Retinoic acid ambivalently regulates the expression of MyoD1 in the myogenic cells in the limb buds of the early developmental stages

Retinoic acid signalling inhibits myogenesis by blocking MYOD translation in pig skeletal muscle cells

Vitamin A is an essential nutrient in animals, playing important roles in animal health. In the pig industry, proper supplementation of vitamin A in the feed can improve pork production performance, while deficiency or excessive intake can lead to growth retardation or disease. However, the specific molecular mechanisms through which vitamin A operates on pig skeletal muscle growth as well as muscle stem cell function remain unexplored. Therefore, in this study, we isolated the pig primary skeletal muscle stem cells (pMuSCs) and treated with retinoic acid (RA), the natural metabolite of vitamin A, and then examined the myogenic capacity of pMuSCs via immunostaining, real-time PCR, CCK8 and western-blot analysis. Unexpectedly, the RA caused a significant decrease in the proliferation and differentiation of pMuSCs. Mechanistically, the RA addition induced the activation of retinoic acid receptor gamma (RARγ), which inhibited the myogenesis through the blockage of protein translation of the master myogenic regulator myogenic differentiation 1 gene (MYOD). Specifically, RARγ inactivate AKT kinase (AKT) signalling and lead to dephosphorylation of eukaryotic translation initiation factor 4E binding protein 1 (eIF4EBP1), which in turn repress the eukaryotic translation initiation factor 4E (eIF4E) complex and block mRNA translation of MYOD. Inhibition of AKT could rescue the myogenic defects of RA-treated pMuSCs. Our findings revealed that retinoid acid signalling inhibits the skeletal muscle stem cell proliferation and differentiation in pigs. Therefore, the vitamin A supplement in the feedstuff should be cautiously optimized to avoid the potential adverse consequences on muscle development associated with the excessive levels of retinoic acid.

Retinoic acid exerts sexually dimorphic effects on muscle energy metabolism and function

The retinol dehydrogenase Rdh10 catalyzes the rate-limiting reaction that converts retinol into retinoic acid (RA), an autacoid that regulates energy balance and reduces adiposity. Skeletal muscle contributes to preventing adiposity, by consuming nearly half the energy of a typical human. We report sexually dimorphic differences in energy metabolism and muscle function in Rdh10+/- mice. Relative to wild-type (WT) controls, Rdh10+/- males fed a high-fat diet decrease reliance on fatty-acid oxidation and experience glucose intolerance and insulin resistance. Running endurance decreases 40%. Rdh10+/- females fed this diet increase fatty acid oxidation and experience neither glucose intolerance nor insulin resistance. Running endurance increases 220%. We therefore assessed RA function in the mixed-fiber type gastrocnemius muscles (GM), which contribute to running, rather than standing, and are similar to human GM. RA levels in Rdh10+/- male GM decrease 38% relative to WT. Rdh10+/- male GM increase expression of Myog and reduce Eif6 mRNAs, which reduce and enhance running endurance, respectively. Cox5A, complex IV activity, and ATP decrease. Increased centralized nuclei reveal existence of muscle malady and/or repair in GM fibers. Comparatively, RA in Rdh10+/- female GM decreases by less than half the male decrease, from a more modest decrease in Rdh10 and an increase in the estrogen-induced retinol dehydrogenase Dhrs9. Myog mRNA decreases. Cox5A, complex IV activity, and ATP increase. Centralized GM nuclei do not increase. We conclude that Rdh10/RA affects whole body energy use and insulin resistance partially through sexual dimorphic effects on skeletal muscle gene expression, structure, and mitochondria activity.

Retinoic acid enhances skeletal muscle progenitor formation and bypasses inhibition by bone morphogenetic protein 4 but not dominant negative beta-catenin

BACKGROUND

Understanding stem cell differentiation is essential for the future design of cell therapies. While retinoic acid (RA) is the most potent small molecule enhancer of skeletal myogenesis in stem cells, the stage and mechanism of its function has not yet been elucidated. Further, the intersection of RA with other signalling pathways that stimulate or inhibit myogenesis (such as Wnt and BMP4, respectively) is unknown. Thus, the purpose of this study is to examine the molecular mechanisms by which RA enhances skeletal myogenesis and interacts with Wnt and BMP4 signalling during P19 or mouse embryonic stem (ES) cell differentiation.

RESULTS

Treatment of P19 or mouse ES cells with low levels of RA led to an enhancement of skeletal myogenesis by upregulating the expression of the mesodermal marker, Wnt3a, the skeletal muscle progenitor factors Pax3 and Meox1, and the myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs) MyoD and myogenin. By chromatin immunoprecipitation, RA receptors (RARs) bound directly to regulatory regions in the Wnt3a, Pax3, and Meox1 genes and RA activated a beta-catenin-responsive promoter in aggregated P19 cells. In the presence of a dominant negative beta-catenin/engrailed repressor fusion protein, RA could not bypass the inhibition of skeletal myogenesis nor upregulate Meox1 or MyoD. Thus, RA functions both upstream and downstream of Wnt signalling. In contrast, it functions downstream of BMP4, as it abrogates BMP4 inhibition of myogenesis and Meox1, Pax3, and MyoD expression. Furthermore, RA downregulated BMP4 expression and upregulated the BMP4 inhibitor, Tob1. Finally, RA inhibited cardiomyogenesis but not in the presence of BMP4.

CONCLUSION

RA can enhance skeletal myogenesis in stem cells at the muscle specification/progenitor stage by activating RARs bound directly to mesoderm and skeletal muscle progenitor genes, activating beta-catenin function and inhibiting bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signalling. Thus, a signalling pathway can function at multiple levels to positively regulate a developmental program and can function by abrogating inhibitory pathways. Finally, since RA enhances skeletal muscle progenitor formation, it will be a valuable tool for designing future stem cell therapies.

Response of human rhabdomyosarcoma cell lines to retinoic acid: relationship with induction of differentiation and retinoic acid sensitivity

The ability of retinoids to induce growth inhibition associated with differentiation of diverse cell types makes them potent anti-cancer agents. We examined the effect of retinoic acid (RA) in cell lines derived from rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS), a malignant soft-tissue tumor committed to the myogenic lineage, but arrested prior to terminal differentiation. We showed that several RMS derived cell lines, including RD human rhabdomyosarcoma cells, are resistant to the growth-inhibitory and differentiation effects of RA. We established that this RA-resistance correlates with reduced expression and activity of RA-receptors in RD cells. We stably expressed either RARalpha, RARbeta, RARgamma, or RXRalpha expression vector into RD cells and found that only RARbeta or RARgamma induced a significant RA growth arrest without promoting differentiation indicating that changes in the amounts of RARs and RXRs are not sufficient to determine the RA myogenic response of rhabdomyosarcoma cells. Activation of RD cell differentiation by ectopic MRF4 expression enhanced RA-receptor activity and led to RA induction of differentiation. These studies demonstrate that RA-resistance of RD cells is linked to their lack of differentiation and suggest that the differentiation-promoting activity of RA requires factors other than RAR-RXR heterodimers.

Betaglycan expression is transcriptionally up-regulated during skeletal muscle differentiation. Cloning of murine betaglycan gene promoter and its modulation by MyoD, retinoic acid, and transforming growth factor-beta

Betaglycan is a membrane-anchored proteoglycan co-receptor that binds transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) via its core protein and basic fibroblast growth factor through its glycosaminoglycan chains. In this study we evaluated the expression of betaglycan during the C(2)C(12) skeletal muscle differentiation. Betaglycan expression, as determined by Northern and Western blot, was up-regulated during the conversion of myoblasts to myotubes. The mouse betaglycan gene promoter was cloned, and its sequence showed putative binding sites for SP1, Smad3, Smad4, muscle regulatory factor elements such as MyoD and MEF2, and retinoic acid receptor. Transcriptional activity of the mouse betaglycan promoter reporter was also up-regulated in differentiating C(2)C(12) cells. We found that MyoD, but not myogenin, stimulated this transcriptional activity even in the presence of high serum. Betaglycan promoter activity was increased by RA and inhibited by the three isoforms of TGF-beta. On the other hand, basic fibroblast growth factor, BMP-2, and hepatocyte growth factor/scatter factor, which are inhibitors of myogenesis, had little effect. In myotubes, up-regulated betaglycan was also detectable by TGF-beta affinity labeling and immunofluorescence microscopy studies. The latter indicated that betaglycan was localized both on the cell surface and in the ECM. Forced expression of betaglycan in C(2)C(12) myoblasts increases their responsiveness to TGF-beta2, suggesting that it performs a TGF-beta presentation function in this cell lineage. These results indicate that betaglycan expression is up-regulated during myogenesis and that MyoD and RA modulate its expression by a mechanism that is independent of myogenin.

Syndecan-1 expression is down-regulated during myoblast terminal differentiation. Modulation by growth factors and retinoic acid

Syndecan-1 is an integral membrane proteoglycan involved in the interaction of cells with extracellular matrix proteins and growth factors. It is transiently expressed in several condensing mesenchymal tissues after epithelial induction. In this study we evaluated the expression of syndecan-1 during skeletal muscle differentiation. The expression of syndecan-1 as determined by Northern blot analyses and immunofluorescence microscopy is down-regulated during differentiation. The transcriptional activity of a syndecan-1 promoter construct is also down-regulated in differentiating muscle cells. The decrease in syndecan-1 gene expression is not dependent on the presence of E-boxes, binding sites for the MyoD family of transcription factors in the promoter region, or myogenin expression. Deletion of the region containing the E-boxes or treatment of differentiating cells with sodium butyrate, an inhibitor of myogenin expression, had no effect on syndecan-1 expression. Basic fibroblast growth factor and transforming growth factor type beta, which are inhibitors of myogenesis, had little effect on syndecan-1 expression. When added together, however, they induced syndecan-1 expression. Retinoic acid, an inducer of myogenesis, inhibited syndecan-1 expression and abolished the effect of the growth factors. These results indicate that syndecan-1 expression is down-regulated during myogenesis and that growth factors and retinoic acid modulate syndecan-1 expression by a mechanism that is independent of myogenin.

Selective regulation of cardiomyocyte gene expression and cardiac morphogenesis by retinoic acid

Early heart development is known to be sensitive to retinoid concentrations; a specific pattern of malformations is observed in both vitamin A-deficiency and retinoid-toxicity states. While the influence of retinoids on early cardiac morphogenesis has been described previously, the effect of retinoids upon cardiomyocyte differentiation and gene expression is largely uncharacterized. We have established an in ovo chick embryo model in which slow-release retinoic acid (RA) induces four distinct cardiac malformations in a dose-dependent fashion. Late primitive streak-stage chick embryos were treated with all-trans-retinoic acid released from anion exchange beads placed on the embryo's left side and then allowed to develop further for 20-24 hr. At low doses (10 and 25 micrograms/ml RA) an abnormal loop structure was observed. At higher doses (50 and 100 micrograms/ml RA) cardia bifida and clustered heart tissue were noted. Situs inversus only occurred after treatment with 100 micrograms/ml RA. RA-treated embryos were subsequently analyzed for appropriate cardiac myocyte differentiation using antibody staining and ELISA analysis to detect sarcomeric myosin heavy chain, tropomyosin, titin, and alpha-actinin protein expression. Alpha-actinin expression was significantly decreased in RA-treated embryos, as compared to DMSO-treated controls. Also, heart contraction rate was depressed after RA exposure. RA exposure did not alter the protein expression levels of sarcomeric myosin heavy chain or tropomyosin. The observed alterations are consistent with suggestions that retinoids may affect both morphogenesis and myofibril formation in the developing heart.

Regulation of a muscle-specific transgene by retinoic acid

Retinoic acid (RA) has been shown to have variable effects on myogenic differentiation in cell culture. The application of RA on primary cultures of embryonic somites, limb buds, and neonatal limbs inhibited myogenic differentiation in a dose-dependent way as indicated by the repression of: (a) myotube formation, (b) myosin heavy chain protein accumulation, (c) myosin light chain (MLC) 1/3, alpha sk-actin and myogenic factor transcript expression. Expression of retinoic acid receptors (RAR) was also affected by RA treatment, specifically RAR gamma transcripts were induced. To further understand the pleiotropic action of RA on myogenesis, we took advantage of two muscle-specific transgene markers which consisted of CAT reporter genes driven by regulatory elements either from the myosin light chain 1/3 locus (MLC-CAT) or the alpha-skeletal actin gene (alpha sk actin-CAT). RA inhibited MLC-CAT transgene but not alpha sk actin-CAT transgene expression in primary cultures from these mice. Analysis of MLC-CAT expression in transgenic mouse primary cultures and in stably transfected C2C12 cells demonstrated that repression of MLC-CAT activity by RA was dependent upon diffusible factors in chick embryo extract. We hypothesize that during development, the pleiotropic effects of RA on myogenesis do not depend solely on the distribution and concentration of RA itself, but are also influenced by extracellular signals in the embryonic environment.

Retinoic acid stimulates glucose transporter expression in L6 muscle cells

Factors that regulate the tissue specific and developmental expression of the GLUT4 gene, whose transcribed protein is primarily responsible for mediating insulin stimulated glucose transport, are poorly defined. In this study we examined the effects of retinoic acid, a circulating factor that can promote cellular differentiation, on glucose uptake and glucose transporter expression in cultured L6 muscle cells. At the myoblast stage, treatment with 1 microM retinoic acid for 24 h increased both 1 h and 8 h insulin stimulated uptake of 2-deoxyglucose by more than twofold. A dose and time dependent effect of retinoic acid on 8 h insulin stimulated 2-deoxyglucose uptake was observed at both the myoblast and myocyte stage. Comparatively little effect from retinoic acid treatment was found on basal uptake at either stage. In myoblast cells, retinoic acid increased the content of GLUT4 mRNA in a dose and time dependent manner, an effect that was partially attenuated by insulin. In myocytes retinoic acid increased GLUT4 mRNA levels to 2.3 times basal. Nuclear run-on studies indicate that the increased GLUT4 mRNA represents enhanced transcriptional activity. The results suggest a role for retinoic acid in regulation of expression of the GLUT 4 gene in muscle cells.

Serum-induced inhibition of myogenesis is differentially relieved by retinoic acid and triiodothyronine in C2 murine muscle cells

We recently reported that triiodothyronine (T3) enhances MyoD gene expression and accelerates terminal differentiation in murine C2 myoblasts. In this paper, we are interested in the effects of other hormones acting through related nuclear receptors. Retinoic acid (RA), but not estradiol or dexamethasone, is also able to enhance MyoD gene expression (about threefold). However, the effects of RA and T3 on myogenesis are quite distinct, with a much more potent RA action. Indeed, although T3 and RA positively regulate myogenesis with similar efficiency in poorly mitogenic conditions, in presence of high serum concentrations T3 can no longer trigger terminal differentiation whereas RA still remains efficient. Thus, serum concentration is a crucial parameter in discriminating between the effects of T3 and RA on myogenesis. The differential effects between these two hormone are likely to be related to the ability of RA-activated endogenous retinoic acid receptors (RARs) to induce C2 myoblasts growth-arrest and to extinguish AP1 activity (thought to act as an inhibitor of myogenesis) whereas T3-activated endogenous thyroid hormones receptors (THRs) are relatively inefficient. We propose that the much higher level of RARs in C2 cells versus THRs could to some extent account for the differential ability of T3 and RA to antagonize serum-regulated mitogenic pathways in myogenic cells. This study provides clear evidence for an important role of RA on MyoD gene expression and myogenesis and suggests that T3 and RA could play overlapping, but distinct, roles on muscle development.