Prospective study of portasystemic encephalopathy after emergency portacaval shunt for bleeding varices

Portal-systemic encephalopathy in a randomized controlled trial of endoscopic sclerotherapy versus emergency portacaval shunt treatment of acutely bleeding esophageal varices in cirrhosis

BACKGROUND

In patients with cirrhosis and bleeding esophageal varices, there is a widespread belief that control of bleeding by portal-systemic shunts is compromised by a high incidence of shunt-related portal-systemic encephalopathy (PSE). This important issue was examined by a randomized controlled trial that compared emergency and long-term endoscopic sclerotherapy (EST) to emergency direct portacaval shunt (EPCS) in patients with cirrhosis and acute variceal hemorrhage.

METHODS

The study was a community-wide undertaking known as the San Diego Bleeding Esophageal Varices Study. A total of 211 unselected, consecutive patients with biopsy-proven cirrhosis and endoscopically proven, acutely bleeding esophageal varices that required at least 2 units of blood transfusion were randomized to EST (n = 106) or EPCS (n = 105). The diagnostic workup was completed in less than 6 hours and EST or EPCS was initiated within 8 hours of initial contact. Long-term EST was performed according to a deliberate schedule over months. Criteria for failure of EST or EPCS were clearly defined and crossover rescue treatment was applied, whenever possible, when failure of primary therapy was declared. PSE was quantitated by a "blinded" senior faculty gastroenterologist. Four variously weighted components of PSE were graded on a scale of 0 to 4: (1) mental state, (2) asterixis, (3) number connection test, and (4) arterial blood ammonia. PSE was classified as recurrent if 2 or more episodes were documented. All patients (100%) had follow-up for more than 9.4 years or until death.

RESULTS

Child's risk classes in the EST and EPCS groups, respectively, were 25% and 30% in class A, 43% and 47% in class B, and 26% and 29% in class C. Mean time from onset of bleeding to EST or EPCS was less than 24 hours, and from study entry to EST or EPCS was 3.1 to 4.4 hours, respectively. EST achieved permanent control of bleeding in only 20% of patients, while EPCS permanently controlled bleeding in every patient (P ≤ 0.001). Survival following EPCS was 3.5 to 5 times greater than that of EST at 5, 10, and 15 years (P ≤ 0.001). The incidence of recurrent PSE following EST (35%) was more than twice the incidence following EPCS (15%) (P ≤ 0.001). EST patients had a total of 179 episodes of PSE and 146 PSE-related hospital admissions, compared with EPCS patients who had 94 episodes of PSE and 87 hospital admissions (P ≤ 0.001). Recurrent upper gastrointestinal bleeding, which was rare in the EPCS group, was a major causative factor of PSE in the EST patients.

CONCLUSIONS

In contrast to EST, EPCS permanently controlled variceal bleeding, resulted in significantly greater long-term survival, and was followed by a relatively low (15%) incidence of PSE. These results were facilitated by rigorous, frequent, and lifelong follow-up that included regular counseling on dietary protein restriction and abstinence from alcohol, and by long-term patency of the portacaval shunt in 98% of patients. Furthermore, these results call into question the practice of avoiding portacaval shunt because of fear of PSE, and thereby foregoing the lifesaving advantage achieved by surgical control of bleeding. (clinicaltrials.gov NCT00690027).

Hepatic encephalopathy verified by psychometric testing and EEG in cirrhotic patients: effects of mesocaval interposition shunt or sclerotherapy

BACKGROUND

The aim of this randomised prospective study was to evaluate hepatic encephalopathy after mesocaval interposition shunt operation and after repeated endoscopic sclerotherapy.

METHODS

Forty-five patients with bleeding oesophageal varices due to liver cirrhosis were randomised to the two treatment groups, 24 to the shunt group and 21 to the sclerotherapy group. The patients were evaluated preoperatively regarding blood tests, hepatic encephalopathy as measured by electroencephalogram with spectral analysis and by a battery of psychometric tests. The direction of portal flow in the shunt group was investigated by shunt phlebography and ultrasonography with Doppler. During follow-up the same investigations were performed twice at median 6.7 and 14.7 months after operation.

RESULTS

No statistically significant difference was found during follow-up regarding blood tests and electroencephalography with spectral analysis. Although the preoperative psychometric tests showed that the shunt group performed significantly better than the sclerotherapy group, the first follow-up showed that the shunt group performed statistically worse than the sclerotherapy group in seven of the tests: Synonyms (measuring verbal ability), Block Design Test (measuring visuo-spatial ability), Memory for Design Test, Error Score (measuring memory function), Revised Visual Retention Test, correct answers and the same test error answers (measuring visuo-spatial memory, ability and immediate memory), Digit Symbol Test (measuring perceptual ability) and Trial Making Test B (measuring cognitive motor abilities).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients treated by mesocaval interposition shunt showed a progressive general reduction in psychometric performance compared with patients treated with repeated sclerotherapy, in whom a general intellectual improvement was observed. This finding corresponds to the reverse direction of the preoperative portal flow to a hepatofugal pattern at first follow-up and at 12 months among two-thirds of the patients.

Portographic evaluation for recurrent esophagogastric varices following devascularization surgery

PURPOSE

To investigate, by transhepatic portography, the changes in portosystemic collaterals and recurrent esophagogastric varices after devascularization surgery.

METHODS

Thirty-five patients, who had undergone devascularization surgery 2-8 years previously, underwent follow-up portography and the collaterals and drainage routes were compared with preoperative portography results.

RESULTS

Newly formed collaterals were present in 30 of 35 patients and the origins and drainage routes differed from preoperative ones. Most common were new collaterals arising from the junction of the portal and superior mesenteric veins; the next most frequent arose from a main portal branch, the portal trunk, or the superior mesenteric vein. New collaterals with recurrent varices were seen in 20 patients and without varices in 10; 5 patients had no collaterals or varices.

CONCLUSION

Since the development of new collaterals is common in portal hypertensive patients following devascularization surgery, regular follow-up for recurrent varices is necessary.

Prospective randomized trial of emergency portacaval shunt and emergency medical therapy in unselected cirrhotic patients with bleeding varices

A prospective randomized trial was conducted in unselected, consecutive patients with bleeding esophageal varices resulting from cirrhosis comparing (1) emergency portacaval shunt performed within 8 hr of initial contact (21 patients) with (2) emergency medical therapy (intravenous vasopressin and esophageal balloon tamponade) followed in 9 to 30 days by elective portacaval shunt in survivors (22 patients). All patients underwent the same diagnostic workup within 3 to 6 hr of initial contact, and received identical supportive therapy initially. All patients were followed up for at least 10 yr. The protocol contained no escape or cross-over provisions. There were no statistically significant differences between the two treatment groups in the incidence of any of the clinical variables, results of laboratory tests or degree of portal hypertension. Child's risk classes in the shunt group were A-2 patients, B-8 patients and C-11 patients, whereas in the medical group they were A-10 patients, B-5 patients, and C-7 patients, a significant difference (p < 0.01) that might have favored emergency medical treatment. Bleeding was controlled initially and permanently by emergency shunt in every patient, but by medical therapy in only 45% (p < 0.001). Mean requirement for blood transfusion was 7.1 +/- 2.6 units in the shunt group and 21.4 +/- 2.6 units in the medical group (p < 0.001). Eighty-one percent of the patients in the shunt group were discharged alive compared with 45% in the medical group (p = 0.027). Five- and 10-yr observed survival rates were 67% and 57%, respectively, after emergency shunt compared with 18% and 18%, respectively, after the combination of emergency medical therapy and elective shunt (p < 0.01). These survival rates produced by emergency shunt performed within 8 hr of initial contact confirm the effectiveness of this procedure observed in our previous unrandomized studies.

Prognostic value of indocyanine green and lidocaine kinetics for survival and chronic hepatic encephalopathy in cirrhotic patients following elective end-to-side portacaval shunt

The objective of this study was to assess the prognostic value of spontaneous portosystemic shunting and liver function for survival and spontaneous hepatic encephalopathy after end-to-side portacaval shunt in cirrhotic patients. One hundred ninety-eight patients with variceal hemorrhage as shown by endoscopy were evaluated. Forty-five were excluded because of uncontrollable hemorrhage; 84 were rejected because they were poor operative risk, had portal vein thrombosis or had been previously treated with beta-blockers, sclerotherapy or surgery. The remaining 69 patients were enrolled in this prospective study. There were 43 patients with alcoholic cirrhosis, 23 with cryptogenic cirrhosis and three with primary biliary cirrhosis. The severity of liver disease was assessed according to the Pugh classification: 37 patients (54%) had Pugh's score 5 to 7, 26 (38%) had 8 to 10 and six (8%) had 11 to 12. Indocyanine green intrinsic clearance was used as a probe of preoperative liver function and lidocaine systemic availability as an index of spontaneous preoperative shunting. All the patients underwent an elective end-to-side portacaval shunt. The length of minimal follow-up was 40 months. One-year survival was 76% and 5-year survival was 46%. During follow-up, 25 patients died from their liver disease and 11 patients died from various causes unrelated to their liver disease. Spontaneous chronic encephalopathy occurred in 16 patients (23%). Age, Pugh's score, active alcoholism, indocyanine green intrinsic clearance and lidocaine systemic availability were tested as prognostic factors in a multivariate analysis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Randomized trial of portacaval shunt, stapling transection and endoscopic sclerotherapy in uncontrolled variceal bleeding

Seventy consecutive cirrhotic patients with persistent or recurrent variceal bleeding were included in a clinical trial to compare the efficacy and safety of portacaval shunt (PCS) and stapler transection (ST) in patients with low surgical risk, and of stapler transection and endoscopic sclerotherapy (ES) in patients with high surgical risk. To classify the patients into low- and high-risk groups a new scoring system was used, based on an analysis of factors influencing operative mortality in an earlier series of emergency portacaval shunt. Thirty-eight low-risk patients were randomly allocated for treatment with portacaval shunt (19 patients) or stapler transection (19 patients), and 32 high-risk patients for stapler transection (17 patients) or ES (15 patients). The operative mortality of patients treated by PCS was close to that expected according to retrospective data, this indicating that the proposed scoring system is highly discriminant. In low-risk patients, portacaval shunt evidenced greater haemostatic efficacy and fewer complications than stapler transection. However, hepatic encephalopathy during follow-up was more frequent in the portacaval shunt group and there were no significant differences in operative mortality and long-term survival between the two groups. In high-risk patients, stapler transection and sclerotherapy had a similar haemostatic efficacy, operative mortality and long-term survival. However, sclerotherapy occasioned fewer complications than stapler transection. Our results motivate us to recommend stapler transection for low-risk patients and to consider sclerotherapy as an alternative for high-risk patients in the emergency treatment of uncontrolled variceal bleeding.

Distal splenorenal (Warren) shunt in the management of actively bleeding oesophageal varices

Distal splenorenal shunts have been performed on 53 patients during or soon after variceal haemorrhage. In 38 patients active haemorrhage was occurring at the time of operation or was controlled by tamponade and 12 of these patients died. There was no mortality in the semi-elective group. A higher mortality was found in patients with poor liver reserve and in whom prolonged conservative management had been attempted. Rebleeding occurred in 20 per cent of patients in the early postoperative period and this was a significant factor in the death of three patients. Of 39 patients with longer term follow-up, 8 suffered minor encephalopathy. Subsequent mortality could be related to the progression of liver disease and was no worse than that seen in a population of cirrhotic patients.

Long-term survival after emergency portacaval shunting for bleeding varices in patients with alcoholic cirrhosis

Since 1963, a prospective evaluation of the emergency portacaval shunt procedure has been conducted in 264 unselected patients with cirrhosis and bleeding varices who underwent operation within 8 hours of admission to the emergency department. Of 153 patients who underwent operation 10 or more years ago, 45 (29 percent) have survived from 10 to 22 years and their current status is known. On admission, 40 percent of the long-term survivors had jaundice, 44 percent had ascites, 13 percent had encephalopathy (with an additional 9 percent with a history of encephalopathy), 29 percent had severe muscle wasting, and 82 percent had a hyperdynamic state. There were 9 Child's class A patients, 33 Child's class B patients, and 3 Child's class C patients. At operation, all patients had portal hypertension which was reduced by the shunt to a mean corrected free portal pressure of 18 mm saline solution. The emergency portacaval shunt procedure permanently controlled variceal bleeding. None of the patients bled again from varices, and the shunt remained patent throughout life in every patient. Encephalopathy did not affect 91 percent of the patients, but was a recurrent problem in 9 percent, usually related to the use of alcohol. Lifelong abstinence from alcohol occurred in 58 percent of the long-term survivors, but 11 percent resumed regular drinking and 31 percent consumed alcohol occasionally. Liver function declined compared with preoperative function in only 18 percent of the patients, almost always because of alcohol use. Ten years after operation, 73 percent of the patients were in excellent or good condition, and 68 percent were gainfully employed or engaged in full-time housework. Comparison of the 10 to 22 year survivors with our early group of 180 patients reported previously and our recent group of 84 patients showed no significant differences in preoperative or operative data. The single factor that appeared to influence long-term survival was resumption of regular use of alcohol. We conclude that the emergency portacaval shunt procedure, by preventing hemorrhage from varices, results in prolonged survival and an acceptable quality of life for a substantial number of patients with advanced alcoholic cirrhosis.

Esophageal transection fails to salvage high-risk cirrhotic patients with variceal bleeding

A small proportion of portal hypertensive patients with acute variceal bleeding do not respond to medical management and require emergency control of hemorrhage, yet are not candidates for shunt surgery. Transgastric esophageal transection and stapling of the esophagus has been suggested as a rapid, simple means to halt variceal bleeding in such high-risk patients. This should theoretically allow a hemorrhage-free interval for resuscitation and improvement in metabolic and cardiopulmonary status before definitive shunt surgery. We tested this hypothesis in 10 high-risk patients with variceal bleeding who underwent transection of the esophagus, sometimes with splenectomy and coronary vein ligation, over a 4 year period. In our experience, esophageal transection in high-risk patients with variceal bleeding controlled acute variceal hemorrhage, was neither rapid nor free of technical misadventures, was associated with a high rate of serious postoperative complications resulting in death in nearly all patients, and consistently failed to result in sufficient metabolic improvement to permit shunt surgery.

Hepatopedal flow restoration in patients intolerant of total portal diversion

This report describes an experience with operative restoration of hepatopedal portal blood flow in five patients intolerant of total splanchnic shunting. Portal flow was reestablished by takedown of the total shunt and construction of a selective, distal splenorenal shunt, or by isolation and arterialization of the hepatic limb of the shunted portal vein. In two patients, shunt revision was undertaken electively for chronic encephalopathy, which had been unresponsive to low-protein diet, intestinal antibiosis and oral lactulose. Eighteen and 48 months after operation, both patients have had no encephalopathy on an unrestricted protein intake, and work actively as homemakers. Needle liver biopsies showed enhanced mitotic activity in the early postoperative period, suggesting hepatocyte regeneration. In three patients, shunt conversion or arterialization was undertaken in desperate circumstances, characterized by liver failure (bilirubin greater than 10 mg/dl, albumin less than 2.5 g/dl, prothrombin time greater than 16 sec), coma, and respirator dependency. Although the patients showed immediate, marked improvement in mentation, all three died of intraabdominal hemorrhage in the first few postoperative days, in spite of maximum blood product support. Two conclusions can be drawn from this limited experience: (1) at a time of election, restoration of hepatopedal portal flow can be accomplished with considerable benefit in patients with side-to-side portacaval or hemodynamically equivalent shunts, and (2) similar procedures in patients with fulminant liver failure are unlikely to succeed.