Surgical management for recurrent pharyngoesophageal (Zenker's) diverticulum

Surgical management of recurrent Zenker's diverticulum: A multi-institutional cohort study

OBJECTIVE

This study identifies how recurrent Zenker's diverticula are treated.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review was performed from four tertiary referral academic voice and swallowing centers to identify individuals who underwent surgery for recurrent Zenker's diverticulum. Demographic data, surgical modalities for primary and revision surgery, symptoms pre and post revision and complications were recorded.

RESULTS

56 individuals met inclusion criteria. Primary surgery was open in 30.3% (n = 17) and endoscopic in 69.6% (n = 39). Revision surgery was performed via an open approach in 37.5% of cases (N = 21) and via an endoscopic approach in 62.5% of cases (N = 35). Revision surgical technique was based on pouch size, patient age and comorbidities, as well as patient and surgeon preference. There were no major complications and few minor complications.

CONCLUSION

Zenker's diverticulum symptoms can recur regardless of primary treatment modality. Both endoscopic and open approaches can safely treat recurrent Zenker's diverticula.

Carcinoma arising from pharyngeal diverticula

BACKGROUND

Pharyngeal diverticulum or Zenker's diverticulum carcinoma is a rare malignancy with a poor prognosis. Carcinoma arising in a recurrent pharyngeal diverticulum is even rarer, with only 1 such case reported in the English-language literature. We report 2 patients with pharyngeal diverticulum carcinoma exhibiting an unusual presentation and good long-term, disease-free survival with normal speech and swallowing.

METHODS

A 70-year-old man with a carcinoma in a recurrent pharyngeal diverticulum excised 20 years previously and a 65-year-old man with a neck mass as the only presentation of pharyngeal diverticulum carcinoma.

RESULTS

Our patients were treated with open resection, laryngeal preservation, and postoperative radiotherapy (PORT), resulting in long-term tumor control and disease-free survival of 5 and 15 years (longest reported), respectively.

CONCLUSION

One-stage diverticulectomy with or without radiotherapy is the treatment of choice and can provide long-term control and survival.

Risk factors in patients undergoing cricopharyngeal myotomy

Background

Cricopharyngeal myotomy for oropharyngeal dysphagia is designed to improve symptoms, but the operation can result in significant morbidity and even death.

Methods

A retrospective analysis was carried out of all complications and deaths among 253 patients who had cricopharyngeal myotomy performed by a single surgeon.

Results

A single wound infection developed among 15 patients with neurological dysphagia. The same patient subsequently required laryngeal exclusion and tracheostomy. Of 139 patients treated for dysphagia secondary to muscular dystrophy, haematoma formation or infection occurred in four, and eight patients developed postoperative pulmonary complications, four of whom died from respiratory distress syndrome. Two patients with myogenic dysphagia required laryngeal exclusion with a permanent tracheostomy. Infection of the wound or retropharyngeal space was the main problem in 90 patients with a pharyngo-oesophageal diverticulum, affecting 9 per cent of the patients. Fistula was documented in three patients overall (1·2 per cent). Systemic morbidity unrelated to the technique occurred in 26 patients (10·3 per cent).

Conclusion

Pulmonary aspiration and lethal respiratory distress occurred only in patients with myogenic dysphagia. Local infection was the main complication in those with pharyngo-oesophageal diverticulum. Persistent aspiration can lead to laryngeal exclusion or resection with permanent tracheostomy.

Results of reoperation on the upper esophageal sphincter

OBJECTIVE

Reoperation on the upper esophageal sphincter is infrequent. We reviewed our experience in patients who underwent reoperation on the upper esophageal sphincter.

METHODS

This is a retrospective report of accumulative series from 2 separate institutions.

RESULTS

From September 1, 1976, to February 28, 1997, 37 patients underwent reoperation on the upper esophageal sphincter for recurrent or persistent obstructive symptoms. There were 29 men and 8 women. The median age was 69 years (range, 38-87 years). The original indication for the operation was a pharyngoesophageal (Zenker's) diverticulum in 33 patients (89.2%), oculopharyngeal dystrophy in 3 patients (8.1%), and muscular dystrophy in 1 patient (2.7%). One prior upper esophageal sphincter operation had been performed in 26 patients (70.3%), two operations in 9 patients (24. 3%), and three operations in 2 patients (5.4%). All patients were symptomatic; 35 patients (94.6%) had dysphagia; 23 patients (62.2%) had regurgitation; and 12 patients (32.4%) had episodes of aspiration. Thirty of the patients (91.0%) with Zenker's diverticulum were found to have a recurrent or persistent diverticulum at reoperation. A diverticulectomy and cricopharyngeal myotomy were performed in 23 patients (62.2%); cricopharyngeal myotomy alone, in 7 patients (18.9%); diverticulopexy and cricopharyngeal myotomy, in 6 patients (16.2%); and diverticulectomy alone, in 1 patient (2.7%). There were no operative deaths. Complications developed in 10 patients (27.0%). Follow-up was complete in 34 patients (91.9%) and ranged from 2 to 149 months (median, 39 mo). Thirty-two patients (94.1%) were improved. Functional results were classified as excellent in 26 patients (76. 5%), good in 2 patients (5.9%), fair in 4 patients (11.7%), and poor in 2 patients (5.9%).

CONCLUSIONS

Reoperation for patients who have persistent or recurrent symptoms after an operation on the upper esophageal sphincter is associated with acceptable morbidity and mortality rates. Resolution of symptoms occurs in most patients.

Cricopharyngeal dysfunction in Parkinson's disease: role in dysphagia and response to myotomy

We report five patients with Parkinson's disease and dysphagia who were found, by radiological and manometric evaluation, to have evidence of cricopharyngeal dysfunction, which included the presence of a Zenker's diverticulum in two. Cricopharyngeal myotomy was performed in four patients with excellent and sustained improvement in swallowing. We conclude that cricopharyngeal function should be carefully evaluated in patients with Parkinson's disease and dysphagia and that surgical treatment should be considered in appropriate cases.

The surgical management of motility disorders

Surgical treatment is either the therapy of choice or a facultative procedure in various types of esophageal motility disorders. In achalasia, cardiomyotomy, frequently combined with fundoplasty, achieves good or excellent results in > 80% of cases, and is, therefore, advised in cases when pneumostatic dilatation fails. Diverticulectomy and myotomy of the upper or lower esophageal sphincter are proven procedures to treat cervical and epiphrenic diverticula, leading to good/excellent results or at least an improvement in more than 95%. If, exceptionally, parabronchial diverticula require therapy, they should be excised transthoracically. Cervical myotomy is indicated in cases of cervical achalasia, when sufficient pharyngeal propulsion is preserved. In systemic diseases like scleroderma reflux induced complications may require surgical intervention in medically intractable cases. In these rather few cases, subtotal gastrectomy with a Roux-en-Y anastomosis is advised. In patients suffering from diffuse esophageal spasm or symptomatic "nutcracker" esophagus, extended esophageal myotomy can relieve symptoms. If a clear diagnosis is provided, about 75% of patients will have an improvement of symptoms.

Pharyngeal diverticula

A series of 73 hypopharyngeal (Zenker's) diverticula is reported and the choice of treatment and technique of excision are discussed. The problems of excision include operation on an infected site with limited access but few patients are unfit for the procedure. Preoperatively the sac should be packed and the oesophagus stented. The side of approach is unimportant as the condition is essentially midline. Cricopharyngeal myotomy appears to reduce the recurrence rate, possibly by improving coordination of pharyngeal contraction and upper oesophageal relaxation. The use of electrocoagulation is not recommended as 20% of patients require repeated general anaesthesia and the procedure fails in 13%. For all but the smallest pouches, excision is the treatment of choice.