stress and the absence of cumulus cell support in oocytes could account for the failure of rIVM.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

We applied single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) to capture the transcriptomes of human in vivo oocytes (IVO) (n = 10) from 7 donors and rIVM oocytes (n = 10) from 10 donors. The effects of maternal age and ovarian responses on rIVM oocyte transcriptomes were also studied. In parallel, we studied the effect of gallic acid on the maturation rate of mouse oocytes cultured in IVM medium with (n = 84) and without (n = 85) gallic acid.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Human oocytes were collected from donors aged 28-41 years with a body mass index of <30. RNA extraction, cDNA generation, library construction and sequencing were performed in one preparation. scRNA-seq data were then processed and analysed. Selected genes in the rIVM versus IVO comparison were validated by quantitative real-time PCR. For the gallic acid study, we collected immature oocytes from 5-month-old mice and studied the effect of 10-μM gallic acid on their maturation rate.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

The transcriptome profiles of rIVM/IVO oocytes showed distinctive differences. A total of 1559 differentially expressed genes (DEGs, genes with at least 2-fold change and adjusted P < 0.05) were found to be enriched in metabolic processes, biosynthesis and oxidative phosphorylation. Among these DEGs, we identified a repression of WNT/β-catenin signalling in rIVM when compared with IVO oocytes. We found that oestradiol levels exhibited a significant age-independent correlation with the IVO mature oocyte ratio (MII ratio) for each donor. rIVM oocytes from women with a high MII ratio were found to have over-represented cellular processes such as anti-apoptosis. To further identify targets that contribute to the poor clinical outcomes of rIVM, we compared oocytes collected from young donors with a high MII ratio with oocytes from donors of advanced maternal age and lower MII ratio, and revealed that CREB1 is an important regulator. Thus, our study identified that GATA-1/CREB1/WNT signalling was repressed in both rIVM oocytes versus IVO oocytes and in rIVM oocytes of lower versus higher quality. Consequently we investigated gallic acid, as a potential antioxidant substrate in human rIVM medium, and found that it increased the mouse oocyte maturation rate by 31.1%.

LARGE SCALE DATA

Raw data from this study can be accessed through GSE158539.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

In the rIVM oocytes of the high- and low-quality comparison, the number of samples was limited after data filtering with stringent selection criteria. For the oocyte stage identification, we were unable to predict the presence of oocyte spindle, so polar body extrusion was the only indicator.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This study showed that GATA-1/CREB1/WNT signalling was repressed in rIVM oocytes compared with IVO oocytes and was further downregulated in low-quality rIVM oocytes, providing us the foundation of subsequent follow-up research on human oocytes and raising safety concerns about the clinical use of rescued oocytes.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This work was supported by the Collaborative Research Fund, Research Grants Council, C4054-16G, and Research Committee Funding (Research Sustainability of Major RGC Funding Schemes), The Chinese University of Hong Kong. The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.

Developmental potential of immature human oocytes aspirated after controlled ovarian stimulation

PURPOSE

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) for initially immature oocytes that mature in vitro is controversial and practice varies widely. While it may increase the number of usable embryos, it may also be time-intensive and potentially low-yield. This study sought to elucidate which patients may benefit from ICSI of initially immature oocytes that matured in vitro.

METHODS

A retrospective study comparing fertilization, cleavage, blastulation, and embryo usage rates between sibling initially immature and mature oocytes that underwent ICSI between 2015 and 2019 was performed. Outcomes of initially immature oocytes were stratified by initial maturation stage, timing of progression to metaphase II (MII) in vitro, percentage of mature oocytes in the cycle, and female age.

RESULTS

Ten thousand eight hundred seventeen oocytes from 889 cycles were included. Of 3137 (29.0%) initially immature oocytes, 418 (13.3%) reached MII later on the day of retrieval (day 0) and 1493 (47.6%) on day 1. Overall, embryos originating from initially immature oocytes had lower cleavage and blastulation rates compared to those from initially mature oocytes (P<0.05, all groups). However, embryos from oocytes that matured later on day 0 comprised a unique subset that had clinically similar cleavage (75% vs 80%, RR 0.93, P=0.047) and blastulation rates (41% vs 50%, RR 0.81, P=0.024) compared to initially mature oocytes. Women with low percentages of mature oocytes in the cycle overall and women ≥40 in cleavage cycles derived the highest relative benefit from the use of immature oocytes.

CONCLUSION

ICSI of immature oocytes, particularly those that mature later on the day of retrieval, may improve numbers of usable embryos. This study supports routine reassessment of immature oocytes for progression to MII and ICSI on day 0. An additional reassessment on day 1 may also be of use in older women or those with low percentage of mature oocytes.

Important parameters affecting quality of vitrified donor oocytes

For group of 281 oocytes obtained from 43 stimulated donors and cryopreserved by vitrification protocol using Cryotop and Kitazato medium we determined important parameters of oocytes collection and vitrification processes which strongly affect the probability that warmed oocytes will produce high-quality embryos for transfer. The probability to obtain high-quality embryos for transfer from vitrified and warmed oocytes was highest when two conditions were fulfilled: 1. oocytes were incubated before vitrification for 7-10 h and 2. stimulated ovaries of donors in one cycle produced a smaller number of oocytes (<7 oocytes from one donor per stimulated cycle). The probable reasons for these observations were: 1. early vitrification (less than 7 h) before final oocyte metaphase II maturation negatively affected the crucial process of post-warm remodelling of spindles and chromosomes, which reduced the fertilization and utilization rates, 2. the evaluated vitrification protocol amplifies negative impact of membrane defects of oocytes of those cohorts containing more than 6 oocytes - freezing places great demands on the integrity and elasticity of the cell membranes. The fact that cryopreservation influences a complex state of oocytes was confirmed by confocal microscopy.

Impact of Maturation and Vitrification Time of Human GV Oocytes on the Metaphase Plate Configuration

The combination of in vitro maturation (IVM) techniques and oocyte vitrification (OV) could increase the number of useful oocytes in different types of patients. IVM and subsequent OV is the most widely used clinical strategy. Would the results improve if we reverse the order of the techniques? Here, we evaluated survival, in vitro maturation, time to extrude the first polar body (PB), and the metaphase plate configuration of human prophase I (GV) oocytes before or after their vitrification. Specific, 195 GV oocytes from 104 patients subjected to controlled ovarian stimulation cycles were included. We stablished three experimental groups: GV oocytes vitrified and IVM (Group GV-Vit), GV oocytes IVM and vitrified at MII stage (Group MII-Vit), and GV oocytes IVM (Group not-Vit). All of them were in vitro matured for a maximum of 48 h and fixed to study the metaphase plate by confocal microscopy. According to our results, the vitrification of immature oocytes and their subsequent maturation presented similar survival, maturation, and metaphase plate conformation rates, but a significantly higher percentage of normal spindle than the standard strategy. Additionally, the extension of IVM time to 48 h did not seem to negatively affect the oocyte metaphase plate configuration.

In vitro maturation: a committee opinion

The results of in vitro maturation (IVM) investigations suggest the potential for wider clinical application. This document discusses the efficacy of IVM as reported in the published literature to date. This document replaces the document of the same name, last published in 2013.