Variability of Protein Structure Models from Electron Microscopy

In situ architecture of the ER-mitochondria encounter structure

The endoplasmic reticulum and mitochondria are main hubs of eukaryotic membrane biogenesis that rely on lipid exchange via membrane contact sites^1-3, but the underpinning mechanisms remain poorly understood. In yeast, tethering and lipid transfer between the two organelles is mediated by the endoplasmic reticulum-mitochondria encounter structure (ERMES), a four-subunit complex of unresolved stoichiometry and architecture^4-6. Here we determined the molecular organization of ERMES within Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells using integrative structural biology by combining quantitative live imaging, cryo-correlative microscopy, subtomogram averaging and molecular modelling. We found that ERMES assembles into approximately 25 discrete bridge-like complexes distributed irregularly across a contact site. Each bridge consists of three synaptotagmin-like mitochondrial lipid binding protein domains oriented in a zig-zag arrangement. Our molecular model of ERMES reveals a pathway for lipids. These findings resolve the in situ supramolecular architecture of a major inter-organelle lipid transfer machinery and provide a basis for the mechanistic understanding of lipid fluxes in eukaryotic cells.

Macromolecular refinement of X-ray and cryoelectron microscopy structures with Phenix/OPLS3e for improved structure and ligand quality

With the advent of the resolution revolution in cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM), low-resolution refinement is common, and likewise increases the need for a reliable force field. Here, we report on the incorporation of the OPLS3e force field with the VSGB2.1 solvation model in the structure determination package Phenix. Our results show significantly improved structure quality and reduced ligand strain at lower resolution for X-ray refinement. For refinement of cryo-EM-based structures, we find comparable quality structures, goodness-of-fit, and reduced ligand strain. We also show how structure quality and ligand strain are related to the map-model cross-correlation as a function of data weight, and how that can detect overfitting. Signs of overfitting are found in over half of our cryo-EM dataset, which can be remedied by a re-refinement at a lower data weight. Finally, a start-to-end script for refining structures with Phenix/OPLS3e is available in the Schrödinger 2020-3 distribution.

Simulation-Based Methods for Model Building and Refinement in Cryoelectron Microscopy

Advances in cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM) have revolutionized the structural investigation of large macromolecular assemblies. In this review, we first provide a broad overview of modeling methods used for flexible fitting of molecular models into cryo-EM density maps. We give special attention to approaches rooted in molecular simulations-atomistic molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo. Concise descriptions of the methods are given along with discussion of their advantages, limitations, and most popular alternatives. We also describe recent extensions of the widely used molecular dynamics flexible fitting (MDFF) method and discuss how different model-building techniques could be incorporated into new hybrid modeling schemes and simulation workflows. Finally, we provide two illustrative examples of model-building and refinement strategies employing MDFF, cascade MDFF, and RosettaCM. These examples come from recent cryo-EM studies that elucidated transcription preinitiation complexes and shed light on the functional roles of these assemblies in gene expression and gene regulation.

Protein secondary structure detection in intermediate-resolution cryo-EM maps using deep learning

An increasing number of protein structures have been solved by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). Although structures determined at near-atomic resolution are now routinely reported, many density maps are still determined at an intermediate resolution, where extracting structure information is still a challenge. We have developed a computational method, Emap2sec, which identifies the secondary structures of proteins (α helices, β sheets, and other structures) in an EM map of 5 to 10 Å resolution. Emap2sec uses a 3D deep convolutional neural network to assign secondary structure to each grid point in an EM map. We tested Emap2sec on 6.0 and 10.0 Å resolution EM maps simulated from 34 structures, as well as on 43 maps determined experimentally at 5.0 to 9.5 Å resolution. Emap2sec was able to clearly identify the secondary structures in many maps tested, and showed substantially better performance than existing methods.

Constructing atomic structural models into cryo-EM densities using molecular dynamics - Pros and cons

Accurate structure determination from electron density maps at 3-5 Å resolution necessitates a balance between extensive global and local sampling of atomistic models, yet with the stereochemical correctness of backbone and sidechain geometries. Molecular Dynamics Flexible Fitting (MDFF), particularly through a resolution-exchange scheme, ReMDFF, provides a robust way of achieving this balance for hybrid structure determination. Employing two high-resolution density maps, namely that of β-galactosidase at 3.2 Å and TRPV1 at 3.4 Å, we showcase the quality of ReMDFF-generated models, comparing them against ones submitted by independent research groups for the 2015-2016 Cryo-EM Model Challenge. This comparison offers a clear evaluation of ReMDFF's strengths and shortcomings, and those of data-guided real-space refinements in general. ReMDFF results scored highly on the various metric for judging the quality-of-fit and quality-of-model. However, some systematic discrepancies are also noted employing a Molprobity analysis, that are reproducible across multiple competition entries. A space of key refinement parameters is explored within ReMDFF to observe their impact within the final model. Choice of force field parameters and initial model seem to have the most significant impact on ReMDFF model-quality. To this end, very recently developed CHARMM36m force field parameters provide now more refined ReMDFF models than the ones originally submitted to the Cryo-EM challenge. Finally, a set of good-practices is prescribed for the community to benefit from the MDFF developments.

De novo main-chain modeling with MAINMAST in 2015/2016 EM Model Challenge

Protein tertiary structure modeling is a critical step for the interpretation of three dimensional (3D) election microscopy density. Our group participated the 2015/2016 EM Model Challenge using the MAINMAST software for a de novo main chain modeling. The software generates local dense points using the mean shifting algorithm, and connects them into Cα models by calculating the minimum spanning tree and the longest path. Subsequently, full atom structure models are generated, which are subject to structural refinement. Here, we summarize the qualities of our submitted models and examine successful and unsuccessful models, including 3D models we did not submit to the Challenge. Our protocol using the MAINMAST software was sometimes able to build correct conformations with 3.4–5.1 Å RMSD. Unsuccessful models had failure of chain traces, however, their Cα positions and some local structures were quite correctly built. For evaluate the quality of the models, the MAINMAST software provides a confidence score for each Cα position from the consensus of top 100 scoring models.

CryoEM-based hybrid modeling approaches for structure determination

Recent advances in cryo-electron microscopy (cryoEM) have dramatically improved the resolutions at which vitrified biological specimens can be studied, revealing new structural and mechanistic insights over a broad range of spatial scales. Bolstered by these advances, much effort has been directed toward the development of hybrid modeling methodologies for the construction and refinement of high-fidelity atomistic models from cryoEM data. In this brief review, we will survey the key elements of cryoEM-based hybrid modeling, providing an overview of available computational tools and strategies as well as several recent applications.

De novo main-chain modeling for EM maps using MAINMAST

An increasing number of protein structures are determined by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) at near atomic resolution. However, tracing the main-chains and building full-atom models from EM maps of ~4-5 Å is still not trivial and remains a time-consuming task. Here, we introduce a fully automated de novo structure modeling method, MAINMAST, which builds three-dimensional models of a protein from a near-atomic resolution EM map. The method directly traces the protein's main-chain and identifies Cα positions as tree-graph structures in the EM map. MAINMAST performs significantly better than existing software in building global protein structure models on data sets of 40 simulated density maps at 5 Å resolution and 30 experimentally determined maps at 2.6-4.8 Å resolution. In another benchmark of building missing fragments in protein models for EM maps, MAINMAST builds fragments of 11-161 residues long with an average RMSD of 2.68 Å.