Diagnostic gap in genetic epilepsies: A matter of age

The natural history of CDKL5 deficiency disorder into adulthood

Knowledge of the natural history of CDKL5 deficiency disorder (CDD) is limited to the results of cross-sectional analysis of largely pediatric cohorts. Assessment of outcomes in adulthood is critical for clinical decision-making and future precision medicine approaches but is challenging because of the diagnostic gap and duration of follow-up that would be required for prospective studies. We aimed to delineate the natural history retrospectively from adulthood. We analyzed clinical data about an international cohort of 67 adults with CDD. We analyzed demographic, phenotypic, CDKL5 Developmental Score (CDS), and treatment data, and tested associations with genetic factors, sex, and a positive or negative history of neonatal seizures, as an early predictor of prognosis. All but one of 67 adults (55 females, median age of 24 years at last follow-up) had epilepsy, typically beginning with epileptic spasms or tonic seizures before 4 months of age. Focal-onset and non-motor seizures emerged later. Fewer than a third had been documented as having bilateral tonic-clonic seizures or status epilepticus. Seizures often improved with age, but 73% had never experienced more than 6 months of seizure-freedom. Clobazam, sodium valproate, and lamotrigine were the most frequently prescribed antiseizure medications, but no specific treatment demonstrated superiority. Common comorbidities included movement disorders, visual impairment, sleep disorders, constipation, and scoliosis. All participants had intellectual disability, 75% had not acquired speech and 45% had regressed developmentally. 16% never achieved any CDS skill, but most attained at least three, and 28% attained six or all seven. By adulthood, half of those who had achieved any CDS skill retained all their CDS skills. The skills most frequently lost were independent walking and standing. Those with a history of neonatal seizures tended to attain fewer CDS skills and were more likely to have abnormal muscle tone in adulthood, atrioventricular conduction delay, and potential complications of their illness and treatment. Individuals carrying missense variants attained more CDS skills than those with other variants and were more likely to lose skills in adulthood and develop anxiety, possibly reflecting the limited neurodevelopment of those with non-missense variants, who manifested a more multisystemic disorder. In summary, retrospective data from adulthood elucidates the evolution of symptoms, variation in developmental outcomes, and the treatment landscape in CDKL5 deficiency disorder. Presence a non-missense variants or a history of neonatal seizures indicates a more complex disorder and lower developmental trajectory. Our findings will inform management decisions, prognostication, and the design of clinical trials in CDKL5 Deficiency Disorder.

Adult Phenotype of CHD2-Associated Disorders

Background and Objectives

Pathogenic CHD2 variants are associated with neurodevelopmental disorders and developmental and epileptic encephalopathy. While pediatric CHD2 phenotypes have been readily explored, adult phenotypes are not well understood. We aimed to investigate the phenotypic spectrum of adult patients with CHD2 variants.

Methods

Patients 18 years or older with likely pathogenic or pathogenic (LP/P) CHD2 variants were included. We used standardized tools to evaluate current seizures, medication use, sleep, gastrointestinal symptoms, pain response, gait, social communication disorder, and adaptive behavioral skills of patients.

Results

In this prospective study, 14 unrelated adult patients (age range: 18-45 years, median: 21 years) with LP/P CHD2 variants were described. Eleven novel variants were identified. No genotype-phenotype correlations were identified. 79% of adults still have ongoing seizures. Photosensitivity was present in 64% of adult patients. Autism spectrum disorder was diagnosed in 71% of patients. Only 29% were able to read and understand material at a sixth-grade level or higher. Behavioral issues were reported in 100% of adult patients, and 71% had internalizing features, such as anxiety. Self-injurious behaviors were present in 50%. Only 43% could ambulate independently. Additional characteristics included reflux (36%), constipation (71%), and abnormal pain responsiveness (43%). 1 patient presented with nonepileptic breath-holding spells leading to cyanosis. No patient could perform all basic activities of daily living independently, all the time. Higher seizure severity was associated with worse nonseizure outcomes (p = 0.04).

Discussion

Most adults with CHD2 continue to have seizures, and seizure severity is associated with worse comorbidities such as maladaptive behaviors, gait, gastrointestinal, sleep, and abnormal pain responsiveness. Longevity has not been systematically studied in this group of patients. Here we describe a group of adult patients (up to 45 years of age) and the natural history of this condition. These data may provide prognostic insights for families of pediatric patients and help identify key points to be addressed in future precision trials for patients with CHD2 variants.

Providing quality care for people with CDKL5 deficiency disorder: A European expert panel opinion on the patient journey

Cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) is a developmental and epileptic encephalopathy caused by variants in the CDKL5 gene. The disorder is characterized by intractable early-onset seizures, severe neurodevelopmental delay, hypotonia, motor disabilities, cerebral (cortical) visual impairment and microcephaly. With no disease-modifying therapies available for CDD, treatment is symptomatic with an initial focus on seizure control. Another unmet need in the management of people with CDD is the lack of evidence to aid standardized care and guideline development. To address this gap, experts in CDD and representatives from patient advocacy groups from Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Spain, and the United Kingdom convened to form an Expert Working Group. The aim was to provide an expert opinion consensus on how to ensure quality care in routine clinical practice within the European setting, including in settings with limited experience or resources for multidisciplinary care of CDD and other developmental and epileptic encephalopathies. By means of one-to-one interviews around the current treatment landscape in CDD, insights from the Expert Working Group were collated and developed into a Europe-specific patient journey for individuals with CDD, which was later validated by the group. Further discussions followed to gain consensus of opinions on challenges and potential solutions for achieving quality care in this setting. The panel recognized the benefit of early genetic testing, a holistic personalized approach to seizure control (taking into consideration various factors such as concomitant medications and comorbidities), and age- and comorbidity-dependent multidisciplinary care for optimizing patient outcomes and quality of life. However, their insights and experiences also highlighted much disparity in management approaches and resources across different European countries. Development of standardized European recommendations is required to align realistic diagnostic criteria, treatment goals, and management approaches that can be adapted for different settings. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) is a rare condition caused by a genetic mutation with a broad range of symptoms apparent from early childhood, including epileptic seizures that do not respond to medication and severe delays in development. Due to the lack of guidance on managing CDD, international experts and patient advocates discussed best practices in the care of people with CDD in Europe. The panel agreed that early testing, a personalized approach to managing seizures, and access to care from different disciplines are beneficial. Development of guidelines to ensure that care is standardized would also be valuable.

Genetic Testing in Epilepsy: Improving Outcomes and Informing Gaps in Research

While the diagnosis of epilepsy relies on the presence of seizures, it encompasses a group of phenotypically and etiologically diverse disorders in which seizures may only be one of a constellation of symptoms. There are genetic, structural, and metabolic causes, but most epilepsy syndromes have some genetic predisposition. The importance of genetics in the diagnosis and management of epilepsy has been increasingly recognized over the past 2 decades. With increased access to testing tools and new recommendations that all patients with unexplained epilepsy get genetic testing, it is becoming part of routine clinical care. Increased testing has resulted in an explosion in the number of genes and genetic changes identified and it is changing our understanding of the mechanisms of epileptogenesis. Advances in both clinical genetics and scientific discovery are expanding our potential to impact patient care as well as creating dilemmas. This brief review will highlight where we are regarding our ability to obtain a genetic diagnosis, how diagnoses impact patient care, and the next likely frontiers in diagnosis and management.

The Charlotte Project: Recommendations for patient-reported outcomes and clinical parameters in Dravet syndrome through a qualitative and Delphi consensus study

Objective

The appropriate management of patients with Dravet Syndrome (DS) is challenging, given the severity of symptoms and the burden of the disease for patients and caregivers. This study aimed to identify, through a qualitative methodology and a Delphi consensus-driven process, a set of recommendations for the management of DS to guide clinicians in the assessment of the clinical condition and quality of life (QoL) of DS patients, with a special focus on patient- and caregiver-reported outcomes (PROs).

Methods

This study was conducted in five phases, led by a multidisciplinary scientific committee (SC) including pediatric neurologists, epileptologists, a neuropsychologist, an epilepsy nurse, and members of DS patient advocates. In phases 1 and 2, a questionnaire related to patients' QoL was prepared and answered by caregivers and the SC. In phase 3, the SC generated, based on these answers and on a focus group discussion, a 70-item Delphi questionnaire, covering six topic categories on a nine-point Likert scale. In phase 4, 32 panelists, from different Spanish institutions and with a multidisciplinary background, answered the questionnaire. Consensus was obtained and defined as strong or moderate if ≥80% and 67–79% of panelists, respectively, rated the statement with ≥7. Phase 5 consisted of the preparation of the manuscript.

Results

The panelists agreed on a total of 69 items (98.6%), 54 (77.14%), and 15 (21.43%) with strong and moderate consensus, respectively. The experts' recommendations included the need for frequent assessment of patient and caregivers QoL parameters. The experts agreed that QoL should be assessed through specific questionnaires covering different domains. Likewise, the results showed consensus regarding the regular evaluation of several clinical parameters related to neurodevelopment, attention, behavior, other comorbidities, and sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP). A consensus was also reached on the instruments, specific parameters, and caregivers' education in the routine clinical management of patients with DS.

Conclusions

This consensus resulted in a set of recommendations for the assessment of clinical and QoL parameters, including PROs, related to the general evaluation of QoL, neurodevelopment, attention, behavior, other comorbidities affecting QoL, SUDEP, and QoL of caregivers/relatives and patients with DS.

Effect of Fenfluramine on Seizures and Comorbidities in SCN8A-Developmental and Epileptic Encephalopathy: A Case Series

SCN8A-developmental and epileptic encephalopathy is caused by mutations in the SCN8A gene encoding the Na_v 1.6 sodium channel, and is characterized by intractable multivariate seizures and developmental regression. Fenfluramine is a repurposed drug with proven antiseizure efficacy in Dravet syndrome and Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. The effect of fenfluramine treatment was assessed in a retrospective series of three patients with intractable SCN8A epilepsy and severe neurodevelopmental comorbidity (n=2 females; age 2.8-13 years; 8-16 prior failed antiseizure medications (ASM); treatment duration: 0.75-4.2 years). In the 6 months prior to receiving fenfluramine, patients experienced multiple seizure types, including generalized tonic-clonic, focal and myoclonic seizures, and status epilepticus. Overall seizure reduction was 60%-90% in the last 3, 6, and 12 months of fenfluramine treatment. Clinically meaningful improvement was noted in ≥1 non-seizure comorbidity per patient after fenfluramine, as assessed by physician-ratings of ≥"Much Improved" on the Clinical Global Impression of Improvement scale. Improvements included ambulation in a previously non-ambulant patient and better attention, sleep, and language. One patient showed mild irritability which resolved; no other treatment-related adverse events were reported. There were no reports of valvular heart disease or pulmonary arterial hypertension. Fenfluramine may be a promising ASM for randomized clinical trials in SCN8A-related disorders.

The Genetic Diagnosis of Ultrarare DEEs: An Ongoing Challenge

Epileptic encephalopathies (EEs) and developmental and epileptic encephalopathies (DEEs) are a group of severe early-onset neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs). In recent years, next-generation equencing (NGS) technologies enabled the discovery of numerous genes involved in these conditions. However, more than 50% of patients remained undiagnosed. A major obstacle lies in the high degree of genetic heterogeneity and the wide phenotypic variability that has characterized these disorders. Interpreting a large amount of NGS data is also a crucial challenge. This study describes a dynamic diagnostic procedure used to investigate 17 patients with DEE or EE with previous negative or inconclusive genetic testing by whole-exome sequencing (WES), leading to a definite diagnosis in about 59% of participants. Biallelic mutations caused most of the diagnosed cases (50%), and a pathogenic somatic mutation resulted in 10% of the subjects. The high diagnostic yield reached highlights the relevance of the scientific approach, the importance of the reverse phenotyping strategy, and the involvement of a dedicated multidisciplinary team. The study emphasizes the role of recessive and somatic variants, new genetic mechanisms, and the complexity of genotype–phenotype associations. In older patients, WES results could end invasive diagnostic procedures and allow a more accurate transition. Finally, an early pursued diagnosis is essential for comprehensive care of patients, precision approach, knowledge of prognosis, patient and family planning, and quality of life.

Epilepsy Genetics and Precision Medicine in Adults: A New Landscape for Developmental and Epileptic Encephalopathies

This review aims to provide an updated perspective of epilepsy genetics and precision medicine in adult patients, with special focus on developmental and epileptic encephalopathies (DEEs), covering relevant and controversial issues, such as defining candidates for genetic testing, which genetic tests to request and how to interpret them. A literature review was conducted, including findings in the discussion and recommendations. DEEs are wide and phenotypically heterogeneous electroclinical syndromes. They generally have a pediatric presentation, but patients frequently reach adulthood still undiagnosed. Identifying the etiology is essential, because there lies the key for precision medicine. Phenotypes modify according to age, and although deep phenotyping has allowed to outline certain entities, genotype-phenotype correlations are still poor, commonly leading to long-lasting diagnostic odysseys and ineffective therapies. Recent adult series show that the target patients to be identified for genetic testing are those with epilepsy and different risk factors. The clinician should take active part in the assessment of the pathogenicity of the variants detected, especially concerning variants of uncertain significance. An accurate diagnosis implies precision medicine, meaning genetic counseling, prognosis, possible future therapies, and a reduction of iatrogeny. Up to date, there are a few tens of gene mutations with additional concrete treatments, including those with restrictive/substitutive therapies, those with therapies modifying signaling pathways, and channelopathies, that are worth to be assessed in adults. Further research is needed regarding phenotyping of adult syndromes, early diagnosis, and the development of targeted therapies.

Phenotypic homogeneity in childhood epilepsies evolves in gene-specific patterns across 3251 patient-years of clinical data

While genetic studies of epilepsies can be performed in thousands of individuals, phenotyping remains a manual, non-scalable task. A particular challenge is capturing the evolution of complex phenotypes with age. Here, we present a novel approach, applying phenotypic similarity analysis to a total of 3251 patient-years of longitudinal electronic medical record data from a previously reported cohort of 658 individuals with genetic epilepsies. After mapping clinical data to the Human Phenotype Ontology, we determined the phenotypic similarity of individuals sharing each genetic etiology within each 3-month age interval from birth up to a maximum age of 25 years. 140 of 600 (23%) of all 27 genes and 3-month age intervals with sufficient data for calculation of phenotypic similarity were significantly higher than expect by chance. 11 of 27 genetic etiologies had significant overall phenotypic similarity trajectories. These do not simply reflect strong statistical associations with single phenotypic features but appear to emerge from complex clinical constellations of features that may not be strongly associated individually. As an attempt to reconstruct the cognitive framework of syndrome recognition in clinical practice, longitudinal phenotypic similarity analysis extends the traditional phenotyping approach by utilizing data from electronic medical records at a scale that is far beyond the capabilities of manual phenotyping. Delineation of how the phenotypic homogeneity of genetic epilepsies varies with age could improve the phenotypic classification of these disorders, the accuracy of prognostic counseling, and by providing historical control data, the design and interpretation of precision clinical trials in rare diseases.

Sodium channel blockers for the treatment of epilepsy in CDKL5 deficiency disorder: Findings from a multicenter cohort

OBJECTIVE

This study was aimed to analyze the effectiveness of sodium channel blockers (SCBs) in CDKL5 deficiency disorder (CDD)-related epilepsy.

METHODS

A retrospective, observational study was performed, including patients with CDD diagnosis evaluated between 2016 and 2019 at three tertiary Epilepsy Centers. Demographic, electroclinical and genetic features, as well as ASM treatments and their outcomes were analyzed, with special focus on SCBs.

RESULTS

Twenty-one patients evaluated at three tertiary Epilepsy Centers were included, of which 19 presented with epilepsy (90.5%); all had pathogenic mutations of CDKL5. Six patients (31.6%) were classified as SCB responders (more than 50% reduction), four being currently seizure free (mean seizure-free period of 8 years). Most frequent SCB drugs were oxcarbazepine (OXC), carbamazepine (CBZ), and lacosamide (LCM). None of them presented relevant adverse events. In contrast, three patients showed seizure aggravation in the non-responder group. When comparing both groups, responders had statistically significant younger age at SCB treatment and epilepsy onset, higher proportion of focal epileptiform activity and less frequent history of West syndrome.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study indicate that treatment with SCBs might be effective and safe in a subset of patients with CDD-related epilepsy.