Spinal Cervical Meningiomas: The Challenge Posed by Ventral Location

The Role of Simpson Grading System in Spinal Meningioma Surgery: Institutional Case Series, Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

BACKGROUND

Although its validity has recently been questioned since its introduction, the Simpson grade has remained one of the most relevant factors in estimating the recurrence risk of intracranial meningiomas. This study aims to assess its role in spinal meningiomas through a retrospective analysis of a mono-institutional surgical series and literature meta-analysis.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature from 1980 to 2023, complemented by a mono-institutional series of 74 patients treated at "Santa Maria delle Grazie" hospital. Demographic, clinical, neuroradiological, pathological, surgical, and outcome data of case series were analyzed. For the meta-analysis, studies were selected based on predefined inclusion criteria, and a fixed-effects model was used to synthesize data due to assumed homogeneity among included studies. Statistical analyses included odds ratios (OR) for recurrence risk and assessment of publication bias using Peter's test.

RESULTS

Mono-institutional sample included 74 patients, most of whom were women (85%) with a median age of 61.9 years. The thoracic spine was the most common tumor location (81%). Recurrences occurred in patients with Simpson grade II and III resections. The meta-analysis involved 2142 patients from 25 studies and revealed a significantly higher recurrence rate for Simpson grades III-V compared to grades I-II (OR 0.10; CI95 0.06-0.16). Additionally, Simpson grade II had a higher recurrence risk than grade I (OR 0.42; CI95 0.20-0.90).

CONCLUSIONS

The Simpson grading remains a valid predictor of recurrence also for spinal meningiomas. Our findings revealed a significant increase in recurrence rate with higher Simpson grades. These results support the need to strive for Simpson grade I resection when feasible.

Safety and efficacy of posterior approach for resection of spinal meningioma: Impact of dural attachment location

BACKGROUND

Spinal meningiomas (SMs) are common benign tumors that are typically treated with surgical resection. The choice of surgical approach may vary depending on the location of dural attachment of the SM, with a posterior approach being the traditional preference. However, there is limited research available on the impact of dural attachment location on outcomes following posterior approach for SM resection.

AIM

To investigate the outcomes of posterior approach for SM resection, and compare the results among different dural attachment location subgroups.

METHODS

Between January 2013 and February 2023, a total of 34 SM patients were included in the study. Various clinical and radiologic features, functional states before and after surgery, operating time, intraoperative blood loss, tumor recurrence, and perioperative complications were assessed and compared.

RESULTS

The average age of the included 34 patients' (10 males and 24 females) age was 62.09 years. Mean follow-up duration was 22.65 months. The location of SM was the thoracic spine in 32 cases, with only 2 in the cervical spine. On average, intraoperative blood loss was 520.59 mL, and operating time was 176.76 minutes. Thirty three cases had successful outcomes while only 1 experienced an unexpected outcome. The tumor recurrence rate was 2.9%. After surgery, there were 3 cases of cerebral spinal fluid leakage, 1 case of pneumonia, and 1 case of urinary tract infection. Dural attachments were predominantly found dorsal or dorsolateral (13 cases), followed by ventral or ventrolateral (14 cases), and lateral (7 cases). The outcomes among these subgroups were similar.

CONCLUSION

The posterior approach for SM resection is safe and effective, yielding comparable surgical and neurological outcomes regardless of the dural attachment location.

One-piece resection for the treatment of ventral intradural extramedullary spinal meningioma: a retrospective study

Objective

This study aimed to evaluate the feasibility and efficacy of one-piece resection for the treatment of ventral intradural extramedullary spinal meningiomas (VIESMs).

Methods

Between January 2017 and December 2023, all patients who underwent one-piece resection for VIESMs were retrospectively reviewed with their demographic, intraoperative and postoperative data being recorded. In addition, postoperative neurological status based on the modified McCormick functional schema (mMFS), along with radiological manifestations on the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were assessed and compared with that before the operation.

Results

A total of 27 cases (7 men and 20 women) with an average age of 63.37 ± 10.48 years old were included in the present study with the operation time, blood loss, length of hospital stay, and follow-up periods being 292.41 ± 42.64 min, 286.85 ± 47.03 ml, 10.37 ± 1.69 days, and 16.81 ± 10.79 months, respectively. Postoperatively, one case experienced cerebrospinal fluid leakage without neurological deterioration. At the final follow-up, the mMFS scores were unchanged in seven (25.93%) cases while they improved in the remaining 20 (74.07%) cases. Finally, the MRI examinations showed that one-piece resection was successfully performed for each VIESM without a recurrence.

Conclusion

One-piece resection was a feasible, safe and effective procedure for treating VIESMs. Partial removal of the ipsilateral pedicle, facet joint, and even posterior vertebral wall to establish a wide surgical corridor and vision, resection of the dentate ligaments to minimize spinal cord traction, and meticulous coagulation of the dural attachment to reduce recurrence were the key technical points.

Resection vs. coagulation of dural attachment in patients with spinal meningioma: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

The Simpson grading scale assumes dural resection (grade I) is more effective against recurrence than coagulation (grade II). However, the results of recent studies have raised doubts about this effectiveness in spinal meningiomas. Therefore, we aimed to perform a meta-analysis comparing outcomes between Simpson grades I and II in spinal meningiomas.

METHODS

According to the PRISMA statement, we systematically searched PubMed, EMBASE, and Web of Science for studies involving patients with spinal meningiomas who underwent Simpson grades I, II, III, or IV. Outcomes were radiological tumor recurrence, postoperative neurological deficits, and procedure-related complications.

RESULTS

We included 54 studies with a total of 3334 patients. Simpson grades I, II, III, and IV were performed in 674 (20%), 2205 (66%), 254 (8%), and 201 (6%) patients, respectively. The follow-up ranged from 9 to 192 months, and 95.4% of all tumors were WHO grade 1. There was no difference in radiological tumor recurrence (OR 0.80, 95% CI: 0.46-1.36, P = 0.41; I2 = 0%), postoperative neurological deficits (OR 0.74, 95% CI: 0.32-1.75, P = 0.50; I2 = 0%) or procedure-related complications (OR 2.22, 95% CI: 0.80-6.13, P = 0.12; I2 = 3%) between Simpson grades I and II. Furthermore, no significant difference in postoperative neurological deficits or procedure-related complications was detected when comparing all Simpson's to each other. However, radiological tumor recurrences in Simpson I and II were significantly lower than in III and IV, with Simpson III outperforming IV (OR 0.19, 95% CI: 0.09-0.40, P < 0.01; I2 = 0%).

CONCLUSION

Simpson grade I is not more effective than grade II in any outcome, although both are superior to III and IV in tumor recurrence. Our results might suggest that dural coagulation is preferable over resection when the latter carries a higher risk of complications.

Lateral cervical approach for ventrally located upper cervical meningioma: experience of 14 cases with a narrative comparison with other surgical techniques

BACKGROUND

Upper cervical meningioma represents a large portion of intradural extramedullary tumors that occur in the cervical spinal canal. Most of them are located ventrally or ventrolateral to the spinal cord. Reaching lesions at this location surgically is technically challenging.

OBJECTIVES

The ideal approach to ventrally located upper cervical lesions continues to be controversial. The aim of this study was to discuss the advantage of the lateral cervical approach and compare it with other surgical routes.

METHODS

This retrospective study was conducted on all cases of ventrally located upper cervical meningiomas (C1-C3) who have been operated on using the lateral cervical approach in a tertiary neurosurgery unit between 2006 and 2020. Demographic, clinical, surgical, and follow-up data were collected from hospital records.

RESULTS

During the study period, fourteen patients (Nine females and five males, aged 42-73 years) were recruited. The follow-up period was 2-16 years. The most frequent presenting symptoms were neck pain, occipital headache, motor deficits, and sensory disturbances. Total excision was achieved in all patients. All patients who had preoperative motor deficits improved significantly postoperatively, and those who presented with sensory disturbance had partial recovery. There was neither mortality nor permanent neurological morbidity.

CONCLUSION

A lateral cervical approach is a safe approach for ventrally located upper cervical lesions. In our series, it offered enough exposure for a safe dissection and total or extensive subtotal removal of the tumors. Retraction or rotation of the neuroaxis was avoided, and the incidence of complications (injury of neural or vascular structures, instability, infection) was very low.

Posterolateral Paramass Approach to Lesions Located at the Anterior C1-2 Level: A Cadaver Study

OBJECTIVE

A novel posteriolateral surgical approach is described that will provide safe access to intradural and extradural lesions located in the anterior part of the spinal cord (SC) at the C1-2 level and to the odontoid in single session.

METHODS

A total of five cadavers and two dry C1 vertebrae were used in this study. The study involved obtaining computed tomography magnetic resonance imaging scans and magnetic resonance imaging of all cadaver groups before and after the procedures. Group 1: Control; Group 2: Unilateral C1 posterior arch was removed, the inferomedial part of C1 lateral mass was removed, and access the anterior and lateral aspects of the SC. Group 3: In addition, odontoid was removed, Group 4: In addition, unilateral C1- C2 screw was placed. Group 5: In addition, bilateral C1-C2 screw was placed.

RESULTS

The median distance from the midpoint of C1 posterior tubercle to vertebral groove which was removed in groups is 21.4 ± 2.88 mm. The average width of C1 lateral mass was 13.4±2.4 mm. After the lateral mass was drilled, its width decreased to 10,2 mm.This area was sufficient to open a surgical corridor and reach the anterior of SC and odontoid. After the procedure, no instability was found in group 2 without instrumentation on computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging scans.

CONCLUSIONS

It is possible to access the anterior C1-C2 via a posterolateral paramass approach by drilling 20%-30% of the lateral mass, providing an open pathway for easy intervention in C1-C2 intradural lesions. It is also possible to perform odontoid resection using this approach.

Posterior-based resection of spinal meningiomas: an institutional experience of 141 patients with an average of 28 months of follow-up

OBJECTIVE

Spinal meningiomas pose unique challenges based on the location of their dural attachment. However, there is a paucity of literature investigating the role of dural attachment location on outcomes after posterior-based approach for spinal meningioma resection. The aim of this study was to investigate any differences in outcomes between dural attachment location subgroups in spinal meningioma patients who underwent posterior-based resection.

METHODS

This was a single-institution review of patients who underwent resection of a spinal meningioma from 1997 to 2017. Surgical, oncological, and neurological outcomes were compared between patients with varying dural attachments. Multivariate analysis was utilized.

RESULTS

A total of 141 patients were identified. The mean age was 62 years, and 110 women were included. The sites of dural attachments were as follows: 16 (11.3%) dorsal, 31 (22.0%) dorsolateral, 17 (12.1%) lateral, 40 (28.4%) ventral, and 37 (26.2%) ventrolateral. Most meningiomas were WHO grade I (92.2%) and in the thoracic spine (61.0%). All patients underwent a posterior approach for tumor resection. There were no differences between subgroups in terms of largest diameter of tumor resected (p = 0.201), gross-total resection (GTR) or subtotal resection (p = 0.362), Simpson grade of resection, perioperative complications (p = 0.116), long-term neurological deficit (p = 0.100), or postoperative radiation therapy (p = 0.971). Cervical spine location was associated with reduced incidence of GTR (OR 0.271, 95% CI 0.108-0.684, p = 0.006) on multivariate analysis. The overall incidence of recurrence/progression was 4.6%, with no difference (p = 0.800) between subgroups. Similarly, the average length of follow-up was 28.1 months, with no difference between subgroups (p = 0.413).

CONCLUSIONS

Posterior-based approaches for resection of spinal meningiomas are safe and effective, regardless of dural attachment location, with similar surgical, oncological, and neurological outcomes. Comparison of long-term recurrence rates between dural attachment subgroups is required.

The current state of navigation in robotic spine surgery

The advent and widespread adoption of pedicle screw instrumentation prompted the need for image guidance in spine surgery to improve accuracy and safety. Although the conventional method, fluoroscopy, is readily available and inexpensive, concerns regarding radiation exposure and the drive to provide better visual guidance spurred the development of computer-assisted navigation. Contemporaneously, a non-navigated robotic guidance platform was also introduced as a competing modality for pedicle screw placement. Although the robot could provide high precision trajectory guidance by restricting four of the six degrees of freedom (DOF), the lack of real-time depth control and high capital acquisition cost diminished its popularity, while computer-assisted navigation platforms became increasingly sophisticated and accepted. The recent integration of real-time 3D navigation with robotic platforms has resulted in a resurgence of interest in robotics in spine surgery with the recent introduction of numerous navigated robotic platforms. The currently available navigated robotic spine surgery platforms include the ROSA Spine Robot (Zimmer Biomet Robotics formerly Medtech SA, Montpellier, France), ExcelsiusGPS^® (Globus Medical, Inc., Audubon, PA, USA), Mazor X spine robot (Medtronic Navigation Louisville, CO; Medtronic Spine, Memphis, TN; formerly Mazor Robotics, Caesarea, Israel) and TiRobot (TINAVI Medical Technologies, Beijing, China). Here we provide an overview of these navigated spine robotic platforms, existing applications, and potential future avenues of implementation.

Microsurgical Management of Ventral Intradural-Extramedullary Cervical Meningiomas: Technical Considerations and Outcomes

OBJECTIVE

Cervical meningiomas are uncommon intradural-extramedullary tumors that have a tendency to be situated anterior to the spinal cord. The optimal surgical corridor to reach purely ventral cervical meningiomas has not been established. This article presents a series of patients with ventral cervical meningiomas treated via 1 of 2 microneurosurgical approaches: the anterior approach with corpectomy and fusion or the posterolateral approach.

METHODS

Eight patients who underwent surgical resection of solitary, histopathologically confirmed, intradural-extramedullary cervical meningiomas of purely ventral location were retrospectively examined. Preoperative and postoperative Nurick scores quantified the degree of ambulatory function. Patients were followed for an average of 2.1 years after surgery. Postoperative imaging was performed to determine the extent of resection and to assess for tumor recurrence.

RESULTS

Two patients with lower cervical meningiomas underwent resection via an anterior approach with single-level corpectomy and fusion. Six patients were treated via a posterolateral approach including ipsilateral hemilaminectomy and partial facetectomy without fusion. No intraoperative or postoperative complications were observed. Gross total resection was achieved in 8 of 8 patients, although 1 patient exhibited tumor recurrence. Improvement in ambulatory function was observed in all patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Purely ventral cervical meningiomas are uncommon and pose unique technical challenges for neurosurgeons. We document favorable outcomes from 2 cases of lower cervical meningioma treated via an anterior approach and 6 cases of upper cervical tumors treated via a posterolateral approach. This series demonstrates operative considerations for effectively managing ventral cervical meningiomas.

Surgical management of spinal meningiomas: focus on unilateral posterior approach and anterior localization

OBJECTIVESpinal meningiomas (sMNGs) are relatively rare in comparison to intracranial MNGs. sMNGs localized anterior to the denticulate ligament (aMNGs) represent a surgically challenging subgroup. A high perioperative complication rate due to the need for complex surgical approaches has been described. In the present study, the authors report on their surgical experience that involves two institutions in which 207 patients underwent surgery for sMNGs. Special focus was placed on patients with aMNGs that were treated via a unilateral posterior approach (ULPA).METHODSBetween 2005 and 2017, 207 patients underwent resection of sMNGs at one of two institutions. The following characteristics were assessed: tumor size and localization, surgical approach, duration of surgery, grade of resection, peri- and postoperative complication rates, and neurological outcome. Data were compared between the subgroups of patients according to the lesion's relationship to the denticulate ligament and to surgical approach.RESULTSThe authors identified 48 patients with aMNGs, 86 patients with lateral MNGs, and 76 patients with posterior MNGs (pMNGs). Overall, 66.6% of aMNGs and 64% of pMNGs were reached via a ULPA. aMNGs that were approached via a ULPA showed reduced duration of surgery (131 vs 224 minutes, p < 0.0001) and had surgical complication rates and neurological outcomes comparable to those of lesions that were approached via a bilateral approach. No significant differences in complication rate, outcomes, and extent of resection were seen between aMNGs and pMNGs.CONCLUSIONSThe duration of surgery, extent of resection, and outcomes are comparable between aMNGs and pMNGs when removed via a ULPA. Thus, ULPA represents a safe route to achieve a gross-total resection, even in cases of aMNG.