Does free to total ratio of prostate-specific antigen alter decision-making on prostatic biopsy?

Use of prostate-specific antigen (PSA) isoforms for the detection of prostate cancer in men with a PSA level of 2-10 ng/ml: systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Measurement of serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) for the detection of prostate cancer has poor specificity in men with PSA levels between 2 and 10 ng/ml. It has been suggested that measurement of the ratio of free to total PSA (f/tPSA) or complexed PSA (cPSA) might offer an improvement. We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate the diagnostic performance of these tests among men with PSA levels between 2 and 10 ng/ml.

METHODS

Data on sensitivity and specificity were extracted from 66 eligible studies. Likelihood ratios and summary receiver operating characteristic curves were estimated and possible sources of heterogeneity between studies examined.

RESULTS

Use of the f/tPSA or the cPSA test improved diagnostic performance among men with a total PSA (tPSA) of 2-4 or 4-10 ng/ml compared to tPSA alone. The diagnostic performance of the f/tPSA test was significantly higher in the tPSA range of 4-10 ng/ml compared to a tPSA range of 2-4 ng/ml (p < 0.01); at a sensitivity of 95%, the specificity was 18% in the 4-10 ng/ml tPSA range and 6% in the 2-4 ng/ml tPSA range. Among studies that measured both isoforms, the diagnostic performance of the f/tPSA test and the cPSA was equivalent in both PSA ranges.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of the f/tPSA or cPSA test among men with PSA levels between 2 and 10 ng/ml can reduce the number of unnecessary biopsies whilst maintaining a high cancer detection rate.

Detection of telomerase activity in prostate massage samples improves differentiating prostate cancer from benign prostatic hyperplasia

PURPOSE

We performed a case-control study in which we tested the ability of a non-invasive assay to detect telomerase activity and to distinguish between prostatic cancer (Pca) and benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) on samples of epithelial cells obtained after prostatic massage.

METHODS

Telomerase activity was determined by a telomeric repeat amplification protocol (TRAP) assay. We selected 60 patients with histologically proven Pca (30 cases) or BPH (30 cases). Specimens included in this study were from patients who had no suspicious findings on digital rectal examination for cancer, had clinical evidence of lower urinary tract symptoms, had no sonographic signs of Pca at the transrectal ultrasound evaluation, had total PSA values moderately elevated (2.6-15 ng/ml), and had no evidence of other urological cancers. The whole procedure was conducted in double blind between pathologists and molecular biology operators.

RESULTS

Telomerase activity was detected in 90% of Pca cases and in 13% of BPH cases. The sensitivity (90%) and specificity (76%) of this method were calculated. The positive predictive value, negative predictive value, and diagnostic efficiency were 87%, 90%, and 88% respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our data indicate that telomerase activity detected by TRAP assay on prostate epithelial cells collected by prostate massage can substantially improve the distinction between Pca and BPH conditions. One of the clinical benefits resulting from the use of this new assay would be to refine the biopsy indication and to avoid for several patients without Pca the unnecessary cost and the complications of prostate biopsy.

The Proportion of Prostate-specific Antigen (PSA) Complexed to α1-Antichymotrypsin Improves the Discrimination between Prostate Cancer and Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia in Men with a Total PSA of 10 to 30 μg/L

Background: The aim of this study was to assess the diagnostic accuracy of the proportion of prostate-specific antigen (PSA) complexed to α1-antichymotrypsin (PSA-α1ACT:PSA ratio) in the differential diagnosis of prostate cancer (CaP) and benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) in men with total PSA of 10–30 μg/L.

Methods: We used our immunoassays (ELISAs) for total PSA and PSA-α1ACT complex to study 146 men. In 123, total PSA was between 10 and 20 μg/L; 66 of these had CaP and 57 BPH. In 23 men, total PSA was between 20 and 30 μg/L; 14 of these had CaP and 9 BPH. We calculated the area under the ROC curves (AUC) for total PSA, PSA-α1ACT complex, and PSA-α1ACT:PSA ratio, and determined the cutoff points that gave sensitivities approaching 100%.

Results: In the total PSA range between 10 and 20 μg/L, the AUC was significantly higher for the PSA-α1ACT:PSA ratio (0.850) than for total PSA (0.507) and PSA-α1ACT complex (0.710; P &lt;0.0001). A cutoff ratio of 0.62 would have permitted diagnosis of all 66 patients with CaP (100% sensitivity) and avoided 19% of unnecessary biopsies (11 of 57 patients). In the total PSA range between 20 and 30 μg/L, the AUC for the PSA-α1ACT:PSA ratio (0.980; 95% confidence interval, 0.82–0.99) was greater than the AUC for total PSA (0.750; 95% confidence interval, 0.51–0.89; P = 0.042). In this range, a cutoff point of 0.64 would have permitted the correct diagnosis of all 14 patients with CaP and 6 of the 9 with BPH.

Conclusions: The diagnostic accuracy of the PSA-α1ACT:PSA ratio persists at high total PSA concentrations, increasing the specificity of total PSA. Prospective studies with large numbers of patients are needed to assess whether the ratio of PSA-α1ACT to total PSA is a useful tool to avoid unnecessary prostatic biopsy in patients with a total PSA &gt;10 μg/L.

Using multiple cutpoints for the free-to-total prostate specific antigen ratio improves the accuracy of prostate cancer detection

BACKGROUND

Using a single cutpoint for the free-to-total (F/T) prostate specific antigen (PSA) ratio loses important diagnostic information. We evaluated the performance of multiple F/T PSA cutpoints in detecting prostate cancer in men with nonspecific PSA values.

METHODS

We extracted sensitivity and specificity data from 12 studies reporting on >or=30 cancer patients with PSA values between 2.0 and 10.0 ng/mL. We calculated stratum-specific likelihood ratios (LR) and areas under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves.

RESULTS

Multiple cutpoints for the F/T PSA ratio significantly increased the area under the ROC (0.70) compared with the single investigator-selected cutpoint (0.62), P < 0.004. The LR for the most positive cutpoint stratum (2.62) was significantly higher than the LR for a positive test from the single cutpoint (1.36), P < 0.004.

CONCLUSIONS

Using multiple cutpoints increased the discriminating power of the F/T PSA ratio and led to greater probability revisions in the most positive test-result strata.

Combined Use of Prostate-Specific Antigen Derivatives Decreases the Number of Unnecessary Biopsies to Detect Prostate Cancer

The authors evaluated the prostate cancer detection rate in Turkish patients with prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels of 4 ng/ml to 10 ng/ml and who had normal digital rectal examination (DRE) findings. They also aimed to evaluate the value of PSA density and percent free PSA in minimizing unnecessary prostate biopsies for these PSA ranges. This prospective study included 134 consecutive men referred for early prostate cancer detection or lower urinary tract symptoms. All men underwent transrectal ultrasound with systematic sextant needle biopsies. The ability of PSA density and percent free PSA to improve the power of PSA in the detection of prostate cancer was evaluated with statistical analyses as well as receiver operating characteristics curves. Among the 134 men, 124 (92.5%) had a benign histology and 10 (7.5%) had cancer diagnosed on the initial biopsies. Despite the disappointing results in regard to the sensitivity and specificity of PSA derivatives alone, the combination of PSA density and percent free PSA significantly increased the area under the curve compared with the use of each test alone. To increase the specificity of PSA in this patient population, the authors recommend combining two PSA derivatives in deciding whether to perform a biopsy. In a PSA range of 4 ng/ml to 10 ng/ml and with normal DRE, a percent free PSA < 21% and a PSA density > 0.18 yields highest specificity with 90% sensitivity.

[PSA:alpha 1-antichymotrypsin ratio/total PSA in the diagnosis of prostatic cancer in the range of total PSA from 4 to 10 ng/ml]

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the usefulness of the ratio PSA:alpha-1-antichymotrypsin/total PSA (C/T) in the diagnosis of prostate cancer in the range of total PSA between 4 and 10 ng/mL.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

By using home-made ELISAs we have determined plasmatic concentrations of total PSA and complex PSA:alpha-1-ACT in 300 patients with total PSA between 4-10 ng/mL. All samples were obtained before any manipulation that could interfere the PSA levels.

RESULTS

By prostatic biopsy 85 patients (28.3%) were diagnosed of prostate cancer (CaP) and 215 (71.6%) of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). The mean values of the complex PSA:alpha-1-ACT (4.2 ng/mL in the BPH patients vs 5.0 ng/mL in the CaP patients) and of the C/T ratio (0.70 vs 0.82, respectively) showed significant differences between both groups (p = < 0.0001). The total PSA did not show differences (6.1 ng/mL vs 6.0 ng/mL; p = 0.79). From all three parameter evaluated, the ratio C/T had the biggest area under the ROC (0.884) and statistically significant differences in comparison with total PSA (0.490; p = < 0.001) and the complex PSA:alpha-1-ACT (0.696: p = < 0.001). Therefore, by using a ratio C/T > 0.62 to decide the performance of a biopsy, 27% of the patients with BPH could have avoided this procedure with a 100% sensitivity. Increasing the ratio to 0.68 the specificity is 47% and the sensitivity is 95.2%. Rectal examination did not have influence on the cut-off, sensitivity, specificity and area under the ROC of the ratio C/T.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results confirm that the ratio C/T improve the diagnostic capacity of the total PSA between 4-10 ng/ml. Moreover, the rectal examination does not influence the selection of ratio C/T cut-off suggestives of CaP neither the diagnostic efficacy.

Using the free-to-total prostate-specific antigen ratio to detect prostate cancer in men with nonspecific elevations of prostate-specific antigen levels

BACKGROUND

Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels between 4.0 to 10.0 ng/ml have poor specificity in prostate cancer screening, leading to unnecessary biopsies.

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether the free-to-total PSA ratio (F/T PSA) improved the diagnostic accuracy of these nonspecific PSA levels.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

MEDLINE searchedwas from 1986 to 1997. Additional studies were identified from article bibliographies and by searching urology journals. Two investigators independently identified English-language studies providing F/T PSA ratio test-operating characteristics data on > or = 10 cancer patients with PSA values between 2.0 and 10.0 ng/ml. Twenty-one of 90 retrieved studies met selection criteria. Two investigators independently extracted data on methodology and diagnostic performance. Investigator-selected cut points for the optimal F/T PSA ratio had a median likelihood ratio of 1.76 (interquartile range, 1.40 to 2.11) for a positive test and 0.27 (0.20 to 0.40) for a negative test. Assuming a 25% pretest probability of cancer, the posttest probabilities were 37% following a positive test and 8% following a negative test. The summary receiver operating characteristic curve showed that maintaining test sensitivity above 90% was associated with false positive rates of 60% to 90%. Methodologic problems limited the validity and generalizability of the literature.

CONCLUSIONS

A negative test reduced the posttest probability of cancer to approximately 10%. However, patients may find that this probability is not low enough to avoid undergoing prostate biopsy. The optimal F/T PSA ratio cut point and precise estimates for test specificity still need to be determined.

Change in the ratio of free-to-total prostate-specific antigen during progression of advanced prostate cancer

BACKGROUND

The ratio of free-to-total prostate-specific antigen (PSA) is different in benign prostatic hyperplasia and in the early stage of prostate cancer. The present study was undertaken to examine the ratio of free-to-total PSA in the advanced stage of this cancer and its subsequent change during course of the disease.

METHODS

Free and total PSA were measured in sera collected from the following patients with benign and cancerous prostatic diseases: 47 cases of benign prostatic hypertrophy, nine in TIC with less than 10 ng/mL of total PSA, 11 in stage C, 16 in D2, 22 in remission under endocrine therapy, and 12 in relapse. In addition, PSA was measured sequentially in four other patients who were also in relapse.

RESULTS

The ratio of free-to-total PSA was similar in early and advanced stages of untreated prostate cancer and was lower than that in benign prostatic hyperplasia. The ratio increased to the level of benign prostatic hyperplasia during remission from stages C and D2 under endocrine therapy. There was no correlation with the intervals from the start of the therapy to examination. Following relapse, the ratio came down gradually to the level obtained in untreated prostate cancer.

CONCLUSION

The ratio of free-to-total PSA was similar in all stages of untreated prostate cancer. Response and relapse to endocrine therapy were associated with increase and decrease in ratio, respectively.

The necessity of a second prostate biopsy cannot be predicted by PSA or PSA derivatives (density or free:total ratio) in men with prior negative prostatic biopsies

Serum prostate specific antigen, prostate specific antigen density and free:total prostate specific antigen are known to be useful for determining the risk of prostate cancer in patients undergoing prostate cancer screening. The patient with a positive biopsy presents no future prostate specific antigen dilemma. Those with negative biopsies often go on to numerous repeat biopsies. Our goal was to establish criteria that could be used to identify patients who will require repeat prostate biopsies (possibly false negative initial biopsy), while not exposing the low risk population (probable true negative initial biopsy) to additional invasive procedures. Between March 1991 and March 1998, 148 patients who had a biopsy for an elevated prostate specific antigen value (4.1-10.0) or an altered digital rectal examination, had no cancer found in the specimen. From these, 51 (34.4%) had repeated biopsies, while the others persisted on close follow-up. We examined their serum prostate specific antigen, prostate specific antigen density and free:total prostate specific antigen value, as well as their age and histology results of the initial and repeat biopsy, to determine if any predictor of the need for a repeat biopsy could be identified. Eight (15.7%) from 51 men who had repeat biopsy had prostate cancer detected. Forty three (84.3%) patients persisted with a negative biopsy, despite filling the criteria for re-biopsy. Multivariate analysis failed to identify any significant predictors of prostate cancer in the repeat biopsy group. Despite initial success, the prostate specific antigen derivatives and free:total prostate specific antigen have not safely limited the number of biopsies performed for an abnormal prostate specific antigen (4.1-10.0). Neither prostate specific antigen density nor free:total prostate specific antigen predicted the need for repeat biopsy in this specific group. The results of this ongoing study demonstrate that to date, prostate specific antigen and prostate specific antigen derivatives can not be utilized to determine which patients will be at high risk for requiring repeat prostate biopsy. All patients must be closely monitored for evidence of a change in status from benign to malignant disease, and new markers for this purpose are urgently needed.

Inadequacy of free prostate-specific antigen parameters in the prediction of pathologic extent of prostate cancer in Japanese men

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate free prostate-specific antigen (PSA) and free to total PSA ratio as predictors of pathologic extent in Japanese patients with prostate cancer.

METHODS

By TOSOH assay, pretreatment serum serologic markers of free PSA, total PSA, free to total PSA ratio, and PSA density (PSAD) were determined for 108 patients subsequent to radical prostatectomy for resectable prostate cancer. Serum values for these markers were compared with pathologic findings and tumor volume on the basis of pathologic assessment of whole mount section histology.

RESULTS

Mean total PSA, free PSA, free to total PSA ratio, and PSAD significantly differed for pathologically confined (pT2 or lower) and advanced (pT3 or higher) cancers (P < 0.05). Total PSA, free PSA, and PSAD provided indication of seminal vesicle involvement, surgical margin status, nodal involvement, and total tumor volume (P < 0.05). Free PSA was more closely correlated with total tumor volume than the free to total PSA ratio; this ratio was not correlated with total tumor volume or specimen Gleason score. Free PSA and free to total PSA ratio were not found to be any more useful than total PSA and PSAD for predicting pT3 disease by receiver operating characteristic curve analysis. Multivariate logistic regression analysis and log likelihood ratio test results indicated little additional value of these parameters for predicting pT3 disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Contrary to previous reports, free PSA and the free to total PSA ratio are of little use subsequent to the diagnosis of prostate cancer.