New insights into the mechanisms underlying biochar-assisted sustained high-efficient co-digestion: Reducing thermodynamic constraints and enhancing extracellular electron transfer flux

Unraveling the Trade-Off Effect of Pyrogenic Carbons Between Biopseudocapacitors and Bioconductors During Anaerobic Methanogenesis

Pyrogenic carbons (PCs), with varying structures depending on the materials and thermal treatment conditions, have been extensively used to enhance anaerobic digestion by mediating electron transfer. However, the underlying mechanism has yet to be explored. Herein, the redirection and enhancement of the direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) pathway were evidenced, along with the upregulated electrochemical properties and structural proteins in the methanogenic consortia. Further, we found that PCs featured trade-off properties of "biopseudocapacitor" and "bioconductor" during thermal treatment, as endowed by the evolution of oxygen-containing functional groups (for charging and discharging) and graphitic structure (for conductivity). Correspondingly, their trade-off effect on mediating syntrophic methanogenesis (SM) was realized between the generally acknowledged bioconductor role and the pseudocapacitive effect, as highlighted by the enhanced SM of reduced PCs from more balanced electron exchange capacities. Consequently, a performance comparison of PCs obtained at 450, 650, and 850 °C in SM resulted in an optimized sample at 650 °C, where a 61.3 ± 1.8% increase in methane production rate and a 33.4 ± 1.1% decrease in lag time were observed. Microbiologically, DIET-active Methanothrix and Geobacteraceae flourished with the intra- and extracellular electron transport channels established. These findings provide new insights into the mediating mechanism and renewable potential of PCs in regulating energy-harvesting biochemical processes toward carbon neutrality.

Unlocking anaerobic digestion potential via extracellular electron transfer by exogenous materials: Current status and perspectives

The efficiency of energy transfer among microorganisms presents a substantial hurdle for the widespread implementation of anaerobic digestion techniques. Nonetheless, recent studies have demonstrated that enhancing the extracellular electron transfer (EET) can markedly enhance this efficiency. This review highlights recent advancements in EET for anaerobic digestion and examines the contribution of external additives to fostering enhanced efficiency within this context. Diverse mechanisms through which additives are employed to improve EET in anaerobic environments are delineated. Furthermore, specific strategies for effectively regulating EET are proposed, aiming to augment methane production from anaerobic digestion. This review thus offers a perspective on future research directions aimed at optimizing waste resources, enhancing methane production efficiency, and improving process predictability in anaerobic digestion.

An in-situ biochar-enhanced anaerobic membrane bioreactor for swine wastewater treatment under various organic loading rates

A biochar-assisted anaerobic membrane bioreactor (BC-AnMBR) was conducted to evaluate the performance in treating swine wastewater with different organic loading rates (OLR) ranging from 0.38 to 1.13 kg-COD/(m3.d). Results indicated that adding spent coffee grounds biochar (SCG-BC) improved the organic removal efficiency compared to the conventional AnMBR, with an overall COD removal rate of > 95.01%. Meanwhile, methane production of up to 0.22 LCH4/gCOD with an improvement of 45.45% was achieved under a high OLR of 1.13 kg-COD/(m3.d). Furthermore, the transmembrane pressure (TMP) in the BC-AnMBR system was stable at 4.5 kPa, and no irreversible membrane fouling occurred within 125 days. Microbial community analysis revealed that the addition of SCG-BC increased the relative abundance of autotrophic methanogenic archaea, particularly Methanosarcina (from 0.11% to 11.16%) and Methanothrix (from 16.34% to 24.05%). More importantly, Desulfobacterota and Firmicutes phylum with direct interspecific electron transfer (DIET) capabilities were also enriched with autotrophic methanogens. Analysis of the electron transfer pathway showed that the concentration of c-type cytochromes increased by 38.60% in the presence of SCG-BC, and thus facilitated the establishment of DIET and maintained high activity of the electron transfer system even at high OLR. In short, the BC-AnMBR system performs well under various OLR conditions and is stable in the recovery energy system for swine wastewater.

Biokinetic and microbial insights into regulatory mechanisms of long-chain fatty acid degradation during food waste-lipid co-digestion within anaerobic membrane bioreactor

This study investigated the effects of varying lipid ratios on the anaerobic co-digestion of high-lipid food waste (FW) in a mesophilic anaerobic membrane bioreactor (AnMBR). At a lipid concentration of 5 %, optimal biogas production (3.84 L/L/d) and lipid removal efficiency (78 %) were achieved; however, increasing lipid concentrations resulted in significant accumulations of long-chain fatty acids (LCFAs) and volatile fatty acids (VFAs). Batch tests further demonstrated the impact of various types of LCFAs, with stearic acid showing the slowest microbial growth rate (0.033d-1), confirming its role in the accumulation of acetate-dominated VFAs, potentially limiting the methanogenesis process at elevated lipid levels. Furthermore, at 8 % lipid content, the downregulation of key LCFA degradation enzymes and dominance of hydrogenotrophic methanogens indicated adverse conditions. The importance of the intricate interplay between LCFA degradation kinetics and microbial community for the system efficiency was evidenced, offering insights for optimizing and managing high-lipidic wastes.

Integration of Digestate-Derived Biochar into the Anaerobic Digestion Process through Circular Economic and Environmental Approaches-A Review

The growing energy consumption and the need for a circular economy have driven considerable interest in the anaerobic digestion (AD) of organic waste, offering potential solutions through biogas and digestate production. AD processes not only have the capability to reduce greenhouse gas emissions but also contribute to the production of renewable methane. This comprehensive review aims to consolidate prior research on AD involving different feedstocks. The principles of AD are explored and discussed, including both chemical and biological pathways and the microorganisms involved at each stage. Additionally, key variables influencing system performance, such as temperature, pH, and C/N ratio are also discussed. Various pretreatment strategies applied to enhance biogas generation from organic waste in AD are also reviewed. Furthermore, this review examines the conversion of generated digestate into biochar through pyrolysis and its utilization to improve AD performance. The addition of biochar has demonstrated its efficacy in enhancing metabolic processes, microorganisms (activity and community), and buffering capacity, facilitating Direct Interspecies Electron Transfer (DIET), and boosting CH4 production. Biochar also exhibits the ability to capture undesirable components, including CO2, H2S, NH3, and siloxanes. The integration of digestate-derived biochar into the circular economy framework emerges as a vital role in closing the material flow loop. Additionally, the review discusses the environmental benefits derived from coupling AD with pyrolysis processes, drawing on life cycle assessment investigations. Techno-economic assessment (TEA) studies of the integrated processes are also discussed, with an acknowledgment of the need for further TEA to validate the viability of integrating the biochar industry. Furthermore, this survey examines the techno-economic and environmental impacts of biochar production itself and its potential application in AD for biogas generation, aiming to establish a more cost-effective and sustainable integrated system.

Synergistic effects of biochar addition and filtration mode optimization on mitigating membrane fouling in high-solid anaerobic membrane bioreactors

In this study, a high-solid anaerobic membrane bioreactor was established for treating food waste, and membrane fouling rates were regulated through multivariate modulation. The anaerobic membrane bioreactor operated stably at a high organic loading rate of 28.75 gCOD/L/d achieved a methane production rate of 8.03 ± 0.61 L/L/d. Experimental findings revealed that the most effective control of membrane fouling was achieved at a filtration- relaxation ratio (F/R) of 10/90 s. This indicates that a higher relaxation frequency provided improved the mitigation of membrane fouling. Compared with single F/R modulation, the combined modulation of biochar and F/R provided enhanced control over membrane fouling. Moreover, the addition of biochar altered the sludge properties of the reactor, thereby preventing the formation of a dense cake layer. Additionally, biochar enhanced the sheer force of the fluid on the membrane surface and facilitated the separation of pollutants during the relaxation stage, thereby contributing to improved control of membrane fouling.

Comparing the mechanisms of syntrophic volatile fatty acids oxidation and methanogenesis recovery from ammonia stress in regular and biochar-assisted anaerobic digestion: Different roads lead to the same goal

Biochar has been recognized as a promising additive to mitigate ammonia inhibition during syntrophic methanogenesis, while the key function of biochar in this process is still in debates. This study clarified the distinct mechanisms of syntrophic volatile fatty acids -oxidizing and methanogenesis recovery from ammonia inhibition in regular and biochar-assisted anaerobic digestion. Under 5 g/L ammonia stress, adding biochar shortened the methanogenic lag time by 10.9% and dramatically accelerated the maximum methane production rate from 60.3 to 94.7 mLCH4/gVSsludge/d. A photometric analysis with a nano-WO3 probe revealed that biochar enhanced the extracellular electron transfer (EET) capacity of suspended microbes (Pearson's r = -0.98), confirming that biochar facilitated methanogenesis by boosting EET between syntrophic butyrate oxidizer and methanogens. Same linear relationship between EET capacity and methanogenic rate was not observed in the control group. Microbial community integrating functional genes prediction analysis uncovered that biochar re-shaped syntrophic partners by enriching Constridium_sensu_stricto/Syntrophomonas and Methanosarcina. The functional genes encoding Co-enzyme F420 hydrogenase and formylmethanofuran dehydrogenase were upregulated by 1.4-2.3 times, consequently enhanced the CO2-reduction methanogenesis pathway. Meanwhile, the abundances of gene encoding methylene-tetrahydrofolate transformation, a series of intermediate processes involved in acetate oxidation, in the biochar-assisted group were 28.2-63.7% higher than these in control group. Comparatively, Methanosaeta played a pivotal role driving aceticlastic methanogenesis in the control group because the abundance of gene encoding acetyl-CoA decarbonylase/synthase complex increased by 1.9 times, suggesting an aceticlastic combining H2-based syntrophic methanogenesis pathway was established in control group to resist ammonia stress. A 2nd period experiment elucidated that although depending on distinct mechanisms, the volatile fatty acid oxidizers and methanogens in both groups developed sustained and stable strategies to resist ammonia stress. These findings provided new insights to understand the distinct methanogenic recovery strategy to resist toxic stress under varied environmental conditions.

Mechanistic insights into synergistic facilitation of copper/zinc ions and dewatered swine manure-derived biochar on anaerobic digestion of swine wastewater

Biochar-assisted anaerobic digestion (AD) has been proposed an advanced system for swine wastewater (SW) management. However, the effects of metallic nutrients in SW, such as copper/zinc ions (Cu2+/Zn2+), on the biochar-assisted AD of SW are not well understood. This study investigated the influences of individual Cu2+/Zn2+ or dewatered swine manure-derived biochar, as well as their combined additions, on the AD of SW. The results showed that exposure to 50 mg/L Cu2+/Zn2+ temporary inhibited methane production, but the addition of 20 g/L biochar alleviated this inhibition by shortening the methanogenic lag time and increasing methane yield. Following a period of acclimation, both Cu2+/Zn2+ and biochar promoted methane production, although metagenomic analysis revealed distinct mechanisms underlying their promotion. Cu2+/Zn2+ enhanced ATP processing, including electron exchange between NADH/NAD+ and succinate/fumarate transformation, by 26.0-35.8%. Additionally, the gene encoding Coenzyme M methylation was upregulated by 36.2% along with enrichments of Methanocullus and Methanosarcina, contributing to accelerated hydrolysis and methanogenesis rates by 54.7% and 44.8%, respectively. On the other hand, biochar mainly stimulated bacterial F-type ATPase activities by 28.4%, likely facilitating direct interspecies electron transfer between Geobacter and Methanosarcina for syntrophic methanogenesis. The combined addition of Cu2+/Zn2+ and biochar resulted in "win-win" benefits, significantly increasing the maximum methane production rate from 40.3 mL CH4/d to 53.7 mL CH4/d. Moreover, the introduction of biochar into AD of SW facilitated the transformation of more Cu2+/Zn2+ from a reducible Fe-Mn oxides form to a residual form, which potentially reduced the metallic toxicity of the digestate for soil amendment. The findings of this study provide novel insights into understanding the synergistic impacts of heavy metals and biochar in regulating SW during AD, as well as the management of associated digestate.

A review of microbial responses to biochar addition in anaerobic digestion system: Community, cellular and genetic level findings

The biochar is a well-developed porous material with various excellent properties, that has been proven with excellent ability in anaerobic digestion (AD) efficiency promotion. Current research is usually focused on the macro effects of biochar on AD, while the systematic review about the mechanisms of biochar on microbial behavior are still lacking. This review summarizes the effects and potential mechanisms of biochar on microorganisms in AD systems, and found that biochar addition can provide habitats for microbial colonization, alleviate toxins stress, supply essential nutrients, and accelerate interspecies electron transferring. Moreover, it also improves microbial community diversity, facilitates EPS secretion, enhances functional enzyme activity, promotes functional genes expression, and inhibits the antibiotic resistance genes transformation. Future research directions including biochar targeted design, in-depth microbial mechanisms revelation, and modified model development were suggested, which could promote the widely practical application of of biochar-amended AD technology.

Evaluating effects of biochar on anaerobic digestion of dewatered waste activated sludge: Digester performance, microbial co-metabolism and underlying mechanism

Biochar has been proven to be capable of improving the performance of anaerobic digestion (AD). However, the effect of biochar on microbial communities remains ambiguous. In this study, the influence of pH was excluded in a semi-continuous anaerobic digestor for the treatment of dewatered waste activated sludge (WAS) to determine the effect of biochar on microbes. Compared with the control group, the average methane production increased by 24.5% and 23.2% at the organic loading rates (OLRs) of 1.56 and 3.00 gTS/L/d, respectively, in the presence of biochar. This study innovatively found biochar accelerated the enrichment of Methanofastidiosaceae, which competed with Methanobacteriaceae for H2, and its abundance increased from 0.99% at the OLR of 1.56 g TS/L/d to 16.57% and 38.11% at the OLR of 3.00 and 5.60 gTS/L/d, respectively. The efficient metabolic network of f__norank_o__Aminicenantales, syntrophic bacteria, Methanofastidiosaceae and Methanosaetaceae promoted the conversion of WAS to CH4 in the biochar group. In addition, metagenome analysis revealed that biochar optimized the metabolites related to energy conservation and electron transfer, particularly for hydrogenase (frhABG, mbhLHK and hndA-D), confirming that biochar changed the way H2 was involved in methanogenesis. These findings provide novel insights into the direct effect of biochar on microbial evolution and facilitate the reduction of WAS to achieve higher economic benefits in biogas production.

Effects of biochar on anaerobic treatment systems: Some perspectives

Many anaerobic activities involve carbon, nitrogen, iron, and sulfur cycles. As a well-developed porous material with abundant functional groups, pyrolytic biochar has been widely researched in efforts to promote microbial activities. However, the lack of consensus on the biochar mechanism has limited its practical application. This review summarizes the effects of different pyrolysis temperatures, particle sizes, and dosages of biochar on microbial activities and community in Fe(III) reduction, anaerobic digestion, nitrogen removal, and sulfate reduction systems. It was found that biochar could promote anaerobic activities by stimulating electron transfer, alleviating toxicity, and providing suitable habitats for microbes. However, it inhibits microbial activities by releasing heavy metal ions or persistent free radicals and adsorbing signaling molecules. Finding a balance between the promotion and inhibition of biochar is therefore essential. This review provides valuable perspectives on how to achieve efficient and stable use of biochar in anaerobic systems.

Insight into the Impacts and Removal Pathways of Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA) in Anaerobic Digestion

Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) that accumulates in wastewater and excess sludge interact with the anaerobes and deteriorate the energy recovery and pollutants removal performance in the anaerobic digestion (AD) system. However, the interaction between PFOA and microbial metabolism in the AD systems remains unclear. This study aimed to clarify the effects and mechanism of PFOA on the AD process as well as the removal pathways of PFOA in an AD system. The results showed that the methane recovery efficiency was inhibited by 7.6–19.7% with the increased PFOA concentration of 0.5–3.0 mg/L, and the specific methanogenesis activity (SMA) was inhibited by 8.6–22.3%. The electron transfer system (ETS) was inhibited by 22.1–37.3% in the PFOA-containing groups. However, extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) gradually increased due to the toxicity of PFOA, and the ratio of protein to polysaccharide shows an upward trend, which led to the formation of sludge aggregates and resistance to the toxic of PFOA. The PFOA mass balance analysis indicated that 64.2–71.6% of PFOA was removed in the AD system, and sludge adsorption was the main removal pathway, accounting for 36.1–61.2% of the removed PFOA. In addition, the anaerobes are proposed to have the potential to reduce PFOA through biochemical degradation since 10.4–28.2% of PFOA was missing in the AD system. This study provides a significant reference for the treatment of high-strength PFOA-containing wastes.