Arsenate uptake by Al nanoclusters and other Al-based sorbents during water treatment

Induced Aggregation, Solvent Regulation, and Supracluster Assembly of Aluminum Oxo Clusters

ConspectusRecent years have witnessed the development of cluster materials as they are atomically precise molecules with uniform size and solution-processability, which are unattainable with traditional nanoparticles or framework materials. The motivation for studying Al(III) chemistry is not only to understand the aggregation process of aluminum in the environment but also to develop novel low-cost materials given its natural abundance. However, the Al-related clusters are underdeveloped compared to the coinage metals, lanthanides, and transition metals. The challenge in isolating crystalline compounds is the lack of an effective method to realize the controllable hydrolysis of Al(III) ions. Compared with the traditional hydrolysis of inorganic Al(III) salts in highly alkaline solutions and hydrolysis of aluminum trialkyl compounds conducted carefully in an inert operating environment, we herein developed an effective way to control the hydrolysis of aluminum isopropanol through an alcoxalation reaction. By solvothermal/low melting point solid melting synthesis and using "ligand aggregation, solvent regulation, and supracluster assembly" strategies, our laboratory has established an organic-inorganic hybrid system of aluminum oxo clusters (AlOCs). The employment of organic ligands promotes the aggregation and slows the hydrolysis of Al(III) ions, which in turn improves the crystallization process. The regulation of the structure types can be achieved through the selection of ligands and the supporting solvents. Compared with the traditional condensed polyoxoaluminates, we successfully isolated a broad range of porous AlOCs, including aluminum molecular rings and Archimedes aluminum oxo cages. By studying ring expansion, structural transformation, and intermolecular supramolecular assembly, we demonstrate unique and unprecedented structural controllability and assembly behavior in cluster science. The advancement of this universal synthetic method is to realize materials customization through modularly oriented supracluster assembly. In this Account, we will provide a clear-cut definition and terminology of "ligand aggregation, solvent regulation, and supracluster assembly". Then we will discuss the discovery in this area by using a strategy, such as aluminum molecular ring, ring size expansion, ring supracluster assembly, etc. Furthermore, given the internal and external pore structures, as well as the solubility and modifiability of the AlOCs, we will demonstrate their potential applications in both the solid and liquid phases, such as iodine capture, the optical limiting responses, and dopant in polymer dielectrics. The strategy herein can be applied to extensive cluster science and promote the research of main group element chemistry. The new synthetic method, fascinating clusters, and unprecedented assembly behaviors we have discovered will advance Al(III) chemistry and will also lay the foundation for functional applications.

A review on multi-synergistic transition metal oxide systems towards arsenic treatment: Near molecular analysis of surface-complexation (synchrotron studies/modeling tools)

The science and interface chemistry between the arsenic (As) anions and the different adsorbent systems have been gaining interest in recent years in environmental remediation applications. Metal-oxides and the corresponding hybrid systems have shown promising performance as novel adsorbents in various treatment technologies. The abundance, surface chemistry, high surface area (active-centres), various synthesis and functionalization methodologies, and good recyclability make these metal oxide-based nanomaterials as potential remediating agents for As oxyanions. This work critically reviews eight different platforms focused on the arsenic contamination issue, where the first classification describes the origin of arsenic contamination and presents geographical and demo-graphical considerations. The following section briefs the state-of-the-art remediation techniques for arsenic treatment with a comparative evaluation. An emphasized discussion has been provided regarding the adsorption and classification of various metal oxide adsorbents. In the next classification, various multi-synergism abilities like Redox activity, Surface functional groups, Surface area/morphology, Heterogeneous catalysis, Reactive oxygen species, Photo-catalytic/electro-catalytic reactions, and Electrosorption are detailed. The classification of various characterization tools for accessing the arsenic remediation qualitatively and quantitatively are given in the fifth chapter. The first-of-its-kind dedicated analysis has been given on the surface complexation aspects of the arsenic speciation onto various metal adsorbent systems using synchrotron results, surface-complexation modeling, and molecular simulation (e.g., DFT) in the sixth chapter. The current sensing applications of these novel nano-material systems for arsenic determination using colorimetric and electrochemical-based analytical tools and a note about the economic parameters, i.e., regeneration aspects of various adsorbent systems/the sustainable applications of the treated sludge materials, are provided in the final sections. This work makes a critical analysis of 'Environmental Nanotechnology' towards 'Arsenic Treatment'.

Highly efficient removal of arsenate and arsenite with potassium ferrate: role of in situ formed ferric nanoparticle

It is well known the capacity of potassium ferrate (Fe(VI)) for the oxidation of pollutants or co-precipitation and adsorption of hazardous species. However, little information has been paid on the adsorption and co-precipitation contribution of the Fe(VI) resultant nanoparticles, the in situ hydrolytic ferric iron oxides. Here, the removal of arsenate (As(V)) and arsenite (As(III)) by Fe(VI) was investigated, which focused on the interaction mechanisms of Fe(VI) with arsenic, especially in the contribution of the co-precipitation and adsorption of its hydrolytic ferric iron oxides. pH and Fe(VI) played significant roles on arsenic removal; over 97.8% and 98.1% of As(V) and As(III) removal were observed when Fe(VI):As(V) and Fe(VI):As(III) were 24:1 and 16:1 at pH 4, respectively. The removal of As(V) and As(III) by in situ and ex situ formed hydrolytic ferric iron oxides was examined respectively. The results revealed that As(III) was oxidized by Fe(VI) to As(V), and then was removed though co-precipitation and adsorption by the hydrolytic ferric iron oxides with the contribution content was about 1:3. For As(V), it could be removed directly by the in situ formed particles from Fe(VI) through co-precipitation and adsorption with the contribution content was about 1:1.5. By comparison, As(III) and As(V) were mainly removed through adsorption by the 30-min hydrolytic ferric iron oxides during the ex situ process. The hydrolytic ferric iron oxides size was obviously different in the process of in situ and ex situ, possessing abundant and multiple morphological structures ferric oxides, which was conducive for the efficient removal of arsenic. This study would provide a new perspective for understanding the potential of Fe(VI) treatment on arsenic control.

Efficient Sorption of Arsenic on Nanostructured Fe-Cu Binary Oxides: Influence of Structure and Crystallinity

To study the structure-performance relationship, a series of nanostructured Fe-Cu binary oxides (FCBOs) were prepared by varying synthesis conditions. The obtained binary oxides were well characterized using X-ray diffraction (XRD), transmission electron microscope (TEM), Brunner-Emmet-Teller (BET), magnetic and Zeta potential measurement techniques. Both As(V) and As(III) sorption on the FCBOs were evaluated by batch tests. Results show that the surface structure and crystallinity of FCBOs are greatly dependent on preparation conditions. The crystallinity of FCBOs gradually increases as the synthesis pH value increasing from 9.0 to 13.0, from amorphous phase to well-crystalline one. Simultaneously, the morphology change of FCBOs from irregular agglomerate to relatively uniform polyhedron has been observed. The sorption of arsenic is greatly influenced by the crystallinity and structure of FCBOs, decreasing with increasing degree of crystallinity. The amorphous FCBO has higher surface hydroxyl density than well-crystalline one, which might be the reason of higher sorption performance. As(V) is sorbed by the FCBOs via formation of inner-sphere surface complexes and As(III) is sorbed through formation of both inner- and outer-sphere surface complexes. This investigation provides new insights into structure-performance relationship of the FCBO system, which are beneficial to develop new and efficient sorbents.

Vanadium-substituted polycationic Al-oxo cluster in a porous ionic crystal exhibiting Lewis acidity

A vanadium-substituted polycationic Al-oxo cluster (Al28V4) in an all-inorganic porous ionic crystal exhibits Lewis acidity.

Efficient removal of arsenite by a composite of amino modified silica supported MnO2/Fe-Al hydroxide (SNMFA) prepared from biotite

Developing materials from natural minerals to efficiently remove arsenite (As(Ⅲ)) from solution is vital important for resources comprehensive utilization and environment protection. In this study, biotite containing minerals was used to prepare a novel composite of amino modified silica supported MnO₂/Fe-Al hydroxide (SNMFA composite), which was then applied to remove arsenite. Scanning electron microscope (SEM), X-ray diffraction (XRD) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) results indicated that many amorphous MnO₂ and Fe-Al hydroxide nano sheets were loaded on the surface of layered silica structure. Batch experiments showed that this composite could efficiently remove As(Ⅲ) from aqueous solution, and the maximal removal capacity was identified as 46.11 mg/g. As(Ⅲ) adsorption behaviours of SNMFA composite were confirmed by the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and Langmuir model, indicating that As(Ⅲ) adsorption on its surface was monolayer adsorption. The adsorption process was a pH and temperature dependent process, and increasing pH and temperature have facilitated the removal of As(Ⅲ). Thermodynamic analysis showed that As(Ⅲ) adsorption process was a spontaneous endothermic reaction. The As(Ⅲ) removal was mainly relied on the stable inner-sphere coordination model, and the corresponding mechanisms were involved in chelation, precipitation, oxidation-adsorption and electrostatic interaction.

Enhanced arsenic removal from water by mass re-equilibrium: kinetics and performance evaluation in a binary-adsorbent system

Because arsenic (As) is highly toxic and carcinogenic, its efficient removal from drinking water is essential. Considering some adsorption media may adsorb As fast but are too expensive to be applied in a household, while others could be abundantly available at low cost but with slow uptake kinetics, we explored a novel mass re-equilibrium (MRE) process between two media with different adsorption characteristics to enhance the overall As removal. We employed an adsorbent with fast adsorption kinetics to grab As from water, and then allow it to transfer to a second adsorbent with large capacity for As retention. In the system containing two adsorbents separated by a dialysis membrane, the results showed that As associated with a fast-adsorbing iron-based ordered mesoporous carbon could diffuse to a slow-adsorbing but high-capacity iron-based activated carbon. Column tests were further conducted, showing that the mixed medium, composed of the two adsorbents, could be used to adsorb As at a very short empty bed contact time (≤ 1 min) and the removal was improved by the MRE that potentially redistributed solid-phase As during pump-off periods. This study points to a new direction that by the MRE process, novel binary-adsorbent approaches may be developed for contaminant removal, if suitable media and process configuration could be identified.

Density functional theory and thermodynamics analysis of MAl12 Keggin substitution reactions: Insights into ion incorporation and experimental confirmation

Polyaluminum cations, such as the MAl₁₂ Keggin, undergo atomic substitutions at the heteroatom site (M), where nanoclusters with M = Al³⁺, Ga³⁺, and Ge⁴⁺ have been experimentally studied. The identity of the heteroatom M has been shown to influence the structural and electronic properties of the nanocluster and the kinetics of ligand exchange reactions. To date, only three ε-analogs have been identified, and there is a need for a predictive model to guide experiment to the discovery of new MAl₁₂ species. Here, we present a density functional theory (DFT) and thermodynamics approach to predicting favorable heteroatom substitution reactions, alongside structural analyses on hypothetical ε-MAl₁₂ nanocluster models. We delineate trends in energetics and geometry based on heteroatom cation properties, finding that Al³⁺-O bond lengths are related to heteroatom cation size, charge, and speciation. Our analyses also enable us to identify potentially isolable new ε-MAl₁₂ species, such as FeAl₁₂ ⁷⁺. Based upon these results, we evaluated the Al³⁺/Zn²⁺/Cr³⁺ system and determined that substitution of Cr³⁺ is unfavorable in the heteroatom site but is preferred for Zn²⁺, in agreement with the experimental structures. Complimentary experimental studies resulted in the isolation of Cr³⁺-substituted δ-Keggin species where Cr³⁺ substitution occurs only in the octahedral positions. The isolated structures Na[AlO₄Al_9.6Cr_2.4(OH)₂₄(H₂O)₁₂](2,6-NDS)₄(H₂O)₂₂ (δ-Cr_nAl_13-n-1) and Na[AlO₄Al_9.5Cr_2.5(OH)₂₄(H₂O)₁₂](2,7-NDS)₄(H₂O)_18.5 (δ-Cr_nAl_13-n-2) are the first pieces of evidence of mixed Al³⁺/Cr³⁺ Keggin-type nanoclusters that prefer substitution at the octahedral sites. The δ-Cr_nAl_13-n-2 structure also exhibits a unique placement of the bound Na⁺ cation, which may indicate that Cr³⁺ substitution can alter the surface reactivity of Keggin-type species.

Density Functional Theory and Thermodynamics Modeling of Inner-Sphere Oxyanion Adsorption on the Hydroxylated α-Al2O3(001) Surface

The inner-sphere adsorption of AsO₄^3-, PO₄^3-, and SO₄^2- on the hydroxylated α-Al₂O₃(001) surface was modeled with the goal of adapting a density functional theory (DFT) and thermodynamics framework for calculating the adsorption energetics. While DFT is a reliable method for predicting various properties of solids, including crystalline materials comprised of hundreds (or even thousands) of atoms, adding aqueous energetics in heterogeneous systems poses steep challenges for modeling. This is in part due to the fact that environmentally relevant variations in the chemical surroundings cannot be captured atomistically without increasing the system size beyond tractable limits. The DFT + thermodynamics approach to this conundrum is to combine the DFT total energies with tabulated solution-phase data and Nernst-based corrective terms to incorporate experimentally tunable parameters such as concentration. Central to this approach is the design of thermodynamic cycles that partition the overall reaction (here, inner-sphere adsorption proceeding via ligand exchange) into elementary steps that can either be fully calculated or for which tabulated data are available. The ultimate goal is to develop a modeling framework that takes into account subtleties of the substrate (such as adsorption-induced surface relaxation) and energies associated with the aqueous environment such that adsorption at mineral-water interfaces can be reliably predicted, allowing for comparisons in the denticity and protonation state of the adsorbing species. Based on the relative amount of experimental information available for AsO₄^3-, PO₄^3-, and SO₄^2- adsorbates and the well-characterized hydroxylated α-Al₂O₃(001) surface, these systems are chosen to form a basis for assessing the model predictions. We discuss how the DFT + thermodynamics results are in line with the experimental information about the oxyanion sorption behavior. Additionally, a vibrational analysis was conducted for the charge-neutral oxyanion complexes and is compared to the available experimental findings to discern the inner-sphere adsorption phonon modes. The DFT + thermodynamics framework used here is readily extendable to other chemical processes at solid-liquid interfaces, and we discuss future directions for modeling surface processes at mineral-water and environmental interfaces.

Ga3+ Incorporation into Al13 Keggin Polyoxometalates and the Formation of δ-(GaAl12)7+ and (Ga2.5Al28.5)19+ Polycations

Keggin-type polyaluminum species (ε-Al₁₃, δ-Al₁₃, Al₂₆, Al₃₀, Al₃₂) can form upon partial hydrolysis of Al³⁺-bearing solutions and are important species for water purification and contaminant transport. While the structural features for the major Al³⁺ polyaluminum species have been delineated, much less is known regarding heteroatom substitution and resultant structures other than the previously identified ε-GaAl₁₂⁷⁺ and ε-GeAl₁₂⁸⁺ cations. Single-atom substitution within polyaluminum species can change the surface reactivity within water treatment scenarios; thus, it is important to understand heteroatom incorporation within this system. The present work describes the synthesis and characterization of two novel Ga³⁺-substituted Keggin-type polyaluminum species. Na[GaO₄Al₁₂(OH)₂₄(H₂O)₁₂](2,6-NDS)₄(H₂O)_20.5 (δ-GaAl₁₂) and [Ga₂O₈Al_28.5Ga_0.5(OH)₅₈(H₂O)₂₇(SO₄)₂](SO₄)₄Cl₇(H₂O)_8.5 (Ga_2.5Al_28.5) were crystallized from a thermally aged, partially hydrolyzed Ga³⁺/Al³⁺ solution. Structural refinement from single-crystal X-ray diffraction indicated fully occupied Ga³⁺ within tetrahedral site(s) of both isolated species. Partial substitution was observed for octahedral sites for the larger Ga_2.5Al_28.5 cluster. The chemical compositions of both clusters were confirmed by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). Density functional theory (DFT) calculations corroborated the structural refinement, with the energetics of Ga³⁺ substitution suggesting preferential substitution within tetrahedral sites for both species. Additional theoretical work suggests that the rotated trimer in δ-GaAl₁₂ is highly reactive, which can serve as the driving force in the formation of the Ga_2.5Al_28.5 cluster.

Designable Aluminum Molecular Rings: Ring Expansion and Ligand Functionalization

Presented herein are the Al^III molecular ring architectures from 8-ring to 16-ring. Although there are numerous reported cyclic coordination compounds based on transition metals, gallium, or lanthanides, the Al versions are less developed due to the fast hydrolysis nature of Al³⁺ ion. With the assistant of monohydric alcohols, a series of atomic precisely Al molecular rings based on benzoates are synthesized. The ring expansion of these Al-rings from 8-ring to 16-ring is related to the monohydric alcohol structure-directing agents. Moreover, the organic ligands on the Al-rings can be modified by using various benzoate derivatives, which lead to tunable surface properties of the Al-rings from hydrophilicity to ultra-hydrophobicity. Importantly, 4-aminobenzoic acid bridged 16-ring is soluble in organic solvents and exhibits high solution stability revealed by mass spectroscopy. Ligand substitution also can be performed between these Al-rings, which reveal controllable ligand functionalization of these Al-rings.

Arsenic surface complexation behavior in aqueous systems onto Al substituted Ni, Co, Mn, and Cu based ferrite nano adsorbents

The present study is about surface complexation behavior of arsenic species adsorbed onto ternary metal oxide adsorbents (Ni-Al-Fe, Co-Al-Fe, Mn-Al-Fe, and Cu-Al-Fe). The analysis is carried out by X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) tool. XANES (μ(E) vs. E) spectra close to the absorption edge (i.e., As K-edge) of all samples are observed along with the As(III) and As(V) standards. The first derivative of XANES for Ni-As(V), and Cu-As(V) samples agree with that of As(V) standards, respectively. Whereas, As(III) adsorbed adsorbent systems (i.e., Ni, Co, Mn, and Cu) are observed with mixed oxidation state of arsenic. A total of 65-85 % is observed with initial oxidation state (As(III) or As(V)), and remaining 15-35 % is observed with modified oxidation state (As(V) or As(III)) that explains the occurrence of possible charge transfer. EXAFS analysis shows the As-O bond distances in the range of 1.7-1.8 Å. The corresponding As-M bond distances are around 2.7, 3.2, and 3.6 Å which confirms the formation various edge sharing (²E), and corner sharing (²C, ¹V) surface complexes. Surface coverage is understood as an important parameter as bidentate attachments (²E, ²C) are evident in As(III), and As(V), but monodentate attachments (¹V) are only observed in As(V).

Characteristics and components of poly-aluminum chloride coagulants that enhance arsenate removal by coagulation: Detailed analysis of aluminum species

We evaluated 51 poly-aluminum chloride (PACl) coagulants to determine the coagulant characteristics that were responsible for effective arsenate removal from contaminated river water by means of experiments involving coagulation, settling, and microfiltration. Some of the high-basicity PACls exhibited high arsenate removal percentages, particularly under alkaline conditions, and we investigated various relevant properties and characteristics of these high-basicity PACls. Effective arsenate removal was correlated with the content of polymeric and colloidal aluminum species (Alb and Alc) in the PACls but was not well correlated with colloid charge or zeta potential. Multiple regression analysis revealed that a portion of Alb and Alc, which reacted with the ferron reagent during the period from 30 min to 3 h, that is, the (Al_30min-3h) fraction, had the highest arsenate sorption capacity, followed by a colloidal aluminum fraction (Al_>3h, which reacted with ferron at a time of >3 h). The Al_30min-3h fraction was stable, and its arsenate sorption capacity did not decrease markedly with increasing pH. The Al_30min-3h fraction did not correspond to the Keggin-type e-Al₁₃ polycation or the δ-Al₃₀ polycation; it is likely to be an aluminum polymer that is unobservable by ²⁷Al NMR spectroscopy. Our results suggest that PACls with a high proportion of the Al_30min-3h fraction should be used for enhanced arsenate removal by coagulation. A high content of the e-Al₁₃ polycation or the δ-Al₃₀ polycation was not indispensable for effective arsenate removal.

MS title: Catalytic oxidation and removal of arsenite in the presence of Fe ions and zero-valent Al metals

Arsenic immobilization in acid mine drainage (AMD) is required prior to its discharge to safeguard aquatic organisms. Zero-valent aluminum (ZVAl) such as aluminum beverage cans (AlBC) was used to induce the oxidation of As(III) to As(V) and enhance the subsequent As removal from an artificially prepared AMD. While indiscernible As(III) oxidation was found in aerated ZVAl systems, the addition of 0.10-0.55mM Fe(II) or Fe(III) into the AMD significantly promoted the As(V) production. Reactions between Fe(II) and H2O2, which was produced through an oxidative reaction of ZVAl with dissolved oxygen, generated OH radicals. Such OH radicals subsequently induced the As(III) oxidation. Over the course of the Fenton like reaction, ZVAl not only directly generated the H2O2, but indirectly enhanced the OH radical production by replenishing Fe(II). Arsenite oxidation in the aerated ZVAl/Fe and AlBC/Fe systems followed zero- and first-order kinetics. Differences in the kinetic reactions of ZVAl and AlBC with respect to As(III) oxidation were attributed to higher productive efficiency of the oxidant in the AlBC systems. After the completion of As(III) oxidation, As(V) could be removed simultaneously with Al(III) and Fe(III) by increasing solution's pH to 6 to produce Al/Fe hydroxides as As(V) scavengers or to form Al/Fe/As co-precipitates.

Using density functional theory to study shape-reactivity relationships in Keggin Al-nanoclusters

Keggin-based aluminum nanoclusters have been shown to be efficient sorbents for the removal of arsenic from water. Obtaining a molecular-level understanding of the adsorption processes associated with these molecules is of fundamental importance, and could pave the way for rational design strategies for water treatment. Due to their size and the availability of experimental crystal structures, Al nanoclusters are computationally tractable at the density functional theory (DFT) level. Here, we compare the reactivity of three aluminum polycations: [Al13O4(OH)24(H2O)12](7+) (Al13), [Al30O8(OH)56(H2O)26](18+) (Al30), and [Al32O8(OH)60(H2O)30](20+) (Al32). We use DFT calculations to determine reactivity as a function of particle topography, using sulfate and chloride as adsorption probes. Our comparative modeling of outer-sphere adsorption of Cl(-) and SO4(2-) on Al13, Al30, and A132 supports that the unique "hourglass" shape characteristic to Al30 gives rise to relatively strong adsorption in the molecular beltway, as well as a wide range of reaction energies as a function of particle topography.