Video-assisted endoscopic thyroidectomy

Comparing Two Approaches for Thyroidectomy: A Health Technology Assessment through DMAIC Cycle

Total thyroidectomy is very common in endocrine surgery and the haemostasis can be obtained in different ways across surgery; recently, some devices have been developed to support this surgical phase. In this paper, a health technology assessment is conducted through the define, measure, analyse, improve, and control cycle of the Six Sigma methodology to compare traditional total thyroidectomy with the surgical operation performed through a new device in an overall population of 104 patients. Length of hospital stay, drain output, and time for surgery were considered the critical to qualities in order to compare the surgical approaches which can be considered equal regarding the organizational, ethical, and security impact. Statistical tests (Kolmogorov–Smirnov, t test, ANOVA, Mann–Whitney, and Kruskal–Wallis tests) and visual management diagrams were employed to compare the approaches, but no statistically significant difference was found between them. Considering these results, this study shows that the introduction of the device to perform total thyroidectomy does not guarantee appreciable clinical advantages. A cost analysis to quantify the economic impact of the device into the practice could be a future development. Healthy policy leaders and clinicians who are requested to make decisions regarding the supply of biomedical technologies could benefit from this research.

Video-assisted neck surgery (VANS) using a gasless lifting procedure for thyroid and parathyroid diseases: "The VANS method from A to Z"

Purpose

To describe and evaluate our video-assisted neck surgery (VANS) method for thyroid and parathyroid diseases.

Methods

We describe in detail the VANS method for enucleation, lobectomy, total (nearly total) thyroidectomy, and lymph node dissection for malignancy and Graves’ disease. In collaboration with the Japan Society of Endoscopic Surgery (JSES), we evaluated several aspects of this method. The JSES evaluated the method for working-space formation and surgical complications, whereas we examined the learning curve of the surgeons, and the cosmetic satisfaction of the patients and the degree of numbness and pain they experienced. We also asked patients who underwent conventional surgery whether they would have selected VANS had it been available.

Results

The working space for 81.5% of the procedures in Japan was created using the gasless lifting method. The learning curve, considering both blood loss and operating time, decreased after 30 cases. Both factors improved for tumors smaller than 5 cm in diameter. Over 60% of the patients who underwent conventional surgery stated that they would have selected VANS, had it been available. Postoperative pain was worse after conventional surgery than after VANS, but neck numbness after VANS was more frequent than expected.

Conclusions

The VANS method is a feasible, safe, and cost-effective procedure with clear cosmetic advantages over conventional surgery.

Natural Orifice Total Transtracheal Endoscopic Thyroidectomy Surgery: First Reported Experiment

BACKGROUND

Natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES(®); American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy [Oak Brook, IL] and Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons [Los Angeles, CA]) is an improvement in surgical interventions. In this study we developed an innovative transtracheal endoscopic thyroidectomy technique and explored its feasibility in animal models.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Transtracheal endoscopic thyroidectomy was performed in anesthetized dogs and pigs. The endoscope was advanced into the pretracheal space via a longitudinal incision on the anterior tracheal wall. Hemithyroidectomies and partial lobectomy were performed using special double-lumen endotracheal tubes and conventional endoscopic instruments. The tracheal wall incision was closed using absorbable sutures, and the animals were sacrificed at Day 5 postsurgery.

RESULTS

Hemithyroidectomy and partial thyroidectomy were successfully performed on pigs and dogs. The average operative time for each model was 69.4 minutes. No significant complications were encountered during surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The transtracheal endoscopic thyroidectomy technique is feasible and has the potential to be an alternative method for other types of thyroid surgeries.

Clinical experience with modified Miccoli's endoscopic thyroidectomy for treatment of thyroid carcinoma in 86 cases

Background

The main purpose of this study was to assess the feasibility and relevant applying techniques of total thyroidectomy for thyroid carcinoma with a modified Miccoli’s approach.

Methods

Eighty-six patients with thyroid carcinoma consecutively received radical operation from October 2007 to June 2012. A cavity above the gland was constructed by a modified suspension method using the suspension retractor with suction catheter after the pathway making. Eighty-six cases underwent the modified Miccoli’s endoscopic thyroidectomy using the ultrasonic scalpel and the space maintain-regulating device. Level VI lymph node dissection was performed using the method of inspection pit.

Results

All the procedures were completed successfully. The average detection rate of level VI lymph nodes, the average time of thyroidectomy and lymph nodes dissection were 7.27 ± 3.99 pieces per case, 51.32 ± 13.35 min, and 38.43 ± 15.24 min, respectively. With regard to postoperative complications, there were three cases of delayed transient hoarseness, two patients with transient numbness of hands and feet, one subject with chylous fistula, and no hemorrhage.

Conclusion

Total thyroidectomy for thyroid carcinoma can be safely performed with the modified Miccoli’s approach by using ultrasonic scalpel and the space maintain-regulating device. Application of these adaptive reforms can obviously reduce the difficulties in manipulation and have the advantages of minimal incisions, good cosmetic results, less bleeding, shorter hospital stay, and fewer complications.

Prospective study of sensation in anterior chest areas before and after a bilateral axillo-breast approach for endoscopic/robotic thyroid surgery

BACKGROUND

The bilateral axillo-breast approach for endoscopic/robotic thyroid surgery (BABA) shows good oncologic and surgical outcomes and does not result in neck scars. However, there is concern about potential sensory changes of the skin flaps after BABA, especially of the breast areas. This prospective study was undertaken to evaluate sensory changes in the skin flaps after BABA.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 19 women (mean age 36.9 ± 8.7; age range 21-51 years) who underwent BABA were enrolled. Skin flap sensory assessments were performed for each patient preoperatively and again at 1 and 3 months postoperatively. The Semmes-Weinstein monofilament test was used to evaluate the cutaneous light-pressure thresholds, a biothesiometer was used to evaluate the vibration thresholds, and an infrared thermometer was used to measure skin temperatures of the skin flaps.

RESULTS

There were changes in the sensations of the anterior chest areas over time, as determined by the Semmes-Weinstein monofilament test (1.5 vs 4.3 versus 1.4; P < 0.05) and the biothesiometer (26.8 vs 31.2 vs 22.3; P < 0.05). The sensations in the anterior chest areas normalized to preoperative levels at 3 months postoperatively. No significant differences were seen in the infrared thermometer test at any of the time points (36.2 vs 36.2 vs 36.3 °C; P = 0.9927).

CONCLUSIONS

While anterior chest area sensations were changed at 1 month postoperatively, the sensations normalized at 3 months after BABA. These results suggest that BABA has minimal adverse effects on anterior chest area sensation.

Endoscopic neck surgery

Endoscopic surgery in the neck was attempted in 1996 for performing parathyroidectomy. A similar surgical technique was used for performing thyroidectomy the following year. Most commonly reported endoscopic neck surgery studies in literature have been on thyroid and parathyroid glands. The approaches are divided into two types i.e., the total endoscopic approach using CO(2) insufflation and the video-assisted approach without CO(2) insufflation. The latter approach has been reported more often. The surgical access (port placements) may vary-the common sites are the neck, anterior chest wall, axilla, and periareolar region. The limiting factors are the size of the gland and malignancy. Few reports are available on endoscopic resection for early thyroid malignancy and cervical lymph node dissection. Endoscopic neck surgery has primarily evolved due to its cosmetic benefits and it has proved to be safe and feasible in suitable patients with thyroid and parathyroid pathologies. Application of this technique for approaching other cervical organs such as the submandibular gland and carotid artery are still in the early experimental phase.

Endoscopic thyroidectomy via an axillo-breast approach without gas insufflation for benign thyroid nodules and micropapillary carcinomas: preliminary results

PURPOSE

To examine the feasibility of endoscopic thyroidectomy (ET) via an axillo- breast approach without gas insufflation for large thyroid tumors and micropapillary carcinomas.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The patients in the benign group were separated into groups 1 (n=95, <4 cm in tumor diameter) and 2 (n=37, ≥4 cm in tumor diameter). Also, 57 patients in the micropapillary carcinoma group underwent an endoscopic hemithyroidectomy (HT) (group 3) and were compared with 60 patients who received conventional open HT (group 4). Postoperative functional outcome, local complications, surgical outcomes, and pathological outcomes were compared between the groups.

RESULTS

In the benign group, there was no significant difference in mean operating time, hospital stay, or overall perioperative complications between the two groups. In the micropapillary carcinoma group, mean operating time and hospital stay in group 3 were significantly longer than in group 4 (p=0.015 and p≤0.001). The overall perioperative complications did not differ significantly between the groups. The postoperative cosmetic result was better in groups 1-3 (endo group) than in group 4 (open group).

CONCLUSION

ET via a gasless axillo-breast approach seems to be a safe procedure even for benign thyroid lesions ≥4 cm and micropapillary carcinomas. Although it has the advantage of better cosmetic results over open thyroidectomy, there is room for improvement in terms of lessening its invasiveness and shortening the operative time.

Endoscopic vs. conventional thyroidectomy for the treatment of benign thyroid tumors: A retrospective study of a 4-year experience

Endoscopic thyroidectomy (ET) allows surgeons to remove a thyroid tumor from a remote site, while providing excellent results from a cosmetic viewpoint. The aim of this study was to explore the appropriateness and outcomes of ET via breast approach for the treatment of benign thyroid tumors. A total of 637 patients with benign thyroid tumors were recruited in our department. Two hundred and eighty-five patients underwent the ET via breast approach (ET group) and 352 matched control patients underwent conventional thyroidectomy (ConT group). Variables, such as surgery-related outcomes and postoperative complications, were compared between these two groups. A unilateral lobectomy was performed in 126 patients (44.2%) of the ET group and in 163 patients (46.3%) of the ConT group. A bilateral total thyroidectomy was performed in 159 patients (55.8%) of the ET group and in 189 patients (53.7%) of the ConT group. The operative time in the ET group was longer compared to the ConT group (79.9±20.10 vs. 45.4±11.90 min, P<0.001, for unilateral lobectomy; and 89.9±14.60 vs. 60.0±8.44 min, P<0.001, for bilateral total thyroidectomy). The ET group had a significantly longer mean hospital stay compared to the ConT group (5.5±0.50 vs. 5.3±0.75 days, P=0.002). There was no case of conversion to conventional open surgery in the ET group. The recurrent laryngeal nerves and parathyroid glands were identified and protected in all cases. Our results indicate that ET performed via breast is a technically feasible and safe procedure with excellent cosmetic results for patients with benign thyroid tumors.

Endoscopic hemithyroidectomy with prophylactic ipsilateral central neck dissection via an unilateral axillo-breast approach without gas insufflation for unilateral micropapillary thyroid carcinoma: preliminary report

BACKGROUND

Recently, various endoscopic approaches have been applied to thyroid surgery. However, few specific data exist on endoscopic thyroidectomy with central neck dissection (CND) for micropapillary thyroid carcinoma. This study aimed to evaluate the feasibility and safety of endoscopic hemithyroidectomy (HT) plus CND.

METHODS

In this study, 29 consecutive patients underwent endoscopic HT with ipsilateral CND via a unilateral axillo-breast approach (endo group), and 30 matched control patients underwent conventional open HT with ipsilateral CND (open group). The following variables were compared between these two groups: perioperative complications, surgery-related outcomes, and pathologic outcomes.

RESULTS

The operating time in the endo group was longer than in the open group (p = 0.012). In terms of parathyroid gland (PTG) preservation, there were no statistically significant differences between the two groups. The mean numbers of dissected central lymph nodes and metastatic central lymph nodes were similar in the two groups (p = 0.506 vs. 0.975). The endo group had a significantly longer mean hospital stay (6.21 +/- 0.94 days) than the open group (4.30 +/- 1.02 days; p = 0.000). No significant difference was observed in the overall perioperative complications between the two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that the endoscopic approach of CND plus HT is feasible for selected unilateral, intrathyroidal, micropapillary carcinomas. In the future, prospective and comparative studies on the surgical techniques of total thyroidectomy and CND are needed to verify their oncologic safety.

Endoscopic thyroidectomy using a new bilateral axillo-breast approach

INTRODUCTION

Endoscopic techniques have recently been applied in thyroid surgery using cervical, axillary, and breast approaches. We modified the axillo-bilateral breast approach (ABBA) and developed the bilateral axillo-breast approach (BABA) to obtain optimal visualization for total thyroidectomy.

METHODS

We used two 12-mm ports through bilateral circumareolar incisions for flexible videoscopy and Harmonic scalpel and two 5-mm ports through both axillae for graspers and dissectors. Thyroidectomy was performed under full visualization of the superior and inferior thyroidal arteries, parathyroid glands, and recurrent laryngeal nerves.

RESULTS

After performing 25 ABBA endoscopic thyroid surgeries, we developed BABA and performed 110 operations using this method. The BABA operations included 52 total thyroidectomies, 2 near-total thyroidectomies, 8 subtotal thyroidectomies, 43 lobectomies, and 3 subtotal lobectomies. Pathology revealed 41 benign lesions and 69 cancers. Mean operation time was 165.3 +/- 43.5 minutes. There were 2 cases of conversion to open surgery, 1 due to cancer with capsular invasion and the other due to tracheal injury. Nine postoperative complications developed: transient unilateral vocal cord palsy in 4 cases, transient hypocalcemia in 4 cases, and postoperative infection in 1 case. The 2-month postoperative thyroglobulin level was less than 1 ng/ml in all examined cases of total thyroidectomy. Cosmetic results were excellent.

CONCLUSIONS

The BABA technique for endoscopic thyroid surgery is a feasible method of total thyroidectomy with a low rate of postoperative complications and, additionally, excellent cosmetic results. Therefore, in selected cases of thyroid cancer, the BABA endoscopic total thyroidectomy should be considered as a valid surgical option.

Cervical scarless endoscopic thyroidectomy: Axillo-bilateral-breast approach (ABBA)

BACKGROUND

Neck surgery is one of the latest applications of minimally invasive surgery. We applied a new technique for totally endoscopic thyroidectomy, the axillo-bilateral-breast approach (ABBA). This approach does not leave a scar on the neck.

METHODS

Between February 2005 and October 2005, 13 patients were treated by ABBA for uni- or multinodular goitres. Surgery is performed under general anaesthesia and in supine position. 5 mm bilateral skin incisions are made on the margin of the areola of nipple. They are used to insert and subcutaneously push forward a 20 cm long, 5 mm trocar to the jugular fossa. A further 5 mm incision is performed in the right axilla. The right breast trocar is the optical trocar. A Maryland clamp in axillary position and 5 mm harmonic scalpel via the left breast trocar permit a clear view of the further subfascial preparation. The caudal hyoidal muscles are longitudinally split along the linea alba. Using delicate blunt dissection, both thyroid lobes are exposed. After isthmus transection is performed, the upper thyroid pole is being mobilized. The upper pole vessels are isolated and divided close to the thyroid capsule. Preparation of the retrothyroidal area includes visualization of the recurrent laryngeal nerve. The resection is performed without bleeding with a harmonic scalpel. Via the axillary approach, with the incision being widened, a 20 mm trocar is inserted and advanced up to the thyroid lodge to remove the specimen.

RESULTS

The average operation time was 132 minutes. No patient had to be converted to a conventional approach. Hypocalcaemia or recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy were not observed postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

Our preliminary results show that the ABBA technique is a feasible, safe procedure with excellent cosmetic benefits. The small scars in the right axilla and bilateral nipple areola are almost invisible.

Gasless endoscopic thyroidectomy via an axillary approach: experience of 30 cases

Surgery for thyroid disease requires skin incisions that can result in postsurgical problems such as prominent scars, adhesions, hypesthesia, and paresthesia in the neck. To overcome these problems we performed gasless endoscopic thyroidectomy via an axillary approach. Between May 2004 and April 2005, 30 patients underwent gasless endoscopic thyroidectomy via an axillary approach. The mean operating time was 126.8+/-32.4 minutes, and the mean length of hospital stay was 4.3+/-1.1 days. No cases required conversion to open surgery and none involved significant intraoperative complications. Three patients (10.0%) complained of slight hypesthesia or paresthesia in the anterior chest wall, and only 2 patients (6.7%) complained of discomfort while swallowing 4 months after surgery. All patients were satisfied with the cosmetic results. Gasless endoscopic thyroidectomy via an axillary approach is feasible and safe and provides excellent cosmetic results with a minimal degree of postoperative complaints.

A camera handler for Miccoli's minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy and paratiroidectomy procedures

BACKGROUND

Minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy and paratiroidectomy (MIVAT/P) are surgical procedures performed with 5-mm cameras handled by a camera assistant.

METHODS

The authors created a new camera handler for video-assisted neck surgery. It consists of a telescopic tripod device designed for mechanical handling of the camera, which is directly oriented by the operator even in solo surgery procedures. The camera is placed inside an O-shaped support, and moved by the operator himself for exploration and work on the surgical field.

RESULTS

Thanks to this simple device, the camera holder provides a firm field and prevents blood stains in limited working spaces.

CONCLUSIONS

The novel camera handler may be useful in either MIVAT/P or other simple laparoscopic procedures (i.e., cholecystectomy) for a steady handling of the camera, even in solo surgery procedures.

Video-assisted thyroidectomy: report on the experience of a single center in more than four hundred cases

BACKGROUND

We report on our series of patients selected for video-assisted thyroidectomy (VAT) over a 7-year period and discuss the results obtained.

METHODS

Video-assisted thyroidectomy is a gasless procedure performed under endoscopic vision through a single 1.5-2.0-cm skin incision, using a technique very similar to conventional surgery. Eligibility criteria were these: thyroid nodules < 35 mm; thyroid volume < 30 ml; no previous conventional neck surgery. Small, low-risk, papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTC) were considered eligible.

RESULTS

A total of 473 VATs were attempted on 459 patients. Locoregional anesthesia was used in 15 patients. Conversion was necessary in 6 (difficult dissection in 1 case, large nodule size in 3, gross lymph node metastases in 2). Thyroid lobectomy was successfully performed in 110 cases, total thyroidectomy in 343, and completion thyroidectomy in 14. In 66 patients with carcinoma, central neck nodes were removed through the same access. Concomitant parathyroidectomy was performed in 14 patients. Pathology showed benign disease in 277 cases, PTC in 175, and medullary microcarcinoma in 1. Postoperative complications included 8 transient recurrent nerve palsies, 64 transient hypocalcemias, 3 definitive hypocalcemias, 1 postoperative hematoma, and 2 wound infections. Postoperative pain was minimal and the cosmetic result excellent. In patients with PTC no evidence of recurrent or residual disease was shown.

CONCLUSIONS

Indications for VAT are still limited (20% of patients who require thyroidectomy). Nonetheless, in selected patients, it seems a valid option for thyroidectomy and it could be considered even preferable to conventional surgery because of its significant advantages, especially in terms of cosmetic result.

The minimally invasive open video-assisted approach in surgical thyroid diseases

BACKGROUND

The targets of minimally invasive surgery (MIVA) could be summarised by: achievement of the same results as those obtained with traditional surgery, less trauma, better post-operative course, early discharge from hospital and improved cosmetic results. The minimally invasive techniques in thyroid surgery can be described as either endoscopic "pure" approach (completely closed approach with or without CO2 insufflation), or "open approach" with central neck mini-incision or "open video-assisted approach". Traditionally, open thyroidectomy requires a 6 to 8 cm, or bigger, transverse wound on the lower neck. The minimally invasive approach wound is much shorter (1.5 cm for small nodules, up to 2-3 cm for the largest ones, in respect of the exclusion criteria) upon the suprasternal notch. Patients also experience much less pain after MIVA surgery than after conventional thyroidectomy. This is due to less dissection and destruction of tissues. Pathologies treated are mainly nodular goiter; the only kind of thyroid cancer which may be approached with endoscopic surgery is a small differentiated carcinoma without lymph node involvement. The patients were considered eligible for MIVA hemithyroidectomy and thyroidectomy on the basis of some criteria, such as gland volume and the kind of disease. In our experience we have chosen the minimally invasive open video-assisted approach of Miccoli et al. (2002). The aim of this work was to verify the suitability of the technique and the applicability in clinical practice.

METHODS

A completely gasless procedure was carried out through a 15-30 mm central incision about 20 mm above the sternal notch. Dissection was mainly performed under endoscopic vision using conventional endoscopic instruments. The video aided group included 11 patients. All patients were women with a average age of 54.

RESULTS

We performed thyroidectomy in 8 cases and hemithyroidectomy in 3 cases. The operative average time has been 170 minutes.

CONCLUSION

Nowadays this minimally invasive surgery, in selected patients, clearly demonstrates excellent results regarding patient cure rate and comfort, with shorter hospital stay, reduced postoperative pain and most attractive cosmetic results.

Minimal access thyroid surgery: technique and report of the first 25 cases

BACKGROUND

Minimal access thyroid surgery, using various techniques, is increasingly being reported. The present study reviews our experience with thyroid surgery using a lateral focused mini-incision approach, and assesses its safety and feasibility.

METHODS

The study group comprised all patients undergoing minimal access thyroid surgery (MATS) during the period May 2002-May 2003. Data were prospectively gathered, including patient demographics, indication for surgery, operation performed, nodule size, final pathology, and complications. Exclusion criteria for this procedure included: family history of thyroid cancer, previous neck irradiation or surgery, carcinoma on fine needle aspiration, presence of significant thyroiditis, multinodular goitre, and nodule size >3 cm. The operation was carried out through a 2.5-cm lateral incision placed directly over the nodule, with exposure gained by dissecting the plane between the sternomastoid muscle and the lateral edge of the strap muscles.

RESULTS

Twenty-five patients underwent MATS, 22 women and three men. Nineteen patients underwent hemithyroidectomy, five underwent isthmectomy, and one underwent local nodule excision. The average measured incision size was 2.63 cm at the end of the procedure. The average nodule size was 2.2 cm, and the average thyroid lobe resected measured 4.7 cm in maximal length. Final pathology revealed benign nodules in 21 patients and four thyroid cancers (two follicular and two papillary). There was one wound infection and two patients had temporary recurrent laryngeal nerve neuropraxia.

CONCLUSION

Minimal access thyroid surgery is a safe and feasible alternative to open thyroid surgery in selected cases.

Video-assisted thyroidectomy under local anesthesia

One theoretical limit of video-assisted thyroidectomy (VAT) was the supposed necessity of general anesthesia. Herein we describe a technique for VAT performed under locoregional anesthesia. Eligibility criteria were small thyroid nodules (<2 cm) in small or normal thyroid glands (thyroid volume < or =20 mL), no previous neck surgery or irradiation, and patient motivation for local anesthesia. VAT using locoregional anesthesia was performed under a superficial cervical block. During the procedure, the patients were completely awake and able to speak with members of the surgical team. Intraoperative and postoperative pain, as evaluated by a visual analogue scale, was usually negligible. No complications occurred. Mean postoperative stay was 26 hours. All of the patients were completely satisfied with the cosmetic result, the procedure, and the surgical outcome. VAT is also feasible and safe under local anesthesia. We are optimistic about the future of this approach, which opens a new frontier for minimally invasive procedures in thyroid surgery.

Video-Assisted Open Thyroid Lobectomy Through a Small Incision

To examine if postoperative morbidity may occur in gasless video-assisted thyroid lobectomy, 111 patients with solitary nodules were treated either by gasless video-assisted lobectomy or by conventional lobectomy. Operating time needed for video-assisted lobectomy significantly exceeded that needed for conventional surgery. No death, massive hemorrhage, wound hematoma, wound infection, or permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve injury occurred in patients treated by either video-assisted or conventional lobectomy. Damage to the external branch of the superior laryngeal nerve occurred in 6 (10.2%) patients following conventional surgery but in no patients following video-assisted lobectomy (P = .0289). Transient recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy occurred in 5 (8.5%) patients after conventional surgery and in 3 (5.8%) patients after video-assisted surgery (P = .7209). It is noteworthy that morbidity occurs in video-assisted lobectomy. The general principles of thyroid surgery should be followed to avoid the occurrence of complications.

Safety of video-assisted thyroidectomy versus conventional surgery

BACKGROUND

Thyroid gland manipulation, surgical stress response, and postoperative outcome in cases of video-assisted thyroidectomy (VAT) and conventional thyroidectomy were compared to verify the safety of VAT.

METHODS

Twenty consenting patients were randomly assigned to undergo VAT or conventional thyroidectomy. Serum thyroglobulin levels were monitored as indicators of thyroid manipulation, and C-reactive protein and white blood cell count were monitored to assess surgical stress response. Thyroid capsule integrity and the presence of spilled cells in the thyroid bed were verified.

RESULTS

No significant differences were found in the indicators of thyroid gland manipulation and surgical stress response between groups. No thyroid capsules ruptured, and no spilled thyroid cells were found. Patients who had VAT experienced less pain, required fewer analgesics, and were more satisfied with the cosmetic result and the surgical outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

VAT is as safe as conventional thyroidectomy and is characterized by a less painful postoperative course and by better cosmetic results and postoperative outcome.

Thyroïdectomie endoscopique pour nodules thyroïdiens isolés

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility and safety of endoscopic thyroidectomy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between September 1998 and February 2000, 18 patients with a solitary thyroid nodule underwent endoscopic thyroidectomy in a single institution. Analgesic requirement, return to normal activity, and cosmetic results were compared to 18 consecutive patients who had conventional thyroidectomy.

RESULTS

Sixteen females and two males, with a mean age of 43 years (17-66 years) were operated on. Indications for surgery included indeterminate cytology (n = 8), follicular neoplasm (n = 8), Hürthle cell neoplasm (n = 1), and toxic thyroid nodule (n = 1). The mean nodule diameter was 2.7 cm (0.6-7 cm). Sixteen of 18 cases were successfully completed endoscopically with a mean operating time of 220 min (120-330 min). There were no major complication, but three patients developed mild hypercarbia and one patient had an incidental parathyroidectomy. When compared to conventional thyroidectomy, patients undergoing endoscopic thyroidectomy had a significantly superior cosmetic result (P < 0.005) and a quicker return to normal activity (P < 0.05), but there was no difference in analgesic requirement.

CONCLUSION

The results of this study seem to confirm that endoscopic thyroidectomy is a technically feasible and safe procedure that leads to an improved cosmetic result and a quicker recovery. However, conventional thyroidectomy is still recommended when thyroid carcinoma is suspected.

Total Video Endoscopic Thyroidectomy by an Axillary Approach

BACKGROUND

A permanent transverse surgical scar is an unavoidable problem after conventional thyroidectomy. Endoscopic thyroidectomy performed via an axillary approach leaves no scarring at the neck and anterior chest wall and so provides an excellent cosmetic result. The axillary scars are usually not seen when the arm is in a normal position.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From April 2001 to February 2003, we used a four-port technique to perform 45 lobectomy and isthmectomy procedures. One 12-mm port for the flexible laparoscope (EL2-TF410, Fuji Photo Optical, Tokyo, Japan) and three additional 5-mm ports for instruments and suction were inserted through the axilla on the side of the nodule. The CO(2 )insufflation pressure was set at 4 mm Hg, and in most cases, a 5-mm Johnson & Johnson Harmonic Scalpel (Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Cincinnati, Ohio, U.S.A.) was used for the dissection.

RESULTS

Of 45 procedures, 44 were performed successfully. In one case, conversion to a conventional technique was required. The mean operating time was 131.2 minutes, and the mean blood loss was 51.6 mL. The recurrent laryngeal nerves were clearly identified in every case, and no case of permanent voice change occurred after surgery. In one patient, a 20-mL seroma developed on the 10th postoperative day, which was treated by simple aspiration. One patient experienced a transient voice change. The patients were discharged on average at 2.9 days after the operation.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic thyroidectomy by an axillary approach to manage benign thyroid disease is feasible and safe and provides promising cosmetic results. We think that this approach may play an important role in the near future.

Videoscopic thyroidectomy: the uncertain path to practicality

Since 1997, successful attempts at endoscopic thyroidectomy have led to controversies. The procedure has, as yet, no alarming operative complication, but its benefits to patients are debatable. By means of very individualized and ingeniously designed approaches, the procedure has proven to be feasible and safe in trained hands. Cautious trials and evaluations of endoscopic thyroid surgery are now in progress internationally at expert centres. The technique itself is undergoing progressive evolution and larger studies are underway. Although endoscopic thyroidectomy has little chance of acquiring the same popularity as open thyroidectomy due to its inherently higher technical demand, it may become a practical and safe alternative option for selected suitable patients.

Endoscopic thyroid surgery through the axillo-bilateral-breast approach

We developed a new endoscopic thyroid surgery by the axillo-bilateral-breast approach (ABBA) method, which is different from the previously described breast approach (BA) in that the port sites are modified to obtain a better view and to prevent the interference of surgical instruments. This modification also improves cosmetic results by eliminating the parasternal incision, which results in hypertrophic scar in a significant number of cases treated with BA. Twelve patients with benign thyroid tumors successfully underwent endoscopic thyroid surgery by ABBA, and their clinical outcomes were compared with those of four patients treated with BA. The mean operation time was significantly shorter in the ABBA group than in the BA group (188 minutes vs. 270 minutes; P < 0.01). Furthermore, the mean blood loss in the ABBA group (53 mL) was half of that in the BA group (108 mL). Neither conversion to open surgery nor significant intraoperative complications were experienced. The operative scars by ABBA became inconspicuous in a few weeks. These results seem to indicate that ABBA is a better method than BA and can be a feasible option, particularly for young patients who opt for the better cosmetic outcome.

Total endoscopic and video-assisted thyroidectomy: cervical approach

Several procedures have been proposed for surgical treatment of the thyroid nodule; they have not gained wide acceptance, however, because of the expertise required, the relatively long operation times, the wide dissection needed to create a working space, and the extra cost of specialized instruments, especially when port sites are created in the remote area. These barriers have led some surgeons to perform video-assisted thyroidectomy via the neck. We describe the indications for, procedures related to, and results of both total endoscopic thyroidectomy and video-assisted thyroidectomy via the neck. Excellent cosmetic results were obtained by both procedures; however, video-assisted procedures required less time and a smaller dissection area.

Video-assisted neck surgery for thyroid and parathyroid diseases

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic surgery has now become a well-established modality for the treatment of various organ diseases. In the present study, we analyzed the surgical results achieved by video-assisted neck surgery (VANS) in thyroid and parathyroid diseases.

METHODS

From January 2000 to April 2002, 87 patients (eight males and 79 females) with a mean age of 49 years underwent VANS. The preoperative diagnoses of these patients included 37 benign thyroid tumors, 30 Graves' diseases, 17 parathyroid adenomas and three thyroid cancers.

RESULTS

The mean operative time of VANS was 165 min for a hemithyroidectomy, 287 min for a subtotal thyroidectomy, and 157 min for a parathyroidectomy. The mean intraoperative blood loss was 60, 183 and 23 g for a hemithyroidectomy, subtotal thyroidectomy and parathyroidectomy, respectively. No conversion from VANS to conventional surgery was experienced. Three patients (3.4%) had temporary palsy of the recurrent laryngeal nerve. Otherwise, the postoperative courses were uneventful.

CONCLUSIONS

VANS for thyroid and parathyroid diseases was found to be safe and effective. From a cosmetic point of view, a high degree of patient satisfaction was obtained. VANS is thus considered to be an excellent option for selected patients with thyroid and parathyroid diseases.

Total video endoscopic thyroidectomy via the anterior chest approach using the cervical region-lifting method

Endoscopic surgery offers superior cosmetic results compared to open procedures and is strongly preferred by many patients, especially women. We performed total endoscopic thyroidectomy via the anterior chest approach using a neck skin-lifting technique in which the skin is lifted by a large number of hooks to create the working space. This method is quite flexible and can be modified based on the size of the space needed. The fine hooks leave no scar on the anterior neck, the skin incisions are small, and the scars are completely covered by patients' undergarments. Endoscopic thyroidectomy is suitable for benign thyroid nodules, but some malignant foci diagnosed by frozen section usually can be managed without conversion to an open procedure. Women under 45 years of age with nodules <2 cm who have no evidence of lymphatic spread or local invasion are ideal candidates for this procedure.

Anterior chest wall approach for video-assisted thyroidectomy using a modified neck skin lifting method

Neck endoscopic surgery is likely to prove less invasive and more cosmetically advantageous than conventional methods. The surgical procedure used for 42 consecutive patients undergoing video-assisted thyroidectomy by the anterior chest wall approach is described herein. A 3-4 cm incision was made at the anterior chest wall 2 cm below the clavicle on the tumor side. Two Kirshner wires connected to a winching device were horizontally inserted beneath the skin in order to lift the neck skin. Specially made retractors were passed through the chest wall wound to the lateral neck bilaterally. Strap muscle on the tumor side was retracted laterally and the thyroid tumor was retracted medially. A suitable working space was thus created using this modified neck lifting method without gas insufflation. All patients underwent video-assisted thyroidectomy utilizing an anterior chest wall approach without conversion to open thyroidectomy. Mean operative time from incision to removal of the tumor was 145 min. Mean tumor size was 4.1 cm (range: 2.0-7.5 cm). The advantage of our approach is that the scar below the clavicle is invisible under normal clothing. In addition, conventional instruments for open thyroidectomy can be used. In our method, the thyroid tumor and trachea are palpable and some parts of the operation can be conducted under direct visualization if the assistant retracts the anterior chest wall wound upward. Video-assisted thyroidectomy utilizing an anterior chest wall approach is cosmetically less invasive, particularly for women who are frequently nervous about operative scars on the neck.

Total endoscopic thyroidectomy

We have developed endoscopic thyroidectomy procedures using anterior chest and axillary approaches. Both of our procedures differ significantly from the usual thyroidectomy, which involves lifting both the platysma and the sternohyoid muscle. Because only the platysma is lifted during our procedures, a CO(2) insufflation pressure of less than 4 mmHg is sufficient. While the sternohyoid muscle is transected to obtain greater exposure of the thyroid gland in minimally invasive procedures in the neck, we do not divide it so as to prevent adhesions to the platysma, unless the nodule is large. As we accumulated experience with these procedures in 58 patients, typical operation time decreased to less than 120 minutes for the anterior approach and to less than 150 minutes for the axillary approach. Large follicular tumours can be extracted using the axillary approach, with all of its cosmetic advantages, whereas the anterior chest approach is advocated for removal of bilateral multinodular goitres and parathyroid lesions. Both approaches result in minimal postoperative hypoaesthesia, paraesthesia, and discomfort during swallowing. We conclude that endoscopic neck surgery is the procedure of choice in carefully selected patients with thyroid disease.

Minimal access thyroid surgery: is it feasible, is it appropriate?

BACKGROUND

Reports of minimal access thyroid surgery (MATS) using various techniques have recently appeared. This study examined the feasibility of MATS using either a lateral 'focused' or endoscopically assisted approach.

METHODS

The study group comprised all patients undergoing minimally invasive parathyroidectomy (MIP) during the period May 1998 to April 2002 in whom a concomitant thyroid procedure was undertaken. All procedures were performed either through a 2-cm lateral cervical incision (n = 19) or endoscopically (n = 7).

RESULTS

Twenty-six patients underwent thyroid surgery, consisting of either local excision of a thyroid nodule (n = 25) or hemi-thyroidectomy (n = 1). In 13 patients the nodule was incidentally discovered, in four patients removal of the parathyroid necessitated partial thyroidectomy, and in nine patients the lesion identified by preoperative parathyroid localization proved to be a thyroid nodule. There were no permanent complications in the study group. Two patients required drainage of a haematoma. The final pathology of all 26 cases revealed benign nodular thyroid disease.

CONCLUSION

Thyroid surgery can safely be performed as a minimally invasive procedure. Minimal access thyroid surgery is therefore a feasible option for selected patients. The question remains to be answered as to whether this surgical approach is appropriate treatment for nodular thyroid disease.

Video-assisted thyroidectomy

OBJECTIVE

In 1998, we developed a technique for video-assisted thyroidectomy (VAT). In this paper, we report on the entire series of patients who underwent VAT and discuss the results obtained.

METHODS

Seventy-three patients were selected for VAT. Eligibility criteria were: thyroid nodules </=35 mm in maximum diameter; estimated thyroid volume within normal range or slightly enlarged; small, low-risk papillary carcinomas; no previous neck surgery or irradiation and no thyroiditis. The VAT procedure was totally gasless. It was performed under endoscopic vision through a single 1.5 to 2.0-cm skin incision, using a technique very similar to conventional surgery.

RESULTS

Eighty-one VATs were attempted on 73 patients. Forty-five lobectomies, 24 total thyroidectomies and eight completion thyroidectomies were successfully performed. Mean operative time was 82 minutes for lobectomy, 100 minutes for total thyroidectomy and 77 minutes for completion thyroidectomy. The conversion rate was 4.9%. Postoperative complications included two transient recurrent nerve palsies, five transient symptomatic postoperative hypocalcaemias and one wound infection. The cosmetic result was considered excellent by most of the patients.

CONCLUSION

VAT is a feasible and and safe procedure that allows for excellent cosmetic results. In selected cases, it can be a valid option for the surgical treatment of thyroid diseases.

Endoscopic thyroid surgery today: a diversity of surgical strategies

The advancement of video-assisted minimally invasive surgery in this decade fostered the successful attempt at endoscopic thyroidectomy in 1997. This technically demanding surgery is now being evaluated in a small number of specialized centers. The procedure earned the most attention in Japan and is performed in more than 20 centers; a conference dedicated to the technique was held in Japan in 2001. By retrieving information from published or presented articles and direct personal communications, we report on the multitude of surgical strategies designed by different experts to enable relocalization of the surgical wounds to optimize cosmesis to the patient while complying with the gold standard of thyroid surgery.

Central neck lymph node removal during minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy for thyroid carcinoma: a feasible and safe procedure

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

In 1998, we developed a technique for video-assisted thyroidectomy (VAT) which we proposed using also in patients with small low-risk papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTC). In some cases, enlarged lymph nodes are incidentally found at surgery for PTC. These nodes should be removed because of the risk of metastases. In this paper, we report on the patients in whom we removed enlarged central neck lymph nodes during VAT for PTC and discuss the feasibility and safety of video-assisted central neck lymph node dissection (VALD).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The procedure is performed by a totally gasless video-assisted technique through a single 1.5-to 2.0-cm skin incision above the sternal notch. Dissection is performed under endoscopic vision using a technique very similar to that of conventional surgery. Only enlarged lymph nodes were removed and sent for frozen section examination (FS). No other dissection was performed in case of negative FS. Five patients underwent VALD during VAT for PTC.

RESULTS

The mean number of lymph nodes removed was 2.4. No metastases were found at FS or final histology examination. Postoperative complications included two transient postoperative hypocalcemias. No evidence of residual or recurrent disease was observed at postoperative follow-up. The cosmetic result was excellent.

CONCLUSION

Our experience demonstrates that removal of central compartment lymph nodes is feasible and safe. Perhaps also complete central neck lymph node dissection can be performed. Some doubts persist about the oncologic validity of this approach. For definitive conclusions, larger series and comparative studies are necessary.

Video-assisted thyroidectomy

BACKGROUND

In 1998, we developed a technique for video-assisted thyroidectomy (VAT). In this article we report on the entire series of patients who underwent VAT and discuss the results obtained.

STUDY DESIGN

Forty-seven patients were selected for VAT. Eligibility criteria were: thyroid nodules of 35 mm or less in maximum diameter; estimated thyroid volume within normal range or slightly enlarged; small, low-risk papillary carcinomas; neither previous neck surgery nor irradiation; and no thyroiditis. After a learning period, VAT was proposed also for completion thyroidectomy (of previous video-assisted lobectomy) and nodules with maximum diameter up to 45 mm. The procedure is performed by a totally gasless video-assisted technique through a single 1.5- to 2.0-cm skin incision. Dissection is performed under endoscopic vision using a technique very similar to conventional operation.

RESULTS

Fifty-three VATs were attempted on 47 patients. Thirty-three lobectomies, 10 total thyroidectomies, and 6 completion thyroidectomies were successfully performed. Six patients with papillary carcinoma underwent central neck lymph node removal by the same access. Mean operative time was 86.8 minutes for lobectomy, 116.0 minutes for total thyroidectomy, and 77.5 minutes for completion thyroidectomy. Conversion rate was 7.5%. Postoperative complications included one transient recurrent nerve palsy, three transient symptomatic postoperative hypocalcemias, and one wound infection. The cosmetic result was considered excellent by most of the patients who successfully underwent VAT.

CONCLUSIONS

VAT is feasible and safe and allows for an excellent cosmetic result. Not all patients are eligible for this procedure, but in selected cases it can be a valid option for the surgical treatment of thyroid diseases.

Video-assisted thyroid lobectomy through a small wound in the submandibular area

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic thyroidectomy has not gained wide acceptance because of the expertise required, the long operation time, the wide dissection, and the extra cost of specialized instruments. We developed a video-assisted hemithyroidectomy procedure that requires only one small incision at the upper neck.

METHODS

Hemithyroidectomy was performed through a 25 to 30 mm transverse incision made in the upper lateral neck for the treatment of benign thyroid nodule. No gas or external lift dissection was needed.

RESULTS

The mean age of 39 patients was 33.8 years. The tumor size ranged from 1.9 to 5.5 cm (mean 3.1 cm). All patients underwent total lobectomy without conversion to traditional cervicotomy. The mean operation time was 56 minutes (range 36 to 90). Follicular adenoma was the final pathologic diagnosis in 25 patients and adenomatous goiter in 14. Transient recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy was seen in 1 patient.

CONCLUSIONS

Our technique is safe, minimally invasive, less time consuming, and cosmetically excellent.

Endoscopic neck dissection in human cadavers

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the feasibility and efficacy of endoscopic neck dissection (END) in human cadavers.

STUDY DESIGN

Experimental self-controlled study.

METHODS

END on five human cadavers through three openings: one for the camera, one for the dissecting instrument, and one for a grasping one. The tissue specimens removed were divided into traditional neck groups (I to V). After the completion of END, open neck dissection was performed using standard surgical techniques and the remaining tissue within each neck group was retrieved. The important neck structures (carotid artery, internal jugular vein, cranial nerves X, XI, and XII, phrenic nerve) were evaluated for lesions. A pathologist evaluated each specimen, without knowing its exact origin in terms of neck group or side, and type of surgical technique used. For each specimen, the number of retrieved lymph nodes and their anatomic integrity was analyzed.

RESULTS

Ten neck dissections were performed on 5 cadavers, without any major difficulty. An injury of the internal jugular vein occurred twice and once the phrenic nerve was cut. Little tissue was usually left for open surgical dissection. The average number of retrieved lymph nodes by endoscopy was 4.9 +/- 2.7 (mean +/- standard deviation). Completion open neck dissection retrieved an additional 0.5 +/- 0.5 lymph nodes. Efficacy of END was 92 +/- 10%. The majority of retrieved lymph nodes were intact but exhibited important postmortem autolysis artifacts.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic neck dissection is possible in human cadavers and is free of lesions to major structures. The majority of neck lymph nodes can be removed endoscopically.