Phylogenetic trends in respiratory rhythmogenesis: Insights from ectothermic vertebrates

Hibernation reduces GABA signaling in the brainstem to enhance motor activity of breathing at cool temperatures

BACKGROUND

Neural circuits produce reliable activity patterns despite disturbances in the environment. For this to occur, neurons elicit synaptic plasticity during perturbations. However, recent work suggests that plasticity not only regulates circuit activity during disturbances, but these modifications may also linger to stabilize circuits during future perturbations. The implementation of such a regulation scheme for real-life environmental challenges of animals remains unclear. Amphibians provide insight into this problem in a rather extreme way, as circuits that generate breathing are inactive for several months during underwater hibernation and use compensatory plasticity to promote ventilation upon emergence.

RESULTS

Using ex vivo brainstem preparations and electrophysiology, we find that hibernation in American bullfrogs reduces GABAA receptor (GABAAR) inhibition in respiratory rhythm generating circuits and motor neurons, consistent with a compensatory response to chronic inactivity. Although GABAARs are normally critical for breathing, baseline network output at warm temperatures was not affected. However, when assessed across a range of temperatures, hibernators with reduced GABAAR signaling had greater activity at cooler temperatures, enhancing respiratory motor output under conditions that otherwise strongly depress breathing.

CONCLUSIONS

Hibernation reduces GABAAR signaling to promote robust respiratory output only at cooler temperatures. Although frogs do not ventilate lungs during underwater hibernation, we suggest this would be beneficial for stabilizing breathing when the animal passes through a large temperature range during emergence in the spring. More broadly, these results demonstrate that compensatory synaptic plasticity can increase the operating range of circuits in harsh environments, thereby promoting adaptive behavior in conditions that suppress activity.

Early development of respiratory motor circuits in larval zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Rhythm-generating circuits in the vertebrate hindbrain form synaptic connections with cranial and spinal motor neurons, to generate coordinated, patterned respiratory behaviors. Zebrafish provide a uniquely tractable model system to investigate the earliest stages in respiratory motor circuit development in vivo. In larval zebrafish, respiratory behaviors are carried out by muscles innervated by cranial motor neurons-including the facial branchiomotor neurons (FBMNs), which innervate muscles that move the jaw, buccal cavity, and operculum. However, it is unclear when FBMNs first receive functional synaptic input from respiratory pattern-generating neurons, and how the functional output of the respiratory motor circuit changes across larval development. In the current study, we used behavior and calcium imaging to determine how early FBMNs receive functional synaptic inputs from respiratory pattern-generating networks in larval zebrafish. Zebrafish exhibited patterned operculum movements by 3 days postfertilization (dpf), though this behavior became more consistent at 4 and 5 dpf. Also by 3dpf, FBMNs fell into two distinct categories ("rhythmic" and "nonrhythmic"), based on patterns of neural activity. These two neuron categories were arranged differently along the dorsoventral axis, demonstrating that FBMNs have already established dorsoventral topography by 3 dpf. Finally, operculum movements were coordinated with pectoral fin movements at 3 dpf, indicating that the operculum behavioral pattern was driven by synaptic input. Taken together, this evidence suggests that FBMNs begin to receive initial synaptic input from a functional respiratory central pattern generator at or prior to 3 dpf. Future studies will use this model to study mechanisms of normal and abnormal respiratory circuit development.

Persistent augmentation of fictive air breathing by hypoxia: An in vitro study of the role of GABAB signaling in pre-metamorphic tadpoles

Tadpole development is influenced by environmental cues and hypoxia can favor the emergence of the neural networks driving air breathing. Exposing isolated brainstems from pre-metamorphic tadpoles to acute hypoxia (~0% O₂; 15 min) leads to a progressive increase in fictive air breaths (~3 fold) in the hours that follow stimulation. Here, we first determined whether this effect persists over longer periods (<18 h); we then evaluated maturity of the motor output by comparing the breathing pattern of hypoxia-exposed brainstems to that of preparations from adult bullfrogs under basal conditions. Because progressive withdrawal of GABA_B-mediated inhibition contributes to the developmental increase in fictive lung ventilation, we then hypothesised that hypoxia reduces respiratory sensitivity to baclofen (selective GABA_B-agonist). Experiments were performed on isolated brainstem preparations from pre-metamorphic tadpoles (TK stages IV to XIV); respiratory-related neural activity was recorded from cranial nerves V/VII and X before and 18 h after exposure to hypoxia (0% O₂ + 2% CO₂; 25 min). Time-control experiments (no hypoxia) were performed. Exposing pre-metamorphic tadpoles to hypoxia did not affect gill burst frequency, but augmented the frequency of fictive lung bursts and the incidence of episodic breathing levels intermediate between pre-metamorphic and adult preparations. Addition of baclofen to the aCSF (0,2 μM - 20 min) reduced lung burst frequency, but the response of hypoxia-exposed brainstems was greater than controls. We conclude that acute hypoxia facilitates development and maturation of the motor command driving air breathing. We propose that a greater number of active rhythmogenic neurons expressing GABAb receptors contributes to this effect.

Evolution of vertebrate respiratory central rhythm generators

Tracing the evolution of the central rhythm generators associated with ventilation in vertebrates is hindered by a lack of information surrounding key transitions. To begin with, central rhythm generation has been studied in detail in only a few species from four vertebrate groups, lamprey, anuran amphibians, turtles, and mammals (primarily rodents). Secondly, there is a lack of information regarding the transition from water breathing fish to air breathing amniotes (reptiles, birds, and mammals). Specifically, the respiratory rhythm generators of fish appear to be single oscillators capable of generating both phases of the respiratory cycle (expansion and compression) and projecting to motoneurons in cranial nerves innervating bucco-pharyngeal muscles. In the amniotes we find oscillators capable of independently generating separate phases of the respiratory cycle (expiration and inspiration) and projecting to pre-motoneurons in the ventrolateral medulla that in turn project to spinal motoneurons innervating thoracic and abdominal muscles (reptiles, birds, and mammals). Studies of the one group of amphibians that lie at this transition (the anurans), raise intriguing possibilities but, for a variety of reasons that we explore, also raise unanswered questions. In this review we summarize what is known about the rhythm generating circuits associated with breathing that arise from the different rhombomeric segments in each of the different vertebrate classes. Assuming oscillating circuits form in every pair of rhombomeres in every vertebrate during development, we trace what appears to be the evolutionary fate of each and highlight the questions that remain to be answered to properly understand the evolutionary transitions in vertebrate central respiratory rhythm generation.

The lamprey respiratory network: Some evolutionary aspects

Breathing is a complex behaviour that involves rhythm generating networks. In this review, we examine the main characteristics of respiratory rhythm generation in vertebrates and, in particular, we describe the main results of our studies on the role of neural mechanisms involved in the neuromodulation of the lamprey respiration. The lamprey respiratory rhythm generator is located in the paratrigeminal respiratory group (pTRG) and shows similarities with the mammalian preBötzinger complex. In fact, within the pTRG a major role is played by glutamate, but also GABA and glycine display important contributions. In addition, neuromodulatory influences are exerted by opioids, substance P, acetylcholine and serotonin. Both structures respond to exogenous ATP with a biphasic response and astrocytes there located strongly contribute to the modulation of the respiratory pattern. The results emphasize that some important characteristics of the respiratory rhythm generating network are, to a great extent, maintained throughout evolution.

Characterization of laryngeal motor neuron properties in the American bullfrog, Lithobates catesbieanus

Motor neurons represent the final output from the central respiratory network. American bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbieanus, have provided insight into development and plasticity of the breathing control system, yet cellular aspects of bullfrog motor neurons are not well-described. In this study, we characterized properties of laryngeal motor neurons that produce motor outflow to the glottal dilator, a muscle that gates airflow to the lungs of anurans. To this end, we measured several intrinsic membrane properties of labeled laryngeal motor neurons in brain slices. Using unsupervised clustering analyses, we identified two broad classes of motor neurons: those with high firing rates and strong adaptation (∼70 %), and those with lower firing rates and less adaptation (∼30 %). These results suggest that two neuronal cell types innervate the glottal dilator, roughly aligning with the composition of fast and slower twitch fibers of this muscle. In sum, these data reinforce the need to consider cell-type when assessing motor neuron function in the respiratory network.

A direct excitatory action of lactate ions in the central respiratory network of bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbeianus

Chemoreceptors that detect O₂ and CO₂/pH regulate ventilation. However, recent work shows that lactate ions activate arterial chemoreceptors independent of pH to stimulate breathing. Although lactate rises in the central nervous system (CNS) during metabolic challenges, the ability of lactate ions to enhance ventilation by directly targeting the central respiratory network remains unclear. To address this possibility, we isolated the amphibian brainstem-spinal cord and found that small increases in CNS lactate stimulate motor output that causes breathing. In addition, lactate potentiated the excitatory postsynaptic strength of respiratory motor neurons, thereby coupling central lactate to the excitatory drive of neurons that trigger muscle contraction. Lactate did not affect motor output through pH or pyruvate metabolism, arguing for sensitivity to lactate anions per se. In sum, these results introduce a mechanism whereby lactate ions in the CNS match respiratory motor output to metabolic demands.

Development of central respiratory control in anurans: The role of neurochemicals in the emergence of air-breathing and the hypoxic response

Physiological and environmental factors impacting respiratory homeostasis vary throughout the course of an animal's lifespan from embryo to adult and can shape respiratory development. The developmental emergence of complex neural networks for aerial breathing dates back to ancestral vertebrates, and represents the most important process for respiratory development in extant taxa ranging from fish to mammals. While substantial progress has been made towards elucidating the anatomical and physiological underpinnings of functional respiratory control networks for air-breathing, much less is known about the mechanisms establishing these networks during early neurodevelopment. This is especially true of the complex neurochemical ensembles key to the development of air-breathing. One approach to this issue has been to utilize comparative models such as anuran amphibians, which offer a unique perspective into early neurodevelopment. Here, we review the developmental emergence of respiratory behaviours in anuran amphibians with emphasis on contributions of neurochemicals to this process and highlight opportunities for future research.

Neural network model of an amphibian ventilatory central pattern generator

The neuronal multiunit model presented here is a formal model of the central pattern generator (CPG) of the amphibian ventilatory neural network, inspired by experimental data from Pelophylax ridibundus. The kernel of the CPG consists of three pacemakers and two follower neurons (buccal and lung respectively). This kernel is connected to a chain of excitatory and inhibitory neurons organized in loops. Simulations are performed with Izhikevich-type neurons. When driven by the buccal follower, the excitatory neurons transmit and reorganize the follower activity pattern along the chain, and when driven by the lung follower, the excitatory and inhibitory neurons of the chain fire in synchrony. The additive effects of synaptic inputs from the pacemakers on the buccal follower account for (1) the low frequency buccal rhythm, (2) the intra-burst high frequency oscillations, and (3) the episodic lung activity. Chemosensitivity to acidosis is implemented by an increase in the firing frequency of one of the pacemakers. This frequency increase leads to both a decrease in the buccal burst frequency and an increase in the lung episode frequency. The rhythmogenic properties of the model are robust against synaptic noise and pacemaker jitter. To validate the rhythm and pattern genesis of this formal CPG, neurograms were built from simulated motoneuron activity, and compared with experimental neurograms. The basic principles of our model account for several experimental observations, and we suggest that these principles may be generic for amphibian ventilation.

Respiratory motoneuron properties during the transition from gill to lung breathing in the American bullfrog

Amphibian respiratory development involves a dramatic metamorphic transition from gill to lung breathing and coordination of distinct motor outputs. To determine whether the emergence of adult respiratory motor patterns was associated with similarly dramatic changes in motoneuron (MN) properties, we characterized the intrinsic electrical properties of American bullfrog trigeminal MNs innervating respiratory muscles comprising the buccal pump. In premetamorphic tadpoles (TK stages IX-XVIII) and adult frogs, morphometric analyses and whole cell recordings were performed in trigeminal MNs identified by fluorescent retrograde labeling. Based on the amplitude of the depolarizing sag induced by hyperpolarizing voltage steps, two MN subtypes (I and II) were identified in tadpoles and adults. Compared with type II MNs, type I MNs had larger sag amplitudes (suggesting a larger hyperpolarization-activated inward current), greater input resistance, lower rheobase, hyperpolarized action potential threshold, steeper frequency-current relationships, and fast firing rates and received fewer excitatory postsynaptic currents. Postmetamorphosis, type I MNs exhibited similar sag, enhanced postinhibitory rebound, and increased action potential amplitude with a smaller-magnitude fast afterhyperpolarization. Compared with tadpoles, type II MNs from frogs received higher-frequency, larger-amplitude excitatory postsynaptic currents. Input resistance decreased and rheobase increased postmetamorphosis in all MNs, concurrent with increased soma area and hyperpolarized action potential threshold. We suggest that type I MNs are likely recruited in response to smaller, buccal-related synaptic inputs as well as larger lung-related inputs, whereas type II MNs are likely recruited in response to stronger synaptic inputs associated with larger buccal breaths, lung breaths, or nonrespiratory behaviors involving powerful muscle contractions.

Central control of air breathing in fishes

The diversity of sites and surfaces that are utilized for gas transfer from air to blood in fish is remarkable. While a few species do utilize their gills for gas exchange in air, this is a rare occurrence and most air-breathing fish utilize other surfaces including air-breathing organs and lungs. At present almost nothing is known about the central sites that initiate and regulate air breathing although hypotheses can be put forward based on our rudimentary understanding of the sites involved in water breathing in lampreys and teleost fishes, and those involved in air breathing in pre-metamorphic anuran ampibians. The pumps involved in producing both water and air breathing in fishes are highly conserved, a buccal pump, assisted by pharyngeal and/or parabranchial/opercular pumps, produce both forms of ventilation. What varies between species are the manner in which air breaths are produced (in two versus four phases), and the 'valving' involved in producing water flow over the gills versus air flow in and out of air-breathing organs. The latter suggests that a major step in the evolution of air breathing was the evolution of the mechanisms that control the flow of the respiratory medium. The neural matrix that underlies the co-ordination of the pump and the valving events remains enigmatic and in much need of further research.

Lamprey: a model for vertebrate evolutionary research

Lampreys belong to the superclass Cyclostomata and represent the most ancient group of vertebrates. Existing for over 360 million years, they are known as living fossils due to their many evolutionally conserved features. They are not only a keystone species for studying the origin and evolution of vertebrates, but also one of the best models for researching vertebrate embryonic development and organ differentiation. From the perspective of genetic information, the lamprey genome remains primitive compared with that of other higher vertebrates, and possesses abundant functional genes. Through scientific and technological progress, scientists have conducted in-depth studies on the nervous, endocrine, and immune systems of lampreys. Such research has significance for understanding and revealing the origin and evolution of vertebrates, and could contribute to a greater understanding of human diseases and treatments. This review presents the current progress and significance of lamprey research.

Opioids for management of episodic breathlessness or dyspnea in patients with advanced disease

BACKGROUND

Episodic breathlessness (EB) or dyspnea is a common symptom with a very negative impact on the quality of life of patients with cancer and with non-oncological advanced diseases, mainly cardiorespiratory and neurological.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this non-systematic review is to ascertain the role played by opioids in the management of episodic breathlessness.

METHODS

A non-systematic literature review was done in the databases MEDLINE, COCHRANE, and DATABASE, and articles of greater scientific rigor, mainly reviews or prospective studies/randomized clinical trials published to date (August 2015), were selected. Terms used in the search included episodic breathlessness, acute breathlessness, episodic dyspnea, opioids, morphine, fentanyl, oxycodone, and breakthrough dyspnea.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the pathophysiology and mechanism of action of opioids for management of breathlessness, and specifically EB, are not fully known, there is scientific evidence, and particularly great clinical evidence, of the benefit of this drug class for dyspnea management. It is important to differentiate hospitalized patients from outpatients because venous or subcutaneous access is easier in hospitalized patients, but use of transmucosal fentanyl, especially in faster formulations like intranasal application, opens up new possibilities to manage outpatients due to its fast onset of action. The main problem is the lack of data available and the multitude of unanswered questions about opioid type, administration route, safety, and dose titration.

The neural control of respiration in lampreys

This review focuses on past and recent findings that have contributed to characterize the neural networks controlling respiration in the lamprey, a basal vertebrate. As in other vertebrates, respiration in lampreys is generated centrally in the brainstem. It is characterized by the presence of a fast and a slow respiratory rhythm. The anatomical and the basic physiological properties of the neural networks underlying the generation of the fast rhythm have been more thoroughly investigated; less is known about the generation of the slow respiratory rhythm. Comparative aspects with respiratory generators in other vertebrates as well as the mechanisms of modulation of respiration in association with locomotion are discussed.

Control of lung ventilation following overwintering conditions in bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbeianus

Ranid frogs in northern latitudes survive winter at cold temperatures in aquatic habitats often completely covered by ice. Cold-submerged frogs survive aerobically for several months relying exclusively on cutaneous gas exchange while maintaining temperature-specific acid-base balance. Depending on the overwintering hibernaculum, frogs in northern latitudes could spend several months without access to air, need to breathe, or chemosensory drive to use neuromuscular processes that regulate and enable pulmonary ventilation. Therefore, we performed experiments to determine whether aspects of the respiratory control system of bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbeianus, are maintained or suppressed following minimal use of air breathing in overwintering environments. Based on the necessity for control of lung ventilation in early spring, we hypothesized that critical components of the respiratory control system of bullfrogs would be functional following simulated overwintering. We found that bullfrogs recently removed from simulated overwintering environments exhibited similar resting ventilation when assessed at 24°C compared to warm-acclimated control bullfrogs. Additionally, ventilation met resting metabolic and, presumably, acid-base regulation requirements, indicating preservation of basal respiratory function despite prolonged disuse in the cold. Recently emerged bullfrogs underwent similar increases in ventilation during acute oxygen lack (aerial hypoxia) compared to warm-acclimated frogs; however, CO2-related hyperventilation was significantly blunted following overwintering. Overcoming challenges to gas exchange during overwintering have garnered attention in ectothermic vertebrates, but this study uncovers robust and labile aspects of the respiratory control system at a time point correlating with early spring following minimal/no use of lung breathing in cold-aquatic overwintering habitats.

Three brainstem areas involved in respiratory rhythm generation in bullfrogs

For most multiphasic motor patterns, rhythm and pattern are produced by the same circuit elements. For respiration, however, these functions have long been assumed to occur separately. In frogs, the ventilatory motor pattern produced by the isolated brainstem consists of buccal and biphasic lung bursts. Previously, two discrete necessary and sufficient sites for lung and buccal bursts were identified. Here we identify a third site, the Priming Area, important for and having neuronal activity correlated with the first phase of biphasic lung bursts. As each site is important for burst generation of a separate phase, we suggest each major phase of ventilation is produced by an anatomically distinct part of an extensive brainstem network. Embedding of discrete circuit elements producing major phases of respiration within an extensive rhythmogenic brainstem network may be a shared architectural characteristic of vertebrates.

ABSTRACT

Ventilation in mammals consists of at least three distinct phases: inspiration, post-inspiration and late-expiration. While distinct brainstem rhythm generating and pattern forming networks have long been assumed, recent data suggest the mammalian brainstem contains two coupled neuronal oscillators: one for inspiration and the other for active expiration. However, whether additional burst generating ability is required for generating other phases of ventilation in mammals is controversial. To investigate brainstem circuit architectures capable of producing multiphasic ventilatory rhythms, we utilized the isolated frog brainstem. This preparation produces two types of ventilatory motor patterns, buccal and lung bursts. Lung bursts can be divided into two phases, priming and powerstroke. Previously we identified two putative oscillators, the Buccal and Lung Areas. The Lung Area produces the lung powerstroke and the Buccal Area produces buccal bursts and - we assumed - the priming phase of lung bursts. However, here we identify an additional brainstem region that generates the priming phase. This Priming Area extends rostral and caudal of the Lung Area and is distinct from the Buccal Area. Using AMPA microinjections and reversible synaptic blockade, we demonstrate selective excitation and ablation (respectively) of priming phase activity. We also demonstrate that the Priming Area contains neurons active selectively during the priming phase. Thus, we propose that three distinct neuronal components generate the multiphase respiratory motor pattern produced by the frog brainstem: the buccal, priming and powerstroke burst generators. This raises the possibility that a similar multi-burst generator architecture mediates the three distinct phases of ventilation in mammals.

Respiratory neuron characterization reveals intrinsic bursting properties in isolated adult turtle brainstems (Trachemys scripta)

It is not known whether respiratory neurons with intrinsic bursting properties exist within ectothermic vertebrate respiratory control systems. Thus, isolated adult turtle brainstems spontaneously producing respiratory motor output were used to identify and classify respiratory neurons based on their firing pattern relative to hypoglossal (XII) nerve activity. Most respiratory neurons (183/212) had peak activity during the expiratory phase, while inspiratory, post-inspiratory, and novel pre-expiratory neurons were less common. During synaptic blockade conditions, ∼10% of respiratory neurons fired bursts of action potentials, with post-inspiratory cells (6/9) having the highest percentage of intrinsic burst properties. Most intrinsically bursting respiratory neurons were clustered at the level of the vagus (X) nerve root. Synaptic inhibition blockade caused seizure-like activity throughout the turtle brainstem, which shows that the turtle respiratory control system is not transformed into a network driven by intrinsically bursting respiratory neurons. We hypothesize that intrinsically bursting respiratory neurons are evolutionarily conserved and represent a potential rhythmogenic mechanism contributing to respiration in adult turtles.

Neural mechanisms underlying respiratory rhythm generation in the lamprey

The isolated brainstem of the adult lamprey spontaneously generates respiratory activity. The paratrigeminal respiratory group (pTRG), the proposed respiratory central pattern generator, has been anatomically and functionally characterized. It is sensitive to opioids, neurokinins and acetylcholine. Excitatory amino acids, but not GABA and glycine, play a crucial role in the respiratory rhythmogenesis. These results are corroborated by immunohistochemical data. While only GABA exerts an important modulatory control on the pTRG, both GABA and glycine markedly influence the respiratory frequency via neurons projecting from the vagal motoneuron region to the pTRG. Noticeably, the removal of GABAergic transmission within the pTRG causes the resumption of rhythmic activity during apnea induced by blockade of glutamatergic transmission. The same result is obtained by microinjections of substance P or nicotine into the pTRG during apnea. The results prompted us to present some considerations on the phylogenesis of respiratory pattern generation. They may also encourage comparative studies on the basic mechanisms underlying respiratory rhythmogenesis of vertebrates.

Testing the role of preBötzinger Complex somatostatin neurons in respiratory and vocal behaviors

Identifying neurons essential for the generation of breathing and related behaviors such as vocalisation is an important question for human health. The targeted loss of preBötzinger Complex (preBötC) glutamatergic neurons, including those that express high levels of somatostatin protein (SST neurons), eliminates normal breathing in adult rats. Whether preBötC SST neurons represent a functionally specialised population is unknown. We tested the effects on respiratory and vocal behaviors of eliminating SST neuron glutamate release by Cre-Lox-mediated genetic ablation of the vesicular glutamate transporter 2 (VGlut2). We found the targeted loss of VGlut2 in SST neurons had no effect on viability in vivo, or on respiratory period or responses to neurokinin 1 or μ-opioid receptor agonists in vitro. We then compared medullary SST peptide expression in mice with that of two species that share extreme respiratory environments but produce either high or low frequency vocalisations. In the Mexican free-tailed bat, SST peptide-expressing neurons extended beyond the preBötC to the caudal pole of the VII motor nucleus. In the naked mole-rat, however, SST-positive neurons were absent from the ventrolateral medulla. We then analysed isolation vocalisations from SST-Cre;VGlut2(F/F) mice and found a significant prolongation of the pauses between syllables during vocalisation but no change in vocalisation number. These data suggest that glutamate release from preBötC SST neurons is not essential for breathing but play a species- and behavior-dependent role in modulating respiratory networks. They further suggest that the neural network generating respiration is capable of extensive plasticity given sufficient time.

GABAergic and glycinergic inputs modulate rhythmogenic mechanisms in the lamprey respiratory network

We have previously shown that GABA and glycine modulate respiratory activity in the in vitro brainstem preparations of the lamprey and that blockade of GABAA and glycine receptors restores the respiratory rhythm during apnoea caused by blockade of ionotropic glutamate receptors. However, the neural substrates involved in these effects are unknown. To address this issue, the role of GABAA, GABAB and glycine receptors within the paratrigeminal respiratory group (pTRG), the proposed respiratory central pattern generator, and the vagal motoneuron region was investigated both during apnoea induced by blockade of glutamatergic transmission and under basal conditions through microinjections of specific antagonists. The removal of GABAergic, but not glycinergic transmission within the pTRG, causes the resumption of rhythmic respiratory activity during apnoea, and reveals the presence of a modulatory control of the pTRG under basal conditions. A blockade of GABAA and glycine receptors within the vagal region strongly increases the respiratory frequency through disinhibition of neurons projecting to the pTRG from the vagal region. These neurons were retrogradely labelled (neurobiotin) from the pTRG. Intense GABA immunoreactivity is observed both within the pTRG and the vagal area, which corroborates present findings. The results confirm the pTRG as a primary site of respiratory rhythm generation, and suggest that inhibition modulates the activity of rhythm-generating neurons, without any direct role in burst formation and termination mechanisms.

Neuronal mechanisms of respiratory pattern generation are evolutionary conserved

A brainstem region, the paratrigeminal respiratory group (pTRG), has been suggested to play a crucial role in the respiratory rhythm generation in lampreys. However, a detailed characterization of the pTRG region is lacking. The present study performed on isolated brainstem preparations of adult lampreys provides a more precise localization of the pTRG region with regard to both connectivity and neurochemical markers. pTRG neurons projecting to the vagal motoneuronal pool were identified in a restricted area of the rostral rhombencephalon at the level of the isthmic Müller cell I1 close to sulcus limitans of His. Unilateral microinjections of lidocaine, muscimol, or glutamate antagonists into the pTRG inhibited completely the bilateral respiratory activity. In contrast, microinjections of glutamate agonists enhanced the respiratory activity, suggesting that this region is critical for the respiratory pattern generation. The retrogradely labeled pTRG neurons are glutamatergic and surrounded by terminals with intense substance P immunoreactivity. Cholinergic neurons were seen close to, and intermingled with, pTRG neurons. In addition, α-bungarotoxin binding sites (indicating nicotinic receptors) were found throughout the pTRG area and particularly on the soma of these neurons. During apnea, induced by blockade of ionotropic glutamate receptors within the same region, microinjections of 1 μm substance P or 1 mm nicotine into the pTRG restored rhythmic respiratory activity. The results emphasize the close similarities between the pTRG and the mammalian pre-Bötzinger complex as a crucial site for respiratory rhythmogenesis. We conclude that some basic features of the excitatory neurons proposed to generate respiratory rhythms are conserved throughout evolution.

Bilateral connectivity in the brainstem respiratory networks of lampreys

This study examines the connectivity in the neural networks controlling respiration in the lampreys, a basal vertebrate. Previous studies have shown that the lamprey paratrigeminal respiratory group (pTRG) plays a crucial role in the generation of respiration. By using a combination of anatomical and physiological techniques, we characterized the bilateral connections between the pTRGs and descending projections to the motoneurons. Tracers were injected in the respiratory motoneuron pools to identify pre-motor respiratory interneurons. Retrogradely labeled cell bodies were found in the pTRG on both sides. Whole-cell recordings of the retrogradely labeled pTRG neurons showed rhythmical excitatory currents in tune with respiratory motoneuron activity. This confirmed that they were related to respiration. Intracellular labeling of individual pTRG neurons revealed axonal branches to the contralateral pTRG and bilateral projections to the respiratory motoneuronal columns. Stimulation of the pTRG induced excitatory postsynaptic potentials in ipsi- and contralateral respiratory motoneurons as well as in contralateral pTRG neurons. A lidocaine HCl (Xylocaine) injection on the midline at the rostrocaudal level of the pTRG diminished the contralateral motoneuronal EPSPs as well as a local injection of 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione (CNQX) and (2R)-amino-5-phosphonovaleric acid (AP-5) on the recorded respiratory motoneuron. Our data show that neurons in the pTRG send two sets of axonal projections: one to the contralateral pTRG and another to activate respiratory motoneurons on both sides through glutamatergic synapses.

Prenatal development of central rhythm generation

Foetal breathing in mice results from prenatal activity of the two coupled hindbrain oscillators considered to be responsible for respiratory rhythm generation after birth: the pre-Bötzinger complex (preBötC) is active shortly before the onset of foetal breathing; the parafacial respiratory group (e-pF in embryo) starts activity one day earlier. Transcription factors have been identified that are essential to specify neural progenitors and lineages forming each of these oscillators during early development of the neural tube: Hoxa1, Egr2 (Krox20), Phox2b, Lbx1 and Atoh1 for the e-pF; Dbx1 and Evx1 for the preBötC which eventually grow contralateral axons requiring expression of Robo3. Inactivation of the genes encoding these factors leads to mis-specification of these neurons and distinct breathing abnormalities: apneic patterns and loss of central chemosensitivity for the e-pF (central congenital hypoventilation syndrome, CCHS, in humans), complete loss of breathing for the preBötC, right-left desynchronized breathing in Robo3 mutants. Mutations affecting development in more rostral (pontine) respiratory territories change the shape of the inspiratory drive without affecting the rhythm. Other (primordial) embryonic oscillators start in the mouse three days before the e-pF, to generate low frequency (LF) rhythms that are probably required for activity-dependent development of neurones at embryonic stages; in the foetus, however, they are actively silenced to avoid detrimental interaction with the on-going respiratory rhythm. Altogether, these observations provide a strong support to the previously proposed hypothesis that the functional organization of the respiratory generator is specified at early stages of development and is dual in nature, comprising two serially non-homologous oscillators.

Genetic factors determining the functional organization of neural circuits controlling rhythmic movements the murine embryonic parafacial rhythm generator

In mammals, fetal movements governed by central pattern generators are essential for the development of adaptive behaviors such as breathing, walking, and chewing, which are vital after birth. Combining targeted mutations and genetic fate mapping can help to define the molecular determinants that control the development of these central pattern generators. In this chapter, recent results are presented on the embryonic parafacial (e-pF) rhythm generator, one of the two oscillators involved in controlling the breathing behavior and chemosensitive responsiveness.

Onset and early development of hypoxic ventilatory responses and branchial neuroepithelial cells in Xenopus laevis

Onset and ontogeny of the O₂ chemoreceptive control of ventilation was investigated in Xenopus laevis. The density and size of branchial serotonin-immunoreactive neuroepithelial cells (5-HT-IR NECs) were also determined using confocal immunofluorescent microscopy. Larvae started gill ventilation at 3 days post-fertilization (dpf), and, at this early stage, acute hypoxic exposure produced an increase in frequency from 28 ± 4 to 60 ± 2 beats x min⁻¹. Concurrent with the onset of ventilatory responses, 5-HT-IR NECs appeared in the gill filament bud. Lung ventilation began at 5 dpf and exhibited a 3-fold increase in frequency during acute hypoxia. At 10 dpf, gill ventilatory sensitivity to hypoxia increased, as did NEC density, from 15 ± 1 (5 dpf) to 29 ± 2 (10 dpf) cells x mm of filament⁻¹. Unlike ventilation frequency, gill ventilation amplitude and lung expired volume were unaltered by acute hypoxia. Chronic exposure to moderate hypoxia, at a P(O₂) of 110 mmHg, attenuated acute responses to moderate hypoxia at 10 and 14 dpf but had no effect at more severe hypoxia or at other stages. Chronic hypoxia also stimulated 5-HT-IR NECs growth at 21 dpf. Collectively, larvae at 5 dpf exhibited strong O₂-driven gill and lung ventilatory responses, and between 10 and 21 dpf, the early hypoxic responses can be shaped by the ambient P(O₂).

Role of neurokinin receptors and ionic mechanisms within the respiratory network of the lamprey

We have suggested that in the lamprey, a medullary region called the paratrigeminal respiratory group (pTRG), is essential for respiratory rhythm generation and could correspond to the pre-Bötzinger complex (pre-BötC), the hypothesized kernel of the inspiratory rhythm-generating network in mammals. The present study was performed on in vitro brainstem preparations of adult lampreys to investigate whether some functional characteristics of the respiratory network are retained throughout evolution and to get further insights into the recent debated hypotheses on respiratory rhythmogenesis in mammals, such as for instance the "group-pacemaker" hypothesis. Thus, we tried to ascertain the presence and role of neurokinins (NKs) and burst-generating ion currents, such as the persistent Na(+) current (I(NaP)) and the Ca(2+)-activated non-specific cation current (I(CAN)), described in the pre-Bötzinger complex. Respiratory activity was monitored as vagal motor output. Substance P (SP) as well as NK1, NK2 and NK3 receptor agonists (400-800 nM) applied to the bath induced marked increases in respiratory frequency. Microinjections (0.5-1 nl) of SP as well as the other NK receptor agonists (1 microM) into the pTRG increased the frequency and amplitude of vagal bursts. Riluzole (RIL) and flufenamic acid (FFA) were used to block I(NaP) and I(CAN), respectively. Bath application of either RIL or FFA (20-50 microM) depressed, but did not suppress respiratory activity. Coapplication of RIL and FFA at 50 microM abolished the respiratory rhythm that, however, was restarted by SP microinjected into the pTRG. The results show that NKs may have a modulatory role in the lamprey respiratory network through an action on the pTRG and that I(NaP) and I(CAN) may contribute to vagal burst generation. We suggest that the "group-pacemaker" hypothesis is tenable for the lamprey respiratory rhythm generation since respiratory activity is abolished by blocking both I(NaP) and I(CAN), but is restored by enhancing network excitability.

Control of respiration in fish, amphibians and reptiles

Fish and amphibians utilise a suction/force pump to ventilate gills or lungs, with the respiratory muscles innervated by cranial nerves, while reptiles have a thoracic, aspiratory pump innervated by spinal nerves. However, fish can recruit a hypobranchial pump for active jaw occlusion during hypoxia, using feeding muscles innervated by anterior spinal nerves. This same pump is used to ventilate the air-breathing organ in air-breathing fishes. Some reptiles retain a buccal force pump for use during hypoxia or exercise. All vertebrates have respiratory rhythm generators (RRG) located in the brainstem. In cyclostomes and possibly jawed fishes, this may comprise elements of the trigeminal nucleus, though in the latter group RRG neurons have been located in the reticular formation. In air-breathing fishes and amphibians, there may be separate RRG for gill and lung ventilation. There is some evidence for multiple RRG in reptiles. Both amphibians and reptiles show episodic breathing patterns that may be centrally generated, though they do respond to changes in oxygen supply. Fish and larval amphibians have chemoreceptors sensitive to oxygen partial pressure located on the gills. Hypoxia induces increased ventilation and a reflex bradycardia and may trigger aquatic surface respiration or air-breathing, though these latter activities also respond to behavioural cues. Adult amphibians and reptiles have peripheral chemoreceptors located on the carotid arteries and central chemoreceptors sensitive to blood carbon dioxide levels. Lung perfusion may be regulated by cardiac shunting and lung ventilation stimulates lung stretch receptors.

Foreword: Respiratory rhythmogenesis

This special issue of Respiratory Physiology & Neurobiology summarizes the current standing of research concerned with synaptic mechanisms, membrane properties, plasticity, pre- and postnatal development and evolutionary origin of neurones involved in respiratory rhythm generation and central chemosensitivity. Moreover, a variety of articles link pathophysiological alterations of synaptic function in rhythmogenesis and chemosensitivity with breathing disorders in neurodevelopmental diseases.