Appelmans protocol - A directed in vitro evolution enables induction and recombination of prophages with expanded host range

Mathematical comparison of protocols for adapting a bacteriophage to a new host

Interest in phage therapy-the use of bacterial viruses to treat infections-has increased recently because of the rise of infections with antibiotic-resistant bacteria and the failure to develop new antibiotics to treat those infections. Phages have shown therapeutic promise in recent work, and successful treatment minimally requires giving the patient a phage that will grow on their infecting bacterium. Although nature offers a bountiful and diverse supply of phages, there have been a surprising number of patient infections that could not be treated with phages because no suitable phage was found to kill the patient's bacterium. Here, we develop computational models to analyze an alternative approach to obtaining phages with new host ranges-directed evolution via laboratory propagation of phages to select mutants that can grow on a new host. The models separately explore alternative directed evolution protocols for phage variants that overcome three types of bacterial blocks to phage growth: a block in adsorption, temperate phage immunity to superinfection, and abortive infection. Protocols assume serial transfer to amplify pre-existing, small-effect mutants that are initially rare. Best protocols are sensitive to the nature of the block, and the models provide several insights for enhancing success specific to each case. A common result is that low dilution rates between transfers are beneficial in reducing the mutant growth rate needed to ascend. Selection to overcome an adsorption block is insensitive to many protocol variations but benefits from long selection times between transfers. A temperate phage selected to grow on its lysogens can evolve in any of three phenotypes, but a common protocol favors the desired changes in all three. Abortive infection appears to be the least amenable to evolving phage growth because it is prone to select phages that avoid infection.

Directed evolution of bacteriophages: thwarted by prolific prophage

Various directed evolution methods exist that seek to procure bacteriophages with expanded host ranges, typically targeting phage-resistant or non-permissive bacterial hosts. The general premise of these methods involves propagating phage(s) on multiple bacterial hosts, pooling the lysate, and repeating this process until phage(s) can form plaques on the target host(s). In theory, this produces a lysate containing input phages and their evolved phage progeny. However, in practice, this lysate can also include prophages originating from bacterial hosts. Here, we describe our experience implementing one directed evolution method, the Appelmans protocol, to study phage evolution in the Pseudomonas aeruginosa phage-host system, where we observed rapid host-range expansion of the phage cocktail. Further experimentation and sequencing revealed that the observed host-range expansion was due to a Casadabanvirus prophage originating from a lysogenic host that was only included in the first three rounds of the experiment. This prophage could infect five of eight bacterial hosts initially used, allowing it to persist and proliferate until the termination of the experiment. This prophage was represented in half of the sequenced phage samples isolated from the Appelmans experiment, but despite being subjected to directed evolution conditions, it does not appear to have evolved. This work highlights the impact of prophages in directed evolution experiments and the importance of genetically verifying output phages, particularly for those attempting to procure phages intended for phage therapy applications. This study also notes the usefulness of intraspecies antagonism assays between bacterial host strains to establish a baseline for inhibitory activity and determine the presence of prophage.IMPORTANCEDirected evolution is a common strategy for evolving phages to expand the host range, often targeting pathogenic strains of bacteria. In this study, we investigated phage host-range expansion using directed evolution in the Pseudomonas aeruginosa system. We show that prophages are active players in directed evolution and can contribute to observation of host-range expansion. Since prophages are prevalent in bacterial hosts, particularly pathogenic strains of bacteria, and all directed evolution approaches involve iteratively propagating phage on one or more bacterial hosts, the presence of prophage in phage preparations is a factor that needs to be considered in experimental design and interpretation of results. These results highlight the importance of screening for prophages either genetically or through intraspecies antagonism assays during selection of bacterial strains and will contribute to improving the experimental design of future directed evolution studies.

Viral adaptations to alternative hosts in the honey bee pathogen Paenibacillus larvae

Bacteriophages (phages) that are intended to be used to treat bacterial infections are often improved using genetic engineering or experimental evolution. A protocol called "Appelmans" utilizes evolution in microtiter plates to promote the evolution of phages that can infect nonpermissive hosts. We tested a modification of the Appelmans protocol using the honey bee pathogen, Paenibacillus larvae. Three phages evolved together on four P. larvae strains following the standard Appelmans protocol and a modified version to ensure high phage diversity throughout ten rounds of passaging. The host range of 360 plaques were characterized and six new phage lysis patterns were identified. These new phage lysis patterns included plaque formation on previously nonpermissive, phage-resistant isolates that were used to identify phage types. The modified protocol did not drastically change the rate or number of new phage types observed but did prevent the phage population from being dominated by one phage that tended to rapidly raise in frequency. These findings showed how a minor modification of the Appelmans protocol influenced the development of phages for phage therapy. The method also provided improved phages for the treatment of bacterial infections in honey bees.

Dietary Effects on the Gut Phageome

As knowledge of the gut microbiome has expanded our understanding of the symbiotic and dysbiotic relationships between the human host and its microbial constituents, the influence of gastrointestinal (GI) microbes both locally and beyond the intestine has become evident. Shifts in bacterial populations have now been associated with several conditions including Crohn's disease (CD), Ulcerative Colitis (UC), irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's Disease, liver diseases, obesity, metabolic syndrome, anxiety, depression, and cancers. As the bacteria in our gut thrive on the food we eat, diet plays a critical role in the functional aspects of our gut microbiome, influencing not only health but also the development of disease. While the bacterial microbiome in the context of disease is well studied, the associated gut phageome-bacteriophages living amongst and within our bacterial microbiome-is less well understood. With growing evidence that fluctuations in the phageome also correlate with dysbiosis, how diet influences this population needs to be better understood. This review surveys the current understanding of the effects of diet on the gut phageome.

Directed evolution of bacteriophages: impacts of prolific prophage

Various directed evolution methods exist that seek to procure bacteriophages with expanded host ranges, typically targeting phage-resistant or non-permissive bacterial hosts. The general premise of these methods is to propagate phage on multiple bacterial hosts, pool the lysate, and repeat the propagation process until phage(s) can form plaques on the target host(s). In theory, this propagation process produces a phage lysate that contains input phages and their evolved phage progeny. However, in practice, this phage lysate can also include prophages originating from bacterial hosts. Here we describe our experience implementing one directed evolution method, the Appelmans protocol, to study phage evolution in the Pseudomonas aeruginosa phage-host system, in which we observed rapid host-range expansion of the phage cocktail. Further experimentation and sequencing analysis revealed that this observed host-range expansion was due to a Casadabanvirus prophage that originated from one of the Appelmans hosts. Host-range analysis of the prophage showed that it could infect five of eight bacterial hosts initially used, allowing it to proliferate and persist through the end of the experiment. This prophage was represented in half of the sequenced phage samples isolated from the Appelmans experiment. This work highlights the impact of prophages in directed evolution experiments and the importance of incorporating sequencing data in analyses to verify output phages, particularly for those attempting to procure phages intended for phage therapy applications. This study also notes the usefulness of intraspecies antagonism assays between bacterial host strains to establish a baseline for inhibitory activity and determine presence of prophage.

IMPORTANCE

Directed evolution is a common strategy for evolving phages to expand host range, often targeting pathogenic strains of bacteria. In this study we investigated phage host-range expansion using directed evolution in the Pseudomonas aeruginosa system. We show that prophage are active players in directed evolution and can contribute to observation of host-range expansion. Since prophage are prevalent in bacterial hosts, particularly pathogenic strains of bacteria, and all directed evolution approaches involve iteratively propagating phage on one or more bacterial hosts, the presence of prophage in phage preparations is a factor that needs to be considered in experimental design and interpretation of results. These results highlight the importance of screening for prophages either genetically or through intraspecies antagonism assays during selection of bacterial strains and will contribute to improving experimental design of future directed evolution studies.

Making the leap from technique to treatment - genetic engineering is paving the way for more efficient phage therapy

Bacteriophages (phages) are viruses specific to bacteria that target them with great efficiency and specificity. Phages were first studied for their antibacterial potential in the early twentieth century; however, their use was largely eclipsed by the popularity of antibiotics. Given the surge of antimicrobial-resistant strains worldwide, there has been a renaissance in harnessing phages as therapeutics once more. One of the key advantages of phages is their amenability to modification, allowing the generation of numerous derivatives optimised for specific functions depending on the modification. These enhanced derivatives could display higher infectivity, expanded host range or greater affinity to human tissues, where some bacterial species exert their pathogenesis. Despite this, there has been a noticeable discrepancy between the generation of derivatives in vitro and their clinical application in vivo. In most instances, phage therapy is only used on a compassionate-use basis, where all other treatment options have been exhausted. A lack of clinical trials and numerous regulatory hurdles hamper the progress of phage therapy and in turn, the engineered variants, in becoming widely used in the clinic. In this review, we outline the various types of modifications enacted upon phages and how these modifications contribute to their enhanced bactericidal function compared with wild-type phages. We also discuss the nascent progress of genetically modified phages in clinical trials along with the current issues these are confronted with, to validate it as a therapy in the clinic.

Lytic Capsule-Specific Acinetobacter Bacteriophages Encoding Polysaccharide-Degrading Enzymes

The genus Acinetobacter comprises both environmental and clinically relevant species associated with hospital-acquired infections. Among them, Acinetobacter baumannii is a critical priority bacterial pathogen, for which the research and development of new strategies for antimicrobial treatment are urgently needed. Acinetobacter spp. produce a variety of structurally diverse capsular polysaccharides (CPSs), which surround the bacterial cells with a thick protective layer. These surface structures are primary receptors for capsule-specific bacteriophages, that is, phages carrying tailspikes with CPS-depolymerizing/modifying activities. Phage tailspike proteins (TSPs) exhibit hydrolase, lyase, or esterase activities toward the corresponding CPSs of a certain structure. In this study, the data on all lytic capsule-specific phages infecting Acinetobacter spp. with genomes deposited in the NCBI GenBank database by January 2024 were summarized. Among the 149 identified TSPs encoded in the genomes of 143 phages, the capsular specificity (K specificity) of 46 proteins has been experimentally determined or predicted previously. The specificity of 63 TSPs toward CPSs, produced by various Acinetobacter K types, was predicted in this study using a bioinformatic analysis. A comprehensive phylogenetic analysis confirmed the prediction and revealed the possibility of the genetic exchange of gene regions corresponding to the CPS-recognizing/degrading parts of different TSPs between morphologically and taxonomically distant groups of capsule-specific Acinetobacter phages.

Controlling Recombination to Evolve Bacteriophages

Recombination among different phages sometimes facilitates their ability to grow on new hosts. Protocols to direct the evolution of phage host range, as might be used in the application of phage therapy, would then benefit from including steps to enable recombination. Applying mathematical and computational models, in addition to experiments using phages T3 and T7, we consider ways that a protocol may influence recombination levels. We first address coinfection, which is the first step to enabling recombination. The multiplicity of infection (MOI, the ratio of phage to cell concentration) is insufficient for predicting (co)infection levels. The force of infection (the rate at which cells are infected) is also critical but is more challenging to measure. Using both a high force of infection and high MOI (>1) for the different phages ensures high levels of coinfection. We also apply a four-genetic-locus model to study protocol effects on recombinant levels. Recombinants accumulate over multiple generations of phage growth, less so if one phage outgrows the other. Supplementing the phage pool with the low-fitness phage recovers some of this 'lost' recombination. Overall, fine tuning of phage recombination rates will not be practical with wild phages, but qualitative enhancement can be attained with some basic procedures.