Donor core-cooling provides improved static preservation for heart-lung transplantation

Cold ischemia or topical-ECMO for lung preservation: a randomized experimental study

CONTEXT AND OBJECTIVE

Lung preservation remains a challenging issue for lung transplantation groups. Along with the development of ex vivo lung perfusion, a new preservation method known as topical-ECMO (extracorporal membrane oxygenation) has been proposed. The present study compared topical-ECMO with cold ischemia (CI) for lung preservation in an ex vivo experimental model.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Randomized experimental study, conducted at a public medical school.

METHOD

Fourteen human lungs were retrieved from seven brain-dead donors that were considered unsuitable for transplantation. The lung bloc was divided and each lung was randomized to be preserved by means of topical-ECMO or CI (4-7 °C) for eight hours. These lungs were then reconnected to an ex vivo perfusion system for functional evaluation. Lung biopsies were obtained at three times. The functional variables assessed were oxygenation capacity (OC) and pulmonary artery pressure (PAP); and the histological variables were lung injury score (LIS) and apoptotic cell count (ACC).

RESULTS

The mean OC was 468 mmHg (± 81.6) in the topical-ECMO group and 455.8 (± 54) for CI (P = 0.758). The median PAP was 140 mmHg (120-160) in the topical-ECMO group and 140 mmHg (140-150) for CI (P = 0.285). The mean LIS was 35.57 (± 4.5) in the topical-ECMO group and 33.86 (± 6.1) for CI (P = 0.367). The ACC was 25.00 (± 9.34) in the topical-ECMO group and 24.86 (± 10.374) for CI (P = 0.803).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study showed that topical-ECMO was not superior to cold ischemia for up to eight hours of lung preservation.

Cardiopulmonary support and extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for cardiac assist

BACKGROUND

Use of cardiopulmonary bypass for emergency resuscitation is not new. In fact, John Gibbon proposed this concept for the treatment of severe pulmonary embolism in 1937. Significant progress has been made since, and two main concepts for cardiac assist based on cardiopulmonary bypass have emerged: cardiopulmonary support (CPS) and extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO). The objective of this review is to summarize the state of the art in these two technologies.

METHODS

Configuration of CPS is now fairly standard. A mobile cart with relatively large wheels allowing for easy transportation carries a centrifugal pump, a back-up battery with a charger, an oxygen cylinder, and a small heating system. Percutaneous cannulation, pump-driven venous return, rapid availability, and transportability are the main characteristics of a CPS system. Cardiocirculatory arrest is a major predictor of mortality despite the use of CPS. In contrast, CPS appears to be a powerful tool for patients in cardiogenic shock before cardiocirculatory arrest, requiring some type of therapeutic procedures, especially repair of anatomically correctable problems or bridging to other mechanical circulatory support systems such as ventricular assist devices. CPS is in general not suitable for long-term applications because of the small-bore cannulas, resulting in significant pressure gradients and eventually hemolysis.

RESULTS

In contrast, ECMO can be designed for longer-term circulatory support. This requires large-bore cannulas and specifically designed oxygenators. The latter are either plasma leakage resistent (true membranes) or relatively thrombo-resistant (heparin coated). Both technologies require oxygenator changeovers although the main reason for this is different (clotting for the former, plasma leakage for the latter). Likewise, the tubing within a roller pump has to be displaced and centrifugal pump heads have to be replaced over time. ECMO is certainly the first choice for a circulatory support system in the neonatal and pediatric age groups, where the other assist systems are too bulky. ECMO is also indicated for patients improving on CPS. Septic conditions are, in general, considered as contraindications for ECMO.

CONCLUSIONS

Ease of availability and moderate cost of cardiopulmonary bypass-based cardiac support technologies have to be balanced against the significant immobilization of human resources, which is required to make them successful.

Lung preservation: a review of current practice and future directions

During the past 10 years, pulmonary transplantation has emerged as a successful mode of surgical therapy for suitable patients with end-stage lung disease. Current preservation techniques of donor lungs for subsequent transplantation include core-cooling and single flush perfusion. The relative merits of these are described. These methods are essentially restricted to 6 hours of ischemia. Research in lung preservation is aimed not only at extending the safe period of ischemia but also at improving the quality of preservation. Areas of interest include the ideal composition of the perfusate, relevant pharmacologic additives, and the best conditions for preservation and harvesting. Advantages and disadvantages of the various animal models are listed in addition to the methods used in assessing the quality of preservation. There have been major advances in experimental lung preservation during the past 10 years, and we are possibly on the threshold of incorporating some of these into clinical practice. Among the most important are the adoption of colloid-based perfusates, the more widespread use of free radical scavengers, and the use of leukocyte depletion.

[The concept of lung and heart-lung preservation within the scope of multiple organ procurement]

Preservation of the lung is still one of the most challenging problems, because due to limited procurement time not all organs available can be used. The most common procurement technique is flush perfusion of the pulmonary artery system. Alternative methods in clinical use are either the autologous working heart-lung preparation or donor core-cooling (DCC). The own concept presented here, modified to the special demands of multi-organ-procurement, combines DCC and interstitial equilibration adapted to intracellular ion concentration. DCC is induced by extracorporeal circulation (ECC) using a transportable heart lung machine including a highly effective cooling system: cooling circuit based on two parallel heat exchangers with ice-water cooling produced by a high-pressure overflow of a low-temperature ice block (-40 degrees C). While cooling by ECC stepwise hemodilution is achieved by priming volume and incorporation of the cardioplegic solution (Bretschneider-HTK). The aim of equilibration is to lower the extracellular levels of sodium and calcium, and to increase the level of potassium. Additionally, the buffer capacity of donor blood is increased by the incorporated histidine-buffer system (alpha-stat). To avoid donor organ edema the time of ECC should be as short as possible. Using our system donor organ temperatures below 10 degrees C are reached within less than 30 min. In addition to ECC, lung surface cooling is achieved by external overflow with cold arterial blood (internal mammary artery). Besides lung preservation the main advantage of this concept is the profound precooling of all visceral organs before their individual flush perfusion.

Lung and heart-lung transplantation

Unilateral lung transplantation has become a successful method for the treatment of end-stage pulmonary disease, whereas double-lung transplantation has provided benefit to patients with nonfibrotic lung disease such as emphysema and cystic fibrosis. In the past 5 years, 16 single-lung and 13 double-lung transplantations have been performed by the Toronto Lung Transplant Group in patients with end-stage lung disease. Seven perioperative and two late deaths have been recorded so far. Since the introduction of heart-lung transplantation at Stanford in 1981 and at Pittsburgh in 1982 for the treatment of Eisenmenger's syndrome and terminal pulmonary vascular disease, more than 350 combined heart-lung transplantations have been carried out throughout the world. Presently, the 2-year actuarial survival is about 62%. The long-term results have not yet reached the same level of success as those of cardiac transplantation alone. Although several factors have played a role in this difference, a prominent cause has been the lack of a reliable and simple method for pulmonary protection against prolonged ischemia. Most of the techniques proposed against ischemia can be classified as normothermic or static hypothermic cardiopulmonary preservation. The use of the normothermic method has not always been successful. For this reason, interest has now been directed toward the potential for hypothermic preservation of the heart-lung bloc and the use of free-radical scavenger therapy in the reduction of reperfusion injury.

Organ procurement for pulmonary transplantation

Selection of suitable donors is critical to the success of clinical pulmonary transplantation. Requirements for lung donors, management before explantation, and methods of preservation were reviewed for the 70 heart-lung, eight double-lung, and two single-lung transplantations performed at the University of Pittsburgh since 1982. Careful observation of trends of hyperoxygenation studies, chest roentgenograms, and Gram stain and culture results of tracheal secretions, as well as findings on bronchoscopy, can help identify which lungs not only have adequate function but are acceptable for transplantation. In spite of the rigid criteria used, 76% of tracheal cultures from donors deemed acceptable grew organisms. The presence of oropharyngeal flora has been shown to correlate with the development of early intrathoracic infections in the recipient. Prophylactic broad-spectrum antibiotic treatment of the donor is desirable to treat microbial contamination that could cause focal injury to the donor lung and predispose to infection in the recipient. Acceptance of less than ideal donors is ill-advised even though rejection of such donors conflicts with the current shortage of organs.