The ratio between class II and class I collagenase determines the amount of neutral protease activity required for efficient islet release from the rat pancreas

Quantifying the Effects of Different Neutral Proteases on Human Islet Integrity

Efficient islet release from the pancreas requires the combination of collagenase, neutral protease (cNP), or thermolysin (TL). Recently, it has been shown that clostripain (CP) may also contribute to efficient islet release from the human pancreas. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of these proteases on human islet integrity in a prospective approach. Islets were isolated from the pancreas of 10 brain-dead human organ donors. Purified islets were precultured for 3 to 4 d at 37 °C to ensure that preparations were cleared of predamaged islets, and only integral islets were subjected to 90 min of incubation at 37 °C in Hank’s balanced salt solution supplemented with cNP, TL, or CP. The protease concentrations were calculated for a pancreas of 100 g trimmed weight utilizing 120 dimethyl-casein units of cNP, 70,000 caseinase units of TL, or 200 benzoyl-l-arginine-ethyl-ester units of CP (1×). These activities were then increased both 5× and 10×. After subsequent 24-h culture in enzyme-free culture medium, treated islets were assessed and normalized to sham-treated controls. Compared with controls and CP, islet yield was significantly reduced by using the 5× activity of cNP and TL, inducing also fragmentation and DNA release. Viability significantly decreased not until adding the 1× activity of cNP, 5× activity of TL, or 10× activity of CP. Although mitochondrial function was significantly lowered by 1× cNP and 5× TL, CP did not affect mitochondria at any concentration. cNP- and TL-incubated islets significantly lost intracellular insulin already at 1× activity, while the 10× activity of CP had to be added to observe a similar effect. cNP and TL have a similar toxic potency regarding islet integrity. CP also induces adverse effects on islets, but the toxic threshold is generally higher. We hypothesize that CP can serve as supplementary protease to minimize cNP or TL activity for efficient pancreas digestion.

Comparison of Clostripain and Neutral Protease as Supplementary Enzymes for Human Islet Isolation

Although human islet transplantation has been established as valid and safe treatment for patients with type 1 diabetes, the utilization rates of human pancreases for clinical islet transplantation are still limited and substantially determined by the quality and composition of collagenase blends. While function and integrity of collagenase has been extensively investigated, information is still lacking about the most suitable supplementary neutral proteases. The present study compared islet isolation outcome after pancreas digestion by means of collagenase used alone or supplemented with either neutral protease (NP), clostripain (CP), or both proteases. Decent amounts of islet equivalents (IEQ) were isolated using collagenase alone (3090 ± 550 IEQ/g), or in combination with NP (2340 ± 450 IEQ/g) or CP (2740 ± 280 IEQ/g). Nevertheless, the proportion of undigested tissue was higher after using collagenase alone (21.1 ± 1.1%, P < 0.05) compared with addition of NP (13.3 ± 2.2%) or CP plus NP (13.7 ± 2.6%). Likewise, the percentage of embedded islets was highest using collagenase only (13 ± 2%) and lowest adding NP plus CP (4 ± 1%, P < 0.01). The latter combination resulted in lowest post-culture overall survival (42.7 ± 3.9%), while highest survival was observed after supplementation with CP (74.5 ± 4.8%, P < 0.01). An insulin response toward glucose challenge was present in all experimental groups, but the stimulation index was significantly decreased using collagenase plus NP (2.0 ± 0.12) compared with supplementation with CP (3.16 ± 0.4, P < 0.001). This study demonstrates for the first time that it is possible to isolate significant numbers of human islets combining collagenase only with CP. The supplementation with CP is an effective means to substantially reduce NP activity, which significantly decreases survival and viability after culture. This will facilitate the manufacturing of enzyme blends with less harmful characteristics.

Enzyme Development for Human Islet Isolation: Five Decades of Progress or Stagnation?

In comparison to procedures used for the separation of individual cell types from other organs, the process of human pancreatic islet isolation aims to digest the pancreatic exocrine matrix completely without dispersing the individual cells within the endocrine cell cluster. This objective is unique within the field of tissue separation, and outlines the challenge of islet isolation to balance two opposing priorities. Although significant progress has been made in the characterization and production of enzyme blends for islet isolation, there are still numerous areas which require improvement. The ultimate goal of enzyme production, namely the routine production of a consistent and standardized enzyme blend, has still not been realized. This seems to be mainly the result of a lack of detailed knowledge regarding the structure of the pancreatic extracellular matrix and the synergistic interplay between collagenase and different supplementary proteases during the degradation of the extracellular matrix. Furthermore, the activation of intrinsic proteolytic enzymes produced by the pancreatic acinar cells, also impacts on the chance of a successful outcome of human islet isolation. This overview discusses the challenges of pancreatic enzymatic digestion during human islet isolation, and outlines the developments in this field over the past 5 decades.

Synergistic Effect of Neutral Protease and Clostripain on Rat Pancreatic Islet Isolation

BACKGROUND

Islet isolation currently requires collagenase, neutral protease and other components. Thermolysin (TL) from Bacillus thermoproteolyticus is the gold standard neutral protease. However, we speculated that neutral protease derived from Clostridium histolyticum (Ch; ChNP) would be biologically superior for islet isolation. Tryptic-like activity has also been reported to be important. Therefore, we focused on clostripain (CP), since it is one of the main proteases in Clostridium histolyticum which possesses tryptic-like activity. We then examined the synergistic effects of highly purified ChNP and CP on rat islet isolation.

METHODS

The same amount of collagenase was used in all four groups (TL, ChNP, TL+CP and ChNP+CP; n = 12/group). The efficiency was evaluated by the islet yield and function. An immunohistochemical analysis, in vitro digestion assay for each enzyme component and evaluation of the activation of endogenous exocrine proteases during islet isolation were also performed.

RESULTS

The islet yield of the TL group was significantly higher than that of the ChNP group (P < 0.01). The islet yield was dose dependently increased in the ChNP+CP group, but was decreased in the TL + CP group. The islet yield in the ChNP + CP group was significantly higher than that in the TL group, but their islet function was similar. Different specificities for laminin, especially laminin-511, were observed in the TL, ChNP, and CP groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Clostripain had a strong synergistic effect with ChNP, but not with TL. Therefore, ChNP and CP, in combination with collagenase derived from the same bacteria, may effectively increase the isolation efficiency without affecting the quality of islets.

Comparison of Neutral Proteases and Collagenase Class I as Essential Enzymes for Human Islet Isolation

Efficient islet isolation requires synergistic interaction between collagenase class I (CI) and class II (CII). The CI degradation alters the ratio between CI and CII and is responsible for batch-to-batch variations. This study compares the role of neutral protease (NP) plus clostripain (CP) with CI as essential enzymes for human islet isolation.

METHODS

Human islets were isolated using 4 different enzyme mixtures composed of CII plus either intact (CI-115) or degraded CI (CI-100). Blends were administered either with or without NP/CP. Purified islets were cultured for 3 to 4 days before islet quality assessment.

RESULTS

Whereas using intact CI-115 without NP/CP did not significantly reduce islet yield (3429 ± 631 vs 3087 ± 970 islet equivalent/g, nonsignificant), administration of degraded CI-100 without NP/CP decreased islet yield from 3501 ± 580 to 1312 ± 244 islet equivalent/g (P < 0.01), doubled the amount of undigested tissue from 11.8 ± 1.6 to 24.4 ± 1.2% (P < 0.01) and triplicated the percentage of trapped islets from 7.7 ± 2.8 to 22.5 ± 3.6% (P < 0.05). Islet yield did not vary between supplemented CI-115 and CI-100, but was increased using CI-115 when NP/CP was omitted (P < 0.05). A trend toward higher viability and increased secretory insulin response was noted in both CI-100 and CI-115 when NP/CP was not added.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that NP/CP can compensate reduced CI activity. Future attempts to optimize enzyme blends should consider the possibility to increase the proportion of collagenase CI to reduce the need for potentially harmful NPs.

A new method to value efficiency of enzyme blends for pancreatic tissue digestion

Islet transplantation, since the 1990s, has been an example of human cell therapy. Nevertheless, the islet isolation procedure is not completely standardized; in fact, >50% of islet procedures do not eventuate in transplantation due both to the variability of a donor's pancreas and to the unpredictable efficiency of an enzymatic blend. The enzymes used in pancreas isolation to digest several substrates are extracted from Clostridium histolyticum. In particular, they have strong collagenolytic activity compared with vertebrate collagenases. However, several impediments persist in human islet isolation success, probably owing to the variable composition and concentration of collagenases employed during the digestion phase. For islet isolation processes, neutral proteases play important roles. However, they should be considered to be double-edged swords, contributing to tissue dissociation but, sometimes, decreasing islet yield through fragmentation, breakdown, and inactivation. Protease activities cannot be preciously adjusted in a narrow range, there is no approach to determine the optimal dosage and composition of enzymes for extraction of human islets from the pancreas. At this time, available data on commercial enzymatic activity are not sufficient to predict their efficiency for pancreas digestion; consequently, it is difficult to select enzyme batches. For these reasons, we sought to generate an innovative evaluation assay to select enzymes useful for isolation procedures of pancreatic islets.

Collagenase isoforms for pancreas digestion

The available information concerning the characteristics and composition of collagenase batches, which are effective in the digestion of human pancreas for islet transplants, is scarce and incomplete. A large inter- and intrabatched variability in activity and efficiency of blend enzymes available for isolation has been observed. The aim of this study was to characterize enzyme blend components. Liberase batches were characterized by SDS-PAGE analyses, microelectrophoresis, and then by MALDI-TOF MS analysis. Three main bands were detected by SDS-PAGE analysis and submitted to MALDI-TOF MS analysis. Two bands were found to correspond to class I (isoform beta and another of 106 kDa) and one to class II (isoform delta) collagenase. These results represent an important step towards a complete characterization of enzymes, with the final aim of identifying key components for a standardized product.

The importance of tryptic-like activity in purified enzyme blends for efficient islet isolation

BACKGROUND

The isolation of islets from the human pancreas critically depends on an efficient enzyme blend. Previous studies have solely focused on the presence of collagenase and neutral protease/thermolysin. Despite improved characterization of these components, the lot-related variability in efficacy still persists suggesting that additional so far disregarded enzymes are required for efficient islet cleavage.

METHODS

Varying activities of a tryptic-like enzyme were identified within collagenase NB1 lots, which were selected according to a matched ratio between tryptic-like and collagenase activity (TLA-ratio). Rat and human pancreata were processed with current standard procedures.

RESULTS

Increasing the TLA-ratio from 1.3% to 10% reduced pancreas dissociation time in rats by 50% without affecting islet yield, viability, or posttransplant function in diabetic nude mice. Enhancing the TLA-ratio from 1.3% to 12.6% for human pancreas processing resulted in a significant reduction of recirculation time and increased incrementally human islet yield without affecting purity, in vitro function or recovery after culture. Optimized pancreas digestion correlated with a higher percentage of islet preparations fulfilling quality criteria for clinical transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that TLA is an effective component that should be included in moderate amounts in enzyme blends for human islet isolation to optimize the efficiency and minimize the lot-related variability.

Characterization of collagenase blend enzymes for human islet transplantation

BACKGROUND

Efficient islet isolation represents a necessary requirement for successful islet transplantation as a treatment for type 1 diabetes. The choice of collagenase for pancreas digestion is critical for the isolation outcome, and Liberase is the most widely used enzyme, although large intra-batched variability in activity and efficiency has been observed.

METHODS

The aim of this study was to characterize Liberase components and their relative role in pancreas digestion. Liberase batches were characterized by microelectrophoresis.

RESULTS

By means of microelectrophoresis, we identified three main proteins each with different prevalences between batches. Two proteins were found to correspond to class I (CI) and one to class II (CII) collagenase. In a series of 163 islet isolations, we observed that the CII correlated with islet yield (P<0.001) and digestion time (P<0.001); additionally, CI directly correlated with purity (P=0.028). Finally, when CII and one of the CI isoforms were >50 percentile, 15 of 36 preparations were transplanted, with 27 of 127 transplanted in the other cases (P=0.013).

CONCLUSION

These results represent an important step toward the characterization of enzymes, with the final aim of identifying key components for a standardized product.

Multi-lot analysis of custom collagenase enzyme blend in human islet isolations

INTRODUCTION

Variability currently in Liberase HI from lot to lot limits the ability to effectively isolate islets with consistency. Roche Diagnostics Inc (Indianapolis, Ind, USA) has developed a Custom Collagenase enzyme blend in hopes that producing collagenase II and I and thermolysin separately will eliminate variability. In this study we examined the variability in Custom Collagenase lots in respect to isolation results and isolation success rates and compared those to Liberase HI.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed records from 68 islet isolations where either Liberase HI (lot A: n = 23, Lot B: n = 20) or Custom Collagenase blend (Lot C: n = 10, Lot D: n = 15) was employed. Human islets were isolated from cadaveric pancreata using standardized methods performed in a controlled islet isolation facility.

RESULTS

Analysis of Liberase HI and Custom Collagenase using Student t test showed no difference between the two groups. Comparison of the two Custom Collagenase lots using the t test showed a statistical difference between undigested pancreas weight and pancreas digestion times. Using chi-square test, no statistical significance was found in isolation success rates from lot to lot.

CONCLUSION

Although the Custom Collagenase blend is comparable to Liberase HI in its ability to isolate human islets, variability still exists from lot to lot when used conventionally as Liberase HI is. The ability to predetermine doses is beneficial, and as techniques to manipulate the activity levels prior to isolations improve so to will the enzymes' ability to isolate islets on a consistent basis.