Optimization in high dose rate brachytherapy for utero-vaginal applications

Biological Predictors of Response to Radiotherapy in Head and Neck Cancer: Recent Advances and Emerging Perspectives

The study of new biological parameters has received considerable attention in radiotherapy during the last decade due to their potential value in predicting treatment response in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck (SCC-HN) and the foreseen possibility of selecting altered fractionation radiotherapy for the individual patient. Although there are established clinical parameters in SCC-HN patients that relate to radiation response (extent of disease, hemoglobin level), recent advances with direct measurement of tumor oxygenation, inherent radiosensitivity and proliferation rate have increased the promise of individualization of treatment strategy according to these radiobiologically based parameters. Molecular research has now identified a host of new biological parameters with potential predictive utility; oncogenes, tumor suppressor genes, cell-cycle control genes, apoptosis genes and angiogenesis genes have been extensively studied and correlated with radiation response. Moreover, study of the epidermal growth factor receptor signal-transduction system as a possible response modulator has recently fostered molecular strategies which employ blockade of the receptor to down-regulate tumor growth. This article briefly reviews and analyzes the main controversial issues and drawbacks that hinder the general use of biological parameters for predicting tumor response to radiotherapy. It highlights the future perspectives of radiotherapy predictive assay research and the need to shift from single-parameter analysis to multiparametric studies which take into account several potential predictors that together are involved in different biological and clinical pathways.

Tandem-ring dwell time ratio in Nigeria: dose comparisons of two loading patterns in standard high-dose-rate brachytherapy planning for cervical cancer

Purpose

In high-dose-rate (HDR) brachytherapy (BT), the source dwell times and dwell positions are essential treatment planning parameters. An optimal choice of these factors is fundamental to obtain the desired target coverage with the lowest achievable dose to the organs at risk (OARs). This study evaluates relevant dose parameters in cervix brachytherapy in order to assess existing tandem-ring dwell time ratio used at the first HDR BT center in Nigeria, and compare it with an alternative source loading pattern.

Material and methods

At the Radiotherapy Department, University College Hospital (UCH), Ibadan, Nigeria, a total of 370 standard treatment plans in two alternative sets were generated with HDR basic 2.6 software for one hundred and eighty five cervical cancer patients. The initial 185 individual plans were created for clinical treatment using the tandem-ring dwell time ratio of 1 : 1. Modifying the initial applicator loading ratio, the second set of plans with related dose data were also obtained for study purposes only. Total reference air kerma (TRAK), total time index (TTI), ICRU volume, treatment time, point B dose, ICRU bladder dose, and rectal points dose were evaluated for both sets of plans.

Results

The means of all evaluated dose parameters decreased when the existing tandem-ring dwell time ratio (1 : 1) was modified to other dwell weightings (1 : 1 – 3 : 1). These reductions were 13.43% (ICRU volume), 9.83% (rectal dose), 6.68% (point B dose), 6.08% (treatment time), 5.90% (TRAK), 5.88% (TTI), and 1.08% (bladder dose). Correspondingly, coefficients of variation changed by –7.98%, –5.02%, –5.23%, –4.20%, –3.93%, 8.65%, and 3.96% from the existing pattern to the alternative one.

Conclusion

Tandem-ring dwell time ratio has significant influence on dosimetric parameters. This study has indicated the need to modify the existing planning approach at UCH.

Combined External and Intracavitary Irradiation in Treatment of Advanced Cervical Carcinomas: Predictive Factors for Treatment Outcome and Early and Late Radiation Reactions

Objective

The objective of this study was to find out predictive factors of tumor control as well as acute and late radiation reactions in treatment of advanced cervical carcinomas.

Methods

In a series of 134 primary cervical carcinomas in International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics stages I to IV treated with combined external pelvic and intraluminal cervical-vaginal brachytherapy, predictive and prognostic factors were analyzed with regard to tumor control, recurrences, survival data, and adverse effects. Concomitant chemotherapy was given to 48 patients (35.8%). The external beam therapy was given with a 4-field technique (50–60 Gy) and brachytherapy was given with a high-dose rate (iridium-192) afterloading technique using a ring applicator set. A computed tomographically based 3-dimensional dose-planning system was used for the external beam therapy and for the brachytherapy planning. The mean age of the patients was 65 years. A total of 110 tumors were squamous cell carcinomas and 24 were adenocarcinomas or adenosquamous carcinomas. A total of 111 tumors were in International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics stages I to II; 23 tumors, in stages III to IV.

Results

The primary control rate of the complete series was 92.5%. Tumor size, the brachytherapy dose, the combined external and brachytherapy dose, as well as the number of days of interruption (delay) of irradiation were all significant predictive factors for local tumor control. Forty recurrences (30%) were recorded. Early radiation reactions were recorded in 67% (mostly grade 1) and were associated with the widths of the anterior-posterior and lateral pelvic fields. Serious late radiations reactions (grade 3–4) were noted in 11%.

Conclusions

The width of the lateral pelvic fields, left point A and B doses, dose to the rectal reference point, as well as asymmetry of the dose distribution were associated with late severe reactions. Prior abdominal and pelvic surgery was also a high-risk factor for late tissue reactions. Concomitant chemotherapy did not increase the risk for acute or late toxicity.

Optimized dose distribution of Gammamed plus vaginal cylinders

Endometrial carcinoma is the most common malignancy arising in the female genital tract. Intracavitary vaginal cuff irradiation may be given alone or with external beam irradiation in patients determined to be at risk for locoregional recurrence. Vaginal cylinders are often used to deliver a brachytherapy dose to the vaginal apex and upper vagina or the entire vaginal surface in the management of postoperative endometrial cancer or cervical cancer. The dose distributions of HDR vaginal cylinders must be evaluated carefully, so that clinical experiences with LDR techniques can be used in guiding optimal use of HDR techniques. The aim of this study was to optimize dose distribution for Gammamed plus vaginal cylinders. Placement of dose optimization points was evaluated for its effect on optimized dose distributions. Two different dose optimization point models were used in this study, namely non-apex (dose optimization points only on periphery of cylinder) and apex (dose optimization points on periphery and along the curvature including the apex points). Thirteen dwell positions were used for the HDR dosimetry to obtain a 6-cm active length. Thus 13 optimization points were available at the periphery of the cylinder. The coordinates of the points along the curvature depended on the cylinder diameters and were chosen for each cylinder so that four points were distributed evenly in the curvature portion of the cylinder. Diameter of vaginal cylinders varied from 2.0 to 4.0 cm. Iterative optimization routine was utilized for all optimizations. The effects of various optimization routines (iterative, geometric, equal times) was studied for the 3.0-cm diameter vaginal cylinder. The effect of source travel step size on the optimized dose distributions for vaginal cylinders was also evaluated. All optimizations in this study were carried for dose of 6 Gy at dose optimization points. For both non-apex and apex models of vaginal cylinders, doses for apex point and three dome points were higher for the apex model compared with the non-apex model. Mean doses to the optimization points for both the cylinder models and all the cylinder diameters were 6 Gy, matching with the prescription dose of 6 Gy. Iterative optimization routine resulted in the highest dose to apex point and dome points. The mean dose for optimization point was 6.01 Gy for iterative optimization and was much higher than 5.74 Gy for geometric and equal times routines. Step size of 1 cm gave the highest dose to the apex point. This step size was superior in terms of mean dose to optimization points. Selection of dose optimization points for the derivation of optimized dose distributions for vaginal cylinders affects the dose distributions.

Nouveautés en curiethérapie gynécologique : nouvelles technologies, curiethérapie pulsée, imagerie, définitions de nouveaux volumes d'intérêt et leur impact sur la dosimétrie : applications dans le cadre d'un STIC

Brachytherapy plays a fundamental role in the therapeutic approach of patients with stage I-IV cervical carcinoma. Technical modalities have evolved during the last decades: stepping source technology, imaging modalities development, specially IMN, treatment planning system integrating 3D images. Images from CT-Scan and MRI have contributed to a better knowledge of tumoral extension and critical organs. CT and/or MRI compatible applicators allow a sectional image based approach with a better definition of tumour volume compared to traditional approaches. The introduction of 3D image based approach for GTV and CTV requires new definitions and a common language. In 2000, a working group within GEC-ESTRO was created to support 3D image based 3D treatment planning approach in cervix cancer BT. The task was to determine a common terminology enabling various groups to use a common language. Recommendations were described and proposed based on clinical experience and dosimetric concepts of different institutions. Two CTVs were described en relation to the risk for recurrence: high-risk CTV and intermediate risk CTV. In order to better define the role of such definitions and their potential impact on the complication incidence in patients with cervical cancer, a special French programme was developed. The aim of this programme is to study the incidence of the severe 2-year complication rate in two comparable patient populations: one population is treated using PDR brachytherapy with CT-Scan or MRI with the applicators in place allowing a 3D dosimetry with optimization, the second population is treated using standard X-rays radiographs without any delineation of the target nor optimisation. Each population arm includes 425 patients. A medicoeconomic assessment is performed, allowing a real cost of the most sophisticated approach compared to a historical dosimetric system.

Potential dose-conformity advantages with multi-source intensity-modulated brachytherapy (IMBT)

The possibilities for optimizing brachytherapy by including additional degrees of freedom in source design were investigated. This included examining optimised dose delivery with a brachytherapy source that can provide intensity-modulated dose delivery in angle about the source travel direction (to achieve intensity-modulated brachytherapy-IMBT). A prostate HDR case was selected as an example. An inverse planning algorithm was used to define how an asymmetric radiation source can be controlled in multiple source catheters to maximize tumour dose coverage and minimize urethral and rectal doses. Substantial improvements in conformity in terms of tumour coverage and urethral dose reduction could be achieved when conventional HDR source positioning was used with IMBT. With the objective definition used in the example however, rectal doses could not be improved over those delivered via conventional HDR. When source position was included as a variable in IMBT, significant conformity improvements result for all structures. IMBT would be a technically challenging form of therapy that would be strongly influenced by the type of sources that could be created for it. This study has shown however that there is a potential for improving dose conformity with such a therapy. Introduction of IMBT techniques would require conventional brachytherapy concepts to be radically modified.

Cervical brachytherapy utilizing ring applicator: Comparison of standard and conformal loading

PURPOSE

Afterloading high-dose-rate brachytherapy (HDR) treatment of cervical cancer with cross-sectional imaging and three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction offers opportunities for individualized conformal treatment planning rather than fixed point-A dosimetry.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between June 2003 and September 2004, 15 patients with FIGO Stage 1B-4A cervical carcinoma, median age 56 years, were treated with radical external-beam radiotherapy to pelvis, including paraortic nodes if positive on staging investigations. Fourteen patients received concurrent cisplatin chemotherapy. All patients received HDR brachytherapy administered by intrauterine tube and ring applicator. Clinical target volume (CTV) and organs at risk (OAR)--rectum, bladder, and small bowel--were outlined from postinsertion CT planning scans. Planning target volume (PTV) was derived by use of 2-mm to 3-mm 3D expansion. A standard plan was produced that delivered 6 Gy to point A, and a second plan delivered 6 Gy to PTV. Constraints were defined for the OAR: bladder, 6 Gy; rectum, 5 Gy; and small bowel, 5 Gy. Dosimetric comparison was performed by use of the Baltas conformal index (COIN).

RESULTS

Mean COIN values were 0.39 for conformal plans and 0.33 for standard plans (p = 0.001); mean D95 values were 4.79 Gy and 4.50 Gy, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The majority of patients achieved a plan closer to ideal for coverage of PTV, with minimization of radiation received by normal tissues for conformal loading measured by COIN compared with fixed point-A prescription that used the cervical ring applicator.

Recommendations from Gynaecological (GYN) GEC-ESTRO Working Group (I): concepts and terms in 3D image based 3D treatment planning in cervix cancer brachytherapy with emphasis on MRI assessment of GTV and CTV

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Brachytherapy (BT) plays a crucial role in the management of invasive cervix cancer from stage I to IV. Intracavitary techniques are based on afterloading devices, with different types of applicators. CT and/or MRI compatible applicators allow a sectional image based approach with a better assessment of gross tumour volume (GTV) and definition and delineation of target volume (CTV) compared to traditional approaches. Accurate and reproducible delineation of GTV, CTV and PTV, as well as of critical organs has a direct impact on BT treatment planning, especially if it is possible to adapt the pear-shape isodose by optimisation using DVH analysis. When introducing a 3D image based approach for GTV and CTV assessment, there is a need for a common language to describe the concepts and to define the terms which are to be used.

METHODS

In 2000, GEC-ESTRO decided to support 3D imaging based 3D treatment planning approach in cervix cancer BT with the creation of a Working Group. The task was to describe basic concepts and terms and to work out a terminology enabling various groups working in this advanced field to use a common language. The recommendations described in this report were proposed based on clinical experience and dosimetric concepts of different institutions (IGR, Leuven, Vienna) and were stepwise validated against the background of different clinical experience.

CONCLUSIONS

As GTV and CTV for BT change significantly during treatment, time frame for assessment of GTV and CTV for BT is specified in this report: at time of diagnosis GTV(D), CTV(D) and at time of BT GTV(B), CTV(B). Furthermore, CTV for BT is defined related to risk for recurrence: high risk CTV and intermediate risk CTV. Beside verbal descriptions detailed examples are given, partly in form of schematic drawings.

Significant rectal and bladder dose reduction via utilization of foley balloon catheters in high-dose-rate tandem and ovoid intracavitary brachytherapy of the uterine cervix

PURPOSE

To ascertain the potential for dose reduction to bladder and rectal points by using intravaginal Foley balloon catheters as a mechanism for structural displacement during tandem and ovoid high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy of the uterine cervix.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In 22 patients, two Foley balloons were placed intravaginally, with one balloon placed anterior to the tandem and one posterior, as close to the flange as patient geometry allowed. A series of 57 consecutive digitized treatment plans was assessed with and without liquid contrast inflation of Foley catheter balloons. Planning X-rays were acquired and digitized. Software calculated dose was then defined for two bladder and two rectal points, both with and without Foley balloon inflation. Results were then assessed using parametric statistical analysis.

RESULTS

Collectively and between equivalent points, a statistically significant (p < or = 0.01) diminution in calculated dose was observed with inflation of intracavitary balloon catheters, with a mean reduction in calculated dose of 16% and 17.6% for bladder and rectal points, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The potential advantages available from dose reduction using intracavitary balloon catheters include decreased high-dose-rate-induced organ toxicity, case-by-case customizability, and low cost of implementation. As such, further exploration of this technique is warranted.

Is simulation necessary for each high-dose-rate tandem and ovoid insertion in carcinoma of the cervix?

PURPOSE

To evaluate the dose variation in high-dose-rate (HDR) intracavitary brachytherapy for cancer of the cervix when treatment planning is performed prior to each applicator insertion versus when the initial plan is used for each treatment.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Fourteen patients with carcinoma of the cervix were treated with chemoradiotherapy followed by five intracavitary tandem and ovoid insertions of 600 cGy/fraction. We modified the actual plans to calculate the dose each dose point would have received using only the treatment plan created for the initial fraction.

RESULTS

An increase in the percent dose to the rectum, bladder, and vaginal surface of 5%, cGy (p = 0.038), 6% (p = 0.006), and 11%, respectively, were observed when the initial treatment plan was used versus using the optimized treatment plan for each insertion. The greatest single change resulted in a percent increase of 35%, 30%, and 45% to the rectum, bladder, and vaginal surface points, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased dose to at-risk structures occurred when individualized treatment planning was not performed. Since a significant increase in dose to the rectum (p = 0.038) and bladder (p = 0.006) was obtained without customized treatment planning, we continue to advocate individualized treatment planning in HDR tandem and ovoid insertions for the treatment of cervix cancer.

Possibilities for intensity-modulated brachytherapy: technical limitations on the use of non-isotropic sources

An investigation was undertaken into possible dose conformity advantages and technical limitations of utilizing radially asymmetric internally applied radiation sources for intensity-modulated brachytherapy (IMBT). A feasible form of a source for IMBT would be a linear source with a high-intensity angular region, with some fractional transmission through the remainder of the source, which inhibits the resolution achievable in intensity modulation. Indexed rotation of the source about its axis would provide radial intensity modulation, which could compensate for variations in the spatial relationship between the source position and location of the target edge. Two treatment situations were simulated--one two-dimensional and one three-dimensional--both utilizing a single source (single catheter). The optimal intensity distribution of the source was determined by simulated annealing optimization using a conformality-based objective. The parameters in the optimization included the angular size of the source high-intensity region, and the fractional transmission through the low-intensity part of the source. Results indicate that limitations in source design suggest an optimal high-intensity resolution of approximately pi/4 to pi/8. The advantages of IMBT are rapidly reduced when fractional transmission through the low-intensity side of the source is increased.