Recent Advances in Gas-phase Ion/Ion Chemistry for Lipid Analysis

Light-Reactive Norharmane Derivatization of Lipid Isomers by Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization Mass Spectrometry

The lipidome, encompassing the comprehensive lipid fingerprint of a biological system, includes thousands of unique isomeric and isobaric lipid species. Mass spectrometry (MS) is an effective technique for characterizing the lipidome, although the resolution of isomeric lipid species through MS typically requires specialized or modified equipment. In this study, we introduce a novel matrix derivatization technique that leverages the unique photoreactive properties of unsaturated lipids to reveal the double-bond location in conventional matrix-assisted laser desorption-ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) experiments. The principle mechanistic framework of this technique is type II photosensitization, where the MALDI matrix norharmane acts as an organic photosensitizer to generate singlet oxygen upon light exposure. The singlet oxygen then reacts with unsaturated lipid species, forming hydroperoxide derivatives at acyl group carbon double bonds, facilitating their identification. The labile nature of these hydroperoxide-functionalized lipids allows for further decomposition under normal MALDI laser exposure, enhancing the analytical resolution of isomeric lipids without additional experiments. With this approach, we were able to distinguish the 18:1 (Δ6-cis) and 18:1 (Δ9-cis) PC lipid isomers. We also demonstrated that the approach works in an imaging context, mapping lipid species in both mouse tissue and 3D cell cultures.

Glial Biologist's Guide to Mass Spectrometry-Based Lipidomics: A Tutorial From Sample Preparation to Data Analysis

Neurological diseases are associated with disruptions in the brain lipidome that are becoming central to disease pathogenesis. Traditionally perceived as static structural support in membranes, lipids are now known to be actively involved in cellular signaling, energy metabolism, and other cellular activities involving membrane curvature, fluidity, fusion or fission. Glia are critical in the development, health, and function of the brain, and glial regulation plays a major role in disease. The major pathways of glial dysregulation related to function are associated with downstream products of metabolism including lipids. Taking advantage of significant innovations and technical advancements in instrumentation, lipidomics has emerged as a popular omics discipline, serving as the prevailing approach to comprehensively define metabolic alterations associated with organismal development, damage or disease. A key technological platform for lipidomics studies is mass spectrometry (MS), as it affords large-scale profiling of complex biological samples. However, as MS-based techniques are often refined and advanced, the relative comfort level among biologists with this instrumentation has not followed suit. In this review, we aim to highlight the importance of the study of glial lipids and to provide a concise record of best practices and steps for MS-based lipidomics. Specifically, we outline procedures for glia lipidomics workflows ranging from sample collection and extraction to mass spectrometric analysis to data interpretation. To ensure these approaches are more accessible, this tutorial aims to familiarize glia biologists with sample handling and analysis techniques for MS-based lipidomics, and to guide non-experts toward generating high quality lipidomics data.

Altering Lipid A Precursor Ion Types in the Gas Phase for In-Depth Structural Elucidation via Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Lipid A, a well-known saccharolipid, acts as the inner lipid-glycan anchor of lipopolysaccharides in Gram-negative bacterial cell membranes and functions as an endotoxin. Its structure is composed of two glucosamines with β(1 → 6) linkages and various fatty acyl and phosphate groups. The lipid A structure can be used for the identification of bacterial species, but its complexity poses significant structural characterization challenges. In this work, we present a comprehensive strategy combining condensed-phase sample preparation, electrospray ionization, and gas-phase ion/ion reactions with tandem mass spectrometry for detailed lipid A structural elucidation. We use proton transfer reactions, charge-inversion reactions, and sequential ion/ion reactions for magnesium transfer to generate targeted lipid A ions. The strategy, established with a synthetic monophosphoryl lipid A (MPLA) and known MPLA and diphosphorylated lipid A (DPLA) from Escherichia coli F583, demonstrated that [MPLA - 2H]2-, [MPLA - H]-, and [MPLA - H + Mg]+ precursor ions offer complementary information for MPLA, while [DPLA - H]-, [DPLA + H]+, and [DPLA - H + Mg]+ precursor ions provide analogous information for DPLA analysis. We validated the strategy using known lipid A species and also successfully applied this strategy to profile unknown MPLA and DPLA in the same E. coli strain.

Enhancing Spatial Resolution in Tandem Mass Spectrometry Ion/Ion Reaction Imaging Experiments through Image Fusion

We have recently developed a charge inversion ion/ion reaction to selectively derivatize phosphatidylserine lipids via gas-phase Schiff base formation. This tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) workflow enables the separation and detection of isobaric lipids in imaging mass spectrometry, but the images acquired using this workflow are limited to relatively poor spatial resolutions due to the current time and limit of detection requirements for these ion/ion reaction imaging mass spectrometry experiments. This trade-off between chemical specificity and spatial resolution can be overcome by using computational image fusion, which combines complementary information from multiple images. Herein, we demonstrate a proof-of-concept workflow that fuses a low spatial resolution (i.e., 125 μm) ion/ion reaction product ion image with higher spatial resolution (i.e., 25 μm) ion images from a full scan experiment performed using the same tissue section, which results in a predicted ion/ion reaction product ion image with a 5-fold improvement in spatial resolution. Linear regression, random forest regression, and two-dimensional convolutional neural network (2-D CNN) predictive models were tested for this workflow. Linear regression and 2D CNN models proved optimal for predicted ion/ion images of PS 40:6 and SHexCer d38:1, respectively.

Sequencing of Phosphopeptides Using a Sequential Charge Inversion Ion/Ion Reaction and Electron Capture Dissociation Workflow

Protein phosphorylation, a common post-translational modification (PTM), is fundamental in a plethora of biological processes, most importantly in modulating cell signaling pathways. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) is an attractive method for phosphopeptide characterization due to its high speed, low limit of detection, and surface sampling capabilities. However, MALDI analysis of phosphopeptides is constrained by relatively low abundances in biological samples and poor relative ionization efficiencies in positive ion mode. Additionally, MALDI tends to produce singly charged ions, generally limiting the accessible MS/MS techniques that can be used for peptide sequencing. For example, collision induced dissociation (CID) is readily amendable to the analysis of singly charged ions, but results in facile loss of phosphoric acid, precluding the localization of the PTM. Electron-based dissociation methods (e.g., electron capture dissociation, ECD) are well suited for PTM localization, but require multiply charged peptide cations to avoid neutralization during ECD. Conversely, phosphopeptides are readily ionized using MALDI in negative ion mode. If the precursor ions are first formed in negative ion mode, a gas-phase charge inversion ion/ion reaction could then be used to transform the phosphopeptide anions produced via MALDI into multiply charged cations that are well-suited for ECD. Herein we demonstrate a multistep workflow combining a charge inversion ion/ion reaction that first transforms MALDI-generated phosphopeptide monoanions into multiply charged cations, and then subjects these multiply charged phosphopeptide cations to ECD for sequence determination and phosphate bond localization.

Structural characterization of fatty acid anions via gas-phase charge inversion using Mg(tri-butyl-terpyridine)2 2+ reagent ions

RATIONALE

Free fatty acids and lipid classes containing fatty acid esters are major components of lipidome. In the absence of a chemical derivatization step, FA anions do not yield all of the structural information that may be of interest under commonly used collision-induced dissociation (CID) conditions. A line of work that avoids condensed-phase derivatization takes advantage of gas-phase ion/ion chemistry to charge invert FA anions to an ion type that provides the structural information of interest using conventional CID. This work was motivated by the potential for significant improvement in overall efficiency for obtaining FA chain structural information.

METHODS

A hybrid triple quadrupole/linear ion-trap tandem mass spectrometer that has been modified to enable the execution of ion/ion reaction experiments was used to evaluate the use of 4,4',4″-tri-tert-butyl-2,2':6',2″-terpyridine (ttb-Terpy) as the ligand in divalent magnesium complexes for charge inversion of FA anions.

RESULTS

Mg(ttb-Terpy)2 2+ complexes provide significantly improved efficiency in producing structurally informative products from FA ions relative to Mg(Terpy)2 2+ complexes, as demonstrated for straight-chain FAs, branched-chain FAs, unsaturated FAs, and cyclopropane-containing FAs. It was discovered that most of the structurally informative fragmentation from [FA-H + Mg(ttb-Terpy)]+ results from the loss of a methyl radical from the ligand followed by radical-directed dissociation (RDD), which stands in contrast to the charge-remote fragmentation (CRF) believed to be operative with the [FA-H + Mg(Terpy)]+ ions.

CONCLUSIONS

This work demonstrates that a large fraction of product ions from the CID of ions of the form [FA-H + Mg(ttb-Terpy)]+ are derived from RDD of the FA backbone, with a very minor fraction arising from structurally uninformative dissociation channels. This ligand provides an alternative to previously used ligands for the structural characterization of FAs via CRF.

Lipid Isobaric Mass Tagging for Enhanced Relative Quantification of Unsaturated sn-Positional Isomers

Changes in the levels of lipid sn-positional isomers are associated with perturbation of the physiological environment within the biological system. Consequently, knowing the concentrations of these lipids holds significant importance for unraveling their involvement in disease diagnosis and pathological mechanisms. However, existing methods for lipid quantification often fall short in accuracy due to the structural diversity and isomeric forms of lipids. To address this challenge, we have developed an aziridine-based isobaric tag labeling strategy that allows (i) differentiation and (ii) enhanced relative quantification of lipid sn-positional isomers from distinct samples in a single run. The methodology enabled by aziridination, isobaric tag labeling, and lithiation has been applied to various phospholipids, enabling the determination of the sn-positions of fatty acyl chains and enhanced relative quantification. The analysis of Escherichia coli lipid extracts demonstrated the enhanced determination of the concentration ratios of lipid isomers by measuring the intensity ratios of mass reporters released from sn-positional diagnostic ions. Moreover, we applied the method to the analysis of human colon cancer plasma. Intriguingly, 17 PC lipid sn-positional isomers were identified and quantified simultaneously, and among them, 7 showed significant abundance changes in the colon cancer plasma, which can be used as potential plasma markers for diagnosis of human colon cancer.

Gas-Phase Ion/Ion Reactions to Enable Radical-Directed Dissociation of Fatty Acid Ions: Application to Localization of Methyl Branching

Methyl branching on the carbon chains of fatty acids and fatty esters is among the structural variations encountered with fatty acids and fatty esters. Branching in fatty acid/ester chains is particularly prominent in bacterial species and, for example, in vernix caseosa and sebum. The distinction of branched chains from isomeric straight-chain species and the localization of branching can be challenging to determine by mass spectrometry (MS). Condensed-phase derivatization strategies, often used in conjunction with separations, are most commonly used to address the identification and characterization of branched fatty acids. In this work, a gas-phase ion/ion strategy is presented that obviates condensed-phase derivatization and introduces a radical site into fatty acid ions to facilitate radical-directed dissociation (RDD). The gas-phase approach is also directly amenable to fatty acid anions generated via collision-induced dissociation from lipid classes that contain fatty esters. Specifically, divalent magnesium complexes bound to two terpyridine ligands that each incorporate a ((2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-1-piperidine-1-yl)oxy) (TEMPO) moiety are used to charge-invert fatty acid anions. Following the facile loss of one of the ligands and the TEMPO group of the remaining ligand, a radical site is introduced into the complex. Subsequent collision-induced dissociation (CID) of the complex exhibits preferred cleavages that localize the site(s) of branching. The approach is illustrated with iso-, anteiso-, and isoprenoid branched-chain fatty acids and an intact glycerophospholipid and is applied to a mixture of branched- and straight-chain fatty acids derived from Bacillus subtilis.

Mass Spectrometry-based Single-Cell Lipidomics: Advancements, Challenges, and the Path Forward

In the past decade, lipidomics, now recognized as standalone subdiscipline of metabolomics, has gained considerable attention. Due to its sensitivity and unparalleled versatility, mass spectrometry (MS) has emerged as the tool of choice for lipid identification and detection. Traditional MS-based lipidomics are performed on bulk cell samples. While informative, these bulk-scale cellular lipidome measurements mask cellular heterogeneity across seemingly homogeneous populations of cells. Unfortunately, single cell lipidomics methodology and analyses are considerably behind genomics, transcriptomics, and proteomics. Therefore, the cell-to-cell heterogeneity and related function remains largely unexplored for lipidomics. Herein, we review recent advances in MS-based single cell lipidomics. We also explore the root causes for the slow development of single-cell lipidomics techniques. We aim to provide insights on the pivotal knowledge gaps that have been neglected, prohibiting the propulsion of the single-cell lipidomics field forward, while also providing our perspective towards future methodologies that can pave a path forward.