[Medical school admission test at the University of Goettingen - which applicants will benefit?]

Association of professional pre-qualifications, study success in medical school and the eligibility for becoming a physician: A scoping review

BACKGROUND

Literature, individual experiences and common considerations suggest that prior professional qualification can be an advantage for later career development. For instance, in Germany, professional pre-qualification has been honored by medical faculties in selection procedures for several years. However, a systematic evaluation of this relationship lacks. This scoping review summarizes existing literature and addresses the role of prior professional pre-qualifications on objective or subjective study success and the choice of a specialization.

METHODS

The scoping review was performed oriented on the PRISMA guidelines. PsycINFO and PubMed databases were searched for relevant studies that included data of medical students with and without professional pre-qualifications. To answer the underlying research questions, this scoping review also includes studies that examine professional pre-qualifications in association with non-cognitive "soft" criteria.

RESULTS AND FURTHER DIRECTIONS

1055 items were identified and reviewed by two independent reviewers with final 11 studies were included for this scoping review. The results of identified studies that report possible effects of prior pre-professional qualifications are inconclusive but suggest that prior professional qualifications tend not to have rather an advantage on study success. Medical school success for students with prior professional qualifications tended to be below average in the preclinical setting, and there were no differences in the clinical setting compared with students without prior professional qualifications. The influence of professional pre-qualifications has not yet been adequately studied without the moderator variable "waiting time" and "A-levels grade". The scoping review indicates insufficient number of articles stating a co-relation of prior pre-qualifications and subjective data. Again, the results found are not sufficient to state a clear relationship between professional pre-qualifications and the choice of a specific speciality preference. However, professional pre-qualifications, both in medicine and as "practical experience in rural areas", tend to be beneficial for the choice of becoming a rural physician. Large-scale cross-sectional and longitudinal studies are needed to investigate the influence of professional pre-qualifications on different study trajectory parameters.

[Selection interviews at Hanover Medical School (MHH): determinants of student selection in medical studies]

INTRODUCTION

In order to incorporate social and communicative skills in its student admissions process, Hanover Medical School (MHH) has conducted selection interviews (in combination with the high-school GPA) to choose 60 % of its freshmen in medical studies. The present article analyses if applicants' performances in the interviews were the determining criterion of student selection, despite a higher weighting of school grades in the admission process. Furthermore, this article checks whether the grading of the interviews was independent of the applicants' gender, age, origin and educational background.

METHODS

For a sample of more than 3,000 successful and unsuccessful participants in the MHH student admission process in the years 2010-2017, we employ variance analysis and logistic regression analysis to determine those factors that have contributed to the chances of being offered a place at the MHH after a successful interview.

RESULTS

The scores received in the selection interview were the sole determinant of being offered a place at the MHH; neither the applicants'age nor their gender or origin biased the decisions of the selection committees. The grading of the interview was also not affected by school GPAs.

DISCUSSION

The selection interviews at the MHH have been costly in terms of both financial and human resources. However, this selection method has been popular among students and lecturers alike, not least because its elements fit the MHH's focus on early bedside teaching and social skills of prospective physicians. However, there is no evidence that selection interviews are effective in predicting academic success.

CONCLUSIONS

The present article has shown that the selection interviews acted up to the principles defined by the MHH: very homogenous high school GPAs were complemented by differentiated interview assessments that did not discriminate by sociodemographic characteristics. It is, however, unclear if the MHH will resume the interviews after the end of a federally mandated halt to stand-alone selection methods at medical schools in Germany.

From HAM-Nat to the "Physikum" - Analysis of the study success parameters before and after the introduction of a science test in the approval procedure

Background/Objectives: For the winter semester 2012/13, the Medical School of Otto-von-Guericke University Magdeburg introduced the HAM-Nat test (Hamburg Assessment Test for Medical Degrees - Natural Sciences Section) for the selection of its study applicants with the aim of improving the academic success of their students in the pre-clinical part which has a heavy emphasis on natural sciences. The study examines the extent to which the new University Selection Procedure (AdH) influences two criteria for measuring students' success, compliance with the standard period of study up until the first part of the medical state exam (M1) and its result. Methodology: A comparison of above-mentioned parameters for measuring student success for the matriculation years 2008-2011 (no HAM-Nat test, Pre-Matriculation) and those of the matriculation years 2012-2014 (Nat-Matriculation), whose students have passed the HAM-Nat test in the selection process of the university. In addition, it was taken into account the number of course certificates gained within the standard time period. In the Nat-Matriculation, the HAM-Nat results were merged with the associated M1 exam results. Results: The proportion of AdH students who were admitted to the Physikum (first part of the medical state exam (M1)) within the standard period of study only increased slightly in the period studied. Within the AdH group, 70% of the Pre-Matriculation group gained entry to the second phase of studies without delay, rising to 78% in the AdH-group of the Nat-Matriculation. For all admission groups taken together, the overall grades for the first section of the medical state exam 2010-2016 show a positive trend, regardless of the selection procedure. The proportion of correctly answered questions in the nationwide M1 increased accordingly in the period studied. The better those matriculating had performed in the HAM-Nat test, the better their results were in the written and oral parts of the first part of the medical state exam. Conclusion: Although a significant proportion of students in the AdH group had obtained their place of study only on the basis of their test result and the score in the HAM-Nat test only weakly correlated with the school leaving grade (Abitur), the quantifiable study success parameters to date - in an albeit short observation period before and after introduction of the test - improved slightly. The number of Nat-Matriculations is too low to be able to assess the effect of the HAM-Nat test bearing in mind natural fluctuations. Nevertheless, the HAM-Nat test as an instrument of selection also made it possible for candidates with originally insufficient Abitur grades to gain admission without negative effects on the study success of the AdH cohort.