Outcome after cortico-amygdalo-hippocampectomy in patients with severe bilateral mesial temporal sclerosis submitted to invasive recording

Treatment of Multi-Focal Epilepsy With Resective Surgery Plus Responsive Neurostimulation (RNS): One Institution's Experience

Objective: Patients with medically refractory focal epilepsy can be difficult to treat surgically, especially if invasive monitoring reveals multiple ictal onset zones. Possible therapeutic options may include resection, neurostimulation, laser ablation, or a combination of these surgical modalities. To date, no study has examined outcomes associated with resection plus responsive neurostimulation (RNS, Neuropace, Inc., Mountain View, CA) implantation and we describe our initial experience in patients with multifocal epilepsy undergoing this combination therapy.

Methods: A total of 43 responsive neurostimulation (RNS) devices were implanted at UCI from 2015 to 2019. We retrospectively reviewed charts of patients from the same time period who underwent both resection and RNS implantation. Patients were required to have independent or multifocal onset, undergo resection and RNS implantation, and have a minimum of six-months for follow-up to be included in the study. Demographics, location of ictal onset, location of surgery, complications, and seizure outcome were collected.

Results: Ten patients met inclusion criteria for the study, and seven underwent both procedures in the same setting. The average age was 36. All patients had multifocal ictal onset on video electroencephalogram or invasive EEG with four patients undergoing subdural grid placement and four patients undergoing bilateral sEEG prior to the definitive surgery. Five patients underwent resection plus ipsilateral RNS placement and the remainder underwent resection with contralateral RNS placement. Two minor complications were encountered in this group. At six months follow up, there was an average of 81% ± 9 reduction in seizures, while four patients experienced complete seizure freedom at 1 year.

Conclusion: Patients with multifocal epilepsy can be treated with partial resection plus RNS. The complication rates are low with potential for worthwhile seizure reduction.

How Different Are the Patients With Bilateral Hippocampal Sclerosis From the Unilateral Ones Clinically?

PURPOSE

There is a lack of knowledge on consecutive patients with epilepsy associated with bilateral hippocampal sclerosis (BHS). We aimed to investigate the differentiating features of BHS in comparison with unilateral HS (UHS).

METHOD

We investigated our database for patients with epilepsy fulfilling the major magnetic resonance imaging criteria for BHS; namely, presence of bilateral atrophy and high signal changes on T2 and FLAIR series in the hippocampi. UHS patients seen in past 2 years were included as the control group. Clinical, EEG, and other laboratory findings, data on treatment response and epilepsy surgery were investigated from their files.

RESULTS

A total of 124 patients (31 with BHS and 93 with UHS; 49 right-sided and 44 left-sided) were included. We found that 16.1% of the BHS and 18.3% of the UHS groups were not drug-refractory. A binary logistic regression analysis performed with significant clinical features disclosed that history of febrile status epilepticus, mental retardation, and status epilepticus were statistically more common in BHS group. Moreover, diagnosis of psychosis established by an experienced psychiatrist and slowing of the EEG background activity were both found significantly more frequent in BHS. 66.67% of the operated BHS patients showed benefit from epilepsy surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

BHS is a heterogeneous group, showing significant differences such as increased frequencies of mental retardation, status epilepticus, febrile status epilepticus and psychosis, in comparison to UHS. In all, 16.1% of the BHS cases showed a benign course similar to the UHS group and some patients with drug-resistant epilepsy may show benefit from epilepsy surgery.

Contralateral Hippocampal Stimulation for Failed Unilateral Anterior Temporal Lobectomy in Patients with Bilateral Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

AIMS

To prospectively study the surgical outcomes of unilateral anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) in patients with intractable bilateral temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) as well as two-staged contralateral hippocampal stimulation in patients after failed unilateral ATL.

METHODS

Eighteen carefully selected patients with bilateral TLE underwent unilateral ATL. Five cases with failed ATL underwent two-staged contralateral hippocampal stimulation. Seizure control and changes in intelligence quotient (IQ), memory quotient, and quality of life (QOL) were analyzed 2-5 years after treatment.

RESULTS

In the patients with unilateral ATL, the percentages seizure free were 55.6% (10/18), 50.0% (9/18), and 44.4% (4/9) at the 1-, 2-, and 5-year follow-up visits, respectively. There were significant difference in seizure control between the patients with unilateral ATL and the 12 cases in the medication group. Significant differences were also found in changes in the patients' QOL and full-scale IQ at the 2-year follow-up between the surgical and medication groups. Five patients who underwent contralateral hippocampal stimulation after failed unilateral ATL experienced 80-100% seizure reductions, and 80% were seizure free 1 year after hippocampal stimulation.

CONCLUSION

Unilateral ATL provides good seizure control and does not cause serious memory or IQ injury in carefully selected patients with true bilateral TLE. Contralateral hippocampal stimulation is a useful approach for patients who experience unilateral ATL failure.

Predictors of surgical outcome in medically-resistant temporal lobe epilepsy with bilateral features on pre-operative evaluation

OBJECTIVE

This study identifies potential prognostic factors for favorable anterior mesial temporal lobe (AMTL) resection outcomes in patients with medically refractory temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) with bilateral features on pre-operative examination.

METHODS

Thirty-one patients demonstrated bilateral features defined as: bilateral independent temporal or bitemporal ictal onsets on surface or intracranial EEG, or bitemporal interictal epileptiform abnormalities on surface EEG with bilateral radiographic mesial temporal sclerosis. Surgical outcomes were classified according to reduction in seizure frequency: I (100% reduction), II (≥75% reduction), III (50-74% reduction), IV (<50% reduction).

RESULTS

Of 31 patients, 14 (45%) improved to class I and 9 (29%) had a class II outcome at an average of 4 years after surgery. Eight (26%) patients did not exhibit good surgical outcome (class III, class IV). We found that neuropsychological and Wada memory scores were significantly correlated (p<0.05) with surgical outcome, and logistic regression found neuropsychological evaluation significantly predicted better surgical outcome (p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

When bilateral features are present on pre-operative evaluation, neuropsychological and Wada test results can provide unique data to better identify those patients more likely to achieve substantial seizure reduction.

Surgical outcomes with non-invasive presurgical evaluation in MRI determined bilateral mesial temporal sclerosis: A retrospective cohort study

BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVE

Epilepsy surgery for bilateral hippocampal sclerosis continues to pose a challenge and outcomes even with invasive evaluations have not been very promising. Very few studies have analyzed surgery outcomes for patients with MRI determined, bilateral mesial temporal sclerosis (MTS) after non-invasive pre-surgical evaluation.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We studied 35 patients with bilateral MTS who underwent anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) after non-invasive pre-surgical evaluation. Clinical history, EEG, neuropsychology profile and symmetry of MTS on MRI were reviewed in the groups of 'seizure free' and 'not seizure free' patients.

RESULTS

At an average follow up of 44 months (range 12-110 months), 26 out of 35 patients (74%) were seizure free. Unilateral interictal discharges were seen in 57% patients. 94% patients had unilateral ictal EEG onset. Bilateral interictal discharges were significantly associated with 'not seizure free' outcome (p = 0.02). Pre-operatively, 24 (71%) patients had bilateral (verbal and visual) memory impairment while 10 (28%) patients had unilateral (verbal or visual) memory impairment and 1 patient had a normal memory profile. Overall, no significant decline in memory was seen in left or right surgery groups post-operatively. There was significant improvement in Quality of Life scores in all patients (p = <0.0005).

CONCLUSION

Patients with bilateral MTS on MRI can be unilateral on electro physiology and neuropsychology, and can have a very good surgical outcome. In a setting of limited resources, a noninvasive pre-surgical protocol can be used. With proper patient selection, the outcomes may be comparable to those reported with invasive pre-surgical protocols. Patients with unilateral interictal and ictal EEG have the best outcome. Up to 50% patients with bilateral interictal discharges can have a seizure free outcome. Patients with bilateral independent seizure onset have a less favourable prognosis. Patients who are not seizure free can still attain worthwhile improvement in seizure frequency without significant decline in memory and some improvement in quality of life.

Neuropsychological outcome after epilepsy surgery in patients with bilateral Ammon's horn sclerosis

Object

The purpose of this study was to retrospectively assess the objective and subjective neuropsychological outcome after epilepsy surgery in patients with bilateral Ammon's horn sclerosis (AHS).

Methods

Memory and executive functions were evaluated at baseline and at follow-up in 11 surgically treated patients and compared with 8 pharmacologically treated patients with temporal lobe epilepsy and bilateral AHS. The median follow-up duration was 16 months in the surgically treated patients and 80.5 months in the pharmacologically treated group. Subjective outcome was evaluated by questionnaires and included mood, quality of life, subjective memory, and activities of daily living.

Results

At the follow-up assessment, 82% of the surgically treated patients as opposed to 0% of the nonsurgery patients were seizure free. In the surgical group, nonverbal memory performance did not change significantly in any patient after surgery, but there was a floor effect in 55% of the surgical patients. Regarding verbal memory, 9% of the surgical patients improved while 73% declined, despite severe impairments already evident at baseline. In the nonsurgery control group, 13% of the patients declined in nonverbal memory (floor effect in 63%) and 25% declined in verbal memory (floor effect in 25%) at follow-up. None of the controls improved at follow-up. Executive functions remained unchanged on an impaired level in both groups. At follow-up, the patient groups did not differ significantly with respect to mood, quality of life, subjective memory, or activities of daily living. However, in most aspects, surgically treated patients reported a slightly better subjective outcome than pharmacologically treated patients and a significantly improved quality of life.

Conclusions

These results suggest that beyond benefits concerning seizure control, surgically treated patients with bilateral AHS, despite already poor baseline performance, are still at risk for severe postoperative decline in memory. In the light of predominantly minor benefits on a subjective level, the findings put the overall outcome of epilepsy surgery in bilateral AHS patients into perspective.

Long-term therapeutic effects of corticoamygdalohippocampectomy for bilateral mesial temporal lobe epilepsy

Background:

Some cases of paradoxical mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE) are shown to be bilateral MTLE (BMTLE) by intracranial electrodes. The treatment for BMTLE is difficult, which poses several questions. Can corticoamygdalohippocampectomy (CAH) be applied to treat BMTLE? What are the long-term therapeutic effects if CAH is performed in BMTLE patients?

Methods:

Four patients were shown to have BMTLE through bilateral intracranial electrode implantation. CAH was performed on the side with relatively more seizure originations. These patients were followed-up at 6 months, 1 year, 2 years and longer, in some cases, after the CAH. The postoperative seizure frequency was recorded. Preoperative and postoperative clinical memory tests and a postoperative 4-hour video electroencephalography (EEG) were conducted in the hospital at different follow-up times. The average seizure frequencies and memory quotient scores were analyzed.

Results:

The average seizure frequency significantly decreased by 80.8%, 83.5%, and 84.3% at different postoperative times. Although no patient was seizure free, the intensity of the seizures was reduced in all cases. The postoperative average memory quotient score was moderately decreased by 15.8%, 11.7%, and 16.6% at different postoperative times. Both the average values of the postoperative seizure frequency (5.5, 4.75, and 4.5 per month) and the average values of the postoperative memory quotient (73.7, 77.3, and 73) at different postoperative times were approximately the same.

Conclusions:

CAH reduced the seizure frequency and intensity in these BMTLE patients. Mild hypomnesis occurred in every case. We observed the long-term treatment effects at 6 months after the CAH and showed that the effects did not change at that time or over the next few years.

Outcome after cortico-amygdalo-hippocampectomy in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy and normal MRI

RATIONALE

We describe seizure and neuropsychological outcome obtained after CAH in patients with TLE and normal MRI evaluated in the modern imaging era.

METHODS

Forty-five adult consecutive patients with TLE and normal MRI were studied. All patients had neuropsychological testing, interictal and ictal EEG recordings and MRI. They were divided into two groups: Group 1 (n=18), included patients in whom non-invasive neurophysiological evaluation was lateralizing and Group 2 (n=27) included patients with non-lateralizing neurophysiological data who were submitted to invasive recordings.

RESULTS

Seventy-seven percent of the Group 1 patients were rated as Engel I; 11% were rated as Engel II and 11% as Engel III. In Group 2, there were 57% of patients seizure-free, 26% in Engel II and 14% in Engel III. Pre-operatively, mean general IQ was 82 and 78 in Groups 1 and 2, respectively; post-operatively, mean general IQ was respectively 86 and 71. Some degree of verbal memory decline was noted in all patients submitted to dominant temporal lobe resection in both Groups 1 and 2. At last follow-up visit, 22% of Group 1 and 11% of Group 2 patients were receiving no antiepileptic drugs (AED).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data showed that patients with TLE and normal MRI could get good surgical results after CAH although 60% of them would need invasive recordings and their results regarding seizure control and cognition were worse than those obtained in patients with MRI defined temporal lobe lesions. Caution should be taken in offering dominant temporal lobe resection to this subset of patients.