DNA nanomechanics in the nucleosome

Asymmetry in histone rotation in forced unwrapping and force quench rewrapping in a nucleosome

Single molecule pulling experiments have shown that DNA in the nucleosomes unwraps in two stages from the histone protein core (HPC). The first stage, attributed to the rupture of the outer DNA turn, occurs between 3 and 5 pNs, and is reversible. The inner DNA turn ruptures irreversibly at forces between 9 and 15 pNs (or higher) in the second stage. Molecular simulations using the Self-Organized Polymer model capture the experimental findings. The unwrapping of the outer DNA turn is independent of the pulling direction. The rupture of the DNA inner turn depends on the pulling direction and involves overcoming substantial energetic (most likely electrostatic in origin) and kinetic barriers. They arise because the mechanical force has to generate sufficient torque to rotate the HPC by 180°. On the other hand, during the rewrapping process, HPC rotation is stochastic, with force playing no role. The assembly of the outer DNA wrap upon force quench nearly coincides with the unwrapping process, confirming the reversibility of the outer turn rupture. The asymmetry in HPC rotation during unwrapping and rewrapping explains the observed hysteresis in the stretch-release cycles in experiments. We propose experiments to test the prediction that HPC rotation produces kinetic barriers in the unwrapping process.

The role of histone tails in nucleosome stability: An electrostatic perspective

We propose a methodology for the study of protein-DNA electrostatic interactions and apply it to clarify the effect of histone tails in nucleosomes. This method can be used to correlate electrostatic interactions to structural and functional features of protein-DNA systems, and can be combined with coarse-grained representations. In particular, we focus on the electrostatic field and resulting forces acting on the DNA. We investigate the electrostatic origins of effects such as different stages in DNA unwrapping, nucleosome destabilization upon histone tail truncation, and the role of specific arginines and lysines undergoing Post-Translational Modifications. We find that the positioning of the histone tails can oppose the attractive pull of the histone core, locally deform the DNA, and tune DNA unwrapping. Small conformational variations in the often overlooked H2A C-terminal tails had significant electrostatic repercussions near the DNA entry and exit sites. The H2A N-terminal tail exerts attractive electrostatic forces towards the histone core in positions where Polymerase II halts its progress. We validate our results with comparisons to previous experimental and computational observations.

Translational nucleosome positioning: A computational study

About three-quarters of eukaryotic DNA is wrapped into nucleosomes; DNA spools with a protein core. The affinity of a given DNA stretch to be incorporated into a nucleosome is known to depend on the base-pair sequence-dependent geometry and elasticity of the DNA double helix. This causes the rotational and translational positioning of nucleosomes. In this study we ask the question whether the latter can be predicted by a simple coarse-grained DNA model with sequence-dependent elasticity, the rigid base-pair model. Whereas this model is known to be rather robust in predicting rotational nucleosome positioning, we show that the translational positioning is a rather subtle effect that is dominated by the guanine-cytosine content dependence of entropy rather than energy. A correct qualitative prediction within the rigid base-pair framework can only be achieved by assuming that DNA elasticity effectively changes on complexation into the nucleosome complex. With that extra assumption we arrive at a model which gives an excellent quantitative agreement to experimental in vitro nucleosome maps, under the additional assumption that nucleosomes equilibrate their positions only locally.

Ensembles of Breathing Nucleosomes: A Computational Study

About three-fourths of the human DNA molecules are wrapped into nucleosomes, protein spools with DNA. Nucleosomes are highly dynamic, transiently exposing their DNA through spontaneous unspooling. Recent experiments allowed to observe the DNA of an ensemble of such breathing nucleosomes through x-ray diffraction with contrast matching between the solvent and the protein core. In this study, we calculate such an ensemble through a Monte Carlo simulation of a coarse-grained nucleosome model with sequence-dependent DNA mechanics. Our analysis gives detailed insights into the sequence dependence of nucleosome breathing observed in the experiment and allows us to determine the adsorption energy of the DNA bound to the protein core as a function of the ionic strength. Moreover, we predict the breathing behavior of other potentially interesting sequences and compare the findings to earlier related experiments.

Quantitative Modeling of Nucleosome Unwrapping from Both Ends

In eukaryotic cells, DNA is packaged into chromatin where nucleosomes are the basic packaging unit. Important cellular processes including gene expression, DNA replication, and DNA repair require nucleosomal DNA to be unwrapped so that functional proteins can access their target sites, which otherwise are sterically occluded. A key question in this process is what the unwrapped conformations individual nucleosomes adopt within chromatin are. Here, we develop a concurrent nucleosome unwrapping model to address this question. We hypothesize that for a given end-to-end distance of the nucleosomal DNA, the nucleosomal DNA stochastically unwraps from the histone core from both ends independently and that this combination of unwrapping from both sides results in a significant increase in the average distance between the DNA extending from both sides of the nucleosomes. We test our model on recently published experiments using a DNA origami nanocaliper that quantifies nucleosome unwrapping and achieve good agreement between experiment and model prediction. We then investigate the DNA origami caliper distribution when attached to a hexasome (a nucleosome lacking an H2A/H2B dimer). A significant shift in the caliper angle distribution caused by the asymmetric structural features of the hexasome seen experimentally is consistent with the model. Our modeling approach may be more broadly useful to the interpretation of other studies of nucleosome dynamics, chromatin dynamics, and regulatory processes involving nucleosome unwrapping, as well as more generally to optimization of future DNA origami designs to probe mechanical properties of biomolecules.

Bend-Induced Twist Waves and the Structure of Nucleosomal DNA

Recent work indicates that twist-bend coupling plays an important role in DNA micromechanics. Here we investigate its effect on bent DNA. We provide an analytical solution of the minimum-energy shape of circular DNA, showing that twist-bend coupling induces sinusoidal twist waves. This solution is in excellent agreement with both coarse-grained simulations of minicircles and nucleosomal DNA data, which is bent and wrapped around histone proteins in a superhelical conformation. Our analysis shows that the observed twist oscillation in nucleosomal DNA, so far attributed to the interaction with the histone proteins, is an intrinsic feature of free bent DNA, and should be observable in other protein-DNA complexes.

DNA sliding in nucleosomes via twist defect propagation revealed by molecular simulations

While nucleosomes are highly stable structures as fundamental units of chromatin, they also slide along the DNA, either spontaneously or by active remodelers. Here, we investigate the microscopic mechanisms of nucleosome sliding by multiscale molecular simulations, characterizing how the screw-like motion of DNA proceeds via the formation and propagation of twist defects. Firstly, coarse-grained molecular simulations reveal that the sliding dynamics is highly dependent on DNA sequence. Depending on the sequence and the nucleosome super-helical location, we find two distinct types of twist defects: a locally under-twisted DNA region, previously observed in crystal structures, and a locally over-twisted DNA, an unprecedented feature. The stability of the over-twist defect was confirmed via all-atom simulations. Analysis of our trajectories via Markov state modeling highlights how the sequence-dependence of the sliding dynamics is due to the different twist defect energy costs, and in particular how nucleosome regions where defects cannot easily form introduce the kinetic bottlenecks slowing down repositioning. Twist defects can also mediate sliding of nucleosomes made with strong positioning sequences, albeit at a much lower diffusion coefficient, due to a high-energy intermediate state. Finally, we discuss how chromatin remodelers may exploit these spontaneous fluctuations to induce unidirectional sliding of nucleosomes.

Physics behind the mechanical nucleosome positioning code

The positions along DNA molecules of nucleosomes, the most abundant DNA-protein complexes in cells, are influenced by the sequence-dependent DNA mechanics and geometry. This leads to the "nucleosome positioning code", a preference of nucleosomes for certain sequence motives. Here we introduce a simplified model of the nucleosome where a coarse-grained DNA molecule is frozen into an idealized superhelical shape. We calculate the exact sequence preferences of our nucleosome model and find it to reproduce qualitatively all the main features known to influence nucleosome positions. Moreover, using well-controlled approximations to this model allows us to come to a detailed understanding of the physics behind the sequence preferences of nucleosomes.

Benchmarking and refining probability-based models for nucleosome-DNA interaction

Background

In investigations of nucleosome positioning preferences, a model that assigns an affinity to a given sequence is necessary to make predictions. One important class of models, which treats a nucleosome sequence as a Markov chain, has been applied with success when informed with experimentally measured nucleosomal sequence preferences.

Results

We find that we can also use such models as a fast approximative scheme for computationally expensive biophysical models, vastly increasing their reach. Employing these models in this way also allows us to benchmark them for the first time. Doing so for the approximative in silico models indirectly tells us about the accuracy we can expect of them when applied to real data.

Conclusion

We find that models presented in the literature should perform well, but this performance depends on factors such as the order of the Markov model, the preprocessing of the probability distributions on which the model is based, and the size and quality of the sequence ensemble from which those distributions are calculated.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-017-1569-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Same same but different: The evolution of TBP in archaea and their eukaryotic offspring

Transcription factors TBP and TF(II)B assemble with RNA polymerase at the promoter DNA forming the initiation complex. Despite a high degree of conservation, the molecular binding mechanisms of archaeal and eukaryotic TBP and TF(II)B differ significantly. Based on recent biophysical data, we speculate how the mechanisms co-evolved with transcription regulation and TBP multiplicity.

Multiplexing Genetic and Nucleosome Positioning Codes: A Computational Approach

Eukaryotic DNA is strongly bent inside fundamental packaging units: the nucleosomes. It is known that their positions are strongly influenced by the mechanical properties of the underlying DNA sequence. Here we discuss the possibility that these mechanical properties and the concomitant nucleosome positions are not just a side product of the given DNA sequence, e.g. that of the genes, but that a mechanical evolution of DNA molecules might have taken place. We first demonstrate the possibility of multiplexing classical and mechanical genetic information using a computational nucleosome model. In a second step we give evidence for genome-wide multiplexing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Schizosacharomyces pombe. This suggests that the exact positions of nucleosomes play crucial roles in chromatin function.

Nucleosome dynamics: Sequence matters

About three quarter of all eukaryotic DNA is wrapped around protein cylinders, forming nucleosomes. Even though the histone proteins that make up the core of nucleosomes are highly conserved in evolution, nucleosomes can be very different from each other due to posttranslational modifications of the histones. Another crucial factor in making nucleosomes unique has so far been underappreciated: the sequence of their DNA. This review provides an overview of the experimental and theoretical progress that increasingly points to the importance of the nucleosomal base pair sequence. Specifically, we discuss the role of the underlying base pair sequence in nucleosome positioning, sliding, breathing, force-induced unwrapping, dissociation and partial assembly and also how the sequence can influence higher-order structures. A new view emerges: the physical properties of nucleosomes, especially their dynamical properties, are determined to a large extent by the mechanical properties of their DNA, which in turn depends on DNA sequence.

A deformation energy-based model for predicting nucleosome dyads and occupancy

Nucleosome plays an essential role in various cellular processes, such as DNA replication, recombination, and transcription. Hence, it is important to decode the mechanism of nucleosome positioning and identify nucleosome positions in the genome. In this paper, we present a model for predicting nucleosome positioning based on DNA deformation, in which both bending and shearing of the nucleosomal DNA are considered. The model successfully predicted the dyad positions of nucleosomes assembled in vitro and the in vitro map of nucleosomes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Applying the model to Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila melanogaster, we achieved satisfactory results. Our data also show that shearing energy of nucleosomal DNA outperforms bending energy in nucleosome occupancy prediction and the ability to predict nucleosome dyad positions is attributed to bending energy that is associated with rotational positioning of nucleosomes.

Why Do Nucleosomes Unwrap Asymmetrically?

Nucleosomes, DNA spools with a protein core, engage about three-quarters of eukaryotic DNA and play a critical role in chromosomal processes, ranging from gene regulation, recombination, and replication to chromosome condensation. For more than a decade, micromanipulation experiments where nucleosomes are put under tension, as well as the theoretical interpretations of these experiments, have deepened our understanding of the stability and dynamics of nucleosomes. Here we give a theoretical explanation for a surprising new experimental finding: nucleosomes wrapped onto the 601 positioning sequence (the sequence used in most laboratories) respond highly asymmetrically to external forces by always unwrapping from the same end. Using a computational nucleosome model, we show that this asymmetry can be explained by differences in the DNA mechanics of two very short stretches on the wrapped DNA portion. Our finding suggests that the physical properties of nucleosomes, here the response to forces, can be tuned locally by the choice of the underlying base-pair sequence. This leads to a new view of nucleosomes: a physically highly varied set of DNA-protein complexes whose properties can be tuned on evolutionary time scales to their specific function in the genomic context.

Inferring coarse-grain histone-DNA interaction potentials from high-resolution structures of the nucleosome

The histone-DNA interaction in the nucleosome is a fundamental mechanism of genomic compaction and regulation, which remains largely unknown despite increasing structural knowledge of the complex. In this paper, we propose a framework for the extraction of a nanoscale histone-DNA force-field from a collection of high-resolution structures, which may be adapted to a larger class of protein-DNA complexes. We applied the procedure to a large crystallographic database extended by snapshots from molecular dynamics simulations. The comparison of the structural models first shows that, at histone-DNA contact sites, the DNA base-pairs are shifted outwards locally, consistent with locally repulsive forces exerted by the histones. The second step shows that the various force profiles of the structures under analysis derive locally from a unique, sequence-independent, quadratic repulsive force-field, while the sequence preferences are entirely due to internal DNA mechanics. We have thus obtained the first knowledge-derived nanoscale interaction potential for histone-DNA in the nucleosome. The conformations obtained by relaxation of nucleosomal DNA with high-affinity sequences in this potential accurately reproduce the experimental values of binding preferences. Finally we address the more generic binding mechanisms relevant to the 80% genomic sequences incorporated in nucleosomes, by computing the conformation of nucleosomal DNA with sequence-averaged properties. This conformation differs from those found in crystals, and the analysis suggests that repulsive histone forces are related to local stretch tension in nucleosomal DNA, mostly between adjacent contact points. This tension could play a role in the stability of the complex.

DNA shape dominates sequence affinity in nucleosome formation

Nucleosomes provide the basic unit of compaction in eukaryotic genomes, and the mechanisms that dictate their position at specific locations along a DNA sequence are of central importance to genetics. In this Letter, we employ molecular models of DNA and proteins to elucidate various aspects of nucleosome positioning. In particular, we show how DNA's histone affinity is encoded in its sequence-dependent shape, including subtle deviations from the ideal straight B-DNA form and local variations of minor groove width. By relying on high-precision simulations of the free energy of nucleosome complexes, we also demonstrate that, depending on DNA's intrinsic curvature, histone binding can be dominated by bending interactions or electrostatic interactions. More generally, the results presented here explain how sequence, manifested as the shape of the DNA molecule, dominates molecular recognition in the problem of nucleosome positioning.

Mechanical properties of symmetric and asymmetric DNA A-tracts: implications for looping and nucleosome positioning

A-tracts are functionally important DNA sequences which induce helix bending and have peculiar structural properties. While A-tract structure has been qualitatively well characterized, their mechanical properties remain controversial. A-tracts appear structurally rigid and resist nucleosome formation, but seem flexible in DNA looping. In this work, we investigate mechanical properties of symmetric AnTn and asymmetric A2n tracts for n = 3, 4, 5 using two types of coarse-grained models. The first model represents DNA as an ensemble of interacting rigid bases with non-local quadratic deformation energy, the second one treats DNA as an anisotropically bendable and twistable elastic rod. Parameters for both models are inferred from microsecond long, atomic-resolution molecular dynamics simulations. We find that asymmetric A-tracts are more rigid than the control G/C-rich sequence in localized distortions relevant for nucleosome formation, but are more flexible in global bending and twisting relevant for looping. The symmetric tracts, in contrast, are more rigid than asymmetric tracts and the control, both locally and globally. Our results can reconcile the contradictory stiffness data on A-tracts and suggest symmetric A-tracts to be more efficient in nucleosome exclusion than the asymmetric ones. This would open a new possibility of gene expression manipulation using A-tracts.

DNA damage may drive nucleosomal reorganization to facilitate damage detection

One issue in genome maintenance is how DNA repair proteins find lesions at rates that seem to exceed diffusion-limited search rates. We propose a phenomenon where DNA damage induces nucleosomal rearrangements which move lesions to potential rendezvous points in the chromatin structure. These rendezvous points are the dyad and the linker DNA between histones, positions in the chromatin which are more likely to be accessible by repair proteins engaged in a random search. The feasibility of this mechanism is tested by considering the statistical mechanics of DNA containing a single lesion wrapped onto the nucleosome. We consider lesions which make the DNA either more flexible or more rigid by modeling the lesion as either a decrease or an increase in the bending energy. We include this energy in a partition function model of nucleosome breathing. Our results indicate that the steady state for a breathing nucleosome will most likely position the lesion at the dyad or in the linker, depending on the energy of the lesion. A role for DNA binding proteins and chromatin remodelers is suggested based on their ability to alter the mechanical properties of the DNA and DNA-histone binding, respectively. We speculate that these positions around the nucleosome potentially serve as rendezvous points where DNA lesions may be encountered by repair proteins which may be sterically hindered from searching the rest of the nucleosomal DNA. The strength of the repositioning is strongly dependent on the structural details of the DNA lesion and the wrapping and breathing of the nucleosome. A more sophisticated evaluation of this proposed mechanism will require detailed information about breathing dynamics, the structure of partially wrapped nucleosomes, and the structural properties of damaged DNA.

Weak operator binding enhances simulated Lac repressor-mediated DNA looping

The 50th anniversary of Biopolymers coincides closely with the like celebration of the discovery of the Escherichia coli (lac) lactose operon, a classic genetic system long used to illustrate the influence of biomolecular structure on function. The looping of DNA induced by the binding of the Lac repressor protein to sequentially distant operator sites on DNA continues to serve as a paradigm for understanding long-range genomic communication. Advances in analyses of DNA structures and in incorporation of proteins in computer simulations of DNA looping allow us to address long-standing questions about the role of protein-mediated DNA loop formation in transcriptional control. Here we report insights gained from studies of the sequence-dependent contributions of the natural lac operators to Lac repressor-mediated DNA looping. Novel superposition of the ensembles of protein-bound operator structures derived from NMR measurements reveals variations in DNA folding missed in conventional structural alignments. The changes in folding affect the predicted ease with which the repressor induces loop formation and the ways that DNA closes between the protein headpieces. The peeling of the auxiliary operators away from the repressor enhances the formation of loops with the 92-bp wildtype spacing and hints of a structural reason behind their weak binding.

Rigid-body molecular dynamics of DNA inside a nucleosome

The majority of eukaryotic DNA, about three quarter, is wrapped around histone proteins forming so-called nucleosomes. To study nucleosomal DNA we introduce a coarse-grained molecular dynamics model based on sequence-dependent harmonic rigid base pair step parameters of DNA and nucleosomal binding sites. Mixed parametrization based on all-atom molecular dynamics and crystallographic data of protein-DNA structures is used for the base pair step parameters. The binding site parameters are adjusted by experimental B-factor values of the nucleosome crystal structure. The model is then used to determine the energy cost for placing a twist defect into the nucleosomal DNA which allows us to use Kramers theory to calculate nucleosome sliding caused by such defects. It is shown that the twist defect scenario together with the sequence-dependent elasticity of DNA can explain the slow time scales observed for nucleosome mobility along DNA. With this method we also show how the twist defect mechanism leads to a higher mobility of DNA in the presence of sin mutations near the dyad axis. Finally, by performing simulations on 5s rDNA, 601, and telomeric base pair sequences, it is demonstrated that the current model is a powerful tool to predict nucleosome positioning.

Modelling Nucleic Acid Structure and Flexibility: From Atomic to Mesoscopic Scale

This chapter surveys some of the recent developments in coarse-grained modelling of nucleic acids. We first discuss models based on pseudoatoms, effective spherical particles representing groups of atoms. A major part of the chapter is devoted to models in which bases or base pairs are represented as independent, interacting rigid bodies. Two popular definitions of internal coordinates, as implemented in the programs 3DNA and Curves+, are outlined from a common perspective. Recently developed rigid base and basepair models with nonlocal quadratic interactions are presented. A statistical mechanical description of the models on their full phase space yields exact relations between model parameters and expected values of some state functions. We estimated shape and stiffness parameters for nonlocal rigid base and basepair models of a DNA oligomer containing A-tract. The parameterization is based on atomic-resolution molecular dynamics simulation data. We found that the rigid base model is consistent with a local interaction pattern, while interactions in the rigid basepair model are visibly non-local, in agreement with earlier findings. Differences in shape and stiffness parameters obtained using Curves+ and 3DNA coordinates are found to be small for structures within the B-DNA family. Anharmonic effects, coarser models, and other approaches to describe nucleic acid structure and flexibility are discussed.

From crystal and NMR structures, footprints and cryo-electron-micrographs to large and soft structures: nanoscale modeling of the nucleosomal stem

The interaction of histone H1 with linker DNA results in the formation of the nucleosomal stem structure, with considerable influence on chromatin organization. In a recent paper [Syed,S.H., Goutte-Gattat,D., Becker,N., Meyer,S., Shukla,M.S., Hayes,J.J., Everaers,R., Angelov,D., Bednar,J. and Dimitrov,S. (2010) Single-base resolution mapping of H1-nucleosome interactions and 3D organization of the nucleosome. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 107, 9620-9625], we published results of biochemical footprinting and cryo-electron-micrographs of reconstituted mono-, di- and tri-nucleosomes, for H1 variants with different lengths of the cationic C-terminus. Here, we present a detailed account of the analysis of the experimental data and we include thermal fluctuations into our nano-scale model of the stem structure. By combining (i) crystal and NMR structures of the nucleosome core particle and H1, (ii) the known nano-scale structure and elasticity of DNA, (iii) footprinting information on the location of protected sites on the DNA backbone and (iv) cryo-electron micrographs of reconstituted tri-nucleosomes, we arrive at a description of a polymorphic, hierarchically organized stem with a typical length of 20 ± 2 base pairs. A comparison to linker conformations inferred for poly-601 fibers with different linker lengths suggests, that intra-stem interactions stabilize and facilitate the formation of dense chromatin fibers.

Statistical investigation of position-specific deformation pattern of nucleosome DNA based on multiple conformational properties

The histone octamer induced bending of DNA into the super-helix structure in nucleosome core particle, is very unique and vital for DNA packing into chromatin. We collected 48 nucleosome crystal structures from PDB and applied a multivariate analysis on the nucleosome structural data. Based on the anisotropic nature of DNA structure, a principal conformational subspace (PCS) is derived from multiple properties to represent the most significant variances of nucleosome DNA structures. The coupling of base pair-oriented parameters with sugar phosphate backbone parameters presented in principal dimensionalities reveals two main deformation modes that have supplemented the existing physical model. By using sequence alignment-based statistics, a positiondependent conformational map for the super-helical DNA path is established. The result shows that the crystal structures of nucleosome DNA have much consistency in position-specific structural variations and certain periodicity is found to exist in these variations. Thus, the positions with obvious deformation patterns along the DNA path in nucleosome core particle are relatively conservative from the perspective of statistics.