Detection of breast carcinoma metastases in bone: relative merits of X-rays and skeletal scintigraphy

The Established Nuclear Medicine Modalities for Imaging of Bone Metastases

Background:

The skeleton is one of the frequent site of metastases in advanced cancer. Prostate, breast and renal cancers mostly metastasize to bone.

Discussion:

Malignant tumors lead to significant morbidity and mortality. Identification of bone lesions is a crucial step in diagnosis of disease at early stage, monitoring of disease progression and evaluation of therapy. Diagnosis of cancer metastases is based on uptake of bone-targeted radioactive tracer at different bone remodeling sites.

Conclusion:

This manuscript summarizes already established and evolving nuclear medicine modalities (e.g. bone scan, SPECT, SPECT/CT, PET, PET/CT) for imaging of bone metastases.

Risk of metastasis among rib abnormalities on bone scans in breast cancer patients

Bone scan abnormalities, especially rib lesions, are often confusing for physicians due to a high number of false-positive lesions. This study investigated risk factors that are associated with bone metastasis in 613 breast cancer patients with bone scan abnormalities. Significantly increased rates of bone metastasis were observed in patients with multiple lesions, large tumor sizes, and lymph node involvement. In addition, patients with concurrent lesions of rib and other sites exhibited a significant higher rate of metastatic disease compared to those with other site lesions (P = 0.009). In the subset of 324 patients with rib abnormalities, the rate of metastasis was extremely low in patients with pure rib lesions (1.2%; 95% CI: 0.1%-4.1%). Concurrent lesions of rib and other sites were more likely to be rib metastasis compared to pure rib lesions (P < 0.001). Moreover, multiple rib lesions and lesions located on bilateral ribs were more likely to be rib metastasis (P < 0.001). Our data suggest that patients with pure rib abnormalities could be recommended for follow-up only. However, if concurrent lesions of rib and other sites were detected on bone scans, additional radiological examinations should be performed to patients.

Analysis of clinicopathological factors associated with bone metastasis in breast cancer

Breast cancer is the second leading cause of cancer death in women today. Once breast cancer metastasizes to bone, mortality increases. Thus, there is an urgent need to identify patients with high risk of bone metastasis, and to find predictive factors for the occurrence of bone metastasis at an earlier stage of breast cancer. Three hundred and sixty patients with pathologically proved breast cancer visiting the Department of Nuclear Medicine for whole body bone scan from January 2006 and January 2009 were investigated in this study. Clinicopathological information was obtained, which consisted of age, menopausal status, clinical staging, lymph node stage, histological grade, the expression of estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PR) and epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2). Correlation between bone metastasis and the associated factors was tested by using the Chi-square test. A Cox multivariate analysis was used to assess the factors which independently contributed to survival after bone metastasis in breast cancer patients. Survival curves were drawn for metastasis-free interval and the independent factors which contributed to survival, using the Kaplan-Meier method. Twenty-four patients were excluded from subsequent analysis. Three hundred and thirty-six enrolled patients ranged in age from 22 to 77 years (mean, 47.8 years). ER/PR status [ER(+) vs. ER(-), χ (2)=4.328, P=0.037; ER(+)PR(+) vs. ER(+)PR(-), χ (2)=4.425, P=0.035] and histological grade (χ (2)=7.131, P=0.028) were significantly associated with bone metastasis. ER status (x (2)=8.315, P=0.004) and metastasis-free interval (χ (2)=6.863, P=0.009) were independent prognostic factors for survival in breast cancer patients with bone metastasis. Our study suggested that ER/PR status and histological grade are risk factors for the development of bone metastasis in breast cancer patients. However, ER status and metastasis-free interval are independent prognostic factors for survival in breast cancer patients with bone metastasis. Breast cancer bone metastasis has its unique characteristics, which is helpful to choose the appropriate treatment for breast cancer patients with bone metastasis.

The role of 18F-fluoride PET-CT in the detection of bone metastases in patients with breast, lung and prostate carcinoma: a comparison with FDG PET/CT and 99mTc-MDP bone scan

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to compare the role of (18)F-fluoride PET/CT, FDG PET/CT and (99m)Tc-MDP bone scans in the detection of bone metastases in patients with lung, breast and prostate carcinoma.

METHODS

This was a prospective study including patients for staging (S) and restaging (R). Seventy-two patients (23S, 49R) with infiltrating ductal breast carcinoma, 49 patients (25S, 24R) with prostate adenocarcinoma and 30 patients (17S, 13R) with non-small-cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC), without known bone metastases but with high risk/clinical suspicion for the same, underwent a (99m)Tc-MDP bone scan, FDG PET/CT and (18)F-fluoride PET/CT within 2 weeks. All scans were reviewed by two experienced nuclear medicine physicians, and the findings were correlated with MRI/thin-slice CT/skeletal survey. Histological verification was done wherever feasible.

RESULTS

Sensitivity and negative predictive value (NPV) of (18)F-fluoride PET/CT was 100 % in all three malignancies, while that of FDG PET/CT was 79 % and 73 % in NSCLC, 73 % and 80 % in breast cancer and 72 and 65 % in prostate cancer. Specificity and positive predictive value (PPV) of FDG PET/CT were 100 % in NSCLC and prostate and 97 % and 96 % in breast cancer. As compared to the (99m)Tc-MDP bone scan, all parameters were superior for (18)F-fluoride PET/CT in prostate and breast cancer, but sensitivity and NPV were equal in NSCLC. The MDP bone scan had superior sensitivity and NPV compared to FDG PET/CT but had low specificity and PPV.

CONCLUSION

To rule out bone metastases in cases where there is a high index of suspicion, (18)F-fluoride PET/CT is the most reliable investigation. (18)F-fluoride PET/CT has the potential to replace the (99m)Tc-MDP bone scan for the detection of bone metastases.

Detection of metastatic bone lesions in breast cancer patients: fused (18)F-Fluoride-PET/MDCT has higher accuracy than MDCT. Preliminary experience

PURPOSE

So far, no studies comparing (18)F-Fluoride-PET/CT and MDCT for the detection of bone metastases are available. We compared the accuracy of (18)F-Fluoride-PET/CT (MDCT: 3.75 mm thickness-image-reconstruction), whole-body Multi-Detector-CT (MDCT: 1.25 mm thickness-image-reconstruction) and (18)F-Fluoride-PET/MDCT (MDCT: 1.25 mm thickness-image-reconstruction) in identifying bone metastases in breast cancer patients.

METHODS

We studied 39 breast cancer patients for bone metastases. Imaging was performed on an integrated PET/MDCT-system; CT images were reconstructed at 3.75 mm and 1.25 mm thickness. Two nuclear medicine physicians and one radiologist interpreted blindly (18)F-Fluoride-PET/CT, (18)F-Fluoride-PET/MDCT and MDCT. MDCT at 12 months served as the standard of reference.

RESULTS

Overall, 662 bone lesions were detected in our analysis. Of these, 542 were malignant and 120 were benign according to the standard of reference. (18)F-Fluoride-PET/CT detected 491 bone metastases, 114 (23%) of which displayed no clear morphological changes on MDCT, whereas MDCT detected 416 bone metastases, 39 (9.3%) of which showed no (18)F-Fluoride-PET uptake. Overall sensitivity and specificity were: 91% and 91%, respectively, for (18)F-Fluoride-PET/CT, and 77% and 93% for MDCT. The integrated assessment of (18)F-Fluoride-PET/MDCT yielded sensitivity and specificity values of 98% and 93%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

(18)F-Fluoride-PET/MDCT has higher diagnostic accuracy than (18)F-Fluoride-PET/CT and MDCT for the evaluation of bone metastases in breast cancer.

FDG PET for the Detection of Bone Metastases: Sensitivity, Specificity and Comparison with Other Imaging Modalities

A literature review was performed of studies reporting sensitivity and specificity of [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) PET from January 1, 2000 to January 1, 2010. PET was found to have higher sensitivity for the detection of osseous metastases when compared to CT, skeletal scintigraphy, whole body MRI and combined conventional imaging modalities. A potential exception is when comparing PET with bone scan in the setting of blastic metastases. PET may be a better indicator of active bony metastases. The efficacy of PET can be increased with fused anatomic imaging.

Serum bone turnover markers may be involved in the metastatic potential of lung cancer patients

The aim of this study was to investigate several bone markers in Non-Small Cell Lung (NSCLC) and Small Cell Lung (SCLC) patients experiencing or not secondary bony disease. Fasting serum levels of bone formation, bone resorption, and osteoclastogenesis markers were determined in 22 NSCLC patients with bone metastases, 18 without bone metastasis, and 28 SCLC patients. A total of 29 healthy volunteers were also included in the study. Decreased osteocalcin (OC) serum levels and increased osteopontin and ligand of the receptor of nuclear factor kB (RANKL) serum levels were detected in NCSLC patients with bone metastases while increased C-terminal cross-linking telopeptide of type I collagen and increased RANKL/OPG (osteoprotegerin) ratio were detected in SCLC patients. Increased serum levels of OPG were observed in all lung cancer patients. OPG may be actively involved in the development of lung cancer metastasis. Furthermore, OC, OPN, and RANKL in NSCLC and CTX and RANKL in SCLC patients may also have a broader role in the pathogenesis and spread of lung cancer. They also provide useful information in identifying the group of patients that may benefit from a more rigorous treatment.

Detection of bone metastases in breast cancer by positron emission tomography

Positron emission tomography (PET) is able to demonstrate changes in the metabolism of malignant tumors and metastases before they become visible on anatomical imaging. The skeleton is the most common site of distant metastases of breast cancer. There is convincing evidence that FDG-PET is more sensitive in detecting osteolytic metastases than bone scintigraphy, whereas bone scintigraphy is more sensitive in detecting osteoblastic metastases. Because both types of metastases can occur in breast cancer, bone scintigraphy and FDG-PET should be considered as complementary and can currently be regarded as standard of care for staging in breast cancer patients, whereas the decision to use F-18 fluoride PET should be made individually for each patient, depending on the expected change of therapy management.

Detection of Bone Metastases in Breast Cancer by Positron Emission Tomography

Positron emission tomography (PET) is able to demonstrate changes in the metabolism of malignant tumors and metastases before they become visible on anatomical imaging. The skeleton is the most common site of distant metastases of breast cancer. There is convincing evidence that FDG-PET is more sensitive in detecting osteolytic metastases than bone scintigraphy, whereas bone scintigraphy is more sensitive in detecting osteoblastic metastases. Because both types of metastases can occur in breast cancer, bone scintigraphy and FDG-PET should be considered as complementary and can currently be regarded as standard of care for staging in breast cancer patients, whereas the decision to use F-18 fluoride PET should be made individually for each patient, depending on the expected change of therapy management.

Usefulness of bone metabolic markers in the diagnosis of bone metastasis from lung cancer

Bone metastasis is common in lung cancer patient and the diagnosis of bone metastasis is usually made by using imaging techniques, especially bone scintigraphy. However, the diagnostic yield from bone scintigraphy is limited. The aim of this study is to assess the clinical usefulness of urinary pyridinoline cross-linked N-telopeptides of Type I collagen (NTx), urinary deoxypyridinoline (DPD), and serum alkaline phosphatase (ALP) in the assessment of bone metastasis in patients with lung cancer. Urinary NTx, DPD, and serum ALP were measured in 151 lung cancer patients (33 with and 118 without bone metastasis). Lung cancer patients with bone metastasis had a higher urinary excretion of NTx and DPD, and a higher serum ALP than those without bone metastasis. NTx had a better receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve than DPD and ALP, since the areas under the ROC curve were 0.82, 0.79, and 0.71, respectively. Although correlation coefficients among NTx, DPD and ALP were significantly positive (p < 0.005), the strongest relationship was appeared between NTx and DPD (R = 0.616). In conclusion, our results showed the utility of the new bone markers in detecting bone metastasis and suggested that measurement of urinary NTx was valid diagnostic method of bone metastasis from lung cancer.

Bone imaging in metastatic breast cancer

Bone is the most common site to which breast cancer metastasizes. Imaging-by skeletal scintigraphy, plain radiography, computed tomography, or magnetic resonance imaging-is an essential part, and positron emission tomography or single-photon emission computed tomography have a potential of evaluating bone metastases, but no consensus exists as to the best modality for diagnosing the lesion and for assessing its response to treatment. Imaging bone metastases is problematic because the lesions can be osteolytic, osteoblastic, or mixed, and imaging modalities are based on either direct anatomic visualization of the bone or tumor or indirect measurements of bone or tumor metabolism. Although bone metastases can be treated, their response to treatment is considered "unmeasurable" according to existing response criteria. Therefore, the process by which oncologists and radiologists diagnose and monitor the response of bone metastases needs revision, and the current inability to assess the response of bone metastases excludes patients with breast cancer and bone disease from participating in clinical trials of new treatments for breast cancer. In this review of the MEDLINE literature, we discuss the pros and cons of each modality for diagnosing bone metastases and for assessing their response to treatment and we present a practical approach for diagnosis and assessment of bone metastasis.

Value of routine 99mTc-MDP bone scintigraphy in the detection of occult skeletal metastases in women with primary breast cancer

Baseline staging bone scans in 208 women with primary breast cancer in University Hospital Kuala Lumpur from January 1993 to December 1995 were reviewed. A positive bone scan was found in 14.7% of women aged below 50 years, and 9.1% of women aged 50 years and above. No patient with T0/T1, 4.7% with T2, 6.6% with T3 and 35.8% with T4 tumours had a positive scan caused by bone metastases. No patient with clinical Stage 0/1, 4% with Stage 2, 9.5% with Stage 3 and 63% with Stage 4 disease had a positive bone scan. Clinical staging alone was inaccurate in 20.2% of patients. Forty per cent of patients with a positive bone scan did not have bone pain. The false positive rate was 0.5% and the false negative rate was 0.96%. We conclude that a routine bone scan is not required in Stage 1 disease or T1 tumours, is indicated in Stage 3 and 4 disease, or T3 and T4 tumours, and should only be performed in selected women with Stage 2 or T2 cancers.

Prognostic significance of the number of bone scan abnormalities at the time of initial bone metastatic recurrence in breast carcinoma

BACKGROUND

To gain insight into the factors that contribute to the more favorable prognosis associated with recurrence limited to bone in patients with breast carcinoma, the authors analyzed the number of sites of initial involvement identified on radionuclide bone scans in relation to long term outcome.

METHODS

Records of 641 patients with clinical Stage I-III breast carcinoma that originally was diagnosed in 1974-1985 were reviewed. During follow-up, 295 patients (46%) experienced distant recurrence, including 116 with bone as the sole initial site of metastatic disease. Radionuclide bone scans identified the initial site(s) of recurrence in 113 of these latter 116 patients, and these studies were categorized by the number of skeletal lesions subsequently confirmed as metastases (1, 2, or > or = 3). Survival from time of recurrence and time of original diagnosis was analyzed using Kaplan-Meier methods, and factors associated with recurrence and mortality were examined using logistic and Cox regression.

RESULTS

Median survival from time of recurrence was 35 months in the patients with bone-only metastases, compared with 11-26 months for all other sites of visceral recurrence exclusive of bone. Number of positive lymph nodes and estrogen receptor status were the only predictive variables for recurrence. Median survival from time of recurrence and time of original diagnosis for the 3 bone scan categories was: 1 lesion (n = 47), 53 and 86 months; 2 lesions (n = 22), 38 and 68 months; and > or = 3 lesions (n = 44), 22 and 58 months (P < 0.0001 and P < 0.005 for 1 and 2 lesions vs. > or = 3). In the "bone-only" group, the number of scan lesions was the strongest predictor of length of survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with breast carcinoma who experience a recurrence in bone at only one or two sites initially have a survival advantage over those with more extensive (> or = 3 sites) skeletal metastases and those with metastatic disease involving other visceral organs.

Impact of abnormal uptakes in bone scan on the prognosis of patients with lung cancer

The detection of bone metastases is important in the management of patients with lung cancer because bone metastasis has a major impact on the prognosis and choice of treatment modality. Bone scan has been widely used for early detection of bone metastases but its low specificity complicates confirmation of bone scan findings. To evaluate the effects of abnormal bone scan findings on the prognosis of patients with lung cancer, we retrospectively analyzed the effect of abnormal uptakes on the prognosis of patients with primary lung cancer. The overall survival of patients with abnormal bone uptake was not significantly different from those without abnormal uptake. However, the patients with more than two abnormal bone uptakes had significantly shorter survival than those with no abnormal uptake (P<0.05). To confirm the effect of abnormal bone uptakes on survival, we compared the survival curves of three patient groups without knowledge of bone scan findings: group A, stage I-IIIB with more than two abnormal bone uptakes (potential stage IV); group B, stage IIIB with no abnormal bone uptake (true stage IIIB); and group C, stage IV with no abnormal bone uptake. Group A revealed shorter survival than group B (P<0.05). But, there was no significant difference in survival times between group A and group C. In the Cox regression analysis, the presence of more than two abnormal bone uptakes was a significant prognostic factor (P=0.0277), together with performance status, stage, and albumin. These results suggest that one or two abnormal bone uptake at diagnosis did not affect overall survival of the patients, and that the patients with more than two abnormal bone uptakes are considered as clinical stage IV because of high probability of bone metastases.

Bone metastasis after a resection of stage I and II primary lung cancer

In the present study, we reviewed the patients who developed bone metastases after a surgical resection of primary lung cancer and evaluated their clinicopathological features. From 1992 to 1995, 177 patients with stage I and II primary lung cancer underwent a surgical resection at the Kitakyushu Municipal Medical Center. Bone metastases were detected in 14 patients (7.9%) by follow-up examinations including bone scintigraphy (scan). Bone metastasis was one of the most frequent extra-thoracic recurrent forms. Patients with adenocarcinoma tended to develop bone metastases more frequently than those with squamous cell carcinoma. In the preoperative bone scans, an abnormal uptake was observed in 76 patients (42.9%), and 10 (13.1%) of them were found to develop bone metastases in the follow-up studies. A microscopic examination of the primary tumor demonstrated close correlation between intratumoral and peritumoral lymphatic vessel invasion and postoperative development of bone metastases. A bone scan is a very useful and indispensable procedure for diagnosing bone metastases. However, this scan may also show false positive finding in a number of benign conditions. Therefore, a surgical resection should be considered as the first-line treatment for patients with positive findings in the bone scan when the diagnosis of bone metastasis can not be confirmed based on both their symptoms and other clinical examinations.

Evaluation of metastatic bone disease with pentavalent 99Tc(m)-dimercaptosuccinic acid: a comparison with whole-body scanning and 4/24 hour quantitation of vertebral lesions

The aim of this study was to establish the value of 99Tcm(V)-DMSA scintigraphy in the detection of metastatic bone lesions and compare the results to 99Tcm-MDP bone scintigraphy. Thirty-four patients presenting with metastatic bone disease (Group 1) and 12 controls with degenerative skeletal lesions (Group 2) were studied. Conventional bone scanning and 99Tcm(V)-DMSA whole-body scanning were performed on all patients. All scans were interpreted visually. Furthermore, lesion-to-normal bone ratios (L/N) in vertebral metastases on the 4 and 24 h bone scans were obtained in 58 lesions of cancer patients and in 23 benign (degenerative) vertebral lesions of the control group. 99Tcm-MDP L/N ratios at 24 h (3.08 +/- 0.32) were significantly higher than those at 4 h (2.48 +/- 0.24) in the malignant foci (P < 0.001). No significant difference was observed in benign lesions (P > 0.05). In 167 (164 metastatic, 3 traumatic) of 186 99Tcm-MDP positive lesions (90%) of Group 1, 99Tcm(V)-DMSA uptake was observed. The remaining 19 lesions (10%) were 99Tcm(V)-DMSA negative. Fourteen of these 19 sites were diagnosed as benign. The remaining five foci were malignant. In four lung cancer metastases showing no 99Tcm-MDP uptake, 99Tcm(V)-DMSA uptake was observed. There was no 99Tcm(V)-DMSA accumulation in any of the 99Tcm-MDP positive degenerative lesions of Group 2. All quantitatively evaluated (n = 42) vertebral metastatic foci and two compression fractures in Group 1 showed 99Tcm(V)-DMSA accumulation and an increased 99Tcm-MDP L/N ratio at 24 h. A total of 36 degenerative lesions (Groups 1 and 2) and one compression fracture (Group 1) showed neither 99Tcm(V)-DMSA uptake nor an increased 99Tcm-MDP L/N ratio at 24 h. Our results indicate that quantitative 4/24 h analysis of vertebral lesions on 99Tcm-MDP scans has a similar diagnostic value to 99Tcm(V)-DMSA imaging in the detection of bone metastases. However, the accumulation of 99Tcm(V)-DMSA in four lung cancer metastases showing no 99Tcm-MDP uptake is encouraging and justifies further research in patients with proven bone metastases and negative bone scans.

Early detection and accurate description of extent of metastatic bone disease in breast cancer with fluoride ion and positron emission tomography

PURPOSE

Previous studies have shown that bone metastases are revealed by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or bone marrow scintigraphy several months before they are visible by conventional bone scintigraphy (BS). We present a new approach for detecting bone metastases in patients with breast cancer. We compared findings obtained with fluoride ion (F-18) and positron emission tomography (PET) with those obtained with conventional BS.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirty-four breast cancer patients were prospectively examined using F-18-PET and conventional BS. F-18-PET and BS were performed within 3 weeks of each other. Metastatic bone disease was previously known to be present in six patients and was suspected (bone pain or increasing levels of tumor markers, Ca(2+), alkaline phosphatase) in 28 patients. Both imaging modalities were compared by patient-by-patient analysis and lesion-by-lesion analysis, using a five-point scale for receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. A panel of reference methods was used, including MRI (28 patients), planar x-ray (17 patients), and spiral computed tomography (four patients).

RESULTS

With F-18-PET, 64 bone metastases were detected in 17 patients. Only 29 metastases were detected in 11 patients with BS. As a result of F-18-PET imaging, clinical management was changed in four patients (11.7%). For F-18-PET, the area under the ROC curve was 0.99 on a lesion basis (for BS, it was 0.74; P <.05) and 1.00 on a patient basis (for BS, it was 0.82; P <.05).

CONCLUSION

F-18-PET demonstrates a very early bone reaction when small bone marrow metastases are present, allowing accurate detection of breast cancer bone metastases. This accurate detection has a significant effect on clinical management, compared with the effect on management brought about by detection with conventional BS.

The Relationship between Urinary Pyridinoline, Deoxypyridinoline and Bone Metastasis in a Rat Breast Cancer Model

BACKGROUND: Bone metastasis from breast cancer is often recognized clinically, but there are nonetheless several difficulties in diagnosis. In this study we used an animal model of bone metastasis from breast cancer and clarified the relationship between the urinary Pyd/Cr and Dpd/Cr and the progression of bone metastasis, compared with other bone related markers: serum alkaline phosphatase bone isozyme (ALP-BI), osteocalcin, and calcium. METHODS: The evaluation of bone metastasis was assessed by histological examination of the thoracic and lumbar vertebrae. According to the histological findings 4 weeks after the tumor cell injection, 11 animals were retrospectively divided into 2 subgroups: (1) tumor-bearing rats with bone destruction due to bone metastasis (TBR-BD(+), n = 5), (2) tumor-bearing rats without bone destruction (TBR-BD(-), n =6). These animals were compared to age-matched controls without tumor cell injection (n =6). An additional 5 animals were sacrificed at 2 weeks after the tumor cell injection to evaluate micrometastasis to bone. RESULTS: The values of other markers for bone metastasis in animals with micrometastatic foci in bone marrow did not differ significantly from those of the controls. Pyd/Cr and Dpd/Cr in the TBR-BD(+) group were significantly higher than those of the TBR-BD(-) and the control group (233 +/- 78.3 vs 93.8 +/- 6.5, 98.5 +/- 18.7, 123.1 +/- 35.9 vs 67.9 +/- 6.2, 60.6 +/- 9.8, p< 0.01), while there were no significant differences between TBR-BD(-) and the control. CONCLUSION: Both Pyd/Cr and Dpd/Cr are correlated significantly with the volume of bone metastasis, and are useful for the diagnosis and evaluation of progression of bone metastasis compared with other markers.

Skeletal metastases from breast cancer: imaging with nuclear medicine

Breast cancer is a disease that commonly metastasizes to bone, increasing morbidity, mortality, and health service costs. The 99m technetium (99mTc) diphosphonate bone scan historically has played a significant part in the evaluation of skeletal disease and continues to be one of the most clinically utilized investigations in the staging and follow up of breast cancer patients. More tumor-specific radiopharmaceuticals are now being evaluated and, in particular, 18-fluoro-2-deoxyglucose positron emission tomography (18FDG PET) may have a greater role in this disease in the future.

Differentiation of malignant and degenerative benign bone disease using Tc-99m MDP and Tc-99m citrate scintigraphy

The authors present a prospective analysis of Tc-99m MDP and Tc-99m citrate scintigraphy in 108 patients with known malignant or degenerative benign bone disease. Of 108 patients, 59 (group A) had malignant bone disease. The other 49 patients (group B) had degenerative benign bone disease for which the results of Tc-99m MDP scans were positive. In both groups the Tc-99m citrate scan was performed 1 week after the Tc-99m MDP scan. The Tc-99m citrate/Tc-99m MDP lesion-to-background radioisotope uptake ratio (RUR) was calculated for each lesion 3 hours after radionuclide administration. The mean RUR for the malignant lesions was 1.0 +/- 0.484; for the benign lesions, the RUR was 0.29 +/- 0.250. Static imaging was also done for 10 lesions each from the malignant and benign groups at 1, 3, and 24 hours to study the kinetics of Tc-99m citrate. Time-activity curves for malignant lesions showed that the RUR remained high for 24 hours, whereas benign lesions showed a drastic decrease at 3 and 24 hours compared with the 1-hour images. The ratio of Tc-99m citrate to Tc-99m MDP is a promising parameter to differentiate malignant from benign degenerative lesions seen as areas of increased activity on Tc-99m MDP bone scans. The sensitivity and specificity of this technique were 97.8% and 95%, respectively.

Clinical surveillance for early stage breast cancer: an analysis of claims data

This study estimates the costs of clinical follow-up for women with early stage breast cancer and evaluates the effects of patient and provider characteristics on follow-up intensity. Claims data were cumulated from 1/1/89 through 4/30/93 for a comprehensive set of follow-up tests (office visits, radiologic, and laboratory) ordered for 222 women diagnosed at a university hospital between 1/1/89 and 12/31/91. Aggregated measures of the volume and costs of follow-up over 6 month intervals were expressed in terms of Medicare's 1993 relative value units (RVUs) and their 1993 cost equivalents. Excluding the first 6 months, women received on average, 11.7 RVUs of follow-up in the first year (equivalent to a cost of $362), and 9.5 RVUs in the second year ($297). In the first year, chest x-rays, clinical chemistry tests, automated hemograms, and bone scans, accounted for 36% of the cost of follow-up, while computerized tomographic scans and magnetic resonance imaging studies accounted for 30%. Multiple regression analysis of the first year data showed that women who received radiation and/or were followed by oncology, were more likely to receive intensive follow-up. Age, race, socioeconomic status, insurance, stage, and treatment did not impact follow-up. Costs of follow-up for breast cancer are substantial, though much lower than suggested by others. Additionally, wide variations in practice are largely unexplained by patient and/or provider characteristics. In light of recent evidence questioning the benefit of intensive surveillance, this study supports the need for an accepted set of follow-up guidelines for breast cancer.

An analysis of the cost of clinical surveillance after primary therapy for women with early stage invasive breast cancer

Routine surveillance for distant metastases in women with early stage breast cancer has limited clinical utility and can result in large medical care costs. In order to estimate breast cancer surveillance costs, we used the results of a survey administered to a random sample of physician members of the American Society of Clinical Oncology. The survey measured the frequency in which radiographic and laboratory tests are ordered for postmenopausal women with stage I or II breast cancer after the completion of surgery and radiation or adjuvant chemotherapy if indicated. There were 209 completed surveys representing a response rate of 48%. The volume of tests ordered was expressed in terms of Medicare's relative value units (RVUs) and 1993 cost equivalents. The mean total RVUs over 5 years post-diagnosis was 43.8 (interquartile range 30.1-54.2) which represents a cost of $1369 using the 1993 Medicare conversion factor of $31.249. A cumulative logistic regression model categorized RVUs according to intensity of care (minimal, average, and intensive). While medical oncologists compared to surgeons and radiation oncologists, and physicians practicing in the Northeast and Midwest, compared to those practicing in the South and West, were more likely to adopt an intensive practice style, these differences were not statistically significant (p = 0.1). None of the other provider characteristics evaluated, including gender, prior experience, and practice type, had a significant effect on physician practice in a multivariate model. The data showed a wide variation among providers in surveillance practice patterns that was largely unexplained by physician demographics. These results are consistent with the physician practice style hypothesis which suggests that wide variations in treatment patterns result from uncertainty regarding effectiveness of care.

Bone metabolic markers in bone metastases

The efficacy and cost/performance benefit of radionuclide bone scintigraphy in monitoring metastatic bone activity remain controversial. Recently developed bone metabolic markers are expected to play an additional role in the diagnosis of bone metastasis. We measured osteoclastic and osteoblastic markers in 267 patients with breast cancer (100 with bone metastasis), 38 patients with prostatic cancer (25 with bone metastasis), 50 patients with lung cancer (12 with bone metastasis) and 33 patients with miscellaneous cancers (13 with bone metastasis) and compared the values in the presence and absence of bone metastasis. Bone metabolic markers, both osteoclastic and osteoblastic, increased significantly in patients with bone metastasis. In breast cancer (bone metastasis is mostly of the mixed type), osteoclastic markers were good in detecting bone metastasis. In prostatic cancer (bone metastasis is mostly osteoblastic), osteoclastic and osteoblastic markers were equally effective in detecting bone metastasis. In lung cancer (bone metastasis is mostly osteolytic), osteoclastic markers were elevated preferentially in bone metastasis. Over all, osteoclastic markers were more sensitive in the diagnosis of bone metastasis, and among osteoclastic markers, serum pyridionoline-cross-linked carboxyterminal telopeptide was the most efficient in both specificity (91.0%) and sensitivity (48.6%) for detecting bone metastasis.

Differentiation of malignant and degenerative bone lesions using dexamethasone interventional 3- and 24-hour bone scintigraphy

Seventy-seven adult patients with suspected skeletal metastases were divided into two groups. In group A (n = 30), following intravenous administration of 20 mCi (740 MBq) of technetium-99m methylene diphosphonate (99mTc-MDP), 3- and 24-h scintigraphy of bone lesions was performed. The 24/3 h lesion to bone background radiouptake ratio (RUR) was calculated for each lesion. In group B (n = 47), the same procedure was followed with dexamethasone intervention (10 mg in 24 h) following the 3-h acquisition. In group A, after determination of the critical point, malignant and degenerative bone lesions could be separated with a sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of 0.76, 0.72 and 0.73, respectively. The mean RUR of the malignant lesions was 1.20 +/- 0.23, and that of the benign lesions, 0.95 +/- 0.15. In group B cases, significantly increased sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of 0.87, 0.94 and 0.92, respectively, were found (P < 0.001). The mean RUR of the malignant lesions was 1.48 +/- 0.34, and that of degenerative lesions, 0.88 +/- 0.19. Dexamethasone interventional bone scintigraphy seems to be a new cost-effective method for differentiating malignant from degenerative bone lesions using the RUR.

MCA Serum Determination in Breast Carcinoma Patients for the Diagnosis of Bone Metastases

Serum MCA levels were determined in 173 consecutive patients with breast cancer in order to assess the clinical utility of MCA for the detection of bone metastases. Bone pathology was diagnosed by scintigraphy, radiology and clinical follow-up. Metastases were found in 37 patients, benign lesions in 25, and in 111 no bone lesions were found. Eighteen of the 173 bone scans were considered indeterminate for metastases. Based on the receiver-operating characteristic curves (ROC) analysis, the cut-off level for MCA was set at 20 U/ml. Only in 4 of the 37 patients with bone metastases MCA was below 20 U/ml. All 4patients had completed their chemotherapy course within six months before MCA determination. Only in 6 patients of the 136 without bone metastases MCA levels were above 20 U/ml. Of the 18 patients with indeterminate bone scans, 15 had benign lesions and all of them had MCA levels below 20 U/ml.

MCA determination is a sensitive method for the detection of bone metastases in breast carcinoma. We encourage the use of this procedure for the selection of high-risk groups or as a complementary method for the interpretation of bone scintigraphy.

An evaluation of clinical follow-up in women with early stage breast cancer among physician members of the American Society of Clinical Oncology

Routine clinical follow-up for distant metastatic disease among women with early stage breast cancer is of uncertain clinical benefit. In order to evaluate current practice patterns, we administered a mailed survey to a stratified random sample of physician members of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) (N = 435). The survey assessed the frequency and motivation for ordering follow-up medical tests in asymptomatic postmenopausal women with stage I or II breast cancer. The response rate was 55%, distributed as 39% radiation oncologists, 32% medical oncologists, and 29% surgeons. In the first year after treatment, physicians performed, on average, one physical examination every 3 months, one blood panel (CBC, alkaline phosphatase and liver function tests) every 4 months, and one chest radiograph every 9 months. In addition, 38% of the respondents ordered CEA and 21% ordered CA 15-3 levels, 28% ordered bone scans, and less than 4% ordered CT scans, bone surveys, or bone marrow biopsies in the first year after treatment. A logistic regression analysis controlling for physician age, gender, sub-specialty, practice type, years of experience, number of breast cancer patients treated annually, geographic region, and community size, showed that surgeons were less likely to order blood tests (p < 0.001) and tumor markers (p < 0.0029) than medical oncologists in years 3 and 5 of follow-up. Compared to physicians practicing in the northeast, those from the midwest were less likely to order chest radiographs in year 3 of follow-up (p = 0.0028). Other provider characteristics had no significant effect on test ordering behavior. The results of this survey suggest that relatively uniform practice patterns in regard to the follow-up of postmenopausal women with early stage breast cancer exist among ASCO physicians.

Breast cancer surveillance--a cost-effective strategy

The effectiveness of a surveillance program for breast cancer recurrence in extending survival is predicated on two assumptions: 1) most recurrences are detected at an early stage at surveillance visits; and 2) the early treatment of recurrence offers a better chance of cure or longer survival. However, the data suggest that neither of these two assumptions is correct, and that postoperative follow-up of patients with breast cancer is expensive and does not significantly extend survival.

A simplified technique to resect abnormal bony radiolocalizations using a gamma counter

A simplified technique for localizing and verifying the correct biopsy site of lesions identified on a bone scan has been utilized. A hand-held gamma counter was used for localization of incision placement, determination of extent of bone to be resected, and verification that appropriate tissue was resected. This technique was used to guide biopsy of bony lesions in five patients and to guide resection of a pubic ramus chondrosarcoma. We conclude that intraoperative use of a gamma counter to guide biopsy of bony lesions minimizes surgery time, increases the confidence of obtaining correct tissue, and makes a frequently frustrating procedure very simple. In addition, the probe may assist with determining adequate margins at definitive resection of tumours which accumulate technetium-99m MDP.

A rational postoperative follow-up with carcinoembryonic antigen, tissue polypeptide antigen, and urinary hydroxyproline in breast cancer patients

Breast cancer patients (n = 224) aged 28 to 81 were postoperatively followed up with serial determinations of carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), tissue polypeptide antigen (TPA), and urinary hydroxyproline (OHP). The clinical usefulness of these tumor markers to diagnose and monitor distant metastases was compared with that of the imaging techniques commonly used to monitor breast cancer patients (bone scanning [BS], liver echography [LE], chest radiograph, and skeletal radiograph). So far, 23 patients withdrew from the study, and distant metastases occurred in 33 patients. In 91% of the metastatic patients, constant elevation or progressive increase in serum CEA and/or TPA levels were the first pathologic findings of the relapse. Of the remaining 168 nonrelapsed patients, 122 were followed up longer than 24 months (43 +/- 17 months; mean +/- SD). In these 122 patients the false-positive results of CEA, TPA, and OHP were 0.8%, 2.4%, and 0%, respectively, when used simultaneously with clinical examination and the common laboratory examinations. BS and LE are the only imaging techniques that showed such a high sensitivity to be suitable in the postoperative follow-up of breast cancer patients. Nevertheless, because BS has a low specificity and is not harmless, it should be performed at longer intervals than tumor markers. Eventually, in the relapsed patients, TPA and OHP well reflected the response to treatment better than CEA and prevented useless radiologic examinations.

Tests for detecting recurrent disease in the follow-up of patients with breast cancer

In 141 postmenopausal node-positive patients with primary breast cancer, routine biochemical markers (alkaline phosphatase, gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase, carcinoembryonic antigen), and chest x-ray, in combination with history and clinical examination, have been performed at 3 monthly intervals for at least 2 years. Sixty one patients relapsed at a median time of 14 months. The recurrence was detected at routine follow-up in 40 (66%) patients. Of these 40 patients, 26 (65%) presented with symptoms, 11 (28%) were asymptomatic but were found to have relapsed on clinical examination, and only 3 (8%) had their relapse diagnosed on the basis of an abnormal chest x-ray. The remaining 21 patients presented early with symptoms. Therefore symptoms and clinical examination accounted for the detection of relapse in 58 of the 61 (95%) patients. Of the patients who had relapsed, 49% (30 of 61) had one or more abnormal markers/chest x-rays prior to relapse, rising to 79% (48 of 61) at the time of relapse. Of 80 patients with no evidence of recurrence, 36% (29) had no marker abnormality recorded, whereas in 64% (51) one or more abnormalities were found. These results suggest that history and examination are the important procedures in follow-up, and that abnormal markers are not always due to metastatic disease and may be misleading.

Clinical and radiologic characteristics of bone metastases in breast cancer

Metastatic bone disease was evaluated in 380 consecutive patients at the time of first metastasis of breast cancer. Studies included radiographic examination, radionuclide examination, and bone marrow biopsy. Radiographs of the skeleton demonstrated metastases in 120 patients (32%), and in 40 of these patients (13%) the bone was the only site of metastases. The diagnostic efficiency was 82% for bone scanning, 80% for pain evaluation, 59% for s-calcium analyses, and 77% for s-alkaline phosphatase analyses. Bone scanning is an effective method to exclude metastatic bone disease (sensitivity: 96%). A positive scan, however, requires radiologic confirmation (specificity: 66%). Bone scanning of the skeleton should be the initial staging procedure in all patients with recurrent breast cancer with no clinical or biochemical signs of bone metastases. Bilateral posterior iliac crest bone marrow aspirations and bone biopsies were positive in 82 out of the 320 patients who underwent biopsy. The frequency of positive bone marrow biopsy was significantly correlated with both the site of radiographic metastases and with the total number of involved bone regions. Routine bone marrow biopsies are indicated in patients with a positive bone scan, but a negative x-ray examination. In these cases biopsies should be performed bilaterally.

Bone metastases in primary operable breast cancer. The role of a yearly scintigraphy

In 231 patients with primary operable breast cancer bone scintigraphies were performed yearly from the second to the 6th year until recurrence irrespective of localization was diagnosed, another cancer was detected, or the patient refused further follow-up or died. During the observation period (from 2 up to 7 years after surgery) 13 patients (5.6%) had bone metastases verified by X-ray or histology within 12 months after the last bone scintigraphy. The scintigraphy was positive in only 7 of these patients. The yearly incidence of bone metastases varied between 0.6 and 2.6%. Due to this low incidence and a low cost/benefit, we conclude that a fixed schedule of repeated scintigraphies in primary operable breast cancer patients otherwise free of apparent disease is not justified.

Identification of bone and liver metastases from breast cancer by measurement of plasma alkaline phosphatase isoenzyme activity

Plasma alkaline phosphatase isoenzyme activities were determined in patients with breast cancer to diagnose and monitor bone and liver metastases. Bone alkaline phosphatase activity was increased in 21 of 50 patients (42%) with radiologically confirmed bone metastases, while total alkaline phosphatase activity was increased in only 10 of 50 (20%); liver alkaline phosphatase activity was raised in 12 of 25 patients (48%) with liver metastases. All patients with liver metastases had bone metastases. Bone alkaline phosphatase activity was significantly higher in patients with symptomatic bone disease. Isoenzyme determination provided additional information that would have changed patient management in five of 20 patients who were monitored serially. Measurement of alkaline phosphatase isoenzyme activity, though less sensitive than imaging procedures, can assist in screening for, and in early detection of, a high proportion of bone and liver metastases, and can provide useful objective evidence of their response to treatment.

Bone metastases: pathogenesis, treatment, and rationale for use of resorption inhibitors

Tumors in bone are usually metastatic, with breast, prostate, and lung tumors accounting for more than 80 percent of clinically manifest lesions. Untreated, such metastases can produce the symptoms that most concern cancer patients--pain, pathologic fractures, and paralysis through epidural cord compression. Recent advances in the understanding of the metastatic cascade and the regulation of bone formation and resorption provide unique therapeutic approaches for prevention and treatment of these lesions. This article reviews the prevalence, distribution, diagnosis, and treatment of metastatic cancer in the skeleton, as well as the processes involved in the development of such metastases, the local mediators responsible for some of the destructive changes in bone, and their pathologic results. In addition to considering some of the conventional therapeutic approaches, a rationale for the use of bone resorption inhibitors, such as the diphosphonates (bisphosphonates), is presented for the prevention and amelioration of the pathologic consequences of skeletal metastases.

Bone metastasis. Prognosis, diagnosis and treatment

Carcinoma of the breast, lung or prostate cause the majority of all bone metastases. Prolonged survival is common in patients with breast or prostate tumours. Different types of treatment may significantly increase the quality of life. Single-dose or fractionated radiation therapy may be effective, and 70 to 90 per cent of patients obtain partial or complete relief from pain. Surgery followed by irradiation is indicated in most patients with pathologic femur fractures. Immediate surgical treatment, either alone or combined with radiation therapy, may prevent paraparesis in patients with incipient cord compression. For neoplasms sensitive to systemic therapy such treatment should often be added to local treatment.

The clinical use of radionuclide bone marrow imaging

Bone marrow aspiration and biopsy are excellent techniques for evaluating bone marrow, but this evaluation is limited to a small part of the total blood-forming organ. With the introduction of radionuclide bone marrow imaging, a simple technique became available that overcomes marrow sampling errors by giving a total body view of functioning marrow. Furthermore, the procedure is noninvasive and provides an atraumatic method for evaluating a number of clinical problems including a discrepancy between bone marrow histology and clinical status (possible marrow sampling error), the determination of amount of active marrow after radiation and chemotherapy when further therapy is being considered, detection of sites of extramedullary hematopoiesis, location of the optimal sites for bone marrow biopsy, the diagnosis and staging of diffuse hematologic disorders, detection of metastases, the diagnosis of bone marrow infarcts in hemolytic anemias, and detecting avascular necrosis of the femoral heads. There are two major classes of bone marrow agents: (1) those that are incorporated into the erythroid precursors such as radioiron and (2) colloids that are taken up by the reticuloendothelial system (RES). Indium-111 chloride was originally considered to be an erythropoietic agent but appears to share some properties of RES labels. The best label to use is dependent on the disease being evaluated.

Skeletal scintigraphy for the diagnosis of malignant metastatic disease to the bones

The use of skeletal scintigraphy for the detection of metastatic disease of the bone is reviewed. The review is based on published data for sensitivity, specificity, yield and prognostic value. The analysis, and interpretation of published data is complicated by the variation in criteria. It appears nonetheless, that for a number of tumors the relative (in comparison with other methods) and absolute (based on outcome prediction) sensitivity is high. For certain tumors in early stages, and in asymptomatic patients the yield (of positive studies) is low, even when the prognostic value is high. Those factors should be weighed with the availability of therapeutic options to determine the clinical efficacy of skeletal scintigraphy.

Bone scintigraphy in breast cancer: a nine-year follow-up

The results of skeletal scintigraphy performed at presentation in 465 women with histologically confirmed carcinoma of the breast were correlated with tumour size, node status, clinical course and survival during a follow-up of at least 2 years and up to 9 years. Skeletal metastases were eventually confirmed in 17.6% of the population under study, but were identified at presentation by scintigraphy in only half of these. The incidence of significant scintigraphic abnormalities ranged from 1.5% in patients with T0 and T1 node negative tumours to 20.3% in T4 node positive tumours. Patients with scintigraphic evidence of metastases had a significantly shorter survival than those without; 13.6% of the patients with an abnormality considered to be significant on the criteria employed in this study failed to develop confirmatory evidence of skeletal metastases during the period of follow-up. Alternative criteria are proposed which would substantially decrease the incidence of false positives without increasing the incidence of false negatives. Even so, it is concluded that there is no evidence that routine skeletal scintigraphy affects management of newly diagnosed patients with carcinoma of the breast. Unless an algorithm can be defined which requires the information provided by skeletal scintigraphy in order to determine clinical management, this investigation is not justified as a routine staging procedure and should be reserved for patients in whom there is a clinical suspicion of metastases and for clinical trials.