Usefulness of new diagnostic criteria for chronic hypersensitivity pneumonitis established on the basis of a Delphi survey: A Japanese cohort study

Challenges in recognizing airway-centered fibrosis: Observer concordance and its role in fibrotic hypersensitivity pneumonitis

BACKGROUND

The interobserver agreement regarding airway-centered fibrosis (ACF), the key diagnostic feature of fibrotic hypersensitivity pneumonitis (fHP) has not been sufficiently addressed to date. We applied digital image analysis to investigate this issue and extracted histological features of ACF to correlate with fHP diagnosis.

METHODS

A total of 111 selected glass slides from 17 fHP and 30 idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) were scanned and seven expert pulmonary pathologists were tasked with digital annotation of ACF. Interobserver agreement on annotated ACF was assessed using Fleiss' kappa value. ACF recognized by majority of pathologists (4 or more) were considered as consensus ACF (cACF), and their frequencies were compared between fHP and IPF cases.

RESULTS

Fleiss' kappa agreement in ACF recognition was 0.32 among seven pathologists. A significant difference between cryobiopsy and VATS specimens regarding an average ACF count per slide (p = 0.012) was found. The number of cACFs in a single case ranged from 0 to 20 (mean 5.71) for fHP cases and 0 to 13 (mean 1.80) for IPF cases (p = 0.011). When limited to surgical biopsies, the average number of cACF was 10.3 for fHP vs. 1.68 for IPF (p < 0.001). The common characteristic features of cACF in fHP were their confinement to the vicinity of respiratory bronchioles, frequent association with peribronchiolar metaplasia, and mild to moderate lymphocytic infiltration.

CONCLUSIONS

The recognition of ACF varies widely among pathologists. We identified common histologic features of ACF in fHP cases, proposing criteria for ACF recognition in fHP.

Japanese clinical practice guide 2022 for hypersensitivity pneumonitis

Considering recently published two guidelines for the diagnosis of hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP), the Japanese Respiratory Society (JRS) has now published its own Japanese clinical practice guide for HP. Major types of HP in Japan include summer-type, home-related, bird-related, farmer's lung, painter's lung, humidifier lung, and mushroom grower's lung. Identifying causative antigens is critical for increasing diagnostic confidence, as well as improving prognosis through appropriate antigen avoidance. This guide proposes a comprehensive antigen questionnaire including the outbreak sources reported in Japan. Drawing on the 2021 CHEST guideline, this guide highlights the antigen identification confidence level and adaptations for environmental surveys. The detection of specific antibodies against causative antigens is an important diagnostic predictor of HP. In Japan, the assessments of bird-specific IgG (pigeons, budgerigars) and the Trichosporon asahii antibody are covered by medical insurance. Although this guide adopts the 2020 ATS/JRS/ALAT guideline diagnostic criteria based on the combination of imaging findings, exposure assessment, bronchoalveolar lavage lymphocytosis, and histopathological findings, it added some annotations to facilitate the interpretation of the content and correlate the medical situation in Japan. It recommends checking biomarkers; seasonal changes in the KL-6 concentration (increase in winter for bird-related HP/humidifier lung and in summer for summer-type HP) and high KL-6 concentrations providing a basis for the suspicion of HP. Antigen avoidance is critical for disease management of HP. This guide also addresses the pharmacological management of HP, highlighting the treatment strategy for fibrotic HP including combination therapies with anti-inflammatory/immunosuppressive and antifibrotic drugs.

Effect of the 2020 hypersensitivity pneumonitis guideline on the pathologic diagnosis of interstitial pneumonia

It was reported that the 2020 guideline for hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP) might result in the overdiagnosis of fibrotic HP (fHP). fHP and other types of interstitial pneumonias have several overlapping characteristics, and a high diagnostic concordance rate of fHP is rarely obtained. Therefore, we investigated the impact of the 2020 HP guideline on the pathological diagnosis of cases previously diagnosed as interstitial pneumonia. We identified 289 fibrotic interstitial pneumonia cases from 2014 to 2019 and classified them into four categories according to the 2020 HP guideline: typical, probable, and indeterminate for fHP and alternative diagnosis. The original pathological diagnosis of 217 cases were compared to their classification as either typical, probable, or indeterminate for fHP according to the 2020 guideline. The clinical data, including serum data and pulmonary function tests, were compared among the groups. Diagnoses changed from non-fHP to fHP for 54 (25%) of the 217 cases, of which, 8 were typical fHP and 46 were probable fHP. The ratio of typical and probable fHP cases to the total number of VATS cases was significantly lower when using transbronchial lung cryobiopsy (p < 0.001). The clinical data of these cases bore a more remarkable resemblance to those diagnosed as indeterminate for fHP than to those diagnosed as typical or probable. The pathological criteria in the new HP guidelines increase the diagnosis of fHP. However, it is unclear whether this increase leads to overdiagnosis, and requires further investigation. Transbronchial lung cryobiopsy may not be helpful when using the new criteria to impart findings for fHP diagnosis.

Challenges in the Diagnosis and Management of Fibrotic Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis: A Practical Review of Current Approaches

Recent advances in fibrotic hypersensitivity pneumonitis include improved diagnostic guidance, systematic assessments of immunosuppressive therapy, and the recent availability of antifibrotic therapy (nintedanib) for those with progressive disease. A standardized approach to diagnosis may lead to better inclusion criteria for future therapeutic protocols and delineation of disease or treatment response predictors for real-world management. This review will highlight current diagnostic and treatment challenges and remaining knowledge gaps or areas of uncertainty, with a practical overview of supporting evidence and its clinical implications. Exposure history, serologic testing for antigen sensitivity, bronchoalveolar lavage lymphocytosis, histopathology, and radiologic findings will be covered in the diagnosis section, with immunosuppression, antifibrotic therapy, lung transplantation, and disease prognosis in the treatment and management section.

Bronchoalveolar lavage lymphocytosis in hypersensitivity pneumonitis: a retrospective cohort analysis with elimination of incorporation bias

Background

Recent studies support the diagnostic role of bronchoalveolar lavage lymphocytosis (BALL) in patients with suspected hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP). Our study aim was to determine the spectrum of BALL findings with elimination of incorporation bias in non-fibrotic and fibrotic patients and assess correlates of positive BALL cut-off and BALL association with long-term outcomes in those with fibrotic disease (f-HP).

Methods

A single-center retrospective cohort study was pursued of patients undergoing diagnostic bronchoscopy for interstitial lung disease. Strict study enrollment was based on recent ATS/JRS/ALAT diagnostic guidance meeting ‘moderate’ or higher diagnostic confidence. BALL findings were assessed in both fibrotic and non-fibrotic HP patients with regression and survival analysis pursued for correlates of positive BALL cut-off and long-term outcome.

Results

A total of 148 patients (88 fibrotic and 60 non-fibrotic) meeting moderate or higher diagnostic confidence were included. Median BALL in f-HP was 15% compared to 19% in non-fibrotic patients, with only 28% of f-HP meeting diagnostic cut-off (≥ 30%) compared to 41% of non-fibrotic. For f-HP, centrilobular nodules on computed tomography was positively correlated with a diagnostic BALL (OR 4.07; p = 0.018) while honeycombing was negatively correlated (OR 6.9 × e⁻⁸; p = 0.001). Higher BALL was also associated with lower all-cause mortality (HR 0.98; p = 0.015).

Conclusion

With elimination of incorporation bias, most patients with well-described HP did not meet diagnostic BALL thresholds. Higher BALL was associated with better long-term survival in those with fibrosis, but its diagnostic role may be more additive than characteristic or distinguishing.

Exposures and associations with clinical phenotypes in hypersensitivity pneumonitis: A scoping review

Antigen identification is important for establishing a confident diagnosis of hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP). There are no systematically curated lists of HP-associated exposures that inform clinical relevance or disease phenotype. We sought to systematically identify all reported causes of HP in the literature and evaluate their clinical relevance. A scoping review was performed to identify all publications describing HP cases and their associated exposures (even if unknown) from Jan 1990-June 2020. Frequencies of exposures and meta-analysis of proportions for registry-based studies were determined for specific exposure categories, and associations with fibrotic and non-fibrotic HP were assessed. 24,138 publications were identified, with 967 publications included in the final analysis, representing 62 unique exposures associated with HP. Certain exposures were more frequently reported than others, including birds (comprising 32% of HP cases in registry-based studies) and mould (17% registry study HP cases). Antigen-indeterminate HP comprised 15-24% of registry-based studies. Limited data found contaminated metal-working fluids, isocyanate exposure, and hot tub lung were rarely associated with fibrotic features, whereas antigen-indeterminate HP cases were more frequently associated with fibrosis. There was heterogeneity in HP case definition and how causative exposures were identified. We identified 62 unique exposures associated with HP, with specific exposures associated with clinical phenotypes. These data may inform clinical assessment and the development of questionnaires to identify antigens in the diagnostic evaluation of suspected HP. OPEN SCIENCES FRAMEWORK REGISTRATION: osf.io/4aq5m.

[Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis: An update]

Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis (HP) is a common immune-mediated interstitial lung disease (ILD) induced by repeated exposure to environmental antigens in susceptible individuals. The most commonly known forms are bird fancier's disease and farmer's lung. However, the antigens involved are widely diverse. Therefore, the list of causes of HP is frequently expanding. HP seems to be under-diagnosed owing to its highly heterogeneous presentation in both the non-fibrotic and fibrotic subtypes and could represent up to 15% of all ILDs encountered in clinical practice. However, the recognition of HP cases is essential to ensure appropriate therapy for the patient. Home health care workers' intervention is sometimes critical in this context. In case of confirmed exposure, the diagnosis could be considered with high confidence if the high-resolution computed tomography (HR-CT) shows a typical HP pattern associated with a lymphocytosis over 30% in the broncho-alveolar lavage (BAL). In all other situations, the patients should undergo further investigations and additional histopathological sampling should be considered and submitted to a multidisciplinary team discussion. After diagnosis, antigenic eviction is the rule whenever possible. Corticosteroid treatment is the first-line medical treatment for severe forms and aims to prevent the development of fibrosis. Anti-fibrotic therapy is now an option for patients with progressive ILD and failure of immunomodulatory/immunosuppressive therapies.

Performance of a diagnostic algorithm for fibrotic hypersensitivity pneumonitis. A case-control study

Background

The differential diagnosis fibrotic hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP) versus idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) is important but challenging. Recent diagnostic guidelines for HP emphasize including multidisciplinary discussion (MDD) in the diagnostic process, however MDD is not comprehensively available.

We aimed to establish the diagnostic accuracy and prognostic validity of a previously proposed HP diagnostic algorithm that foregoes MDD.

Methods

We tested the algorithm in patients with an MDD diagnosis of fibrotic HP or IPF (case control study) and determined diagnostic test performances for diagnostic confidences of ≥ 90% and ≥ 70%. Prognostic validity was established using Cox proportional hazards models.

Results

Thirty-one patients with fibrotic HP and 50 IPF patients were included. The algorithm-derived ≥ 90% confidence level for HP had high specificity (0.94, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.83–0.99), but low sensitivity (0.35 [95%CI 0.19–0.55], J-index 0.29). Test performance was improved for the ≥ 70% confidence level (J-index 0.64) with a specificity of 0.90 (95%CI 0.78–0.97), and a sensitivity of 0.74 (95%CI 0.55–0.88). MDD fibrotic HP diagnosis was strongly associated with lower risk of death (adjusted hazard ratio [HR] 0.10 [0.01–0.92], p = 0.04), whereas the algorithm-derived ≥ 70% and ≥ 90% confidence diagnoses were not significantly associated with survival (adjusted HR 0.37 [0.07–1.80], p = 0.22, and adjusted HR 0.41 [0.05–3.25], p = 0.39, respectively).

Conclusion

The algorithm-derived ≥ 70% diagnostic confidence had satisfactory test performance for MDD-HP diagnosis, with insufficient sensitivity for ≥ 90% confidence. The lowest risk of death in the MDD-derived HP diagnosis validates the reference standard and suggests that a diagnostic algorithm not including MDD, might not replace the latter.

Correlation of bronchoalveolar lavage lymphocyte count with the extent of lung fibrosis and with plethysmographic lung volumes in patients with newly recognized hypersensitivity pneumonitis

Introduction

Hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP) is an increasingly recognized interstitial lung disease, presenting with elevated total cell counts and high percentage of lymphocytes in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF). Despite many publications, there is no consensus in the literature concerning BALF cellular composition in patients with prolonged course of HP.

Aim

The aim of the present retrospective study was to investigate the influence of disease duration, smoking habits, and the extent of lung fibrosis on BALF cells’ population in patients with newly recognized HP.

Material and methods

In total, 94 patients (49 females, 45 males), mean age 52 (±12) years, with HP recognized according to recently proposed criteria, were enrolled into the present study. Chest CT scans were retrospectively reviewed by two independent radiologists. BALF evaluation was performed as a part of routine diagnostics according to recent recommendations.

Results

Percentage of lymphocytes in BALF was significantly lower in patients with lung fibrosis (stage 1 and 2) comparing to those without lung fibrosis (stage 0). Significant correlation was also found between the percentage of BALF lymphocytes and plethysmographic lung volumes, but not with lung transfer capacity for carbon monoxide (TLCO% pred). Smoking did not influence BALF results in our study group.

Conclusions

BALF lymphocytosis correlated with the presence and the extent of lung fibrosis on chest CT as well as with plethysmographic lung volumes but did not with TLCO and smoking habits in newly recognized HP pneumonitis.

Histology is critical but not always for the diagnosis of chronic hypersensitivity pneumonitis

BACKGROUND

The diagnosis of chronic hypersensitivity pneumonitis (CHP) is often based on the pathology, but evidence is scarce that a pathological diagnosis of CHP may mislead the multidisciplinary diagnosis.

METHOD

We enrolled patients from the consultation case archive whose pathological findings were suggestive of CHP but had a multidisciplinary diagnosis of non-CHP. The histopathological slides were sent to another pathologist, and the ones confirmed with CHP were sent for an additional multidisciplinary discussion (MDD). We examined clinicopathological features of the cases confirmed to be non-CHP through MDD.

RESULTS

Among the 243 cases, five were diagnosed as non-CHP through an additional MDD. The most common causes of discrepancy were the presence of strong autoimmune features, a low lymphocyte level in the bronchoalveolar lavage fluid, and a lack of nodular shadow or mosaic attenuation on computed tomography.

CONCLUSIONS

Cases of suspected CHP on pathology may be determined to be non-CHP through MDD.

Fibrotic Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis: Diagnosis and Management

Fibrotic hypersensitivity pneumonitis is a complex interstitial lung disease that is not entirely understood. In its chronic and fibrotic form, hypersensitivity pneumonitis is one of the main mimickers of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF). Distinguishing between these two conditions is challenging but is of particular clinical relevance. Two approved therapies are available for IPF, and a considerable number of clinical trials are now exploring newer pharmacological options. This impressive research effort is a consequence of new pathogenetic understanding, updated diagnostic criteria and a long history of pharmacological trials. Conversely, current knowledge gaps on pathogenesis of chronic hypersensitivity pneumonitis, coupled with lack of validated diagnostic criteria, make the management of this disease an unsolved clinical challenge. This also reflects the paucity of therapeutic clinical trials in this field. In this review, we describe the current evidence and the possible future options to approach this complex disease.

Current Diagnosis and Management of Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis

Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis (HP) one of the most common interstitial lung diseases (ILDs) is characterized by exposure to an inhaled inciting antigen that leads to a host immunologic reaction determining interstitial inflammation and architectural distortion. The underlying pathogenetic mechanisms are unclear. The absence of international shared diagnostic guidelines and the lack of a "gold-standard" test for HP combined with the presence of several clinical and radiologic overlapping features makes it particularly challenging to differentiate HP from other ILDs, also in expert contests. Radiology is playing a more crucial role in this process; recently the headcheese sign was recognized as a more specific for chronic-HP than the extensive mosaic attenuation. Several classification proposals and diagnostic models have been advanced by different groups, with no prospective validation. Therapeutic options for HP have been limited to antigen avoidance and immunosuppressant drugs over the last decades. Several questions about this condition remain unanswered and there is a need for more studies.