Moderate-intensity exercise training with elements of step aerobics in patients with severe chronic heart failure

Ergophysiological evaluation of heart failure patients with reduced ejection fraction undergoing exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to explore in heart failure (HF) patients with reduced ejection fraction (EF) undergoing exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation the following: 1) the comparison of temporal changes between peak oxygen uptake (VO2peak) and first ventilatory threshold (VO2VT1), 2) the association of VO2peak and VO2VT1 changes with physiological factors, and 3) the differential effects of continuous aerobic exercise (CAE) and interval training (IT) on VO2peak and VO2VT1.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was conducted in PubMed, CENTRAL, and Scopus. Inclusion criteria were 1) original research articles using exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation, 2) stable HF patients with reduced EF, 3) available values of VO2peak and VO2VT1 (in mL/kg/min) both at baseline and after exercise training with comparison between these time points.

RESULTS

Among the 30 eligible trials, 24 used CAE, 5 IT, and one CAE and IT. Multivariable meta-regression with duration of exercise training and percentage of males as independent variables and the change in VO2peak as a dependent variable showed that the change in VO2peak was negatively associated with duration of exercise training (coefficient=-0.061, p=0.027), implying the possible existence of a waning effect of exercise training on VO2peak in the long term. Multivariable meta-regression demonstrated that both age (coefficient=-0.140, p<0.001) and EF (coefficient=-0.149, p<0.001) could predict the change in VO2VT1, whereas only age (coefficient=-0.095, p=0.022), but not EF (coefficient = 0.082, p = 0.100), could predict the change in VO2peak. The posttraining peak respiratory exchange ratio, as an index of maximum effort during exercise testing, correlated positively with the change in VO2peak (coefficient=-0.021, p=0.044). The exercise-induced changes of VO2peak (p = 0.438) and VO2VT1 (p = 0.474) did not differ between CAE and IT groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Improvement of endurance capacity during cardiac rehabilitation may be detected more accurately with the assessment of VO2VT1 rather than VO2peak.

Cardiac rehabilitation in heart failure with severely reduced ejection fraction: effects on mortality

Thirty years ago, patients with low ejection fraction (EF) have often been excluded from rehabilitation programs due to concern about possibility of sudden death or other adverse cardiovascular events during exercise sessions. Recent studies have highlighted the fact that cardiac rehabilitation could improve exercise capacity, cardiac function, and health-related quality of life in congestive heart failure patients. This encouraged us to write a review article and update our latest knowledge about the outcome of rehabilitation program in patients with severely depressed cardiac function. We were particularly interested in effect of cardiac rehabilitation on exercise capacity, quality of life, vascular effects, neuro-hormonal changes, and mortality. We also conducted a mini-systematic review and meta-analysis on randomized controlled trials comparing exercise training with usual care in patients with severely reduced left ventricular ejection fraction, for the mortality subsection to obtain precise estimates of overall treatment benefit on mortality. It is our privilege to submit our manuscript for possible publication in your prestigious journal.

Effects of exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation delivery modes on exercise capacity and health-related quality of life in heart failure: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

Background

This review aimed to compare the relative effectiveness of different exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation (ExCR) delivery modes (centre-based, home-based, hybrid and technology-enabled ExCR) on key heart failure (HF) outcomes: exercise capacity, health-related quality of life (HRQoL), HF-related hospitalisation and HF-related mortality.

Methods and results

Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) published through 20 June 2021 were identified from six databases, and reference lists of included studies. Risk of bias and certainty of evidence were evaluated using the Cochrane tool and Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation, respectively. Bayesian network meta-analysis was performed using R. Continuous and binary outcomes are reported as mean differences (MD) and ORs, respectively, with 95% credible intervals (95% CrI). One-hundred and thirty-nine RCTs (n=18 670) were included in the analysis. Network meta-analysis demonstrated improvements in VO₂peak following centre-based (MD (95% CrI)=3.10 (2.56 to 3.65) mL/kg/min), home-based (MD=2.69 (1.67 to 3.70) mL/kg/min) and technology-enabled ExCR (MD=1.76 (0.27 to 3.26) mL/kg/min). Similarly, 6 min walk distance was improved following hybrid (MD=84.78 (31.64 to 138.32) m), centre-based (MD=50.35 (30.15 to 70.56) m) and home-based ExCR (MD=36.77 (12.47 to 61.29) m). Incremental shuttle walk distance did not improve following any ExCR delivery modes. Minnesota living with HF questionnaire improved after centre-based (MD=−10.38 (−14.15 to –6.46)) and home-based ExCR (MD=−8.80 (−13.62 to –4.07)). Kansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionnaire was improved following home-based ExCR (MD=20.61 (4.61 to 36.47)), and Short Form Survey 36 mental component after centre-based ExCR (MD=3.64 (0.30 to 6.14)). HF-related hospitalisation and mortality risks reduced only after centre-based ExCR (OR=0.41 (0.17 to 0.76) and OR=0.42 (0.16 to 0.90), respectively). Mean age of study participants was only associated with changes in VO₂peak.

Conclusion

ExCR programmes have broader benefits for people with HF and since different delivery modes were comparably effective for improving exercise capacity and HRQoL, the selection of delivery modes should be tailored to individuals’ preferences.

The effects of exercise on VO2peak, quality of life and hospitalization in heart failure patients: A systematic review with meta-analyses

Exercise training has become one of the most fundamental components of cardiac rehabilitation. This systematic review with meta-analyses has the objective to determine the effectiveness of exercise on selected cardiac rehabilitation outcomes, i.e. peak oxygen consumption (VO₂peak), hospitalization and quality of life (QOL) of patients with heart failure. PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library were searched up to May 2019 to identify randomized controlled trials comparing exercise training to usual care. Overall, 131 trials were included with a total of 9,761 patients, the majority of whom were males (74%), predominantly with reduced ejection fraction and NYHA class ranging from II to III. There was a significant improvement in VO₂peak in the exercise group compared to non-exercise control group (mean difference: 2.98 mL/kg/ min, 95% CI: 2.52-3.43, p < 0.001; 84 RCTs, n = 3,690 patients). Exercise training was also beneficial for the patients' QOL. The QOL meta-analysis included 5,786 patients and showed a clinically significant improvement of QOL following exercise (-0.82, 95% CI: -1.02 to -0.62; p = 0.00001; I² = 91%). Hospitalization incidence of heart failure patients was also lower in the exercise compared to control group (fixed-effect Odds Ratio: 0.56, 95% CI: 0.42-0.75, p < 0.0001; 26 trials, 4,664 participants). Exercise-based rehabilitation improves V0₂peak and QOL and reduces the incidence of hospitalization of heart failure patients.

Resistance exercise enhances oxygen uptake without worsening cardiac function in patients with systolic heart failure: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Recent literature suggests that resistance training (RT) improves peak oxygen uptake ([Formula: see text] peak), similarly to aerobic exercise (AE) in patients with heart failure (HF), but its effect on cardiac remodeling is controversial. Thus, we examined the effects of RT and AE on [Formula: see text] peak and cardiac remodeling in patients with heart failure (HF) via a systematic review and meta-analysis. MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Library and CINAHL, AMEDEO and PEDro databases search were extracted study characteristics, exercise type, and ventricular outcomes. The main outcomes were [Formula: see text] peak (ml kg^-1 min^-1), LVEF (%) and LVEDV (mL). Fifty-nine RCTs were included. RT produced a greater increase in [Formula: see text] peak (3.57 ml kg^-1 min^-1, P < 0.00001, I ² = 0%) compared to AE (2.63 ml kg^-1 min^-1, P < 0.00001, I ² = 58%) while combined RT and AE produced a 2.48 ml kg^-1 min^-1 increase in [Formula: see text]; I ² = 69%) compared to control group. Comparison among the three forms of exercise revealed similar effects on [Formula: see text] peak (P = 0.84 and 1.00, respectively; I ² = 0%). AE was associated with a greater gain in LVEF (3.15%; P < 0.00001, I ² = 17%) compared to RT alone or combined exercise which produced similar gains compared to control groups. Subgroup analysis revealed that AE reduced LVEDV (- 10.21 ml; P = 0.007, I ² = 0%), while RT and combined RT and AE had no effect on LVEDV compared with control participants. RT results in a greater gain in [Formula: see text] peak, and induces no deleterious effects on cardiac function in HF patients.

Possible neurocognitive benefits of exercise in persons with heart failure

More than 6 million Americans have heart failure (HF) and more than 500,000 are diagnosed each year. In addition to its many adverse medical consequences, HF is also a significant risk factor for neurological disorders like Alzheimer's disease and associated with cognitive impairment long prior to the onset of these conditions. Converging bodies of literature suggest cognitive dysfunction in HF may be at least partially modifiable. One key mechanism for cognitive improvement is improved cerebral blood flow, which may be possible with exercise in patients with HF. This brief review provides a model for the likely neurocognitive benefits of exercise in HF and encourages further work in this area.

Effect of outpatient exercise training programmes in patients with chronic heart failure: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Advantages of outpatient exercise training are reduced waiting lists, better compliance, reduced time investment by the patient with reduced travel expenses, and less dependence on other people to participate. Therefore, this systematic review studies the effects of outpatient exercise training programmes compared with usual care on exercise capacity, exercise performance, quality of life, and safety in patients with chronic heart failure.

DESIGN

Systematic review with meta-analysis.

METHODS

Randomized controlled trials concerning patients with chronic heart failure, with a left ventricular ejection fraction ≤40%, were included. A meta-analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Twenty-two studies were included. VO(2)max, 6-min walking test, and quality of life showed significant differences in favour of the intervention group of 1.85 ml/kg/min, 47.9 m, and 6.9 points, respectively. In none of the studies, a significant relationship was found between exercise training and adverse events.

CONCLUSION

This meta-analysis illustrates the efficacy and safety of outpatient training programmes for patients with chronic heart failure.

Drug and Device Effects on Peak Oxygen Consumption, 6-Minute Walk Distance, and Natriuretic Peptides as Predictors of Therapeutic Effects on Mortality in Patients With Heart Failure and Reduced Ejection Fraction

Background—

Although peak oxygen consumption (peak V o 2 ), 6-minute walk distance (6MW), and natriuretic peptides (BNP and NT-proBNP) are predictors of mortality in heart failure (HF) patients, it is not known whether therapy-induced changes in these measures can predict therapeutic effect on mortality. The objective of this analysis is to quantitatively assess the relationship between therapeutic effects on commonly proposed short-term markers in HF trials and therapeutic effects on long-term outcome in patients with HF and left ventricular dysfunction.

Methods and Results—

We identified drug or device therapies for which there exists at least 1 randomized, controlled trial (RCT) assessing mortality over at least 6 months in at least 500 patients. For each of these therapies, we identified RCTs assessing the short-term changes in V o 2 , 6MW, BNP, and NT-proBNP (few of the mortality RCTs assessed the short-term changes in markers). For each intervention, we calculated the odds ratio for mortality (using random effect meta-analysis when necessary), as well as the trial level average drug- or device-induced change in the markers. We assessed the correlation between the odds ratio for death with the placebo-corrected change in the functional parameter or biomarker across the interventions. We identified mortality RCTs of 27 distinct therapies (n=73 267 patients) with a median follow-up of 19 months, that directed the search for RCTs of the effect of those interventions on the functional markers and biomarkers. There were 54 peak V o 2 trials (n=4646 patients), 34 6MW trials (n=6995 patients), 15 BNP trials (n=7233), and 6 NT-proBNP trials (n=1946) included in this analysis. There was no significant correlation between the average therapy-induced placebo-corrected change in peak V o 2 and the odds ratio for mortality ( r =0.158, P =0.26). Increased drug or device-induced average change in 6MW was correlated with increased odds ratio for mortality ( r =0.373, P =0.036). There was no significant correlation between the average therapy-induced, placebo-corrected change in the natriuretic peptides and the odds ratio for mortality (BNP: r =−0.065, P =0.82, NT-proBNP: r =−0.667, P =0.15). There was no apparent relation between change in the functional parameter or biomarker and categorical effect on mortality.

Conclusions—

This analysis, limited to trial level data from different therapeutic eras, suggests that drug- or device-induced effects on peak V o 2 , 6MW, and natriuretic peptides found in short-term trials do not predict the corresponding average long-term therapeutic effects on mortality for patients with HF and left ventricular dysfunction.

Current concepts underlying benefits of exercise training in congestive heart failure patients

The pathophysiology of several conditions including heart failure is partly attributable to a failure of the cell energy metabolism. Studies have shown that exercise training (ET) improves quality of life (QOL) and is beneficial in terms of reduction of symptoms, mortality and duration of hospitalization. Increasingly, ET is now achieving acceptance as complimentary therapy in addition to routine clinical practice in patients with chronic heart failure (CHF). However, the mechanisms underlying the beneficial effects of ET are far less understood and need further evaluation. Evidence suggests that while CHF induces generalized metabolic energy depletion, ET largely enhances the overall function of the heart muscle. Hence, research efforts are now aiming to uncover why ET is beneficial as a complimentary treatment of CHF in the context of improving endothelial function and coronary perfusion, decreasing peripheral resistance, induction of cardiac and skeletal muscle cells remodeling, increasing oxygen uptake, substrate oxidation, and resistance to fatigue. Here we discuss the current evidence that suggest that there are beneficial effects of ET on cardiac and skeletal muscle cells oxidative metabolism and intracellular energy transfer in patients with CHF.

Effects of exercise training in patients with chronic heart failure and advanced left ventricular systolic dysfunction receiving β-blockers

BACKGROUND

It remains unclear whether patients with chronic heart failure (CHF) and advanced left ventricular (LV) dysfunction on β-blocker therapy benefit from exercise training (ET).

METHODS AND RESULTS

We studied 45 CHF patients with advanced LV dysfunction [ejection fraction (LVEF) < 25%] and impaired exercise tolerance [normalized peak oxygen uptake (PVO₂) < 70%] receiving a β-blocker: 33 patients participated in a cardiac rehabilitation program with ET (ET group) and 12 did not (inactive control group). Exercise capacity, LV dimension and plasma B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP) were assessed before and after a 3-month study period. At baseline, both groups had markedly reduced LVEF (ET group 18 ± 4% vs. Control group 18 ± 5%, NS) and impaired exercise capacity (normalized PVO₂ 51 ± 10% vs. 55 ± 9%, NS). Although one patient in the ET group withdrew from the program due to worsening CHF, no serious cardiac events occurred during the ET sessions. After 3 months, the ET group (n = 24) had significantly improved PVO₂ by 16 ± 15% (1,005 ± 295 to 1,167 ± 397ml/min, P < 0.001), while the PVO₂ of the control group was unchanged. LV end-diastolic dimension decreased in both groups to a similar extent, but plasma BNP was significantly decreased only in the ET group (432 to 214 pg/ml, P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The data indicate that in CHF patients with advanced LV dysfunction on β-blocker therapy, ET successfully improves exercise capacity and BNP without adversely affecting LV remodeling or causing serious cardiac complications.

Clinical utility of exercise training in chronic systolic heart failure

The volume of literature attesting to the clinical benefits of exercise training in patients with stable chronic heart failure (CHF) is substantial. Training can improve symptoms and exercise capacity, as well as reducing morbidity, mortality, and rates of emergency hospitalization. These benefits are apparent in all patients with stable CHF, irrespective of age or sex, or the etiology or severity of heart failure. Training regimens for patients with stable, systolic CHF should form part of a comprehensive heart-failure support effort and are best delivered using supervised in-hospital exercise combined with some training at home or in a group setting in community centers. In this Review, the modes and intensity of exercise training, selection of patients, duration of training effects, and other clinical guidance for using this treatment option are discussed.

The protective effects of exercise and phosphoinositide 3-kinase (p110α) in the failing heart

Despite the development of a wide range of therapies, heart failure remains a leading cause of death in Western society. New therapies are needed to help combat this debilitating condition. Exercise is becoming an increasingly important feature of rehabilitation programmes for patients with heart failure. Before the 1980s, patients with heart failure were advised not to exercise as it was thought that exercise would increase the risk of a cardiac event (such as myocardial infarction). However, in recent years both aerobic and resistance training have been shown to be safe and beneficial for patients with heart failure, improving exercise tolerance and quality of life, and preventing muscular deconditioning. The molecular mechanisms responsible for exercise-induced cardioprotection are yet to be elucidated, however studies in transgenic mice have identified PI3K(p110α) (phosphoinositide 3-kinase p110α) as a likely mediator. PI3K(p110α) is a lipid kinase which is activated in the heart during chronic exercise training, and is important for maintaining heart structure and function in various pathological settings. In the present review the protective effects of PI3K(p110α) in the failing heart and its potential as a therapeutic strategy for the treatment of heart failure is discussed.

Long-term effects of a group-based high-intensity aerobic interval-training program in patients with chronic heart failure

Studies on the long-term effects of exercise training programs on functional capacity and the quality of life in patients with chronic heart failure (CHF) are sparse. The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term effects of group-based, high-intensity interval training on functional capacity and the quality of life in 80 patients with stable CHF (mean age 70.1 +/- 7.9 years) in New York Heart Association classes II to IIIB. Patients were randomized to either an exercise group (n = 40) or a control group (n = 40). The mean ejection fractions at baseline were 31 +/- 8% in the exercise group and 31 +/- 1% in the control group. The exercise group exercised twice a week for 4 months in addition to 4 consultations with a CHF nurse. Six-minute walking distance, workload and exercise time on a cycle ergometer test, and the quality of life were measured at baseline and 4 and 12 months after enrollment. After 4 months, functional capacity (6-minute walking distance +58 vs -15 m, p <0.001) and the quality of life (Minnesota Living With Heart Failure Questionnaire score +10 vs -1 point, p <0.005) improved significantly in the exercise group compared with the control group. After 12 months, the improvements were still significant in the exercise group compared with the control group for all parameters (6-minute walking distance +41 vs -20 m, p <0.001; workload +10 vs -1 W, p = 0.001; exercise time +53 vs -6 seconds, p = 0.003; quality of life +10 vs -6 points, p = 0.003). In conclusion, the results support the implementation of a group-based aerobic interval training program to improve long-term effects on functional capacity and the quality of life in patients with CHF.

A Systematic Review of Exercise Interventions in Patients With Heart Failure

The incidence of heart failure (HF) is increasing as the population ages. Pharmacotherapy is an important component of treatment and yields significant improvements in survival and quality of life. In recent decades, exercise has gradually become accepted as an intervention beneficial to patients with HF, but more information is needed to clarify the effects of exercise and optimize interventions. Therefore, a systematic review of randomized controlled trials published from 1966 to October 2006 was carried out via PubMed. About 69 trials were reviewed, which used as main outcome measures: (a) central hemodynamic parameters, (b) peripheral blood flow, (c) endothelial function, (d) activation of neurohormones and cytokine systems, (e) structure of and metabolism in skeletal muscles, and/or (f) quality of life. Study findings suggest that the favorable physiological responses to exercise might slow some of the pathophysiological progression of HF. However, most of the trials reviewed here were based on relatively small samples and selected participant groups, and the exercise programs varied widely. These limitations and inconsistencies need to be addressed through further studies. Furthermore, reliable strategies for maintaining the positive effects of exercise and extending them to patients' daily life and quality of life are scarce in these trials. These domains need further exploration through rationally designed, large-scale randomized controlled trials.

Improved exercise tolerance and cardiac function in severe chronic heart failure patients undergoing a supervised exercise program

BACKGROUND

Exercise intolerance is a widespread and serious problem in chronic heart failure (CHF) patients. However, the impact of a supervised exercise and rehabilitation program on exercise tolerance and cardiac performance in severe CHF patients has not yet been fully investigated.

METHODS

Of 56 consecutive patients with severe CHF (New York Heart Association functional class III, Stage D) 44 underwent a hospital-based supervised 18-week, cardiac exercise and rehabilitation program (exercise group), and 12 did not (control group). Cardiac performance was assessed by a 6-minute walk test, peak exercise VO(2), exercise duration time, resting and immediate post peak exercise stroke index (SI), cardiac index (CI) and systemic vascular resistance (SVR), before and after exercise.

RESULTS

Both groups were comparable regarding baseline clinical characteristics. Post exercise training, functional and hemodynamic parameters improved significantly in the exercise group compared to controls. A highly significant interaction between the groups and change was found in the 6-minute walk test (p<0.001), exercise test duration (p<0.001), METs during exercise (p<0.001), immediate post peak exercise CI (0.016), delta peak VO(2) (p=0.028), and immediate post peak exercise SVR (p=0.045).

CONCLUSIONS

A hospital-based supervised exercise and rehabilitation program significantly improves functional and hemodynamic parameters in severe CHF patients, and may partially contribute to better physical conditioning detected in these patients after exercise training.

Long-term versus intermediate-term supervised exercise training in advanced heart failure: Effects on exercise tolerance and mortality

AIM

To date there have been no studies exploring the effects of long-term versus intermediate-term and short-term supervised exercise training program in patients with severe chronic heart failure (CHF) on optimal medical therapy. We assessed exercise tolerance and mortality in CHF patients undergoing long- versus intermediate-term exercise training (ET).

METHODS

Forty-two consecutive severe CHF patients (New York Heart Association functional class III) were referred for a supervised exercise and cardiac rehabilitation program and were followed-up for 3 years: 20/42 (48%) patients discontinued ET after intermediate-term period of 1.6+/-0.8 years (Group A, intermediate-term ET), and 22/42 (52%) remained on the ET program for 3.0+/-0.3 years (Group B, long-term ET). Exercise duration, 6-min walked distance and metabolic equivalents (METs) assessed by modified Bruce protocol were recorded before, 4.5 months after, and 3 years after initiation of ET.

RESULTS

Both groups were comparable regarding age, gender, prevalence of ischemic etiology, mean ejection fraction and medications. Risk factors for ischemic heart disease were similar, except for the prevalence of diabetes, which was higher in Group A compared to Group B (11/20 versus 5/22, p=0.03). Significantly more Group A patients died after ET discontinuation (4/20 versus 0/22, p=0.01). At the end of follow-up a significant improvement could be seen in Group B patients compared to A in exercise duration, 6-min walked distance and metabolic equivalents (p<0.01 for all).

CONCLUSIONS

Higher survival rate was observed in severe CHF patients undergoing long-term versus intermediate-term exercise training. Long-term supervised exercise training is safe and improves exercise tolerance in these patients.

Effects of exercise training on cardiac performance, exercise capacity and quality of life in patients with heart failure: a meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Despite major advances in pharmacological treatment of chronic heart failure (CHF), a number of patients still suffer from dyspnoea, fatigue, diminished exercise capacity and poor quality of life. It is in this context that exercise training is being intensively evaluated for any additional benefit in the treatment of CHF.

AIMS

To determine the effect of exercise training in patients with CHF on cardiac performance, exercise capacity and health-related quality of life. A meta-analysis was performed to obtain this goal.

METHODS AND RESULTS

After including 35 randomised controlled trials, the methodological quality of each study was assessed, summary effect sizes (SESs) and the concomitant 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) were calculated for each outcome. Quantitative analysis showed statistically significant SESs, at rest, for diastolic blood pressure and end-diastolic volume. During maximal exercise, significant SESs were found for systolic blood pressure, heart rate, cardiac output, peak oxygen uptake, anaerobic threshold and 6-min walking test. The Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire improved by an average of 9.7 points.

CONCLUSIONS

Exercise training has clinically important effects on exercise capacity and HRQL, and may have small positive effects on cardiac performance during exercise.

Exercise programmes for patients with chronic heart failure

The safety and efficacy of exercise training in patients with chronic heart failure (CHF) have been reported in a large number of scientific studies, with endurance training representing the most frequently applied training stimulus. Beneath the common continuous method of endurance training, the interval method (short bouts of intense exercise interspersed with pre-scheduled rest intervals), was also applied in some studies. Ergometric testing is a prerequisite for all individualised training prescription and is an appropriate method of efficacy documentation. However, there is a surprisingly large range of exercise intensities being prescribed to patients with CHF. Most of the prescription models refer to maximal ergometric measurements. Submaximal references from lactate and ventilatory curves represent an alternative method in measuring accuracy and efficacy of training. The course of heart rate during submaximal incremental exercise can be reliably used to indicate endurance gains in CHF. Some positive reports exist for carefully executed strength endurance training for patients with CHF and there are convincing arguments for the use of coordination and flexibility exercises; however, substantial scientific evidence is lacking.

Therapeutic exercise for individuals with heart failure: special attention to older women with heart failure

BACKGROUND

A cardinal feature of heart failure (HF) is the reduced peak aerobic power (VO(2peak)) secondary to alterations in cardiovascular and musculoskeletal function. Methods and results During the last decade, a number of randomized trials have examined the role that exercise training plays in attenuating the HF-mediated decline in VO(2peak) and muscle strength. The major finding of these investigations was that aerobic or strength training was an effective intervention to increase VO(2peak), muscular strength, distance walked in 6 minutes, and quality of life without negatively altering left ventricular systolic function. Despite these benefits, a limitation of these investigations was the primary focus on males <60 years with impaired left ventricular systolic function. Thus the role that exercise training may play in attenuating the HF-mediated decline in VO(2peak) in women > or =65 years of age remains unknown.

CONCLUSION

Older women with HF have a VO(2peak) that is below the minimal threshold level required for independent living. Moreover, older women with HF have greater disability then men and are less likely to be referred to an exercise rehabilitation program. Accordingly, future exercise intervention trials are required to examine the role that exercise training may play in attenuating the HF-mediated decline in cardiorespiratory and musculoskeletal fitness and disability in older women with HF.

The implications of physical activity in patients with chronic heart failure

The clinical syndrome of chronic heart failure is increasingly prevalent. It can be considered a multiorgan disorder that may exert a negative physical and psychological influence on a patient. Medication and surgical intervention have important roles to play and have certainly improved both morbidity and mortality in this field, but clearly these interventions alone are not enough. Excessive resource utilization for this group of patients has provided added impetus to research into non-pharmacological interventions. These encompass dietary and other lifestyle measures, including smoking cessation and exercise. Exercise has been shown to favourably affect the functional capacity and quality of life. There is also emerging evidence that it reduces mortality. In the absence of contraindications, regular endurance exercise coupled with strength training is undoubtedly beneficial. As with other cardiovascular research, there is a trend towards recruiting middle-aged males. This effectively means that practitioners need to be cautious when evaluating and/or implementing research evidence. By addressing the implications of physical activity for deconditioned patients with chronic heart failure, a holistic therapeutic regimen is fostered. This has been shown to improve the quality of life of patients and to enhance the quality of service delivered to this patient group.

Effects of a home walking exercise program on functional status and symptoms in heart failure

BACKGROUND

Hospital-based exercise programs using a bicycle ergometer or a combination of exercise modalities have shown positive benefits in heart failure, but may not be readily accessible to many patients. Thus, we sought to evaluate the effects of a 12-week home walking exercise program on functional status and symptoms in patients with heart failure.

METHODS

A randomized controlled trial comparing a 12-week progressive home walking exercise program (n = 42) to a "usual activity" control group (n = 37) was conducted in patients with heart failure (78 [99%] male; mean age 62.6 +/- 10.6 years; ejection fraction 27% +/- 8.8%; 63 [80%] New York Heart Association class II; 15[20%] New York Heart Association class III-IV) from a Veterans Affairs medical center and a university-affiliated medical center. Functional status (peak oxygen consumption via cardiopulmonary exercise testing, 6-minute walk test, the Heart Failure Functional Status Inventory), and symptoms (Dyspnea-Fatigue Index score with a postglobal rating of symptoms) were measured at baseline and 12 weeks.

RESULTS

No adverse events related to exercise training occurred. Overall mean compliance to training was 74 +/- 37%. Peak oxygen consumption and the Heart Failure Functional Status Inventory were unchanged with training. Compared to the usual activity group, the training group had significantly longer walking distances measured by the 6-minute walk test (1264 +/- 255 vs 1337 +/- 272 feet, P =.001), and improved postglobal rating of symptoms (P =.03).

CONCLUSION

In patients with heart failure, a progressive home walking exercise program is acceptable, increases walking distance, and decreases global rating of symptoms.

Exercise based rehabilitation for heart failure

BACKGROUND

The prevalence of chronic heart failure is increasing, and increases with increasing age. Major symptoms include breathlessness and restricted activities of daily living due to reduced functional capacity, which in turn affects quality of life. Exercise training has been shown to be effective in patients with coronary heart disease and has been proposed as an intervention to improve exercise tolerance in patients with heart failure.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the effectiveness of exercise based interventions compared with usual medical care on the mortality, morbidity, exercise capacity and health related quality of life, of patients with heart failure.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register (The Cochrane Library Issue 2, 2001), MEDLINE (2000 to March 2001), EMBASE (1998 to March 2001), CINAHL (1984 to March 2001) and reference lists of articles. We also sought advice from experts.

SELECTION CRITERIA

RCTs of exercise based interventions. The comparison group was usual medical care as defined by the study, or placebo. Adults of all ages with chronic heart failure. Only those studies with criteria for diagnosis of heart failure (based on clinical findings or objective indices) have been included.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Studies were selected, and data were abstracted, independently by two reviewers. Authors were contacted where possible to obtain missing information.

MAIN RESULTS

Twenty-nine studies met the inclusion criteria, with 1126 patients randomised. The majority of studies included both patients with primary and secondary heart failure, NYHA class II or III. None of the studies specifically examined the effect of exercise training on mortality and morbidity as most were of short duration. Exercise training significantly increased VO(2) max by (WMD random effects model) 2.16 ml/kg/min (95% CI 2.82 to 1.49), exercise duration increased by 2.38 minutes (95% CI 2.85 to 1.9), work capacity by 15.1 Watts (95% CI 17.7 to 12.6) and distance on the six minute walk by 40.9 metres (95% CI 64.7 to 17.1). Improvements in VO(2) max were greater for training programmes of greater intensity and duration. HRQoL improved in the seven of nine trials that measured this outcome.

REVIEWERS' CONCLUSIONS

Exercise training improves exercise capacity and quality of life in patients mild to moderate heart failure in the short term. There is currently no information regarding the effect of exercise training on clinical outcomes. The findings are based on small-scale trials in patients who are unrepresentative of the total population of patients with heart failure. Other groups (more severe patients, the elderly, women) may also benefit. Large-scale pragmatic trials of exercise training of longer duration, recruiting a wider spectrum of patients are needed to address these issues.

Exercise training as a therapy for chronic heart failure: can older people benefit?

Despite recent advances in pharmacological therapy, chronic heart failure remains a major cause of morbidity and mortality in older people. Studies of exercise training in younger, carefully selected patients with heart failure have shown improvements in symptoms and exercise capacity and in many pathophysiological aspects of heart failure, including skeletal myopathy, ergoreceptor function, heart rate variability, endothelial function, and cytokine expression. Data on mortality and hospitalization are lacking, and effects on everyday activity, depression, and quality of life are unclear. Exercise therapy for patients with heart failure appears to be safe and has the potential to improve function and quality of life in older people with heart failure. To realize these potential benefits, exercise programs that are suitable for older, frail people need to be established and tested in an older, frail, unselected population with comorbidities.

Regular physical exercise improves endothelial function in heart transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Impaired endothelial function is detectable in heart transplant (HTX) recipients and regarded as risk factor for coronary artery disease. We have studied whether endothelial function can be improved in HTX patients participating in a regular physical training program as demonstrated in patients with chronic heart failure, hypertension and coronary artery disease.

METHODS

Male HTX patients and healthy, age-matched controls were studied. Seven HTX patients (age: 60 +/- 6 yr; 6 +/- 2 yr of HTX) participated in an outpatient training program, six HTX patients (age: 63 +/- 8 yr; 7 +/- 1 yr of HTX) maintained a sedentary lifestyle without regular physical exercise since transplantation. A healthy control group comprised six subjects (age: 62 +/- 6 yr). Vascular function was assessed by flow-mediated dilation of the brachial artery (FMD). Systemic haemodynamic responses to intravenous infusion of the endothelium independent vasodilator sodium nitroprusside (SNP) and to NG-monomethyl-L-arginine (L-NMMA), an inhibitor of constitutive nitric oxide synthase, were also measured.

RESULTS

Resting heart rate was significantly lower (p < 0.05) in healthy controls (66 +/- 13) than in the HTX training group (83 +/- 11) and in non-training HTX patients (91 +/- 9), baseline blood pressure also tended to be lower in healthy subjects and in the training HTX patients. FMD was significantly higher (p < 0.05) in the control group (8.4 +/- 2.2%) and in the training group (7.1 +/- 2.4%), compared with non-training HTX patients (1.4 +/- 0.8%). The response of systolic blood pressure (p = 0.08) and heart rate (p < 0.05) to L-NMMA was reduced in sedentary HTX patients compared with healthy controls and heart rate response to SNP was also impaired in sedentary HTX patients.

DISCUSSION

Regular aerobic physical training restores vascular function in HTX patients, who are at considerable risk for developing vascular complications. This effect is demonstrable in conduit and systemic resistance arteries.

Exercise in the geriatric patient with congestive heart failure

The benefits of exercise in the elderly patient with heart failure have been well documented, but the studies have been limited by restrictive inclusion criteria. Most studies have involved patients who are younger and healthier than those normally seen in clinical practice. Improvements in neurohormonal, metabolic, and vascular status have been well documented in the relatively young patients who have been evaluated. Consequently, peak exercise time, oxygen consumption, submaximal exercise, and quality of life have also improved. Studies suggest that older, more severely limited patients may also benefit from exercise. However, they are less likely to tolerate an exercise program and may not improve their quality of life if the exercise is excessive. Caution is warranted when exercise is prescribed to elderly patients with heart failure.

Exercise and heart failure

Chronic heart failure (CHF) is a common condition with a poor prognosis, commonly associated with poor exercise tolerance and debilitation symptoms despite optimal modern therapy. Recent investigations have shown that the degree of exercise limitation may be related to pathophysiological changes that occur systemically in the patient with CHF. Exercise training in carefully selected stable patients with heart failure has been shown to be safe to correct many of these pathophysiological changes in the periphery and to lead to worthwhile improvements in exercise capacity. Recent studies have suggested a possible improvement in mortality and morbidity with exercise training in this patient group. This article discusses the factors limiting exercise capacity in CHF and reviews the controlled clinical trial of exercise testing in this condition.

Exercise training in heart failure

Chronic heart failure (CHF) is a common condition with a poor prognosis. It is associated with poor exercise tolerance and debilitating symptoms. These symptoms appear to be associated with pathophysiological changes that occur systemically in the patient with CHF. Exercise training in carefully selected patients has been shown to be safe and to improve exercise capacity. Many of the pathophysiological abnormalities of CHF are improved by training. Some studies have suggested a possible improvement in morbidity and mortality with training. This review analyzes the controlled clinical trials of exercise training in CHF published to date.