Clinical experience with recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and urinary FSH: a retrospective case- controlled analysis

Impact of highly purified versus recombinant follicle stimulating hormone on oocyte quality and embryo development in intracytoplasmic sperm injection cycles

The quality of oocytes and developing embryos are the most relevant factors determining the success of an in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment. However, there are very few studies analyzing the effects of different gonadotrophin preparations on oocyte and embryo quality. A retrospective secondary analysis of data collected from a prospective randomized study was performed to compare highly purified versus recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (HP-FSH vs. rFSH). The main outcome measures were quantity and quality of oocytes and embryos, dynamics of embryo development, cryopreservation, clinical pregnancy and live birth rate. The number of retrieved and of mature (MII) oocytes showed no significant differences. Fertilization rate was significantly higher in the HP-FSH group (68.9% vs. 59.9%, p = 0.01). We also found significantly higher rate of cryopreserved embryos per all retrieved oocytes (23.4% vs. 14.5%, p = 0.002) in the HP-FSH group. There were no significant differences in clinical pregnancy and in live birth rates. Oocytes obtained with HP-FSH stimulation showed higher fertilisability, whereas pregnancy and live birth rates did not differ between the groups. However, patients treated with HP-FSH may benefit from the higher rate of embryos capable for cryopreservation, suggesting that cumulative pregnancy rates might be higher in this group.

A 30-day preclinical safety evaluation study of recombinant human follicle-stimulating hormone in female rhesus monkeys

The objective of this study was to identify potential target organs for toxicity of recombinant human follicle stimulating hormone (r-hFSH) in female rhesus monkeys and to establish a no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL). In all, 24 female rhesus monkeys (Chinese origin, weighing 3.4-5.2 kg, approximately 5 years of age) received repeated subcutaneous (sc) r-hFSH at doses of 10, 60, and 300 IU/kg per d or vehicle once daily for 30 days followed by a 15-day recovery period. Endometrial hyperplasia and dermal edema in the external genitals were found in some animals at 300 IU/kg per d. Pharmacologic-related multiple cystic follicles were found in all r-hFSH-treated groups. A weak, anti-FSH antibody response was detected at the end of treatment in animals administered 60 and 300 IU/kg per d. These results indicate that the primary effects of r-hFSH in female rhesus monkeys were related to its pharmacological activity on the reproductive system. The NOAEL was considered to be 60 IU/kg per d.

Recombinant versus highly-purified, urinary follicle-stimulating hormone (r-FSH vs. HP-uFSH) in ovulation induction: a prospective, randomized study with cost-minimization analysis

BACKGROUND

Both recombinant FSH (r-FSH) and highly-purified, urinary FSH (HP-uFSH) are frequently used in ovulation induction associated with timed sexual intercourse. Their effectiveness is reported to be similar, and therefore the costs of treatment represent a major issue to be considered. Although several studies about costs in IVF have been published, data obtained in low-technology infertility treatments are still scarce.

METHODS

Two hundred and sixty infertile women (184 with unexplained infertility, 76 with CC-resistant polycystic ovary syndrome) at their first treatment cycle were randomized and included in the study. Ovulation induction was accomplished by daily administration of rFSH or HP-uFSH according to a low-dose, step-up regimen aimed to obtain a monofollicular ovulation. A bi- or tri-follicular ovulation was anyway accepted, whereas hCG was withdrawn and the cycle cancelled when more than three follicles greater than or equal to 18 mm diameter were seen at ultrasound. The primary outcome measure was the cost of therapy per delivered baby, estimated according to a cost-minimization analysis. Secondary outcomes were the following: monofollicular ovulation rate, total FSH dose, cycle cancellation rate, length of the follicular phase, number of developing follicles (>12 mm diameter), endometrial thickness at hCG, incidence of twinning and ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, delivery rate.

RESULTS

The overall FSH dose needed to achieve ovulation was significantly lower with r-FSH, whereas all the other studied variables did not significantly differ with either treatments. However, a trend toward a higher delivery rate with r-FSH was observed in the whole group and also when results were considered subgrouping patients according to the indication to treatment.

CONCLUSION

Considering the significantly lower number of vials/patient and the slight (although non-significant) increase in the delivery rate with r-FSH, the cost-minimization analysis showed a 9.4% reduction in the overall therapy cost per born baby in favor of r-FSH.

Urinary follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) is more effective than recombinant FSH in older women in a controlled randomized study

OBJECTIVE

The following study was conducted to determine which FSH, recombinant or urinary, works better in older women.

DESIGN

We conducted a controlled randomized study in a single university IVF center.

SETTING

University IVF center.

PATIENT(S)

Women (N = 257) over 39 years old undergoing IVF.

INTERVENTION(S)

The patients were randomized into two study groups at their first IVF cycle: 121 patients were treated with recombinant FSH, and 120 patients were treated with urinary FSH. Both groups were suppressed with a long GnRH analog protocol.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Days of stimulation, E2 at the day of hCG, total amount of FSH administered, number of oocytes collected, amount of FSH per oocyte, and number of embryos obtained.

RESULT(S)

Patients treated with urinary FSH required a significantly lower total amount of FSH, and a lower amount of FSH per oocyte than women treated with recombinant FSH. The other measures evaluated did not show any statistically significant differences.

CONCLUSION(S)

Our study showed that urinary FSH performed better in older women than recombinant FSH when associated with the long protocol.

Bioequivalence of liquid and freeze-dried recombinant human follicle-stimulating hormone

OBJECTIVE

The bioequivalence and tolerability of freeze-dried and liquid formulations of recombinant human follicle-stimulating hormone (r-hFSH) filled-by-mass were assessed in a crossover, open-label, randomised, single-centre, phase I bioequivalence study.

METHODS

Following pituitary down-regulation with the gonadotrophin-releasing hormone agonist goserelin, healthy adult volunteers (18years-45years of age) received single subcutaneous injections of r-hFSH , 300 IU, from freeze-dried and liquid formulations in random order, separated by a 7-day washout period. Blood was obtained over 144 h for pharmacokinetic analysis.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

These were peak serum FSH concentrations (Cmax,), time to peak concentration (Tmax) and area under the concentration-time curve from zero to the last measurable concentration (AUCJ), local and systemic tolerability.

RESULTS

Of 44 volunteers who underwent down-regulation, 39 (18 men, 21 women) completed the study. Cmax and AUClast were similar with the freeze-dried (mean 9.51 IU/L and 844 IU.h/L, respectively) and liquid (mean 8.99 IU/L and 841 IUh/L, respectively) formulations, whereas T was significantly higher with the liquid formulation (median 12h vs 15h, p = 0.0183). The 90% confidence intervals for the ratio of the treatment means for Cnw and AUC,=, were within the pre-defined bioequivalence range of 0.8-1.25.

CONCLUSION

Both formulations were well tolerated with regard to both systemic and local adverse events. The freeze-dried and liquid formulations of r-hFSH are bioequivalent and show no significant differences in tolerability. Thus, the liquid formulation is expected to provide comparable efficacy and tolerability to the freeze-dried formulation in clinical use.

Highly purified human-derived follicle-stimulating hormone (Bravelle) has equivalent efficacy to follitropin-beta (Follistim) in infertile women undergoing in vitro fertilization

BACKGROUND

These data compare the efficacy and safety of highly purified human-derived follicle-stimulating hormone (Bravelle) and recombinant follitropin-beta (Follistim) in women undergoing in vitro fertilization.

METHODS

This report describes the pooled data from two, nearly identical, randomized, controlled, parallel-group, multicenter studies conducted in a total of 19 academic and private IVF-ET centers in the United States. Infertile premenopausal women underwent pituitary down-regulation using leuprolide acetate followed by a maximum of 12 days of subcutaneous Bravelle (n = 120) or Follistim (n = 118), followed by administration of human chorionic gonadotropin, oocyte retrieval and embryo transfer. The primary efficacy measure was the mean number of oocytes retrieved; secondary efficacy measures included the total dose and duration of gonadotropin treatment; peak serum estradion levels; embryo transfer and implantation rates; chemical, clinical and continuing pregnancies; and live birth rates. All adverse events were recorded and injection site pain was recorded daily using a patient, self-assessment diary.

RESULTS

Similar efficacy responses were observed for all outcome parameters in the two treatment groups. Although patients receiving Bravelle consistently reported a greater number of chemical, clinical and continuing pregnancies, as well as an increased rate of live birth, the data did not attain statistical significance (P > 0.05). The overall incidence of adverse events was similar in both groups, but compared to Follistim, injections of Bravelle were reported by patients to be significantly less painful (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Bravelle and Follistim had comparable efficacy in controlled ovarian hyperstimulation in women undergoing IVF-ET. There were no differences in the nature or number of adverse events between the treatment groups although Bravelle injections were reported to be significantly less painful.

Comparison of the effectiveness of recombinant and urinary FSH preparations in the achievement of follicular selection in chronic anovulation

In order to compare the effectiveness of urinary and recombinant FSH (rFSH) preparations in achieving the threshold of follicular growth, stimulated cycles from patients with chronic anovulation, treated with a constant dose of FSH until the emergence of a selected follicle, were retrospectively analysed. Sixty-four cycles were performed using a similar starting dose of either urinary FSH (group 1) or rFSH (group 2), which was kept constant up to the time of follicular selection, assessed on ultrasound (follicular diameter >10 mm). The results of this study showed that, while the number of selected follicles was similar, the mean daily FSH dose required to achieve the threshold of follicular selection was significantly lower in group 2 (70.4 +/- 3.4 IU/day) than in group 1 (86.5 +/- 4 IU/day; P < 0.005). Furthermore, at the time of human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG) administration, the total FSH dose was significantly lower in group 2 than in group 1, but plasma oestradiol values were equivalent. These data suggest that the higher effectiveness of rFSH preparations over urinary ones may be explained by a lower threshold dose required to achieve follicular selection.

Effect of highly purified urinary follicle-stimulating hormone on oocyte and embryo quality

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effects of ovarian stimulation with highly purified urofollitropin on oocyte and embryo quality.

DESIGN

Parallel randomized open-label clinical study.

SETTING

Assisted reproduction centers.

PATIENT(S)

Two hundred sixty-seven infertile couples undergoing IVF/ICSI.

INTERVENTION(S)

All participants underwent standard down-regulation with GnRH analogue. One hundred thirty-three participants received highly purified urinary FSH and 134 controls received recombinant FSH.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Primary end points were number of morphologically mature oocytes retrieved, embryo quality, and pregnancy and implantation rates. Secondary end points were: total number of days of FSH stimulation, total dose of gonadotropin administered, fertilization rate per number of retrieved oocytes, embryo cleavage rate, live birth and miscarriage rates, endometrial thickness and estradiol level on the day of hCG administration, cancellation rate, and incidence of moderate or severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome.

RESULT(S)

Pregnancy and implantation rates were nonsignificantly higher in the urinary FSH group than the recombinant FSH group (46.5% vs. 36.8% and 22.1% vs. 15.8%, respectively). The grade 1 embryo score was significantly higher in the urinary FSH group than the recombinant FSH (42.1% vs. 33.5%), and the live birth rate was nonsignificantly higher in the former group.

CONCLUSION(S)

Highly purified urinary FSH is as effective, efficient, and safe for clinical use as recombinant FSH.

Recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone versus human menopausal gonadotropin in the late follicular phase during ovarian hyperstimulation for in vitro fertilization

OBJECTIVE

To study the effect of exogenous LH in the late follicular phase on ongoing pregnancies and at the different stages of IVF-ET (stimulation, fertilization, and implantation) in patients with low endogenous LH.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study with modeling of the different phases of IVF-ET.

SETTING

IVF center of the teaching hospital in Bordeaux, France.

PATIENT(S)

Women undergoing IVF and ICSI treatment.

INTERVENTION(S)

One group received recombinant FSH alone (FSH group) and the other received recombinant FSH and hMG in the late follicular phase (i.e., when the largest follicle reached 14 mm) (FSH/hMG group).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Ongoing pregnancy, number of oocytes, and number of embryos.

RESULT(S)

The FSH/hMG group had a higher probability of having at least one oocyte (odds ratio [OR] = 2.75 [1.11-6.80]), of having at least one embryo after oocyte retrieval (OR = 2.84 [1.33-6.07]), and of ongoing pregnancy after ET (OR = 2.04 [0.83-5.01]), and globally had a higher probability of ongoing pregnancy (OR = 2.83 [1.19-6.71]).

CONCLUSION(S)

In ovarian hyperstimulation for IVF-ET, LH supplementation in the late follicular phase of women with low endogenous LH is beneficial for ongoing pregnancy by increasing the rate of success of all stages of the treatment.