Excessive portal flow causes graft nonfunction in small size liver transplantation: An experimental study in pigs

Small-for-Size Syndrome: Systemic Review in a Porcine Experimental Model

BACKGROUND

The small-for-size syndrome (SFSS) is characterized by prolonged hyperbilirubinemia, coagulopathy, and/or encephalopathy caused by a small liver graft that cannot sustain the metabolic demands of the recipient after a partial liver transplant (PLT). Models of PLT in pigs are excellent for studying this syndrome. This review aimed to identify the different porcine models of SFSS in the literature and compare their technical aspects and therapeutics methods focused on portal inflow modulation (PIM).

METHODS

We performed a systematic review of the porcine experimental model and SFSS. The MEDLINE-PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, LILACS, and SciELO databases were electronically searched and updated until June 20, 2021. The MeSH terms used were ''ORGAN SIZE'' AND ''LIVER TRANSPLANTATION".

RESULTS

Thirteen SFSS porcine models were reported. Four were performed with portocaval shunt to PIM and 3 with mesocaval shunt to PIM. A few studies focused on clinical therapeutics to PIM; a study described somatostatin infusion to avoid SFSS. Initially, studies on PIM showed its potentially beneficial effects without mentioning the minimum portal flow that permits liver regeneration. However, an excessive portal diversion could be detrimental to this process.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of porcine models on SFSS resulted in a better understanding of its pathophysiology and led to the establishment of various types of portal modulation, surgical techniques with different complexities, and pharmaceutical strategies such as somatostatin, making clear that without reducing the portal vein pressure the outcomes are poor. With the improvement of these techniques, SFSS can be avoided.

Small-for-size syndrome in liver transplantation: Definition, pathophysiology and management

BACKGROUND

Since the first success in an adult patient, living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) has become an universally used procedure. Small-for-size syndrome (SFSS) is a well-known complication after partial LT, especially in cases of adult-to-adult LDLT. The definition of SFSS slightly varies among transplant physicians. The use of a partial liver graft has risks of SFSS development. Persistent portal vein (PV) hypertension and PV hyper-perfusion after LT were identified as the main factors. Hence, various approaches were explored to modulate PV flow and decrease PV pressure in order to alleviate this syndrome. Herein, the definition, clinical symptoms, pathophysiology, basic research, as well as preventive and treatment strategies for SFSS are reviewed based on an extensive review of the literature and on our own experiences.

DATA SOURCES

The articles were collected through PubMed using search terms "liver transplantation", "living donor liver transplantation", "living liver donation", "partial graft", "small-for-size graft", "small-for-size syndrome", "graft volume", "remnant liver", "standard liver volume", "graft to recipient body weight ratio", "sarcopenia", "porcine", "swine", and "rat". English publications published before March 31, 2020 were included in this review.

RESULTS

Many transplant surgeons performed PV flow modulation, including portocaval shunt, splenic artery ligation and splenectomy. With these techniques, patient outcome has been improved even when using a "small" graft. Other factors, such as preoperative recipients' nutritional and skeletal muscle status, graft congestion, and donor factors, were also identified as risk factors which all have been addressed using various strategies.

CONCLUSIONS

The surgical approach controlling PV flow and pressure could help to prevent SFSS especially in severely ill recipients. In the absence of efficacious medications to resolve SFSS, conservative treatments, including aggressive fluid balance correction for massive ascites, anti-microbiological therapy to prevent or control sepsis and intensive nutritional therapy, are all required if SFSS could not be prevented.

Small-for-size syndrome in live donor liver transplantation-Pathways of injury and therapeutic strategies

Due to the severe organ shortage and the increasing gap between the supply and demand for donor grafts, live donor liver transplantation (LDLT) has become an accepted and alternative technique for the expansion of the donor pool. However, donor safety and good recipient outcomes must be balanced regarding risk stratification and decision-making within this patient population. Small-for-size syndrome (SFSS) is one of the complications encountered after LDLT, thus increasing the burden of optimizing donor graft selection and effective treatments during its occurrence. A graft-to-recipient weight ratio (GRWR) <0.8 predisposes the graft to SFSS. However, other factors may induce this complication even without a graft-to-patient size mismatch. Several strategies to prevent this complication include portal vein flow and liver outflow modulation, as well as pharmacological treatment. Also, as an entity with a multifactorial etiology, outcomes vary between right-lobe, left-lobe, and posterior-lobe donation among series encountered in the literature. In this review, we analyze the pathophysiology and classification of this complication, the state-of-the-art on management of SFSS, and the outcomes regarding the best treatment strategy on this patient population.

Decompression of the portal bed and twice-baseline portal inflow are necessary for the functional recovery of a "small-for-size" graft

BACKGROUND

In partial liver transplant, a reduction in the intrahepatic vascular bed produces a rise in the portal vein flow and the portal venous pressure gradient, leading to endothelial and, thereby, hepatocellular injury and death in a process known as "small-for-size" (SFS) syndrome.

OBJECTIVE

To demonstrate that a calibrated portocaval shunt prevents superfluous inflow in a porcine model of SFS transplant.

METHODS

Donor pigs (15-20 kg) underwent 70% hepatectomy. In 2 groups, a 6 mm (S6) (n = 6) or 12 mm (S12) (n = 6) Gore-Tex shunt was placed between the portal vein and infrahepatic inferior vena cava. In a third group, no portocaval shunt was placed (SFS) (n = 17). Grafts were stored for 5 hours at 4°C and then transplanted into recipients (30-35 kg).

RESULTS

Five-day survival was 29% in SFS, 100% in S6, and 0 in S12. Postreperfusion portal vein flow was 4-, 2-, and 1-times flow at baseline in SFS, S6, and S12, respectively. With respect to portal venous pressure gradient, both the 6- and 12-mm shunts effectively decompressed the portal bed. Aspartate aminotransferase and bilirubin rose and the Quick prothrombin time fell in all animals after reperfusion but improved significantly by day 5 in S6. Serum levels of endothelin-1 remained elevated in SFS and S12 but returned to baseline by 12 hours in S6: 2.76 (2.05-4.08) and 2.04 (1.97-2.12) versus 0.43 (0.26-0.50) pg/mL, respectively (P < 0.05 for both comparisons).

CONCLUSIONS

A calibrated portocaval shunt that maintains portal vein flow about twice its baseline value produces a favorable outcome after SFS liver transplantation, avoiding endothelial injury due to portal hyperperfusion or to hypoperfusion because of excess shunting.

Sinusoidal microcirculatory changes after small-for-size liver transplantation in rats

Small-for-size graft injury is characterized by portal venous hypertension and loss of intracellular homeostasis early after transplant. The long-term alteration of sinusoidal microcirculatory hemodynamic state remains unknown. A syngeneic rat orthotopic liver transplantation model was developed using small-for-size grafts (35% of recipient liver weight) or whole grafts (100% of recipient liver weight). Graft survival, portal pressure, liver function, hepatocellular apoptosis as well as morphological changes (by light microscopy and electron microscopy) were assessed. Sinusoidal microcirculatory hemodynamics was examined by intravital fluorescence microscopy. Although portal hypertension lasted only for 1 h after performance of small-for-size liver transplantation, a sustained microcirculatory disturbance was accompanied by dramatic reduction of sinusoidal perfusion rate, elevation of sinusoidal diameter as well as increase in the number of apoptotic hepatocytes during the first 7 days. These resulted in lower survival rate (50% vs. 100%, P = 0.012), higher level of liver function, and more severe morphological changes, which could induce small-for-size syndrome. In conclusion, persistent microcirculatory hemodynamic derangement during the first 7 days after reperfusion as well as transient portal hypertension is significant manifestation after small-for-size liver transplantation. Long-term microcirculation disturbance displayed as decrease of sinusoidal reperfusion area and increase of spread in functional liver mass seems to be the key factor for graft injuries.

Effect of portocaval shunt on residual extreme small liver after extended hepatectomy in porcine

BACKGROUND

When residual liver volume is extremely small after extended hepatectomy, postoperative hepatic failure may ensue. The cause of the hepatic failure is likely associated with the portal hypertension after hepatectomy. We investigated the effects of portocaval shunt on portal hypertension in producing sinusoidal microcirculatory injury after extended hepatectomy in pigs.

METHODS

Fourteen pigs were divided into two groups: a group without a shunt, in which extended hepatectomy was carried out (i.e., residual volume was 17% of the whole liver), and a group with a shunt, in which extended hepatectomy was carried out and a portocaval shunt was inserted. The portocaval shunt was placed by side-to-side anastomosis between the portal vein and the inferior vena cava.

RESULTS

In the group without a shunt, all pigs died of hepatic failure within postoperative day 3. In the group with a shunt, all pigs were alive for more than 4 days, and 4 pigs survived longer than 7 days. Portal vein pressure after hepatectomy was 15.9 +/- 3.8 mmHg in the group without a shunt and 10.5 +/- 0.6 mmHg in the group with a shunt (P < 0.01). The portal vein flow after 83% hepatectomy in the group without a shunt increased significantly more than at laparotomy and in the group with a shunt (P < 0.01). In the group without a shunt, remarkable destruction of the sinusoidal lining and edema of the portal triad and hydropic change of hepatocytes were observed 1 hour after hepatectomy, but these findings were not observed in the group with a shunt.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that, after extended hepatectomy, overload of portal flow is one of the most significant risk factors of hepatic failure by sinusoidal microcirculatory injury.

Effect of portocaval shunt on residual extreme small liver after extended hepatectomy in porcine

BACKGROUND

When residual liver volume is extremely small after extended hepatectomy, postoperative hepatic failure may ensue. The cause of the hepatic failure is likely associated with the portal hypertension after hepatectomy. We investigated the effects of portocaval shunt on portal hypertension in producing sinusoidal microcirculatory injury after extended hepatectomy in pigs.

METHODS

Fourteen pigs were divided into two groups: a group without a shunt, in which extended hepatectomy was carried out (i.e., residual volume was 17% of the whole liver), and a group with a shunt, in which extended hepatectomy was carried out and a portocaval shunt was inserted. The portocaval shunt was placed by side-to-side anastomosis between the portal vein and the inferior vena cava.

RESULTS

In the group without a shunt, all pigs died of hepatic failure within postoperative day 3. In the group with a shunt, all pigs were alive for more than 4 days, and 4 pigs survived longer than 7 days. Portal vein pressure after hepatectomy was 15.9 +/- 3.8 mmHg in the group without a shunt and 10.5 +/- 0.6 mmHg in the group with a shunt (P < 0.01). The portal vein flow after 83% hepatectomy in the group without a shunt increased significantly more than at laparotomy and in the group with a shunt (P < 0.01). In the group without a shunt, remarkable destruction of the sinusoidal lining and edema of the portal triad and hydropic change of hepatocytes were observed 1 hour after hepatectomy, but these findings were not observed in the group with a shunt.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that, after extended hepatectomy, overload of portal flow is one of the most significant risk factors of hepatic failure by sinusoidal microcirculatory injury.

Effect of portocaval shunt on residual extreme small liver after extended hepatectomy in porcine

BACKGROUND

When residual liver volume is extremely small after extended hepatectomy, postoperative hepatic failure may ensue. The cause of the hepatic failure is likely associated with the portal hypertension after hepatectomy. We investigated the effects of portocaval shunt on portal hypertension in producing sinusoidal microcirculatory injury after extended hepatectomy in pigs.

METHODS

Fourteen pigs were divided into two groups: a group without a shunt, in which extended hepatectomy was carried out (i.e., residual volume was 17% of the whole liver), and a group with a shunt, in which extended hepatectomy was carried out and a portocaval shunt was inserted. The portocaval shunt was placed by side-to-side anastomosis between the portal vein and the inferior vena cava.

RESULTS

In the group without a shunt, all pigs died of hepatic failure within postoperative day 3. In the group with a shunt, all pigs were alive for more than 4 days, and 4 pigs survived longer than 7 days. Portal vein pressure after hepatectomy was 15.9 +/- 3.8 mmHg in the group without a shunt and 10.5 +/- 0.6 mmHg in the group with a shunt (P < 0.01). The portal vein flow after 83% hepatectomy in the group without a shunt increased significantly more than at laparotomy and in the group with a shunt (P < 0.01). In the group without a shunt, remarkable destruction of the sinusoidal lining and edema of the portal triad and hydropic change of hepatocytes were observed 1 hour after hepatectomy, but these findings were not observed in the group with a shunt.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that, after extended hepatectomy, overload of portal flow is one of the most significant risk factors of hepatic failure by sinusoidal microcirculatory injury.

Living Donor Liver Transplantation and Management of Portal Venous Pressure

Small-for-size syndrome occurs in the presence of a reduced mass of liver that is insufficient to maintain normal liver function. It has been speculated that this dysfunction is principally associated with graft exposure to excessive portal perfusion. The aim of these cases was to evaluate the efficacy of octreotide, a splanchnic vasoconstrictor, and esmolol, a selective beta-blocker, to modify the portal perfusion in the postoperative phase after left living related liver transplantation (LRLT). Four patients who underwent left LRLT with graft-to-recipient weight ratios of 0.60 +/- 0.24 were studied with a catheter placed in a jejunal vein. We observed high basal values of hepatic venous pressure gradient (HVPG) and portal vein flow (PVF). Octreotide infusion decreased HVPG, an effect that was more pronounced when it was combined with esmolol. The administration of both drugs was also associated with an improvement in portal vein oxygen saturation. Despite variation in PVF, the plasma disappearance rate of indocyanin green did not change during the infusion of the two drugs. In conclusion, octreotide and esmolol infusion allowed a manipulation of portal vein pressure that should be measured in left LRLT using a small-for-size graft.

Kupffer cell-dependent TNF-alpha signaling mediates injury in the arterialized small-for-size liver transplantation in the mouse

Implantation of small liver grafts causes liver injury and defective regeneration leading to graft failure. We investigated whether Kupffer cell-dependent TNF-alpha signaling contributes to this poor outcome. Partial 30% liver transplantation was performed in C57BL/6 wild-type mice (control group), and in three groups with down-regulation of the TNF-alpha pathway: (i) TNF receptor 1 knockout [TNFR-1(-/-)] mice, and mice pretreated with (ii) gadolinium chloride or (iii) pentoxifylline (PTX). Fifty-percent partial liver transplantation, a model associated with full recovery, and transplantation in IL-6 knockout [IL-6(-/-)] mice were performed in some experiments. Graft injury, regeneration, portal flow, liver microcirculation, leukocyte adhesion, and animal survival were assessed. Animal survival rates were 14% in the control group vs. 43% in the gadolinium chloride group, 57% for the TNFR-1(-/-) group, and 86% in the PTX group (P < 0.001). Markers of liver injury were reduced in all treated groups when compared with controls. Each treated group disclosed better portal flow and sinusoid perfusion, decreased leukocyte adherence, particularly in the PTX group. Liver regeneration occurred only in the treated groups. IL-6 and IL-10 levels were dramatically up-regulated (50x) in the PTX group, and at lower levels in other experimental groups. The protective effect of PTX was lost in IL-6(-/-) mice and protection was restored by a single dose of r-IL-6. In conclusion, interruption of TNF-alpha signaling or depletion of Kupffer cells improves survival after 30% liver transplantation, reduces liver injury, and enhances regeneration. The superior effects of PTX are mediated by IL-6.