Endocrine surgeons are performing more thyroid lobectomies for low-risk differentiated thyroid cancer since the 2015 ATA guidelines

Tailoring TSH suppression in differentiated thyroid carcinoma: evidence, controversies, and future directions

PURPOSE

This review focus on the controversial benefits of thyroid hormone suppression therapy (THST) in differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) and its associated risks, highlighting the need for individualized strategies to optimize therapeutic outcomes and guide future research.

METHODS

A systematic literature search on TSH suppression in DTC over the past 10 years was conducted, prioritizing RCTs, large cohort studies, and non-inferiority trials, with additional references identified from retrieved articles.

RESULTS

Tailored postoperative TSH strategies should consider factors such as risk stratification, treatment modality, histologic subtype, and adverse effect risks. In this context, mechanistic studies offer potential insights that could inform personalized TSH management, though further validation is required. Clinical evidence on THST in DTC remains controversial, particularly for high-risk patients, where support for stringent TSH suppression (<0.1 mU/L) is limited. Data for intermediate-risk DTC are insufficient due to cohort heterogeneity, while TSH suppression in low-risk DTC is largely discouraged. The well-documented adverse effects of excessive THST, including cardiovascular complications and osteoporosis, further provide a strong rationale against its routine use. Additionally, achieving and maintaining target TSH levels in real-world practice remains challenging, underscoring the need for refined approaches.

CONCLUSION

Current evidence provides limited support for the TSH targets recommended by the 2015 ATA guidelines. Optimizing postoperative TSH management should account for individualized factors, including risk stratification, treatment modalities, histologic subtypes, and susceptibility to adverse effects. Future research should prioritize well-designed studies with clearly defined suppression levels and appropriate confounder adjustments, emphasizing personalized approaches to balance therapeutic benefits and adverse effects.

Reoperation Rates After Initial Thyroid Lobectomy for Patients with Thyroid Cancer: A National Cohort Study

Introduction: The 2015 American Thyroid Association (ATA) guidelines recommended thyroid lobectomy (TL) as an alternative to total thyroidectomy (TT) for the surgical treatment of low-risk differentiated thyroid cancer. Increasing use of TL has since been reported despite concerns for an increased risk of disease recurrence and need for reoperation. This study sought to compare reoperation rates among patients who underwent initial TL or TT for malignancy, characterize trends at centers based on operative volume, and examine factors associated with reoperation. Methods: We queried the Vizient Clinical Data Base for TL and TT performed preguideline change (pre-GC = 2013-2015) and postguideline change (post-GC = 2016-2021). Reoperations included reoperative thyroid surgery (RTS) and neck dissection (ND); timing was defined as early (≤180 days), thought to indicate inadequacy of initial operative choice, or late (>180 days), suggesting potential disease recurrence. Results: Of 65,627 patients, 31.8% underwent initial TL and 68.2% underwent initial TT; TL increased from 21.4% of total cases pre-GC to 37.0% post-GC (p < 0.001). Among TL patients, early RTS declined from 33.9% to 14.2% and ND declined from 0.8% to 0.4% (p < 0.001). Among TT patients, early RTS remained 0.2%, while ND increased from 0.4% to 0.7% (p < 0.001). TL-associated late RTS declined from 2.0% to 1.7%, while ND increased from 0.6% to 0.8% (p = 0.17). In TT patients, both late RTS and ND increased, from 0.2% to 0.3% (p = 0.04) and 1.7% to 2.1% (p < 0.01), respectively. There was no difference in the late reoperation rate for TL compared with TT post-GC (+0.2%, p = 0.18). TL volume grew annually by 12.5% [8.9-16.2%] at high-volume centers (HVCs) and 8.3% [5.6-11.1%] at low-volume centers (LVCs). TL-associated reoperations at HVCs declined annually by 12.6% [5.6-19.0%] and 10.8% [2.7-18.1%] at LVCs. Uninsured status and more recent initial operation were associated with an increased risk of late reoperation (HR = 1.84 [1.06-3.20] and HR = 1.30 [1.24-1.36], respectively). The type of index operation performed, however, was not predictive of late reoperation. Conclusions: The rate of early reoperations declined for TL after the 2015 ATA guideline release, but late reoperations remained unchanged despite a significant shift in practice patterns towards initial lobectomy. Patients appear to be receiving less aggressive, guideline-concordant care without a significant increase in the late reoperation rate for TL compared with TT.

Changes in Clinical Practice in Adherence to the 2014 American Thyroid Association Guidelines on Thyroid Cancer: A Retrospective Study from a Tertiary Referral Center

Thyroidectomy, a pivotal treatment for various thyroid disorders, has seen its indications evolve, particularly with the 2014 American Thyroid Association (ATA) Guidelines advocating for conservative surgical approaches like lobectomy. This retrospective study analyzes thyroidectomy practices at a high-volume center from January 2014 to December 2023, focusing on patients potentially eligible for lobectomy per ATA guidelines. The inclusion criteria were tumors < 4 cm, indeterminate thyroid nodules, or differentiated thyroid carcinoma with clinically uninvolved lymph nodes (cN0). This study analyzed the proportion of patients undergoing lobectomy versus total thyroidectomy (TT) and the oncological outcomes. Of 357 patients, 243 underwent TT and 114 underwent lobectomy. The prevalence of lobectomies rose markedly, comprising 73.9% of surgeries in 2023. TT patients were predominantly female (83.5%) and had higher rates of autoimmune thyroiditis (67.5%) and malignancy (89.7%). Lobectomy patients had larger nodules and more indeterminate cytology. Among 301 malignant cases, TT was associated with higher lymph node metastasis, but similar recurrence rates, compared to lobectomy. This study underscores a shift towards lobectomy, reflecting adherence to ATA guidelines and suggesting conservative surgery is feasible without compromising outcomes. Further research on long-term outcomes and refined patient selection criteria is needed to optimize surgical approaches.

Nerve monitoring in endocrine surgery: Practice patterns differ among surgeons for parathyroidectomy and thyroidectomy

BACKGROUND

It is unknown whether intraoperative nerve monitoring is associated with reduced vocal cord dysfunction after parathyroidectomy. We aimed to investigate intraoperative nerve monitoring use among Collaborative Endocrine Surgery Quality Improvement Program surgeons and factors associated with vocal cord dysfunction after parathyroidectomy.

METHODS

Patients who underwent parathyroidectomy included in the Collaborative Endocrine Surgery Quality Improvement Program (2014-2022) were identified. The annual percent change in parathyroidectomies performed with intraoperative nerve monitoring was calculated using joinpoint regression. Multivariable logistic regression was used to compare outcomes between patients undergoing parathyroidectomy with/without intraoperative nerve monitoring. To compare surgeon-specific trends, Collaborative Endocrine Surgery Quality Improvement Program thyroidectomy and parathyroidectomy datasets (2014-2021) were combined. Parathyroidectomies performed by surgeons who used intraoperative nerve monitoring consistently in thyroidectomy were identified. Factors associated with intraoperative nerve monitoring were examined using multivariable logistic regression.

RESULTS

A total of 9,813 patients underwent parathyroidectomy. Intraoperative nerve monitoring was used in 49% of cases (n = 4,818). There was an increase in parathyroidectomies with intraoperative nerve monitoring from 2014 to 2018 (annual percent change 22.2, P = .01), followed by a plateau (2018-2022 annual percent change -0.66, P = .85). Few patients (0.44%, n = 43) developed vocal cord dysfunction. Vocal cord dysfunction was not associated with intraoperative nerve monitoring (adjusted odds ratio 0.92, P = .75). Whereas 41% (n = 56/138) of surgeons used intraoperative nerve monitoring routinely in parathyroidectomy, 65% (n = 90/138) used it routinely in thyroidectomy. Among surgeons who used intraoperative nerve monitoring routinely in thyroidectomy, only 57% used it routinely in parathyroidectomy; factors associated with intraoperative nerve monitoring during parathyroidectomy included reoperation (adjusted odds ratio 2.51, P < .01), secondary/tertiary hyperparathyroidism (adjusted odds ratio 1.42, P = .02), multiglandular disease (adjusted odds ratio 1.76, P < .001), and non-localized disease (adjusted odds ratio 1.65, P < .001).

CONCLUSION

Endocrine surgeons use intraoperative nerve monitoring selectively. Surgeons who routinely use intraoperative nerve monitoring during thyroidectomy are more likely to use it during parathyroidectomy. Future studies should determine who may benefit most from intraoperative nerve monitoring in parathyroidectomy.

Behavioral Interventions on Surgeons' Preoperative Decision-Making: A Scoping Review and Critical Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Consensus is lacking regarding the optimal strategy to influence surgeons' behaviors to reduce low-value surgical care. Comprehensively describing the existing body of literature that seeks to intervene on surgeons' preoperative decision-making may aid in structuring future behavior change strategies.

METHODS

We performed a scoping review using four databases (Medical Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online, Embase, Web of Science, and Cumulated Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature) for articles that tested the effect of behavioral-based interventions on any aspect of surgeons' decision-making in the preoperative setting. Abstracted data were characterized by summative descriptions and analyzed using the Tailored Implementation for Chronic Disease framework, mapping aspects of deimplementation strategies in the studies onto the determinant(s) that they altered. Data abstraction and mapping tools were piloted and iteratively revised before two researchers independently assessing studies and categorizing determinants, and then meeting to discuss their decisions.

RESULTS

There were 1460 articles identified from the initial search, with 17 full text articles ultimately included in the scoping review. Eight studies relied on a multidisciplinary preoperative conference to accomplish their aims, while five were multifaceted in their approach to deimplementation, and four studies used only a clinical decision support tool to accomplish their aims. Mapping determinants addressed in these studies onto the Tailored Implementation for Chronic Disease framework demonstrated that most strategies attempted to close knowledge gaps, leverage communication between providers, and broadcast institutional prioritization of change.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a small but growing field of implementation and deimplementation strategies in preoperative surgical decision-making, and different approaches may be equally effective in varied clinical contexts. Deliberate measurement and comparison of outcomes, as well as selection of control groups, are areas for improvement in future work.

Health-Related Quality of Life in Patients with Low-Risk Differentiated Thyroid Cancer: A Systematic Review Examining the Extent of Thyroidectomy

Background: Total thyroidectomy (TT) and hemithyroidectomy (HT) are acceptable surgical options for the treatment of low-risk differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC). While previous data suggest similar disease-free and disease-specific survival regardless of initial surgical treatment, the effect of the extent of surgery on health-related quality of life (HRQOL) is less clear. This systematic review aimed to examine HRQOL in low-risk DTC survivors after TT compared with HT. Methods: A search of PubMed, CINAHL, Cochrane, PsycINFO, and Scopus databases was conducted to identify studies published between January 1, 2011, and December 31, 2022, that assessed HRQOL predominantly in patients with low-risk DTC who underwent open thyroid surgery. Covidence™ software was used to apply the inclusion criteria, and a validated instrument was used to assess study quality. Results: Sixteen of the 1402 identified studies were included: 5 prospective and 11 retrospective cohort studies. The majority of included studies were of good quality (n = 14) and were from Asia and the Middle East (n = 11). Overall, six studies concluded that HT led to a better HRQOL than TT, two concluded that HT only resulted in better HRQOL compared with TT with central neck dissection (CND), and two concluded HT resulted in better short-term HRQOL that dissipated by 6 months postoperatively. The HRQOL domains found across all studies to be most consistently improved after HT included physical health, psychological/emotional, and social function. Factors found to be associated with HRQOL in more than one study included age, stage, and marital status. Conclusion: Differences in HRQOL after HT and TT tended to favor HT particularly when measured <6 months after surgery or when compared with TT with CND. Additional prospective and ideally randomized data are needed to fully determine the impact of the extent of surgery on HRQOL in patients with low-risk thyroid cancer.

Exploring the oral-gut microbiota during thyroid cancer: Factors affecting the thyroid functions and cancer development

Thyroid cancer (TC) is categorized into papillary, follicular, medullary, and anaplastic. The TC is increasing in several countries, including China, the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, France, Australia, Germany, Japan, Spain, and Italy. Thus, this review comprehensively covers the factors that affect thyroid gland function, TC types, risk factors, and symptoms. Lifestyle factors (such as nutrient consumption and smoking) and pollutants (such as chemicals and heavy metals) increased the thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) levels which are directly related to TC prevalence. The conventional and recent TC treatments are also highlighted. The role of the oral and gut microbiota as well as the application of probiotics on TC are also discussed. The variations in the composition of oral and gut microbes influence the thyroid function indirectly through alteration in metabolites (such as short-chain fatty acids) that are eminent for cellular energy metabolism. Maintenance of healthy gut and oral microbiota can help in regulating thyroid function by regulating iodine uptake. Oral or gut microbial dysbiosis can be considered as an early diagnosis factor or TC marker. High TSH during TC can increase the oral microbial diversity while disrupting the high ratio of Firmicutes and Bacteroidetes in the gut. Supplementation of probiotics as an adjuvant in TC treatment is beneficial. However, needs more extensive research to explore the direct effect of probiotics on thyroid function.

Prognostic Value of Preoperative Molecular Testing and Implications for Initial Surgical Management in Thyroid Nodules Harboring Suspected (Bethesda V) or Known (Bethesda VI) Papillary Thyroid Cancer

Importance

Molecular testing is commonly used in the diagnosis of thyroid nodules with indeterminate cytology. The role of molecular testing in prognosticating oncologic outcomes in thyroid nodules with suspicious or malignant cytology is unclear.

Objective

To determine whether molecular profiling of Bethesda V (suspicious for thyroid cancer) and VI (thyroid cancer) nodules is associated with improved prognostication and whether it may inform initial treatment.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This retrospective cohort study included consecutive patients with Bethesda V or VI nodules who underwent surgery, with histopathology showing differentiated thyroid cancer, between May 1, 2016, and July 31, 2019 in the University of California, Los Angeles health system. Data were analyzed between April 2, 2021, and January 18, 2023.

Exposures

Masked ThyroSeq, version 3 molecular analysis after completion of initial treatment and acquisition of follow-up data.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Structural disease persistence or recurrence, distant metastasis, and recurrence-free survival were assessed using ThyroSeq Cancer Risk Classifier (CRC) molecular risk groups (low, RAS-like; intermediate, BRAF-like; high, combination of BRAF/RAS plus TERT or other high-risk alterations) using Cox proportional hazards regression models.

Results

In 105 patients with papillary thyroid cancer (median [IQR] follow-up, 3.8 [3.0-4.7] years), ThyroSeq identified genomic alterations in 100 (95%) samples (6 [6%] low risk, 88 [88%] intermediate risk, and 6 [6%] high risk; median [IQR] age, 44 [34-56] years; 68 [68%] female and 32 [32%] male). No patients with low-risk or negative results experienced recurrence. Of the 88 patients with intermediate risk, 6 (7%) experienced local recurrence, with 1 of them also developing distant metastasis. The 6 patients with high risk (all with BRAF V600E plus TERT mutation) underwent total thyroidectomy followed by radioactive iodine (RAI) ablation. Four patients with high risk (67%) experienced local recurrence, with 3 of them also developing distant metastasis. Thus, patients with high-risk alterations were more likely to experience persistence or recurrence and distant metastasis than patients with intermediate risk. In a multivariable analysis incorporating patient age, sex, cancer size, ThyroSeq molecular risk group, extrathyroidal extension, lymph node positivity, American Thyroid Association risk, and RAI ablation, only cancer size (hazard ratio, 1.36; 95% CI, 1.02-1.80) and ThyroSeq CRC molecular risk group (high vs intermediate and low: hazard ratio, 6.22; 95% CI, 1.04-37.36) were associated with structural recurrence.

Conclusions and Relevance

Among the 6% of patients with high-risk ThyroSeq CRC alterations in this cohort study, the majority experienced recurrence or distant metastasis despite initial treatment with total thyroidectomy and RAI ablation. In contrast, patients with low- and intermediate-risk alterations had a low recurrence rate. Preoperative knowledge of molecular alteration status at diagnosis may allow for deescalation of initial surgery and refining of the intensity of postoperative surveillance in patients presenting with Bethesda V and VI thyroid nodules.

Current Controversies in Low-Risk Differentiated Thyroid Cancer: Reducing Overtreatment in an Era of Overdiagnosis

CONTEXT

Low-risk differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) is overdiagnosed, but true incidence has increased as well. Owing to its excellent prognosis with low morbidity and mortality, balancing treatment risks with risks of disease progression can be challenging, leading to several areas of controversy.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

This mini-review is an overview of controversies and difficult decisions around the management of all stages of low-risk DTC, from diagnosis through treatment and follow-up. In particular, overdiagnosis, active surveillance vs surgery, extent of surgery, radioactive iodine (RAI) treatment, thyrotropin suppression, and postoperative surveillance are discussed.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

Recommendations regarding the diagnosis of DTC, the extent of treatment for low-risk DTC patients, and the intensity of posttreatment follow-up have all changed substantially in the past decade. While overdiagnosis remains a problem, there has been a true increase in incidence as well. Treatment options range from active surveillance of small tumors to total thyroidectomy followed by RAI in select cases. Recommendations for long-term surveillance frequency and duration are similarly broad.

CONCLUSION

Clinicians and patients must approach each case in a personalized and nuanced fashion to select the appropriate extent of treatment on an individual basis. In areas of evidential equipoise, data regarding patient-centered outcomes may help guide decision-making.