Induction chemotherapy with cisplatin, bleomycin and methotrexate in advanced head and neck cancer--lack of therapeutic gain

Induction chemotherapy in locally advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck: role, controversy, and future directions

Background

The value of induction chemotherapy (ICT) remains under investigation despite decades of research. New advancements in the field, specifically regarding the induction regimen of choice, have reignited interest in this approach for patients with locally advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck (LA SCCHN). Sufficient evidence has accumulated regarding the benefits and superiority of TPF (docetaxel, cisplatin, and fluorouracil) over the chemotherapy doublet cisplatin and fluorouracil. We therefore sought to collate and interpret the available data and further discuss the considerations for delivering ICT safely and optimally selecting suitable post-ICT regimens.

Design

We nonsystematically reviewed published phase III clinical trials on TPF ICT in a variety of LA SCCHN patient populations conducted between 1990 and 2017.

Results

TPF may confer survival and organ preservation benefits in a subgroup of patients with functionally inoperable or poor-prognosis LA SCCHN. Additionally, patients with operable disease or good prognosis (who are not candidates for organ preservation) may benefit from TPF induction in terms of reducing local and distant failure rates and facilitating treatment deintensification in selected populations. The safe administration of TPF requires treatment by a multidisciplinary team at an experienced institution. The management of adverse events associated with TPF and post-ICT radiotherapy-based treatment is crucial. Finally, post-ICT chemotherapy alternatives to cisplatin concurrent with radiotherapy (i.e. cetuximab or carboplatin plus radiotherapy) appear promising and must be investigated further.

Conclusions

TPF is an evidence-based ICT regimen of choice in LA SCCHN and confers benefits in suitable patients when it is administered safely by an experienced multidisciplinary team and paired with the optimal post-ICT regimen, for which, however, no consensus currently exists.

Hyperfractionated chemoradiation with carbogen breathing, with or without erythropoietin: a stepwise developed treatment schedule for advanced head-and-neck cancer

PURPOSE

To investigate the influence of carbogen breathing on chemoradiation and the effects of erythropoietin on transfusions.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From March 1996 to April 2000, 42 (4 Stage III and 38 Stage IV) patients with head and neck cancer were treated with a twice-a-day hyperfractionated schedule. Each fraction consisted of 5 mg/m(2) of carboplatin plus 115 cGy with carbogen breathing. Treatment was given 5 days per week up to total doses of 350 mg/m(2) of carboplatin plus 8050 cGy in 7 weeks. Anemia was treated either by transfusion or by erythropoietin.

RESULTS

Forty-one patients tolerated the treatment as scheduled. All patients tolerated the planned radiation dose. Five transfusions were given in the first group, but no transfusion was needed in the erythropoietin group. Local toxicities remained at the level expected with irradiation alone. Chemotherapy toxicity was moderate. Forty-two complete responses were achieved. At two years actuarial local control, cause-specific survival and overall survival are respectively 85%, 69%, and 68%. At four years estimated probabilities of local control, cause-specific survival and overall survival are also 85%, 69%, and 68%.

CONCLUSIONS

These results compare favorably with those of most reported studies. The addition of carbogen breathing appears to improve the results of chemoradiation alone. Erythropoietin therapy avoided transfusions.

Chemotherapy as a part of each treatment fraction in a twice-a-day hyperfractionated schedule: a new chemoradiotherapy approach for advanced head and neck cancer

BACKGROUND

Using chemotherapy as a part of each treatment fraction remains unexplored. This study integrates the concomitant administration of carboplatin with hyperfractionated irradiation by optimizing chemopotentiation through carboplatin administration with each irradiation fraction.

METHODS

From February 1993 to August 1996, 52 patients with advanced head and neck cancer were treated on a twice-a-day chemoradiotherapy schedule. Each fraction consisted of 115 cGy preceded by 5 mg/m2 of carboplatin. Treatment was given 5 days a week up to total doses of 350 mg/m2 of carboplatin + 8050 cGy in 7 weeks.

RESULTS

All (100%) of patients tolerated the treatment (83% as scheduled). Acute and late toxicities were moderate. Rates of 96% complete response (CR) and 4% partial response (PR) were achieved. At 52 months, local control and cause-specific survival rates are 72% and 59%, respectively. Nodal control rate is 95%.

CONCLUSION

These results show potential for improvement upon hyperfractionated radiotherapy alone and compare favorably with those of most reported trials.

The role of adjuvant chemotherapy in the treatment of advanced head and neck cancer

The role of chemotherapy in the multidisciplinary treatment of advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck remains to be defined. Uncontrolled adjuvant studies integrating chemotherapy with local therapies utilizing a 'sequential' or 'simultaneous' strategy have indicated that high response rates to initial chemotherapy and high complete remission rates are achievable. Both these factors appear to predict for improved survival. Unfortunately results of randomized, controlled studies generally have not confirmed any major overall survival advantage. However, these trials clearly failed to utilize optimal therapies: suboptimal trials yield suboptimal results. Encouraging data from large uncontrolled studies have now provided critical information regarding optimal trial design; a) Since primary tumor site has proved a significant predictive factor for response to treatment and survival, future trials must include sufficient numbers of patients for detailed site-by-site analyses, and b) radical surgery may be omitted without compromising survival by using initial chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy for advanced laryngeal cancer.