Reliability of Sonoelastography Measurements of Lower Limb Tendon Properties: A Systematic Review

Measurement properties of shear wave elastography for evaluating rotator cuff muscle stiffness: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Literature assessing elasticity in rotator cuff (RC) muscles with shear wave elastography (SWE) is growing but little is known about the overall measurement properties. However, this information is crucial before implementation in research or practice. The objective of this review was first, to systematically investigate the evidence regarding reliability and validity of RC muscles SWE. Second, to summarize measurement protocols to support uniformity and standardization of SWE methodology.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted using Medline (PubMed), Web of Science, and Embase. Included studies reported measurement properties of reliability, validity, and/or responsiveness of SWE to evaluate RC muscle stiffness in subjects without and with musculoskeletal shoulder pain. Methodological quality was rated with the Consensus-Based Standards for the Selection of Health Measurement Instruments checklist. The level of evidence (LoE) was determined using a best-evidence synthesis approach.

RESULTS

Forty-two articles were included. Studies assessing reliability (n = 29) had a moderate LoE for positive ratings of intratester reliability for supraspinatus, infraspinatus, and teres minor and intertester reliability for supraspinatus and infraspinatus. A limited LoE for positive ratings was implied for intertester reliability of teres minor and unknown LoE for negative ratings for day-to-day variability of supraspinatus. Studies reporting on convergent validity (n = 13) showed inconsistent correlation between SWE and other outcomes. Studies assessing discriminant validity (n = 18) showed higher SWE in shoulder patients but not in frozen shoulder and RC tears. Studies reporting on responsiveness (n = 10) showed decreased SWE values 1-2 months postoperatie RC repair and after stretching.

CONCLUSION

Although RC muscle SWE measurements showed overall moderate reliability, few studies used appropriate reliability study designs and protocols. The evidence regarding convergent validity, discriminant validity, and responsiveness is inconsistent, underscoring the need to improve measurement procedures and explore day-to-day reliability. SWE is a potentially valuable technique for RC muscle assessment. However, future high-quality methodological research with reliability and validity as a primary focus is needed to better understand its applicability in clinical practice.

Achilles Tendon Stiffness: Influence of Measurement Methodology

OBJECTIVE

Mechanical stiffness derived from force-elongation curves is fundamentally different from shear wave (SW) elastography-based tissue properties. We compared these techniques, with a total of five methods of assessing Achilles tendon (AT) stiffness.

METHODS

Seventeen participants (12 male and 5 female) with unilateral AT rupture performed submaximal contractions at 30% and 10% maximal isometric contraction torque of the un-injured limb. SW velocity was acquired at rest. Force-elongation curves were assessed from the free AT and the medial gastrocnemius (MG) tendon. Mechanical stiffness was determined near the end of the linear region of the force-elongation curve and from the toe region. Bivariate correlations between mechanical stiffness and SW velocity, as well as pairwise t-tests between limbs, were computed.

RESULTS

In the injured limb, SW velocity correlated with MG tendon and free AT toe-region stiffness during 10% (r = 0.59, p = 0.020 and r = 0.60, p = 0.011, respectively) and 30% of submaximal contractions (r = 0.56, p = 0.018 and r = 0.67, p = 0.004, respectively). The un-injured limb showed no associations. In both limbs pooled together, SW velocity correlated with MG tendon toe-region stiffness in 30% of submaximal contractions (r = 0.43, p = 0.012). Free tendon mechanical stiffness was lower in the injured limb, with a mean difference of 148.5 Nmm⁻¹ (95% CI: 35.6-261.3, p = 0.013), while SW velocity was higher in the injured limb (1.67 m × s⁻¹, 95% CI; -2.4 to -0.9, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

SW elastography may reflect AT viscoelastic properties at the initial slope of the force-length curve with strains <1% but cannot offer insight into AT mechanics at higher loads. Extended toe regions in the injured limb could have caused the association between mechanical stiffness and SW-based stiffness.

Shear-Wave Elastography of the Achilles tendon: reliability analysis and impact of parameters modulating elasticity values

PURPOSE

Shear wave elastography (SWE) has seen many advancements in Achilles tendon evaluation in recent years, yet standardization of this technique is still problematic due to the lack of knowledge regarding the optimal way to perform the examination. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of ankle position, probe frequency and physical effort on the shear modulus of the Achilles tendon, but also to determine the intra and inter-observer reliability of the technique.

METHODS

37 healthy volunteers were included; SWE protocol was performed by two examiners. We analyzed the shear modulus of the tendon with the ankle in neutral, maximum dorsiflexion and maximum plantar flexion using two different high frequency probes. Afterwards, the subjects performed a brief physical exercise and SWE measurements were repeated.

RESULTS

The L18-5 probe showed the highest ICC values (ICC = 0.798, 95% CI 0.660-0.880, p < 0.001) when positioned at 2 cm from the calcaneal insertion with the ankle in a neutral state. Conversely, utilizing the same L18-5 probe at 1 cm from the insertion during maximum plantar flexion of the ankle resulted in the lowest ICC (ICC = 0.422, 95% CI 0.032-0.655, p = 0.019). Significant variations in elasticity values were noted among different ankle positions and probe types, while no significant changes in elasticity were observed post-physical exercise.

CONCLUSION

Ankle position and probe frequency are factors that influence elasticity values of the Achilles tendon. An ankle position between 10 and 20 degrees of plantar flexion is the most suitable for SWE evaluation. However, more research focusing on Achilles tendon SWE is essential due to the challenges encountered in standardizing this region.

Diagnostic value of Achilles tendon shear wave elastography in patients with ankylosing spondylitis: A case-control study

OBJECTIVES

Ankylosing spondylitis (AS) can cause peripheral arthritis, tendinitis, enthesitis, and axial skeletal involvement. This study aims to determine early tendon damage by shear wave elastography (SWE) for the Achilles tendon in AS patients.

METHODS

48 AS patients and 48 asymptomatic individuals were included in the study. Participants were systematically examined with B-mode, power Doppler, and SWE using a high-resolution linear 6-15 MHz probe. Bilateral Achilles tendon stiffness, thickness, and vascularity were evaluated. Measurements were taken from the middle third of the Achilles tendon in the sagittal plane. Difference between the two groups was evaluated with statistical methods. Receiver operating characteristic analysis was performed to test the diagnostic performance of Achilles tendon stiffness. Additionally, the Spearman correlation test examined the relationship between Achilles tendon stiffness and disease duration.

RESULTS

The difference between the two groups regarding Achilles tendon stiffness was statistically significant (p < 0.05). It was observed that Achilles tendon stiffness decreased in the patient group compared with the control group. The diagnostic value of Achilles tendon stiffness measured by SWE was found to be high. A negative correlation was detected between disease duration and tendon stiffness (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

In patients diagnosed with AS, deterioration in the Achilles tendon structure was observed, and a significant decrease in tendon stiffness compared with the healthy population. It has been determined that these changes in the Achilles tendon are related to the duration of the disease.

Finger flexor rigidity in the healthy population

The involvement of the hand flexors in trigger finger is not clear. This study aimed to examine the rigidity of the flexor tendon in the first pulley territory in the hand by using ultrasound in a healthy population, as well as to create a reference scale of rigidity for the flexor tendons to compare those values in trigger fingers. We tested 35 healthy volunteers using a linear ultrasound transducer and the color Doppler method. Rigidity levels below the first pulley were examined and compared between the different fingers of the hand and the relationship between rigidity and sex and the three different age groups was evaluated. In the healthy population, the rigidity of the flexor tendons of the hand in the territory of the first pulley varied between 233.1 and 962.8 kPa, with an average of 486.42 kPa and standard deviation of 114.85. We showed that the flexors in the dominant hand were more rigid, there was a difference between the rigidity of the flexor tendons of the thumb and the other fingers of the same hand, and the ring finger of the dominant hand had stiffer flexor tendons than the fingers of the other hand in the male population. We created a value scale for the rigidity of the flexor tendons of the fingers. This base scale can be compared between different pathologies, including trigger finger. The study and all experimental protocols were approved by the local ethical committee.

Achilles tendon and triceps surae muscle properties in athletes

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to investigate internal Achilles tendon (AT) displacement, AT shear wave velocity (SWV), and triceps surae (TS) muscle shear modulus in athletes.

METHODS

Internal AT displacement was assessed using ultrasound during isometric contraction. Shear wave elastography was used to assess AT SWV (m × s-1) at rest and TS muscle shear modulus (kPa) during passive ankle dorsiflexion.

RESULTS

A total of 131 athletes participated in this study. Athletes who had not exercised within two days had greater AT non-uniformity and mean anterior tendon displacement, and lower SWV at the proximal AT measurement site (mean difference [95% CI]: 1.8 mm [0.6-2.9], p = 0.003; 1.6 mm [0.2-2.9], p = 0.021; - 0.9 m × s-1 [- 1.6 to - 0.2], p = 0.014, respectively). Male basketball players had a lower mean AT displacement compared to gymnasts (- 3.7 mm [- 6.9 to - 0.5], p = 0.042), with the difference localised in the anterior half of the tendon (- 5.1 mm [- 9.0 to - 1.1], p = 0.022). Male gymnasts had a smaller absolute difference in medial gastrocnemius-minus-soleus shear modulus than basketball players (59.6 kPa [29.0-90.2], p < 0.001) and track and field athletes (52.7 kPa [19.2-86.3], p = 0.004). Intraclass correlation coefficients of measurements ranged from 0.720 to 0.937 for internal AT displacement, from 0.696 to 0.936 for AT SWE, and from 0.570 to 0.890 for TS muscles.

CONCLUSION

This study provides a reliability assessment of muscle and tendon SWV. The relative differences in passive TS muscle shear modulus suggest sport-specific adaptation. Importantly, in healthy individuals, lower AT displacement after exercise may reflect the time required for tendon recovery.

The Use of Shear-Wave Ultrasound Elastography in the Diagnosis and Monitoring of Musculoskeletal Injuries

Ultrasound elastography is a valuable method employed to evaluate tissue stiffness, with shear-wave elastography (SWE) recently gaining significance in various settings. This literature review aims to explore the potential of SWE as a diagnostic and monitoring tool for musculoskeletal injuries. In total, 15 studies were found and included in the review. The outcomes of these studies demonstrate the effectiveness of SWE in detecting stiffness changes in individuals diagnosed with Achilles tendinopathy, Achilles tendon rupture, rotator cuff rupture, tendinosis of the long head of the biceps tendon, injury of the supraspinatus muscle, medial tibial stress syndrome, and patellar tendinopathy. Moreover, SWE proves its efficacy in distinguishing variations in tissue stiffness before the commencement and after the completion of rehabilitation in cases of Achilles tendon rupture and patellar tendinopathy. In summary, the findings from this review suggest that SWE holds promise as a viable tool for diagnosing and monitoring specific musculoskeletal injuries. However, while the field of ultrasound elastography for assessing musculoskeletal injuries has made considerable progress, further research is imperative to corroborate these findings in the future.

Ultrasonographic Evaluation of Thickness and Stiffness of Achilles Tendon and Plantar Fascia in Type 2 Diabetics Patients: A Cross-sectional Observation Study

Background

Diabetes mellitus (DM) can contribute to the development of foot ulcers, a known complication of DM with a high financial and social burden. Achilles tendon (AT) and plantar fascia (PF) are well known to play an important role in foot biomechanics. The present study focuses on the alteration in thickness and stiffness of the AT and PF in Type 2 DM patients compared with the normal controls.

Methods

A cross-sectional observational study was conducted with 55 DM patients and 55 healthy volunteers as controls. The thickness of the AT and PF were measured using B-mode ultrasound and stiffness was measured using shear wave elastography. Both the thickness and stiffness in the patient group and controls were compared. The values were also compared with the clinical and demographic profiles of the patients.

Results

DM patients had considerably thicker AT and PF than controls (P < 0.05); mean values of AT thickness for DM patients and controls were 5.66 ± 0.54 mm and 4.61 ± 0.39 mm, respectively, and for PF were 2.53 ± 0.51 mm and 1.97 ± 0.19 mm, respectively. Furthermore, the stiffness of AT and PF was significantly (P < 0.05) lower in DM patients compared to controls, suggestive of softening of AT and PF in Type 2 DM patients. Mean values of shear wave velocity for DM patients and controls in AT were 5.53 ± 0.54 m/s and 7.25 ± 0.61 m/s, respectively, and for PF, 4.53 ± 0.89 m/s and 6.28 ± 0.88 m/s, respectively.

Conclusion

We conclude that there is softening and thickening of the AT and PF in Type 2 DM patients, which can impair foot biomechanics.

Towards modern understanding of the Achilles tendon properties in human movement research

The Achilles tendon (AT) is the strongest tendon in humans, yet it often suffers from injury. The mechanical properties of the AT afford efficient movement, power amplification and power attenuation during locomotor tasks. The properties and the unique structure of the AT as a common tendon for three muscles have been studied frequently in humans using in vivo methods since 1990's. As a part of the celebration of 50 years history of the International Society of Biomechanics, this paper reviews the history of the AT research focusing on its mechanical properties in humans. The questions addressed are: What are the most important mechanical properties of the Achilles tendon, how are they studied, what is their significance to human movement, and how do they adapt? We foresee that the ongoing developments in experimental methods and modeling can provide ways to advance knowledge of the complex three-dimensional structure and properties of the Achilles tendon in vivo, and to enable monitoring of the loading and recovery for optimizing individual adaptations.

Strain sonoelastography in asymptomatic individuals and individuals with knee osteoarthritis: an evaluation of quadriceps and patellar tendon

An advanced ultrasound imaging technique, sonoelastography (SE) is used to evaluate tissue elasticity. To determine SE potential to detect pathological-related changes, and characteristics related to tendon pathology we aimed to (1) compare quadriceps and patellar tendon findings in individuals with knee osteoarthritis (KOA) and asymptomatic older adults (AC), and (2) explore associations between SE, participant characteristics (age, BMI, and leg circumference) and KOA status. 84 participants (47; KOA and 37; asymptomatic older adults) underwent SE examination of quadriceps (distal) and patellar (distal, proximal) tendon in a supine position with the knee bent at 30°. Colour score (CS) and Elasticity Ratio (ER) analysis were performed by a blinded experienced operator using Esaote Mylab 70 XVG Ultrasound equipment. Significantly reduced elasticity in the distal quadriceps (median (IQR) 2(2), 3(1), p = 0.033 for KOA and AC, respectively) and proximal patellar (3(1), 3(0), p = 0.001) tendons and more elastic distal patellar (1.50 (0.55), 1.87 (0.72), p = 0.034) tendons were observed in the KOA group. Significant associations) were identified between SE and participant BMI (Rs = − 0.249–0.750, p < 0.05) and leg circumference (Rs = − 0.260–0.903, p < 0.05). Age, BMI and KOA status, were independent explanatory variables of SE CS findings at the distal quadriceps tendon patellar tendon, proximal patellar tendon and distal patellar tendon, explaining 66%, 81% and 64% of variance, respectively. Age, BMI and KOA status were independent explanatory variables of SE ER findings at the distal patellar tendon explaining 19% of variance. Potentially clinically relevant altered tendon stiffness were observed between individuals with KOA and asymptomatic controls. Key KOA risk factors and participant characteristics explained variance in tendon stiffness. Findings provide context for future studies to investigate the potential for targeted SE detected early clinical management based on associated participant characteristics.

Sternocleidomastoid size and upper trapezius muscle thickness in congenital torticollis patients: A retrospective observational study

The purpose of this study was to investigate the upper trapezius muscle thickness (UTMT) in congenital muscular torticollis (CMT) patients and determine the correlation among sternocleidomastoid muscle thickness (SCMT), accessory nerve (AN) cross-sectional area (CSA), and UTMT in CMT.This retrospective study consisted of 2 participant groups: Group 1 (SCM mass CMT, n = 20) and Group 2 (Postural CMT, n = 22). For both groups, B-mode ultrasound was performed by a physiatrist to measure the SCMT and UTMT and calculate the CSA of the AN. The correlation among SCMT, CSA of the AN, and UTMT in both groups was evaluated.The between-group comparison revealed that Group 1 had significantly greater SCMT, UTMT, and CSA of the AN on the affected side than Group 2 (P < .05). The intragroup comparison between the affected and unaffected sides also revealed that, in Group 1, the SCMT, UTMT, and CSA of the AN were significantly higher on the affected side than on the unaffected side (P < .05), whereas no significant differences were observed in Group 2. In Group 1, a positive correlation (r = 0.55) was observed between the UTMT and CSA of the AN on the affected side, but not observed between the SCMT and CSA of the AN.The findings of the study indicate that sternocleidomastoid muscle size may impact the thickness of the upper trapezius muscle via the accessory nerve in patients with congenital torticollis.

Ultrasound feature variants of the adductor longus tendon in asymptomatic sportive subjects: Management implications

OBJECTIVES

The potential contribution of ultrasound (US) to diagnose adductor longus (AL) tendinopathy in athletic pubalgia requires clarification. We investigate US findings from AL tendons of asymptomatic participants to identify the range and prevalence of common US features not associated with groin pain.

METHODS

We consecutively enrolled 45 volunteers physically active participants with no history of groin pain. US features of bilateral AL tendons were investigated and recorded by two experienced musculoskeletal radiologists (MSKR) in accordance with a defined ultrasound protocol. Two other MSKRs retrospectively and independently analyzed all US images.

RESULTS

Ninety AL tendons from 45 participants (4/45 women) were imaged (average age: 35 years ±14.6; dominant side: 37/45 (82.2%) right, 8/45 (17.8%) left). Abnormalities on US were found in all 45 (100%) AL tendons, including: abnormal echogenicity (98.9%/100% respectively according to reader), loss of fibrillar structure (92.2%/97.8%), irregularities of the superficial paratendon (23.3%/30%), calcifications (22.2%/25.5%), and cortical erosion (52%/55.5%), with excellent inter-observer assessment. No AL tears or hyperemia at color Doppler were detectable.

CONCLUSIONS

AL tendon abnormalities were identified via US in 100% of our asymptomatic athletes. The significance of these US findings should be interpreted cautiously with respect to clinical presentation. On the other hand, there is a need for supplemental investigation into the clinical relevance of US AL tendon tears not present in the present asymptomatic athlete population.