The challenge of therapy for pancreatitis-related common bile duct stricture

Role of endoscopic stenting for biliary strictures in chronic pancreatitis

AIM

To review the published work concerning the role of biliary stenting for chronic pancreatitis-related strictures.

METHODS

A case study in which multiple plastic stents are used to manage a chronic pancreatitis biliary stricture is presented, and the published work reviewed.

RESULTS

There has been a gradual evolution in the endoscopic management of distal biliary strictures secondary to chronic pancreatitis. Most early series used single (usually 10 F) plastic stents for varying time periods. Long-term stricture resolution occurred in only approximately 25% of patients and stent-related complications were high if stent exchanges were not performed routinely every 3-4 months. Recent studies using multiple (≥ 3) 10 F stents placed sequentially every few months for approximately 12 months have resulted in resolution of biliary strictures in up to 90% of patients. In general, the use of both uncovered and partially covered self-expandable metal stents for biliary strictures due to chronic pancreatitis have been disappointing due to problems with epithelial hyperplasia involving the uncovered portions of the self-expandable metal stents resulting in late stent occlusion and other problems. Similarly, early published data does not at this stage support the routine use of fully covered self-expandable metal stents because of unacceptable stent-related complications.

CONCLUSION

Chronic pancreatitis-related biliary strictures should be managed initially with sequentially-placed multiple 10 F plastic stents for approximately 12 months.

Plastic or metal stents for benign extrahepatic biliary strictures: a systematic review

Background

Benign biliary strictures may be a consequence of surgical procedures, chronic pancreatitis or iatrogenic injuries to the ampulla. Stents are increasingly being used for this indication, however it is not completely clear which stent type should be preferred.

Methods

A systematic review on stent placement for benign extrahepatic biliary strictures was performed after searching PubMed and EMBASE databases. Data were pooled and evaluated for technical success, clinical success and complications.

Results

In total, 47 studies (1116 patients) on outcome of stent placement were identified. No randomized controlled trials (RCTs), one non-randomized comparative studies and 46 case series were found. Technical success was 98,9% for uncovered self-expandable metal stents (uSEMS), 94,8% for single plastic stents and 94,0% for multiple plastic stents. Overall clinical success rate was highest for placement of multiple plastic stents (94,3%) followed by uSEMS (79,5%) and single plastic stents (59.6%). Complications occurred more frequently with uSEMS (39.5%) compared with single plastic stents (36.0%) and multiple plastic stents (20,3%).

Conclusion

Based on clinical success and risk of complications, placement of multiple plastic stents is currently the best choice. The evolving role of cSEMS placement as a more patient friendly and cost effective treatment for benign biliary strictures needs further elucidation. There is a need for RCTs comparing different stent types for this indication.

Long-term results of endoscopic drainage of common bile duct strictures in chronic pancreatitis

OBJECTIVES

Endoscopic stent therapy is an established treatment modality for postoperative biliary strictures. At present, biliary stenting is also widely applied in chronic pancreatitis (CP), but results regarding long-term outcome are scarce.

METHODS

All CP patients who underwent endoscopic biliary drainage of a benign stricture in our hospital between 1987 and 2000 were included in this retrospective study.

RESULTS

Fifty-eight CP patients underwent biliary stenting (median age, 54 years; 44 male). The procedure-related mortality rate was 2% and the complication rate 4%. Median follow-up was 45 months (range, 0-182 months). Endoscopic treatment was successful in 22 patients (38%). Concomitant acute pancreatitis was the only factor identified as predictive of a successful outcome by multivariate analyses. Subanalysis of these 12 patients revealed a success rate of 92%, as opposed to 24% in cases without acute inflammation. In this latter group, continued stenting beyond a 1-year period almost never resulted in additional stricture resolvement. If stricture resolution was accomplished, however, no recurrences were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

For biliary strictures due to CP, without evidence of concomitant acute pancreatitis, the long-term success rate of endoscopic therapy is poor and only one out of four strictures is treated successfully. When a biliary stricture has not resolved after 1 year of endoscopic stenting, surgery should be considered.

Treatment of symptomatic distal common bile duct stenosis secondary to chronic pancreatitis: comparison of single vs. multiple simultaneous stents

BACKGROUND

Common bile duct stenosis occurs in up to 30% of patients with chronic pancreatitis. Most such stenoses are found incidentally during ERCP, but others manifest as obstructive jaundice, recurrent cholangitis, secondary biliary cirrhosis, or choledocholithiasis. Operative drainage has been the main treatment despite the potentially high morbidity in patients with chronic pancreatitis. Endoscopic biliary drainage with a single stent has been successful in the short term. The aim of this study was to determine the long-term benefit of a single stent vs. multiple simultaneous stents for treatment of patients with chronic pancreatitis and symptoms because of distal common bile duct stenosis.

METHODS

Twelve consecutive patients with chronic pancreatitis and common bile duct stenosis underwent endoscopic placement of multiple simultaneous stents and were followed prospectively (Group II). Results were compared with a group of 34 patients in whom a single stent was placed before the start of the present study (Group I). All 46 patients (35 men, 11 women; age range 30-71 years) had chronic pancreatitis and common bile duct stenosis, and presented with symptoms indicative of obstruction (abdominal pain, jaundice, elevated biochemical tests of liver function, acute pancreatitis, cholangitis). The 34 patients in Group I had single stent (10F, 7-9 cm) placement, with exchange at 3 to 6 month intervals (1-4 exchanges) over a mean of 21 months. The 12 patients in Group II underwent placement of multiple simultaneous stents at 3-month intervals (single 10F stents added sequentially) over a mean of 14 months. Mean follow-up was 4.2 years in Group I and 3.9 years for Group II. Factors assessed included symptoms, biochemical tests of liver function, diameter of common bile duct stenosis, and complications.

RESULTS

In Group I, (34 patients), a total of 162 single stent placement/exchanges were performed (mean 5/patient). In Group II (12 consecutive patients), 8 patients had 4 (10F) stents placed simultaneously, and 4 patients had 5 (10F) stents. At the end of the treatment period, near normalization of biochemical tests of liver function was observed for all patients in Group II, whereas only marginal benefit was noted for patients in Group I. Four patients in Group I had recurrent cholangitis (6 episodes), whereas no patient in Group II had post-procedure cholangitis. In the 12 patients with multiple stents, distal common bile duct stenosis diameter increased from a mean of 1.0 mm to 3.0 mm after treatment; no change in diameter was noted in patients treated with a single stent.

CONCLUSIONS

Distal common bile duct stenosis secondary to chronic pancreatitis can be treated long term by stent placement. Multiple, simultaneous stents appear to be superior to single stent placement and may provide good long-term benefit. The former resulted in near normalization of biochemical tests of liver function and an increase in distal common bile duct diameter. Multiple stent placement may obviate the need for surgical diversion procedures.

Endoscopic stenting for common bile duct stenoses in chronic pancreatitis: results and impact on long-term outcome

OBJECTIVES

The overall incidence of common bile duct strictures due to chronic pancreatitis is reported to be approximately 10-30%. It remains a challenging problem for gastroenterologists and surgeons. The exact role of endoscopic stenting has not yet been clearly defined.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Thirty-nine patients with chronic pancreatitis and symptomatic common bile duct stenoses underwent endoscopic stenting and were studied retrospectively. We were particularly interested in how many patients would achieve resolution of the stricture and tolerate removal of the stents in the long term.

RESULTS

Indications for endoscopic stenting were symptomatic cholestasis, jaundice or cholangitis. The initial serum bilirubin was 8.3 mg/dl and the diameter of the common bile duct was 14.2 mm before stenting. Within 3-7 days of stenting, all patients presented improvement of jaundice and cholestasis. After a median stenting time of 9 months (range 1-144 months), 46% of the patients demonstrated regression of the stricture and clinical improvement, 26% required further stenting, and 28% were referred to surgery. Five patients received a self-expandable metal Wallstent. Thirty-one per cent demonstrated complete clinical recovery of the stricture as well as 10.2% a complete, radiologically verified stricture regression in a median follow-up of 58 months.

CONCLUSIONS

There seems to be a therapeutic benefit for short-term endoscopic treatment but medium-term and long-term outcome remains questionable. Endoscopic stenting should be applied as an initial therapy before surgery, but it can be the definitive approach for older and morbid patients or cases with complete stricture regression after stent removal. Overall, it should not be considered as a routine procedure for symptomatic cases.

Is endoscopic drainage of common bile duct stenoses in chronic pancreatitis up-to-date?

OBJECTIVE

Common bile duct (CBD) stenoses often complicate chronic pancreatitis (CP). Although endoscopic drainage is employed as a standard procedure in malignant CBD stenoses, it is not yet the approved standard therapy of CBD stenosis in CP.

METHODS

The records of 31 patients with CBD stenosis in CP who had undergone endoscopic placement of plastic endoprostheses into the bile duct between January 1991 and February 1997 were analyzed retrospectively. In all, 18 patients suffered from jaundice and 13 patients exclusively showed serological cholestasis. Upstream dilation of the CBD (19 +/- 6.6 mm, 12-35 mm) was detected by ERCP in all patients. In total, 101 endoprostheses were implanted endoscopically, exchanged after 3 +/- 2 months, and removed after 10 +/- 8 months.

RESULTS

All jaundiced patients showed immediate improvement of cholestasis after drainage. At the time of last exchange or after stent removal, prestenotic CBD dilation was reduced in 55% of all patients. Complete regression of stenosis and prestenotic dilation was accomplished only in 13%; dilation remained unchanged in 10%, and even showed progression in 22%. A total of 29 patients were followed-up over 24 months. Cholestatic parameters remained normal in all patients with complete normalization of the CBD, and were only moderately increased in another 10 patients, 7 and 28 months after stent removal, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Technical and immediate clinical success of CBD stenting in patients with CBD stenoses due to CP is high; however, long-term complete normalization of the bile duct is rare. Endoscopic drainage of CBD-stenosis in patients with CP can be recommended to alleviate acute cholestasis, but not yet as a definite treatment.

Long term treatment of biliary stricture due to chronic pancreatitis with a metallic stent

The exact role of endoprostheses in the management of chronic pancreatitis-associated biliary strictures has not yet been clearly established. We report an unusual case of a patient with this condition who was treated for an unexpectedly long term with a self-expanding metallic endoprosthesis. There has only been one previous report of the use of metallic stents in this situation. It appears that metallic endoprostheses may have a role to play in the management of selected patients who have chronic pancreatitis-associated bile duct stricture.